A Georgia state lawmaker wants to know the best way to force local jurisdictions to obey a new law governing photo enforcement systems. House Resolution 774, sponsored by state Representative Barry Loudermilk (R-Cassville), would create the “House Study Committee on Compliance by Local Governments with the Red Light Camera Law” in response to evidence that cities are operating automated ticketing programs without complying with Georgia Code 40-14-22. This legal provision, which took effect January 1, mandates a one-second extension of the duration of the yellow warning phase at red light camera intersections. As TheNewspaper first reported earlier this month, several jurisdictions are openly flouting the law.
“Federal guidelines are that minimum yellow light times are three to six seconds,” Loudermilk explained in his weekly column. “The intention of the law is that the minimum time of the yellow light in any intersection with a red light camera should not be less than four seconds… Unfortunately, some cities have refused to comply with state law and have not increased their yellow light times.”
Atlanta, for example, has flat-out refused to alter its yellow times with the majority of monitored intersections having yellow times that last less than 4.0 seconds. Roswell has intersection approaches set at 3.5 seconds, also in defiance of state law. Of the cities that are known to have complied, Duluth, Lilburn, Norcross, Rome, Snellville and Suwanee have dropped or are considering dropping photo enforcement because the yellow time extension immediately cut violations—and revenue—by eighty percent.
Loudermilk’s resolution is intended to create a “careful and thorough study of this issue” for consideration when the General Assembly meets again in 2010. In an interview, Loudermilk said that at this late point in the current legislative session the most sensible response was to form an investigative panel. This five-member committee would have full authority to call witnesses and gather the evidence needed to produce a legislative recommendation while putting local officials on the hot seat.
Loudermilk expects consideration of the resolution as early as this week. If passed by the state House, the measure would take effect immediately without the need for state Senate passage or the signature of Governor Sonny Perdue (R).
About damned time.
Everyone needs to sue the cities and Redflex (or whomever is the Camera Vendor) into the ground.
When we see some real penalties for these villains flouting the law and causing accidents and injuries, that will be a great day.
In Texas they passed a law forcing something like half the money from camera tickets to be spent on trauma centers. Guess what, the legislature is collecting the money, but then not forwarding it to the trauma centers. It is suspected that eventually there will be pork barrel trauma centers built with the money to help buy votes.
Hooray.
I really hope they actually get this taken care of. I live in Atlanta and drive to Roswell at least 4 times a week. Stopping in a hurry at yellows doesn’t feel nearly as safe as knowing I have time to clear the intersection.
If it’s a law then it should be enforced and penalties enumerated in the law assessed.
If there are people who don’t like the law, there are two ways to get rid of it. Have the legislature that passed the law repeal it or sue in court and have the law declared unconstitutional. Ignoring the law if you don’t like it is not correct.
We have some other laws (at the federal level) that are not enforced. What part of illegal is not understood?
Tced2, who said anything about ignoring laws?
I see nothing in any of the comments or the posted article mentioning disobeying laws.
rehposolihp, title of the blog entry says ignoring
“Georgia to Investigate Cities Ignoring Red Light Law”
To pick an example,
“Atlanta, for example, has flat-out refused to alter its yellow times with the majority of monitored intersections having yellow times that last less than 4.0 seconds”
The law (Georgia Code 40-14-22) states that 1 second must be added to minimum yellow light time. Federal guidelines talk about minimum 3 to 6 second yellow lights. By my arithmetic that means the yellow lights must be minimum 4 to 7 seconds. Atlanta has majority of its monitored intersections less than 4 seconds. Sounds like the majority of the monitored Atlanta intersections are less than the minimum 4 seconds. They are not following the law.
Not following the law is illegal until the law is declared unconstitutional by courts or the law is repealed by the legislative body that passed it.
The chief law enforcement officer of the state of Georgia (attorney general) probably needs to charge someone in the municipality with breaking the state law. The municipality is probably a bit murky because is it the police chief? the mayor? Many of the camera systems are privately owned and contracted by the municipality. So it may be the municipal authority that authorized the contract – the city council?
Well you know it’s also in the law that they can’t do anything about it until next January. That amuses me.
If it is illegal, it’ll probably be declared as such by the courts when a motivated person gets a ticket.
Unfortunately, I wouldn’t hold my breath waiting for a any sort of relief in the traffic court. It’s more than just the municipalities that have a vested interest in generating tickets.
Adding one second to the late ‘70s Traffic Signal Engineering (TSE) times would all but end all revenue. The mid-‘80s and early ‘90s TSE times would need about 1.75 seconds added to make them equally reasonable.
A better way to keep the revenue stream flowing would be to re-program those tiny cameras that see movement and trigger a light change. Program them to dynamically cut the Green time so as to always trap an oncoming car or two at every light change.
Screw it down so only a car or two gets through a Green light and the money will flow.
Remember, you can nail just as many cars by cutting the green times as by cutting the yellow times.