Category: Editorials

By on November 1, 2006

studenbaker22.jpgThe new CEO of the company walked into the boardroom. The mood was grim. Recruited from another company in another industry just a few months previously, he carried bleak news. The automaker had just reported the largest third quarter loss in recent history. Their most profitable products, which had been flying off dealer lots, were dead in the water. Strikes at suppliers had crippled production of the few products that sold well. Market share was evaporating, and operations in Europe were drowning in red ink. Worst of all, recent downgrading of their bonds had hurt the profitability of their all-important finance unit, which had underwritten the car business for years. It was time for some bold moves.

The board of directors listened to the bad news as the patriarch of the founding family stared down at them from a portrait on the wall. When the CEO finished, the directors mulled over their options. No matter what course they chose, the lives of thousands of employees would be affected. The economic health of the company’s home town depended on them. It was a heavy burden.

The year was 1963. The company was Studebaker. The CEO was Sherwood Egbert, formerly of McCulloch Chainsaws. After due consideration, the directors decided that there was no economic justification for remaining in the car business. They initiated plans to ease the company out of the automobile industry and expand its portfolio of profitable businesses. When the last Studebaker eventually rolled off the assembly line, the company’s stock almost doubled. Studebaker went on to become a very profitable company, eventually merging with other conglomerates.

Four-and-a-half decades later, Ford stands at the same crossroads. The Blue Oval just reported the worst third quarter earnings in over a decade-and-a-half. Market share has dropped dramatically, by over a third. Consumers have deserted the profitable trucks and SUVs that drove Ford to the heights of profitability. In the meantime, buyers are lined up none deep for the Ford 500 and its clone, the Mercury Montego. Overseas losses continue, with the Premium Automotive Group losing an astounding $600m.

Wall Street’s lack of confidence in Ford’s automotive endeavors has resulted in the continued downgrading of Ford’s bonds. This raises the cost of capital to Ford Financial, which is the profit engine of the Ford Motor Company. Without profits from Financial, Ford would not be a financially tenable organization. This last quarter, profits from Ford Financial were off about $400m, mainly due to the higher cost of borrowing.

The solutions to Ford Financial’s profit problems leave Ford with a Hobson’s choice. If Ford sells a controlling share of Financial to an outside company (a la GM and Cerberus), the credit ratings of Financial’s bonds would rise dramatically. But Ford would then reap only half, or less, of the profits. And it’s entirely possible that the finance unit’s new owners might find better uses for those profits than propping up FoMoCo.

If, on the other hand, Ford allows the deficit-ridden automobile operations to continue to drag down the credit ratings of Ford Financial, less and less cash from Financial will be available to prop up Ford. Declining profits will decrease the value of Ford Financial. If and when Ford is forced to sell it off just to meet the payroll, the finance company will be worth a fraction of its current fair market value.

And then there’s Ford’s seriously deteriorating relationship with its suppliers. A large number of companies that Ford relies on for continued production of its automotive products are in bankruptcy: Delphi, Tower, Dana, Dura, Federal Mogul and Collins & Aikman; to name a few. A failure of any of these mission critical manufacturers would cause an immediate shutdown of one or more of Ford’s production plants. Ford’s relentless pressure on prices has weakened its supply base to the point where continued and reliable production is a tenuous supposition.

Recently, Ford had to shut down its Fusion/Milan/MKZ plant, when Collins and Aikman (C&A) refused (for one shift) to supply parts at a loss. C&A, bankrupt, felt they simply had to have more money to cover their costs. Widely but silently applauded in the supplier community, the move could well be the first in a series of similar supplier “strikes." Just when Ford needs more cost savings, their own supplier base, already destitute, will demand, and get, higher prices. Ford has already deplored the “serious harm to the relationship” caused by C&A’s actions, but it’s clear that relationships with Ford don’t pay the bills.

In response to these issues, Ford’s new CEO Alan Mulally is calling for "incremental continuous improvement.” Meanwhile, Ford’s board of directors is heading towards a sad recognition of the truth: the automaker doesn’t have a viable plan for making cars and trucks at a profit, or the time to devise one. At that point, it’s only a matter of time before Ford thinks the unthinkable: following Studebaker into becoming a multi-national financial company.  

By on November 1, 2006

28002-rollover-accidents-2.jpgLet’s try an experiment. I’ll give you a shiny new multi-blade, swivel head safety razor and an old-fashioned straight razor honed to a fine edge. You shave one side of your face (or one leg, depending on your shaving proclivities) with one razor and the other side with the other one. With which razor will you finish more quickly, and which one will you use very carefully and deliberately? According to a study from a Purdue University research team, the same thing applies to our driving habits: the safer we perceive our cars to be, the less carefully we tend to drive them.

There’s no arguing that today’s vehicles are much safer than those built 20 years ago. Seatbelts, ABS, airbags, ESC, traction control and crumple zones all combine to improve your chances of surviving a major accident and reduce your likelihood and severity of injury in any accident. However, Fred Mannering, a Purdue professor of civil engineering, says the same systems designed to protect us from each other may encourage more aggressive driving. They actually increase our chances of being in an accident and, thus, our chances of injury. 

This phenomenon, which Mannering refers to as the “offset hypothesis,” results when drivers respond to safety improvements by becoming more careless because they expect the technology to protect them regardless of how they drive.

Mannering and his team analyzed accident data from Washington over a five year period, tracking the same drivers as they moved from cars without airbags and ABS into cars with the safety equipment. He and his team built computer models using accident data and driving records for these drivers. They then calculated the probability of being involved in an accident for drivers of different ages and demographics. Mannering reports, "Our findings suggest that the offset hypothesis is occurring and that it is sufficient to counter the modest technological benefits of airbags and antilock brakes."

National Traffic Safety Administration data seem to support his findings. In their last annual report, they show fatalities per 100 million vehicle miles traveled increased 1.4% and the number of fatal crashes increased by 1.9%– in spite of an increased number of airbag and ABS-equipped vehicles on the road. As further validation of his offset hypothesis, more than half of passenger vehicle occupants killed were not wearing seatbelts or other restraint devices.

Psychologist Dr. Gerald Wilde takes this concept a bit further in his analysis of risky behavior. In his books "Target Risk" and "Target Risk 2," he states that “people alter their behavior in response to the implementation of health and safety measures, but the riskiness of the way they behave will not change, unless those measures are capable of motivating people to alter the amount of risk they are willing to incur.”

Based on this theory of risk homeostasis, Dr. Wilde postulates that safety measures such as airbags don't produce the changes in driving behavior needed to reduce accident rates because they fail to reduce people's willingness to take risk. In fact, the opposite appears to be true– they actually increase willingness to take risk because drivers perceive that the increase in safety margin allows them to behave in a more risky manner.

Of course, the automakers and safety experts– all of whom have a vested interest in convincing the public of the benefits of various safety devices– don’t agree with Mannering’s findings or Wilde’s hypothesis. No wonder: all their research and data is based on measurements of the number of drivers killed or seriously injured– not whether or not the devices have an impact on accident or injury rates. Volvo openly admits that while they’ve done plenty research on injuries and death rates, they’ve never looked into whether aggressive driving increases with the perceived safety level of a vehicle.

Dr. Wilde states the best way to change risky behavior is to reward those who engage in less risky behavior, instead of punishing those who take more risks (i.e. speeding tickets). He cites studies that show industrial accident rates decrease when employers give bonuses or special recognition to those who exhibit safe behavior.  Insurance companies do this to some extent by offering lower rates to drivers who have fewer accidents and moving violations.

But why not carry it even further? The government could give tax incentives to those who remain accident free over the year. Drivers not incurring any moving violations over a certain time could be allowed to use the carpool lanes. I’m sure there are other rewards which would encourage less risk-taking on the highway and lower accident rates– if the government was serious about lowering accident rates. In the meantime, though, the best we can do is watch out for the hoons who think they’re impervious to the laws of physics. Airbags may save their lives, but they won’t keep them from running that red light.

By on October 30, 2006

drag3222.jpgThe media’s failure to get ahead of The Big Two Point Five’s swan dive from grace is a source of constant amusement. The press’ collective reluctance to investigate the truth behind the automakers’ plight delivers endless wonder. But Motown media’s “eternal sunshine of the big ass automaker” shtick just plain rankles. In “Detroit Can Ride Out These Strange Days,” Free Press columnist Tom Walsh told his readers to hold fast and be of good cheer. ”These are nutty and painful times for Detroit's auto industry. But they are times for resolve, not for panic.” Hey Tom; are you sure about that?

Tom’s sure, and here’s why: “The most formidable challenge, the one so many in the global auto industry are obsessing about, is Toyota. Indeed, the Toyota monster is the underlying reason for GM's stock price drop after Wednesday's good-news earning report.” And there I was thinking that GM’s stock price drop was the “dump” part of Merrill analyst John Murphy’s “pump and dump” strategy. Or perhaps that GM’s sinking stock price had something to do with GM’s cash burn, employee-related liabilities, bloated dealer network and/or less-than-thrilling product portfolio. Nah; it’s all about ToMoCo.

At least Mr. Walsh is realistic about GM’s future prospects, in a denial-oriented, pay no attention to that man behind the curtain kinda of way. “GM is by no means in safe harbor… But whatever the short-term hiccups, Wagoner and Henderson and the rest of GM's management team are taking a disciplined approach to their issues. Costs are way down, revenue-per-vehicle-sold is up, and they handled the Renault-Nissan alliance issue smartly.”

Short term hiccups? You mean, like sinking market share and billions wiped from the corporate ledger? A disciplined approach meaning… the guys aren’t heading off for the links every Wednesday? Or an endless cycle of “no we won’t yes we will no we won’t” on discounts and spiffs? Sure, revenue-per-vehicle is up, but the company is still losing money. And if Walsh thinks GM handled the Nissan merger “smartly,” let’s hope he means quickly instead of intelligently. The really intelligent thing to do: an independent review of the deal (i.e. not putting the man in charge in charge).

Anyway, despite Tom’s stricture to chill, the facts about GM’s predicament are pretty nerve-racking. In the third financial quarter, GM’s cash position declined by $2.5b. (Short-term liquidity now stands at $20.4b.) Cash flow from its automotive operations– including restructuring costs– was a negative $5.1b. During the quarter, GM turned $2b of short term VEBA funds into cash and scored a $500m dividend from its GMAC financing arm. At the same time, GM forked-over $2.5b to GMAC to cover the “buy down” of its Zero Percent sale; a figure that includes additional loan loss reserves to cover deadbeats. Uh-oh.

As we warned, the Anyone With A Pulse sale boosted GM’s sales and reduced inventory– and hit GM’s cash flow like a Silverado driving into a wall. Sure, GM will receive another cash flow boost when its new pickup trucks arrive at dealers over the next several months, just as it did when the GMT900 SUVs rolled onto dealer lots. But The General’s bottom line remains the same: GM can’t generate cash from its automotive operations. That’s got to be stressful. 

Oh, GM also tapped into its secured credit line this summer-– supposedly to “test the mechanics of the line.” In fact, GM needed the additional liquidity to cover payables during plant shutdowns. The amount of the drawdown is [strangely enough] unknown. The borrowed funds were repaid during the quarter. But it was still a completely unprecedented maneuver. Feeling nervous yet?

CEO Rick Wagoner’s claim that GM’s cost cutting will save $9b annually will actually save the company about $5b in cash. Meanwhile, GM says it needs $400m to cover the deal over at bankrupt parts supplier Delphi in the fourth quarter of ’06, and will then pay Delphi around $100m per year for an “undefined period.” GM is also set to make a $1b contribution to the DC-VEBA in 2007, as per the health care “concessions” made by the UAW earlier this year. Without the proceeds of the GMAC sale… fuhgeddaboutit. Ready to freak?

Actually, panic is a highly evolved behavior. When an animal is trapped and fighting for its life, when it’s tried the logical escape route (fleeing) or last-ditch strategy (fighting), all that’s left are illogical and random actions (a.k.a. panic). By the same token, when a carmaker is trapped (heading for oblivion), when it’s tried the logical escape route (downsizing) or last ditch strategy (“bold” new products), all that’s left are illogical and random actions (filing for bankruptcy, merger, leaving the biz Studebaker-style, triggering a union strike, etc.). Of course, you can’t predict chaos (or its aftermath). But you’d think one of Detroit’s auto hacks would at least, you know, try.

By on October 30, 2006

dragon-car222.jpgEvery industry craves a hit, whether it’s a bestseller, a summer blockbuster or 300k crossovers off a Canadian assembly line. It is, however, only one way to make a buck. According to “The Long Tail: Why the Future of Business Is Selling Less of More,” consumers are quickly evolving beyond cookie-cutter mass consumption. In fact, a careful reading of Wired editor Chris Anderson’s tome indicates that the days when a single vehicle could “save” a company may be long gone. Automakers who want to survive must now chase the tail of the dragon.

Anderson defines The Long Tail as a curve on a graph that looks like an old Hot Wheels ramp; the orange kind clamped with a purple vice high on a kitchen table. The tall end represents a few instances of big numbers; the swooping tail represents many instances of small numbers. To illustrate its power, Anderson’s book applies this curve to several industries. Netflix, for example, will send out thousands of copies of a movie the week it’s released. It will also send out tens of thousands of copies of other movies. They may have only one request for that movie that week.

The single requests aren’t as obvious a source of large profits, but experience shows that all these individual orders can conglomerate into a sum that’s greater than the box office boffo “headline” numbers. In Anderson’s words, "Our culture and economy are increasingly shifting away from a focus on a relatively small number of hits (mainstream products and markets) at the head of the demand curve and moving toward a huge number of niches in the tail.”

In other words, you can make more money hammering away at the small stuff than going for the gold. The implications for the US automobile industry are clear: the days when Henry Ford could base an entire company on one black car are toast. By the same token, the one-size-fits-all mentality that assumes hundreds of thousands of people will buy a new Chevy Malibu or Chrysler Aspen is also extinct. Consumer desire for choice has fragmented the automotive market beyond the point of no-return.

Consumer desire for differentiation is stretching the long tail of the US automotive market like so much taffy. You can see these fragments made manifest in the astounding proliferation of automotive makes and models vying for pistonhead patronage. And yet automotive development costs are massive; the development process is complicated, slow and cumbersome. It’s far easier for Hollywood to crank out hundreds of new movies for Netflix than it is for the automobile industry to create 40 plus all-new models per year— never mind adjusting its retail channels to profit from this niche proliferation.

The explosion in the automotive aftermarket hlghlights the discrepancy between supply and demand. In the last two decades, the Specialty Equipment Manufacturers’ Association has grown to represent a $30b a year domestic industry. BMW earns about a $60b a year. In other words, the North American automotive market now supports the equivalent of half a small car company– just so owners can differentiate themselves from drivers of “stock” products.  

The mainstream manufacturers’ recent efforts to capitalize on the long tail underscore their inherent inability to rise to the challenge. It took Cadillac an entire model cycle to develop the sort of bling wheels its Escalade owners were buying in their tens of thousands. And almost as soon as they were released, aftermarket wheel makers offered cheaper, more stylish and more exclusive alternatives. Manufacturers know they must create more choice, but their inefficiency means that have to do so with less. Hence their increasing reliance of platform sharing and its evil twin, badge engineering.

To most enthusiasts, badge engineering is about as acceptable as cannibalism. The differences between a Chevy Uplander and Saturn Relay, for example, are so insignificant as to be insulting. A look at the Ford 500 and Volvo XC90 reveals a different tail. These aesthetically and dynamically differentiated vehicles in no way threaten to steal customers from one another. From style to function to price, these cousins are so far from the Patty Duke variety that they do exactly what the market wants. They offer a genuine, easily understandable increase in consumer choice.

Whether or not the long tail turns out to be a serviceable economic theory is irrelevant. The marketplace in general demands, and now receives, more products: more movies, more books, more videos of cats falling off stools, more cars, more wheels, more of everything. The auto companies that can find a way to cater to this desire with authenticity will find treasure, whether that’s by platform sharing or so-called mass customization. The ones that continue to base their business on breakout blockbusters simply won’t survive.

By on October 29, 2006

alonsocampeon222.jpgThe Brazilian Grand Prix at Sao Paolo marked the final act of the 2006 Formula 1 season. It was the scene of a pulsating and emotionally charged contest, where Michael Schumacher (Ferrari) battled Fernando Alonso (Renault) for the driver’s championship. Well, it wasn’t really a “battle;” all Alonso had to do to win was stay in the race. This he did, although Schumacher unleashed yet another in a seemingly endless number of superlative drives, proving that he was still The Man, mechanical misfortunes notwithstanding.

Many people had asked what would become of Formula 1 after Ayrton Senna’s tragic demise. The F1 world was asking the same question as Michael Schumacher hung up his helmet. Michael has decided to call it quits after winning seven world championships, and demolishing all previous records for race wins, pole positions and fastest laps. Although Schumacher had more to offer, he now faces the enviable challenge of administering his estimated $750m empire from the peace and tranquillity of his $50m estate cuddled in the Swiss mountains.

Meanwhile, praise to Fernando Alonso. At 25, Alonso has become the youngest driver ever to win back-to-back F1 championships. The Spaniard made the most of an impressive racing package, slightly betrayed by a fall in performance from Michelin at one stage of the championship. He also surmounted ‘political’ obstacles, such as the abolition of the ‘mass dumper’ device from his Renault, and the much-debated penalty for ‘apparently’ blocking Felipe Massa (Ferrari) during the final practice of the Italian GP at Monza.

Fernando will drive for McLaren next season, with the clear intention of reviving the fortunes of the Anglo-German outfit, hunting for his third successive championship victory. A quick overview of the 2006 season and the final race at San Paolo tells us that next year will bring many changes in driver line-ups, engine suppliers and technical regulations. Let’s take a quick look at the top teams:

Ferrari: Felipe Massa and Kimi Raikkonen will lead the challenge of the Scuderia. They have inherited the onus of keeping Ferrari on top, although that in itself is not a heavy burden to carry.

Renault: Deploying Giancarlo Fisichella and Heikke Kovalainen, Team Boss Flavio Briatore has opted for experience and exuberance. Renault’s compulsory switch to Bridgestone tyres (due to Michelin’s exit) may be a technical setback, but they have a winning basis from which to progress.

McLaren: Uncharacteristically, McLaren didn’t win a single Grand Prix race in 2006. Team Boss Ron Dennis will push his men hard to return to their winning ways. Alonso’s co-driver will either be Pedro de la Rosa and GP2 champion or McLaren protégé Louis Hamilton. Raikkonen, though always a front runner, was daunted by poor reliability. A demotivated Juan Pablo Montoya was dropped halfway through the season.

Toyota: The big spending Japanese team has again failed to reap the rewards of their huge investment. Jarno Trulli and Ralf Schumacher only produced flashes of brilliance, as their racing package lacked consistency. Toyota is supplying engines to Williams for 2007, in an effort to raise its prospects in the Formula 1 circus on two fronts.

Honda: Jenson Button and Rubens Barrichello may provide the only real competition to the Ferrari and Renault teams. Honda has certainly displayed a positive progression of performance through the ’06 season, culminating in Button’s maiden Formula 1 victory at the Hungaroring.

Williams: Team owner Sir Frank Williams characterized the ‘06 season as ‘decidedly humiliating.’ It was certainly a transitional season; running Cosworth engines, Nico Rosberg and Mark Webber struggled with reliability and committed points-killing racing blunders. For ’07, Rosberg will be partnered by Austrian Alex Wurz and Toyota engines.

BMW-Sauber: Joining forces was a wise decision for both partners. The arrival of young polish driver Robert Kubica, replacing Jacques Villeneuve mid-season, gave Nick Heidfeld and the team extra motivation. Kubica could well be the next big thing.

With a proposed 18-race calendar, a single tire manufacturer, the retirement of Michael Schumacher and a renewed tussle between the big constructors to edge their way to the top spot, one question springs to mind: who will be the dominant force in Formula 1 next season, and who will take the place of Michael Schumacher as the true Number One? Will Fernando Alonso make McLaren winners again? Will Kimi Raikkonen continue in Schumacher’s footsteps? Will Giancarlo Fisichella be top dog at the helm of Constructor’s Championship winners Renault? Can the young guns, Rosberg, Kovalainen, Kubica and Hamilton challenge the ‘old guard’?

Teams will fight to retain their supremacy. Others will attempt to regain lost glory, while the majority will work hard to present themselves with a competitive package. Winter testing may prove to be deceptive. As always, as it should be, the answers to these questions and more will only be revealed on race-day.  

By on October 28, 2006

1pri20772222.jpgAs five o’ clock rolls around on Sunday afternoon, the Pratt & Miller Corvette Racing team is getting its second wind. Twenty-odd hours into the 24 Heures du Mans marathon and the finish line is finally in sight– literally and figuratively; the garage opens onto the racetrack’s historic grandstands. The Pratt & Miller team has persisted through an intense all-night battle with rivals Aston Martin and, finally, the blazing afternoon heat of the French countryside in summer.

The race started an hour later than normal, to avoid conflict with World Cup soccer. Race activity in the following hours has gone from frenetic to merely hectic. Qualifying fourth and fifth, the Corvettes start as they mean to finish; showing typical pace over the 8.5 mile Circuit de la Sarthe. They're only a few seconds slower than the not-so-ironically named 007 and 009 Astons. And then, less than an hour into the race, the team runs into its first major stumbling block. Johnny O’Connell, driver of the number 63 Corvette, radios-in to report a shunt on the back side of the circuit. 

Just before the crash, Pratt & Millers’ trackside engineers were treated to a blizzard of blinking lights on their telemetry readouts. Wildly fluctuating oil and water pressure, tire temperatures and other data– all highlighted by insistent red and green warnings– blipped onto their screens. In a heartbeat, the mood in the garage shifts from anxious to serious.

The crew members prepare for the damaged car’s arrival. The garage grows quieter and more focused. Finally, the fierce baritone of the Corvette’s 7.0-liter V-8 can be heard bouncing off the pit lane walls. Seconds later, the car slides into its designated stall. Dan Binks and the crew of #63 leap into action, pneumatically raising the car, lowering it onto dollies and rolling it nose-first into the garage. With the race only a few hours old, the energy level is high. A dozen mechanics swarm over the car, like worker bees attending to the queen. Within 10 minutes, the crew has replaced the rear wing, wheel arch and tie rod.  A few moments later, #63 fires up and roars out of the pit stall to rejoin the race.

The sound of the Corvette’s engine switching off is the hallmark of the Pratt & Miller pit stop; roaring in, the drivers kill the engine even before the car has come to a halt. Car up, refueling rig in, tires swapped. Done. The car drops back to the tarmac with an audible clunk. The driver whips the outrageous V-8 to life. The engine starts with a pop exponentially louder than a 12-gauge shotgun. Leaving the pits under full throttle, the powerplant’s loud enough to painful pierce an enclosed radio headset. No wonder the team doesn’t let the engine run in the garage. Pit lane is a precisely choreographed ballet that will start and finish again and again, until the waning hours of Sunday afternoon.

And then the most dramatic event of the race for the Pratt & Miller pit crew: the 63 car arrives in a cloud of smoke with a destroyed gearbox. As before, the team leaps into action, pushing the car into the garage. This time it goes ass-end first, as if to hide the Corvette’s all-important inner workings from their rivals. In an instant, they remove the rear deck. A cloud of milky, acrid oil smoke billowing from under the bodywork fills the garage. In times of crisis like this, crew members are their assigned responsibilities. Mechanics from both the 63 and 64 cars rush to one side of the garage to contribute all they can to the resuscitative effort. 

Within minutes, they strip the rear of the car bare of its carbon-fiber skin, exposing its skeleton. Mechanics lean deep into the rear of the car and lift the smoking gearbox from its innards with asbestos-gloved hands. At Le Mans, gearbox replacement is prohibited by the regulations. So the team dives into the unit, removing its casing and exposing the six-speed box' intricate workings. The unit is intensely hot, melting into the rubberized floor covering. Forty-five minutes later, the 63 again roars out of the pit stall, the shafts and cogs of the cooked box lying on the counter in the tool trailer for later inspection.

After 24 grueling hours, the Corvettes cross the finish line in formation, the 64 a nose ahead of the 63.  For the fifth time in six years, a Corvette wins the GT1 class at the 24 Hours. The race’s final image: Corvette Racing program manager Doug Fehan holding aloft the Stars and Stripes as the cars cross the line, his American muscle once again proving victorious in this seemingly endless crucible of speed.

[Thanks to Jim Durbin and the Pratt & Miller team for trackside access.]

 

By on October 27, 2006

1974-ford-pinto-122.jpgThe Truth About Cars (TTAC) TWAT Award Selection Committee has convened. Fifteen members of our cadre of car critics and commentators carefully considered the full horror of your 131 nominations. They then selected 20 vehicles that deserve your consideration for the final 10 winners/losers. And so, now, we turn to you, our avid devotees and unshakeable critics, for your knowledge, passion, honesty and sarcasm. It’s time to VOTE for the ten vehicles which will be anointed TTAC’s top TWATs for 2006.

As you may have noticed during the nomination process, some vehicles practically dripped with TWAT-iness, bobbing to the top of the toilet bowl and staying there for the duration. Many of these execrable rides made it all the way to the top 20. Others kept a fairly low profile, but were decreed fully TWAT-worthy by my esteemed colleagues. The list of finalists shows that bad taste, poor design and questionable construction know no price, market segment or country of origin. So without further ado, here are the 20 finalists, listed in alphabetical order:

Buick Rendezvous

Cadillac Escalade

Chevrolet Aveo

Chevrolet Cobalt / Pontiac G5 / Saturn Ion

Chevrolet Impala

Chevrolet Monte Carlo

Chrysler Aspen

Chysler Crossfire

Ford Ranger / Mazda B-series

GM Minivans

Hummer H2

Infiniti QX56

Jaguar X-type

Jeep Commander

Jeep Compass

Lincoln Mark LT

Lincoln Navigator

Saab 9-7x

Subaru B9 Tribeca

Subaru Baja 

Selecting 10 of these worst of all possible vehicles from such an undistinguished list will be tough. How do you decide which cars are the crème de la crap? To help you separate the chaff from the toxic waste, here are some factors to consider when voting. [Fair Disclosure: we’re providing this guide simply to give the award gravitas amongst any media spies who may be monitoring our efforts.]

Market segment suitability/competitiveness  Is it a badly badge-engineered bodge born to placate greedy, boneheaded dealers looking to sell something, anything in a particular market? Does it live up to the claims of the marketing goons? (Then again, can anything?) Is there any justification whatsoever for its existence?

Reliability/Safety  Has it been recalled more times than a favorite fairy tale? Does it have a reputation (anecdotal or statistical) for dying (perhaps of shame)? Would you put your loved ones in one of them for a cross-country trip, assuming you're not planning on collecting on the insurance?

Build quality  How does the overall quality of construction, fit and finish compare with other vehicles in the same price class/market segment or, say, a Walmart sofa? Does the vehicle rattle, thrum, drum and hum so much you could dance the conga to its beat?

Quality of materials  How do the materials used compare with other vehicles in the same price class or, say, a K-Mart suit? How well do the controls work? Is there obvious cost-cutting everywhere you look or touch? Can you look or touch it without puking?

Styling  When you look at the vehicle, do you feel yourself slowly turning to stone? Could it be a useful tool for interrogators at Guantanamo Bay?

Performance/handling  How well do the acceleration, handling, fuel economy, and drivability compare to other vehicles in the same price class/market segment or, say, one of those rolling tables teachers use for overhead projectors?  

Design  How well does the vehicle’s overall design (interior, ergonomics, exterior styling, space utilization, visibility) work? Is it an exercise in wretched excess or a paean to bad taste? Is it a modern design or does it hearken back to ye olde days of crapteryear?

Desirability  How would you feel about owning this vehicle? Would you rather walk/watch The Wiggles than be seen behind the wheel? If a rental agent handed you the keys, would you consider it an insult?

Je ne sais quoi  Does the vehicle have that certain “something” that makes you throw up in your mouth a little when you see one drive by? Should it be sent to the crusher on general principles?  

Yada, yada, yada. It’s time to vote for your TWAT. Click here and you’ll link through to the polling site. Again, vote for ten choices from the list. Once you’ve made your choices, you’ll be magically returned to the TTAC home page. Obviously, your votes will be held in the strictest confidence and tabulated with mindless electronic impartiality. You are, of course, invited to list your choices below with a short explanation of your decision making process.

The poll will be online through next Wednesday evening. We’ll announce the winners (losers?) on Monday. Thanks you for your help in this important experiment in journalistic freedom and, let’s face it, payback.

By on October 26, 2006

gme85virginia03222.jpgYesterday, a Yahoo news bulletin popped up: “GM’s losses narrow.” If that’s the way you see it, please don’t tarry here. You know GM CEO Rabid Rick Wagoner’s turnaround plan is “gaining traction.” You know GM’s too big to fail, that the supertanker will change course and avoid the jagged rocks of bankruptcy. The fact that GM’s fundamentals are still broken— too many brands, models and dealers; excessive bureaucracy and crushing union obligations— is not your concern. For those of you willing to stare into the abyss, let’s take a closer look at those third quarter results.

First, GM’s cash flow is still negative. GM NA dropped $367m for the quarter. That might not seem like much compared to last year’s $1.67b hit, but it’s not chicken feed— especially considering its origins. As the official press release joyfully proclaims “This significant progress largely reflects improvements in structural costs, as the company executes the pension, health care and manufacturing cost reduction initiatives related to its North American turnaround plan.” In other words, GM has reduced its costs and it’s still taking in less money than it spends. Even worse, there ain’t much more GM can cut.

No wonder Rabid Rick Wagoner was talking up the chances of the new Chevrolet Silverado/GMC Sierra pickups and the Saturn Outlook/GMC Acadia crossovers. While these vehicles offer the prospect of higher profits, their market segments are heating up, driving margins down. And they only represent a fraction of GM’s lineup across its eight US brands. The fact that GM’s margins are being squeezed across the board is a far more important financial factor than the Silverado/Outlook’s potential success. With over a million unsold units on the ground, the pressure to slash prices will grow, reducing margins yet further, and continuing GM’s reputation as the K-Mart of cars.

And there's your fundamental problem: GM is not a price leader. It’s still a high cost producer selling products at a discount. Public demand for its retail products just isn’t strong enough for it to charge prices equal to Honda/Toyota/Nissan. Bottom line: GM makes little to no margin overall on its North American auto business. Not to put too fine a point on it, it’s unclear whether GM can ever make a profit in North America again.

As always, market share is key, and the signs are on the disastrous side of bad. Despite public pledges to reduce bulk sales, nearly 25% of GM's sales still go to fleets. Pull those sales out of the equation and GM's market share at the retail level is only about 19%, spread over eight brands. Take out employee/vendor pricing deals, and the true retail demand for GM products is less than Toyota’s.

Now consider this: GM's third-quarter North American market share slipped a percentage point compared to a year earlier. In light of Ford and DCX' falling market shares, GM’s highly-trumpeted “market share stabilization” actually means it’s losing ground to the so-called imports. That ain’t good. Conquesting sales from Ford and Chrysler is hard enough. Taking on the non-union guys over at Honda, Nissan and Toyota will be just about as hard as it sounds— if not harder.

GM’s balance sheet may not show this sort of mission critical information, but there’s plenty else to set off warning bells (for those who aren’t deaf to the dangers). What are we to make of the fact that GM drew on its secured line of credit in Q3, and then repaid the money? We’ve been saying for quite some time that GM’s wandering on the edges of a liquidity crisis. The sale of half of the GMAC finance unit grows more important by the day— especially considering the rapidly deteriorating asset quality of their mortgage/auto receivables. Are the loan loss reserves adequate? If not, bad things are bound to happen.

There are other "hidden" shoals, such as the psychological impact of federal changes in the rules regarding corporate accounting for pensions and other post-employment benefits. When they kick-in in ‘07, GM will have no stockholder equity. None. While the development won’t have any cash impact, the the development will bring to light the magnitude of the liabilities facing Generous Motors. It’s a huge negative, despite being downplayed by GM’s management. And if that isn't enough to convince GM execs to break out the Prozac, UAW negotiations are set to begin…

In short, GM’s future is far from secure. Wagoner’s highly touted “turnaround” is based on the idea that GM can return to profit without changing its business basics (downsizing does not equal change). It won’t because it can’t. It no longer has the time or the money to do so. But more than that, its management doesn’t have the will. The man who does— investor Kirk Kerkorian— knows that he’d have to destroy GM to save it. If he lives long enough, one way or another, it will come to pass. 

By on October 25, 2006

x04pn_az001222.jpgAutomotive history is littered with titanic failures. For every hot-selling Mustang, there’s a hatful (hateful?) of Vegas, Pintos, Excels, Yugos, Edsels and, of course, Azteks. From its introduction until its timely demise some four years later, the Pontiac Aztek SUV was the subject of journalistic dog-piling and a thousand weak jokes. But really, does it belong in this infamous company? The answer is a bit complicated; the Aztek was certainly a failure, but not exactly in the way you might expect.

First, let’s look at the Aztek’s indisputable failure: sales. Pontiac aimed to sell 75k Azteks a year. In its first model year (2001), GM shipped less than 10k Azteks to private buyers, dumped quite a few thousand on unfortunate middle-managers and sent the rest to the rental fleets. After an emergency re-style, a price-cut and deep discounts, sales climbed to around 25 – 27k units per year, and stayed there until the car’s demise. 

2001pontiacaztek-2222.jpgThe Aztek may have been a car lot pariah, but it was no Chevy Vega. There were no major recalls or horror stories involving melting engines. The model was as reliable as any GM vehicle of its time, cutting edge in many ways (CAD-CAM designed, red light dash, optional heads-up display), outdoorsy (could be converted into a camper, complete with built-in air compressor for your air mattress), lifestyle-oriented (racks for bikes, canoes, kayaks, etc.) and beloved (high scores on “CSI" owner surveys). Despite abuse from all quarters, the Aztek earned itself a group of passionate devotees.  

Even so, it bombed. So who exactly gets the blame for this so-called fiasco? Again, there's no denying that the engineers didn’t make it pretty, but they made it well. The UAW also gets a pass; GM built the Aztek (and Buick Rendezvous) in Mexico’s Ramos Arizpe plant. No, the blame lies squarely on the shoulders of GM's bean counters. That’s because the Aztek’s biggest problem wasn’t its confused looks (though they didn’t help). It was price.

The Aztek was designed for younger couples and families who didn’t want a great honking SUV. Pontiac priced the Aztek in the region of $25k to $30k. Unfortunately, the price was well into premium minivan and three-row SUV territory. The Aztek offered Versatrak all-wheel drive and a lot (a LOT) of cladding, but it fooled no one. The vehicle its makers labeled “quite possibly the most versatile vehicle on the planet” was priced at least $5k above its logical, non-SUV competition. 

x2pn_az04222.jpgGiven that most of the Aztek’s technology was off-the-shelf, and south-of-the-UAW labor costs were low, why was the initial asking price so high? When the Aztek was designed, Pontiac had no high profit SUV’s. When their line finally got an SUV (ok, a proto-crossover), Pontiac’s brass were hungry for big profit margins, despite the fact that the Aztek was a more-expensive unitary design. So GM cut production costs as deeply as possible and then set the retail price to deliver big profits while still undercutting Chevy’s mid-sized SUVs (Trailblazer). Great in theory, poison in practice.

Even so, why did GM/Pontiac think they could sell 75k Azteks? Of course, missing a sales target is hardly a novelty in the car industry, especially at General Motors. Even though the domestic automaker pays thousands of researchers huge amounts of money to find out how many people want (or think they want) what, no one has quite cracked that particular nut. The market research leading to the Aztek is locked away, deep inside GM's vaults. Did they ask the wrong questions, or simply draw the wrong conclusions? 

x05pn_az00322.jpgGM certainly was on to something with the Aztek's manufacturing system. Like Honda's Odyssey/Ridgeline twins, the Mexican plant could switch between Azteks and Rendezvous. Unfortunately, there wasn't enough demand for either vehicle to make the so-called "flexible" system work. In fact, GM has had some terrible luck with plants capable of making limited production runs, such as the now-closed Lansing facility (Reatta, EV1, SSR). As a result, the majority of GM's business is still built on big runs, with the “extra” (i.e. surplus to retail demand) units going to fleets. The company is still not set up to profit on small volumes for niche markets. Which is exactly what today's fragmenting market demands.

Now that it’s gone, many want to write off the Aztek as one of the great all-time automotive disasters. On the face of it (should you be able to look), it was. But in many important ways, it wasn’t. Again, the model broke new ground in many areas. The epitaph should not be “GM’s Edsel”. Or maybe it should. Edsel Ford was hounded by his famous father and ruined by the stress of holding a disintegrating company together. The Aztek died because it was forced to carry the hopes and dreams of an entire division, when it was just a decent, homely little people-carrier.

 

 

By on October 25, 2006

ma0025222.jpgEarlier this year, FoMoCo assembled a panel of “futurists” and “trend spotters” from academia, nonprofit organizations and the private sector to identify trends that could impact future product development. While people who’d never read Wired might say Ford needs to put out the fire in the kitchen before they make blueprints for a new bedroom, it’s also true that those who do not see the future are condemned to flashing double zeros on their VCR– I mean DVD-R. Anyway, at the risk of clouding Ford’s crystal ball, I’ve taken the liberty of preparing a couple of potential news releases as a rough guide to future automotive trends…

Hummer H7 Debuts  General Motors have finally unveiled their latest Hummer model, the H7. The H7 is Hummer’s first front wheel-drive SUV, sharing its basic platform and drivetrain with the Chevrolet Aveo. Bob Lutz, GM’s 107-year old Vice Chairman Emeritus, spoke enthusiastically about the new model: “The H7 shows Hummer’s firm commitment to improving fuel economy while providing all the off-road capability our market studies show the typical Hummer buyer needs.”

The H7 comes standard with 18” chrome wheels, nine inches of ground clearance, running boards and a snorkel-style air intake for its 1.2-liter hybrid diesel engine (licenced from Briggs & Stratton), along with five cup holders capable of holding Starbucks’ new gigantesco latte. Options include brush bars, a skid plate package, parking assist and hands-free cell phone. Prices are expected to start in the low-to-mid-20s, and fall from there.

Bill Ford's Operation Called a Success The Ford Motor Company announced today that former Chairman Bill Ford recently completed a highly experimental medical procedure. According to company Press Secretary Haki Yamomota, Mr. Ford’s radical new spine transplant was a complete success. Ford, who surrendered control of the family-owned automaker to CEO Alan Mulally immediately prior to its sale to Toyota, is already making some “bold moves.”  “His digestion is obviously in working order,” Yamamoto said. “He’ll start making tough decisions any day now."

Ford’s rehabilitation will continue with a special regimen of tasks designed to help him stand on his own two feet. “He’ll begin by telling his valet what he wants to wear for the day, without being able to change his mind, delegate the decision, fire or change the job title of any member of his domestic staff. From there, we hope he’ll figure out something to do with Ford’s two remaining Brands.”

Porsche PU  Hot on the heels of the successful Panamera sedan, Porsche AG has released concept drawings of a new pickup truck designed specifically for the American market, based on its next-generation Cayenne SUV. “The partial success of luxury vehicles like the Escalade EXT and the Lincoln Mark LT just about proved that Americans will buy anything with a pickup bed attached, regardless of price, utility or need,” claims Werner Schnitzel, Chief of New(ish) Product Development. “Our research clearly shows that there’s a market for a luxury-performance- off-road pickup truck for owners who’ve already bought our sports car, SUV and sedan.”

Schnitzel said the prototype Porsche pickup has been tested at the legendary Nürburgring race track, where it removed large pieces of privately owned exotic cars without incident. Schnitzel denied rumors that Porsche was developing an amphibious performance-speedboat-off-road-delivery van.

Car & Driver Names 100Best  In response to Motor Trend’s new “Car of the Week” award, Car and Driver released their “100Best” issue today. Editor-in-Chief Portly Emmental explained, “There are so many good cars out there today that restricting ourselves to ten vehicles didn't make any economic sense.”  The winners included everything built by BMW and Honda, along with a token Chevrolet and Chrysler. In a totally unrelated press release, Hachette Filipacchi Media U.S. announced that the words "Special Advertising Section" will now appear on the main cover of the magazine.

BMW Rebuffs Criticism of iCan’tDrive155  BMW went on the offensive today in response to the criticism aimed at their new control system, referred to by its detractors as iCan’tDrive155. The new voice-activated system operates everything from the glove box door operation to steering, and only responds to commands in perfectly inflected German. BMW claims the device was designed to make BMW's the ultimate hands-free driving machine. Owners report that the “hands-free” part of the system works fine, as they can’t figure out how to get the doors open.

Rejecting the complaints, spokesmeister Dieter Badenhoff stated “We know what is best for BMW owners. If they are unwilling to learn the proper operation of the system there’s nothing we can do.” In other news, the BMW's legal department has been granted a restraining order prohibiting anyone working for The Truth About Cars website to move any closer than 100 feet from any vehicle produced by BMW, or use any word rhyming with "bunt" in any product description.

The Truth About Cars Begins Toyota Death Watch Editor Robert Farago says he began the series due to the large number of Chinese built cars stealing market share from domestically-produced Toyotas. "It's only a matter of time," Farago said.

We offer these predictions in the hope it will help Ford develop a clearer vision of the automotive future. It’s at least as accurate– and much cheaper– than calling the Psychic Friends Network.

By on October 24, 2006

oacampodium222.jpgIs there any doubt that that Ford is heading for Chapter 11? Sure. There are plenty of auto industry eggheads and company officials who continue to believe that FoMoCo has what it takes– or will have what it takes at some point in the near to distant future– to pull out of its current corporate nosedive and return to greatness. OK, profitability. Um, how about market stabilization? Actually, at this point, staying out of Chapter 11 would be something of a victory. Meanwhile, Monday was Dia de los Muertos for The Blue Oval.

The headline number was almost enough to fell an elephant, never mind the bulls of Wall Street: $5.8b disappeared down the rat hole in the third financial quarter. In fact, Wall Street seemed unfazed, despite the announcement that Ford is in the process of lining-up a secured bank line facility. In other words, Ford's lenders will no longer fund on the committed unsecured line. The company will have to pay more money for its money, borrow more money and risk more of its tangible assets to keep the ship afloat. Needless to say, S&P was not impressed.

Ford's problems are a combination of continuing losses in NA and the huge cost of restructuring the business. While the $4b Ford is spending on downsizing will be spread out over time, The Blue Oval also has to fund product development, and there a lot of mouths competing for the corporate tit. As part of their ritual display of corporate entrails, Ford also revealed that they’re going to have to restate their earnings back to November 1947. OK, it’s “only” back to 2001, but this Accounting Odyssey is not good news. Oh, and Ford wants us to know that things are going to get worse before they get worse.

“Both the third quarter and fourth quarter of this year will be tough because of the production cuts on trucks and SUVs," Ford’s Chief Financial Officer (CFO) Don Leclair admitted, quashing the notion that the new Edge/MKX cross-border crossover will toss the floundering automaker a Taurus-like lifeline. "In addition, the first half of next year also will be tough." Coming off a $5.8b loss, what the Hell does “tough” mean? With $23.6b in the bank, the necessity to maintain [at least] a $5b pad just to keep the lights on, and a year-to-date hemorrhage knocking on $7.2b, she kennay take much more Captain!

FoMoCo helmsman Alan Mulally was so aghast/mortified at the results that he stopped making sense. “These business results are clearly unacceptable. Not just because they're unacceptable, [but] because this is not a viable business going forward with this kind of business model." When the tongue-tied CEO of America’s soon-to-be third largest automaker says his company’s financial results are unacceptably unacceptable, you know his employer is, um, struggling. And what’s with the broken business model routine? You’d think Ford’s newly-minted jeffe would’ve progressed beyond the “yup it sucks” part of the program by now.

I know, Big Al’s only been using the executive washroom (and corporate jet) for a few weeks. But FoMoCo’s running out of time. Aside from dumping $2b domestically, their hi-falutin’ Premier Auto Group (Jaguar, Volvo, Land Rover and Aston Martin) drained another $593m. Anyone who thinks that Ford’s should hang onto these foreign entanglements (save Volvo) any longer than say, next Thursday, should not pass Go or collect a thirty-five million dollar paycheck.

Yes sir; it’s time for some of them bold moves we keep hearing about. Aside from deeply worrying questions about Ford’s liquidity– which could force the company-killing “run on the bank” supplier scenario previously posited for GM– Ford’s product mix is about as appetizing as Aunt Jemima’s pancake batter formulated with battery acid. At the same time, Ye Olde Cash Cow is looking sickly. Ford Motor Credit Company is getting seriously squeezed, thanks to margin compression and a simple (if deadly) drop in automotive volume (down 64k units from last year's third quarter). 

Although the Detroit News’ article on Ford’s losses dissed The Truth About Cars’ prognostication of a GM Chapter 11, the situation is so bad at Ford the august publication is happy to bandy about the “b” word for The Blue Oval. Why the disparity? Apparently, Bill Vlasic thinks FoMoCo's situation is different from the General’s: “GM, which reports its third-quarter earnings on Wednesday, has attacked its costs by completing a massive buyout of blue-collar workers and beginning a series of plant shutdowns. GM is also rolling out a redesigned line of pickup trucks that compete directly with Ford's older models.” I guess he missed the bit about Ford’s massive buyout of blue-collar workers, its series of plant closures and its soon-to-be-refreshed pickups.

Never mind. The stupid money is now on GM, as their inflated stock price proves. And no wonder. GM’s CEO is the company’s former CFO, a man with a storied history of playing fast and loose with the company’s books, to the point where department heads rolled and results were re-reported. Ford’s upcoming restatement of its earnings shows FoMoCo is not immune to the dubious charms of creative accounting. But the simple truth is that all three domestic automakers are in the same boat, and it’s leaking like crazy. The funny things is, if Ford ends-up beating GM to Chapter 11, it may finally find the edge it’s looking for.

By on October 24, 2006

zoom-zoom2222.jpgI'm fresh back from a Mazda marketing boondoggle called “Zoom-Zoom Live." Ford's Japanese brand conducted these ride 'n drives in major markets across the US: DC, Boston, New York, Miami, Houston, Dallas, Atlanta and Chicago. I attended the San Francisco event [actually on a decommissioned Naval air base in Alameda, but the SF skyline was visible]. These kind of "bring the consumers to the product and let 'em loose" deals are supposedly the wave of the future, "high-touch" marketingspeakwise. Unfortunately, car companies seem to have a very strange idea of what "let 'em loose" actually means. 

Upon arrival, we were parked in designated areas – Mazda owners and performance cars over here, please – then herded into the Registration tent. Organizers quickly made with the paperwork: a form releasing Mazda from any responsibility for anything, ever. Just in case that didn't cow us into submission, a smiling Mazda rep read us the riot act and pinned us with some stinking badges– which had to be worn at all times. A (static) Mazdaspeed 6 and a CX-7 whetted our automotive appetites while we waited for the mandatory advance penance video. This paean to pistonhead performance tried to convince us that Mazda is the only brand producing passion on planet earth, narrated by a man wearing a polo shirt without a Mazda logo.

Finally, we were cut loose. Gimme a steering wheel! Well, wait just a minute there buddy-san. Or 120. When signing up online, we were invited to select a starting time. It quickly became obvious that temporal measurement was provided by Albert Einstein; the process was nothing more than a relatively feeble attempt to create an even flow of mass over the event’s two day time – space continuum. Meanwhile, we perused tents displaying all of Mazda's fine products. Except the Mazdaspeed 3 (MS3). And the Tribute. And the MPV. And the B-Series truck (which was probably just as well, since the event was about driving, not plodding about with mulch). Other tents sheltered Mazda engines, the new MX-5 Retractable Hardtop and, oddly, a neglected slot car track. A roach coach served up greasy grub for g-force nausea induction.

We had four different coned tracks from which to pick, The "Mazdaspeed Challenge" was a half-mile hike away, where the lines were deeply reminiscent of a certain mouse-themed amusement park (30-minute wait, 25-second ride). In fact, the the hang time for a MazdaSpeed6 (MS6) stretched over two hours. The "Sports Course" was another Rip Van Winkle deal, [eventually] ending with some seat time in an MX-5 or RX-8. The "Matched Time Gymkhana" was a shorter wait, as was the "CX-7 Target Hunt." This something-less-than-PC event gave attendees the chance to shoot rolling cardboard cutouts of the Ford Edge and Buick Enclave with a large caliber paintball gun.

Not really. Pilots drove Mazda's new CUV down a closed course, aiming towards (but not directly at) a set of yellow cones. Our aim: run the CX-7’s nose sensor so that the outside edge of your left front wheel steers between 6 and 18 inches from each of these yellow cones, and complete the course within a specified time frame. I did neither very well, proving what? The CX-7’s sight lines and maneuverability are just as crummy as any numb and inept SUV. Most excellent marketing Ted!

The Gymkhana was a bit more fun, but many of us forgot that the point was to match a time, not to go as fast as humanly possible. This is not advisable in a “Multi Activity Vehicle,” as evidenced by the number of drivers who negotiated curves in the Mazda 5 on three wheels– only to be shown the exit gate by some sour-faced Mazkateers. The outside rear left tread on one of the 5’s was completely worn. All of the vehicles presented for our dining and dancing pleasure had autoboxes or, at best, manumatics. This was probably a good thing.

On the Sports Course, four MX-5's were evenly equipped with manuals and automatics, the latter quite rightly shunned by unqualified drivers in search of public humiliation. Waiting in line, we were entertained by "contestants" who stalled and shuddered their way to the starting line, accompanied by a chorus of most unsportsmanlike hoots and hollers. The event organizers needed a wiffle bat to pound these drivers about the head into the slushbox cars. Those of us who are three pedals proficient waited impatiently, inhaling the acrid smell of burning clutches in the morning. I asked for a list of VINs at exit, so I wouldn't meet any of these vehicles on the used market. Very funny sir. Request denied.

At the end of this [non-Tapscott] carnival of cars, we were awarded “points” in the great Whose Line Is It Anyway? tradition. We were then handed an exit questionnaire and a hat. I’m sure we’ll see an emailed post-briefing, just in case we want to see how badly the data capture fiends had mispelled our names.

From a TTAC industry observer's POV, the most interesting part of the program was the demographics of those inattentive– I mean, in attendance. Fully 90% of the participants were 20-somethings. So where was the MS3? If you're trying to build street cred with a touchy-feely demo, why keep your star player in the locker room? Sure the great unwashed (though not fully indebted) might have broken it, but c'mon. Who's zooming who?

By on October 23, 2006

airflow22.jpgAs the launch of Ford’s new Edge illustrates, the Big Two Point Five’s next “great white-walled hope” is something called the “cross-over.” It’s not a traditional SUV and it’s not a road-hugging car. It could be a station wagon on stilts with [optional] four-wheel drive and maybe even a hybrid powerplant, but it’s definitely not for towing [much] or plugging [deep] mud or surmounting [any] boulders. From the waves of hype you’d think this less-than-genetically gifted half-breed was a revolutionary development. Actually, it’s a vehicle design from the second half of the last century.

Back in the day, automakers mounted an engine, transmission and wheels onto a metal framework (called a “ladder frame” for its shape). The bodywork was then attached to the frame, which carried all the weight. It was simple, sturdy and made customization easy; whether turning a Model-T into a pickup truck or putting a custom body on a $10k Duesenberg chassis. The problem with this early construction technique was simple enough: weight. It takes more fuel to motivate heavy than light.

The next big idea in auto body construction came courtesy the airplane industry, where weight-saving is mission critical (yes I know it’s really “mass” physics boy, back off). Instead of setting the body on a load-bearing frame, the frame is the body, and vice-versa. The substantial weight savings delivered by this so-called unitary construction technique allowed for smaller engines and reduced vibrations. The first mass-produced American car to incorporate these ideas (and airplane-like streamlining) was Chrysler’s Airflow. It was a car that many manufacturers copied, but very few people bought.

Despite the Airflow fiasco, unitary construction slowly began to win favor within the American automobile industry. The Big Three lagged behind smaller companies like Nash and Hudson; body-on-frame construction was more practical for yearly model changes (since only the shell had to change). Even so, Lincoln went unitary in 1958, and other models slowly followed. Many of the American cars (and even the revolutionary Mini) kept a separate frame mounting to hold the engine, even when their bodies went unitary. While construction methodology changed, there was no great shift in the type of cars being built.

It wasn’t for lack of trying. Back in the ‘60’s, a team at Ford developed an idea for a people-carrier built on a unitary platform. As detailed in David Halberstam‘s “The Reckoning,” despite great customer survey results, they were never able to sell the vehicle internally. One reason: it needed a new (front wheel-drive) platform. A decade on, most of the Ford team had moved to Chrysler (who had the requisite platform). The minivan was born.        

While the minivan dented the ladder frame-based “conversion” market, the truck and van market remained the last great refuge of the old manufacturing technique (aside from the Ford Crown Victoria triplets). A ladder frame made it much easier to customize a chassis for special uses (delivery van, camper, flat bed, etc.). The extra weight involved was balanced by the need for additional strength for hauling/towing (which a commercial user actually needs). Plus, ladder frames are cheaper to build.

When SUVs began to take off in the late eighties, consumers discovered ladder frame construction’s weak points. The vehicles were heavy (i.e. thirsty), top-heavy (i.e. unstable), rode like trucks (of course) and interior space was not nearly as large as it appeared from the outside. The Big Three improved their truck’s brakes and fitted plusher interiors, but ladder frames ruled because, well, no one complained. And they’re cheap (i.e. more profitable).

Japanese automakers cashed-in on the SUV trend with whatever trucks they could muster. But they also saw a case for a small pseudo-SUV, especially in their own backyard. Toyota and Honda developed nearly parallel solutions on their small-car, unitary platforms: the RAV-4 and CR-V. The “uni-utes” found soon found fame and fortune on the other side of the Pacific. Eventually Honda and Toyota gave the same treatment to a family-size car, creating a macho brother to their mini-vans. Subaru already specialized in four-wheel drive wagons, so their Forester wasn’t much of a stretch (though interesting as a “missing link”).

While these “crossovers” couldn’t match their bigger brethren for towing or rock hopping, they carried more people for less gas and handle more like a car. In the last few years, The Big Two Point Five has finally responded, releasing a few crossovers to significant sales– without denting the existing competitors’ market share. And therein lies the problem with The Big Two Point Five’s desire to “cross over” into renewed prosperity: they’re not creating a new niche, they’re moving into an existing one. Sad to say, their track record in that regard leaves much to be desired. Besides, if you’re constantly changing your running shoes in the middle of a marathon, you may be quicker than you were, but you’ll also be last.

By on October 22, 2006

x07ct_up0011222.jpgLater today, I’ll compose an email to The Truth About Cars’ (TTAC) coterie of writers asking them to select the final candidates for our Ten Worst Automobiles Today (TWAT) awards. Thanks to Mr. Williams’ organizational OCD, our best and brightest will have a most Excel-ent spreadsheet of all the vehicles you’ve nominated, with your reasons for doing so. Frank will collate their choices. By mid-week, we should have both the final 20 and the software we need to throw it to you for a democratic vote. Again, thank you for your help and support. Before the deal goes down, I want to highlight the importance of this award to all of us.

The purchase of a new or used vehicle is the average consumer’s second largest financial expenditure, after their house. While most of us here are pistonheads who’ve elevated this acquisition to something approaching a religious commitment, it’s important to remember that most motorists share neither our passion nor knowledge. To select their next vehicle, they rely on you, their friendly neighborhood automotive alpha, and, increasingly, the new media. JD Power recently revealed that US car buyers spend some six hours on the net researching their next car purchase. That’s more time than I spent to choosing my investment portfolio. (Both shares.)

TTAC has a large influence in this electronic sphere. Google “Ford Fusion SEL.” We’re number one. Google “Chevrolet Aveo.” We’re number seven. The vast majority of our reviews lie within the top 20 Google listings. Yes, we’re still small potatoes compared to the e-tuber mountains called Edmunds.com and kbb.com. But we are still the largest “take no prisoners” automotive review site on the web. Those of you who believe that these e-monoliths equal our commitment to tell the “truth” about cars, consider their reviews of a couple of our TWATs.

Take the Jeep Compass [please], a heavy favorite for a TWAT. Edmunds’ review acknowledges the vehicle's brand betrayal, dismisses it as irrelevant, and then tries to damn the model: “We're not so sure the brand's first crossover delivers what young urbanites are looking for.” And Darwinism is unproven. “The interior of our test car was also plagued with a few fit and finish issues like misaligned trim, manufacturing flash and bunched carpeting.” Plagued with a few? “The result is an interior that screams ‘rental car,’ which is a shame, because the seats are unquestionably comfortable and the driving position is excellent.”

Bottom line? “The Jeep, like the Caliber, is also generally satisfying to drive, quite affordable and sometimes fun. Comfortable, too. But upscale? Fashionable? Refined? Ah, not so much.” Obviously and in relation to their other critiques, Edmunds is not so much enamored with the Compass. Yes, well, why doesn’t reviewer Scott Oldham simply come our and say the Compass blows? Two guesses and the first one can’t have the word “advertising” in it. Hey, at least we got Edmunds to admit that the manufacturer loaned them the vehicle.

Kbb.com hasn’t reviewed the Compass. But they have cast their electronic eyes upon the Uplander, the Chevrolet minivan our reviewer William C. Montgomery called “a half-assed has-been that never was and never shoulda been.” Kbb doesn’t quite see it that way. Their unnamed sage proclaims the interior “one of the nicest you’ll find in any minivan” and “the Uplander is well-suited to the needs of small families.” Fair enough– if you’re a masochist who harbors a near-murderous hatred for your family.

As you’d expect, the situation is even worse in the print media. I just received AutoWeek’s “07 Ultimate Car, Truck and Sport/UTE Buyers Guide,” bundled with my weekly issue. Jeep Compass? “While not ‘Trail Rated,’ the Compass offers many Jeep-like qualities to fend off incursions from the growing number of crossovers.” So that’s alright then. After perusing all the “Our Opinion” summaries of the vehicles named, I found myself searching (in vain) for the words “Special Advertising Section.” And yes, Jeep has a full-page ad within Crain Communications' “ultimate” guide (albeit touting the Wrangler).

Clearly, there’s still a need for an automotive website that’s willing to tell it like it is for the public good and, let’s face it, our mutual amusement. While this article (and our award) are predicated on the theory that by thy willingness to slag-off a loser thy shall be known, it’s important to remember that TTAC is just as quick to identify and praise automotive quality wherever we find it. Despite being banned by BWM from their press vehicles and launch events, we’re happy to declare that we LOVE the new 335i.

In short, our readers are our first, last and only priority. We’re proud to be able to serve you with the plain, unvarnished truth about cars. The TWAT awards symbolize and extend that “brand positioning.” Again, thank you for the opportunity to provide this service. 

Since this article was written, we've begun voting on the '06 TWAT awards.

Please click HERE to cast your vote on the final 10. You will be returned to the TTAC home page.

By on October 22, 2006

istanbul_kimmi2222.jpgSo that’s it. F1’s greatest talent will not win the 2006 World Drivers Championship (WDC). Michael Schumacher admitted as much after last week’s Japanese GP, when engine failure sidelined his car and his hopes of an eighth title. “One cannot always win and things do not always go as planned.” Although Schuey threw in the proverbial towel, there is a way he could snatch victory from the jaws of defeat: if he wins the final race of the season and Renault pilot Fernando Alonso fails to score a single point. It’s not likely. But one thing is for sure: next year’s F1 will be the sport’s new dawn.

Ferrari and Renault remain heavy favorites for the 2007 constructor’s championship, though they should face significant pressure from teams lower down in the pecking order. Red Bull Racing will bring the brand new Adrian Newey-designed RB3 to the track. Given Newey's reputation at McLaren, the  RB3 could emerge as a strong contender for the checkered flag– although the McLaren cars' rep for unreliability could mean that Red Bull is unlikely to remain competitive with the top teams for the duration of the season. Toyota’s impressive late-season performance has hinted at the team’s potential. With a blank slate and a blank check, we may well see Toyota challenging for the constructors' title– provided they can motivate the two stiffs they employ as drivers (Ralf Schumacher and Jarno Trulli).

In terms of the World Drivers' Championship, common wisdom holds Kimi Raikkonen as the front runner for next year’s title. Though universally acclaimed as a phenomenal driver, Raikkonen’s championship aspirations have been thwarted by the aforementioned mechanical "issues" over at McLaren. The Iceman’s move to the Ferrari team will finally provide F1 fans a chance to see how good the young Finn really is. Over the last few years, the Scuderia has shown itself peerless in race car design, quality and execution. Aside from the Ferrari team's mechanical prowess, their corporate culture will give the young Finn the backup he needs to concentrate on the job at hand.

Combined with Raikkonen’s well-deserved reputation for relying on his “attachments” (thank you David Hobbs), Kimi should set a blazing pace straight out of the box. In Hobbs’ immortal words, “that Kimi’s a brave boy." In other words, Raikkonen's a Ferrari ace in the classic mold. Back when Enzo Ferrari stalked the halls of Maranello, the Scuderia was known for bringing in young, reckless, extremely quick drivers; many of whom didn’t live out their time in scarlet (see Derrick “Death” Daley’s The Cruel Sport for a fascinating look at the period). Kimi should fit in well with the prevailing ethos, and provide the team with another guiding spirit.

Next season will also go down as first “Year of the Manufacturers.” Manufacturer teams will compromise more of the field in 2007 than ever before. There will be only a handful on privateers on the grid, as many of the independent teams have become little more than adjuncts of the manufacturer teams that supply their engines. This is a trend that is sure to continue in the years to come; whether for good or ill remains to be seen.

The freeze on engine development instituted by the FIA could well be the most significant change for '07. The engines that teams ran over the last two weekends of this season will be homologated for use through the 2010 season. Given the political volatility surrounding F1, it's highly unlikely that the strict, [ostensibly] long-term regulations will remain as they are now. But they signal a significant shift in the sport’s technological development paradigm for the foreseeable future. “Free” from the need to spend significant funds on engine development, aerodynamic development will become paramount.

This development is good news for some teams, particularly Red Bull Racing. When RBR “recruited” Adrian Newey from McLaren this year, they secured one of F1’s premier aerodynamicists. While Newey arrived too late to make a significant impact on the current RB2 racecar, its successor, the RB3, will be a clean sheet Newey design. While untested, it should provide a huge performance leap for the team. In the off-season, we should also see some clever aerodynamic solutions from the rest of the teams vying for pole position.

In short, the 2007 F1 season will be like none before. Despite the much-lamented FIA rule changes, new story lines will arise to breathe new life into both the drivers’ and the constructors’ championships. Raikkonen in scarlet, the consolidation of manufacturer power and Schumi’s absence should all provide ample entertainment and a highly competitive championship. For the first time in years, F1 is wide-open.

Recent Comments

  • Lou_BC: @Carlson Fan – My ’68 has 2.75:1 rear end. It buries the speedo needle. It came stock with the...
  • theflyersfan: Inside the Chicago Loop and up Lakeshore Drive rivals any great city in the world. The beauty of the...
  • A Scientist: When I was a teenager in the mid 90’s you could have one of these rolling s-boxes for a case of...
  • Mike Beranek: You should expand your knowledge base, clearly it’s insufficient. The race isn’t in...
  • Mike Beranek: ^^THIS^^ Chicago is FOX’s whipping boy because it makes Illinois a progressive bastion in the...

New Car Research

Get a Free Dealer Quote

Who We Are

  • Adam Tonge
  • Bozi Tatarevic
  • Corey Lewis
  • Jo Borras
  • Mark Baruth
  • Ronnie Schreiber