Category: Editorials

By on July 29, 2006

Z28studio.jpgThe sound jolted me from my reverie at a stoplight in a small town just east of San Antonio.  It sounded like a weed whacker farting.  I heard it again.  I looked to my left.  In the lane next to my Z/28 sat a two-door Hyundai Accent with Beavis at the wheel and Butthead riding shotgun.  It had the obligatory coffee can-sized muffler hanging below the rear valence.  Bolted to the deck lid: an erector set-type spoiler that looked like it weighed more than the rest of the car.  Beavis (or maybe it was Butthead) had plastered the fenders and doors with decals of kanji characters and there was a bright red VTEC sticker splayed across the top of the windshield.  It looked as though they had just seen “The Fast and the Furious” and they were out to cop some street creds in their killer kimchee burner.

Beavis revved the engine a third time and they both looked at me in slack-jawed expectation.  I raised one eyebrow, Spock-like, then rolled my eyes, shook my head slightly and went back to watching the red light.  Undaunted, Beavis blipped the throttle yet again.  This time the car lunged forward slightly.  Obviously he was spoiling for a fight.  After all, what did he have to fear from the middle-aged guy in the rear wheel drive midlife crisis car with an automatic transmission who was listening to the same music his grandparents liked?  What was that group?  Something called The Beach Boys?  What could a fogey like that possibly know about cool street machines?  I decided to teach him that he should be careful what he wished for.

The light turned green.  Beavis must have had the engine fully tached up because he actually managed to chirp the Hyundai’s front tires when he took off.  He was winding the engine for all it was worth, blaaat-blaaaaat-ing through the gears.  I sat there and watched the show as they headed toward the next stoplight about a mile up the road, at full throttle. 

After waiting a three-count I took off.  No drama, no smoke, no squealing tires.  Just the transfer of copious amounts of all-American torque to the tarmac, accompanied by the mellifluous soundtrack of the LS1’s 310 horses.   It’s the sweetest music this side of heaven, but a sound that’s totally foreign to a generation raised on four-cylinder front-drive econoboxes and SUV poseurmobiles.  It’s a sound I don’t think B & B ever heard before, and probably one they didn’t soon forget. 

As I closed in on them I could tell they were beginning to panic.  I could see them both lurching back and forth in their seats as though they hoped their bodily inertia would improve their forward momentum. The frantic exhaust note told me the Accent was giving its all to the cause, but to no avail.  B & B were about to experience first hand what happens when youthful ignorance and arrogance run head first into the cruel, unyielding roadblock of reality. 

The end was mercifully quick.  Before I got halfway to redline in second gear, I passed them and gave them a slight wave.  (Yes, I used my entire hand.)  Their expressions were priceless, like they’d just learned the truth about Santa Claus, the Easter Bunny and the tooth fairy all at once, in a single blinding flash.  I actually felt sorry for them– for a moment. 

Then my pity gave way to laughter as I considered the utter ridiculousness of the situation.  I felt a little like Evelyn Couch (Kathy Bates) in the parking lot scene from “Fried Green Tomatoes” – minus the willful destruction of personal property, of course – scoring a small victory for old farts everywhere.  As you get older, such victories are fewer and further between.  You take ‘em when and where you can get ‘em, and you revel in ‘em as long as you can.

I drove that same route every day for about a year.  I never saw Beavis, Butthead or that Hyundai again.  I’d like to think they pushed it off in the nearest arroyo and invested their money in a real car and some driving lessons.  And hopefully by now they’ve learned kanji isn’t Korean and that VTEC has no relevance to a Hyundai.  Probably not, though.  They probably just added more decals, ground effects and badges to that poor Hyundai and kept on getting humiliated.   Either that or they’ve moved on the latest fad and donked their whip with 26-inch spinners, candy paint and Lambo doors. 

And me?  I still enjoy the Beach Boys. I now drive a six-speed Corvette instead of the Z/28.  I still enjoy an occasional stoplight challenge, too.  Anyone with a Sonata want to run for pinks?

By on July 28, 2006

mazda323.jpgYou’ll never see one on the cover of a buff book or tuner title. They’re never the subject of motorsports art.  Chip Foose's Overhaulin' crew wouldn’t touch one with a ten foot spanner. But for every pristine vintage roadster, numbers matching cruise night star and drag strip trailer queen, there are millions of "beaters” out there, saving wear and tear on a car owner's pride and joy or just racking-up the miles.  A non-descript econo-box, compact hatchback, sedan, four-cylinder pickup or mini-van, the beater is motoring’s unsung hero.

The classic beater is an integral part of mainstream family life.  I have fond memories of our family's 1960 Buick LeSabre, christened the "Blue Witch.”  On long weekend road trips, confined to the back seat, our youthful imaginations stretched to relieve the monotony of long Sunday drives.  If we grew tired and napped, we awoke with nubby damask patterns etched on our cheeks.  By the same token, I remember the grey seats of a friend's parent's Renault that ferried us to and from swimming lessons while we sang Partridge Family songs (mea culpa), marking the vinyl with our wet bathing suits.  A green Plymouth sedan– boring as Danny Partridge’s do– eventually became The Millennium Falcon to my pre-teen cohorts. 

And who can forget their very first set of wheels?  For most of us it wasn't a fancy performance machine, a new car or even a nice car.  It was whatever we could get our hands on– after we’d begged, borrowed and yes, worked for the cash.  Mine was a Nissan Micra.  I quickly became adept at beater basics: the 'running-push-and-leap-in’ start, bending clothes hangers to temporarily hold up the exhaust and 1001 uses of duct tape. Don’t knock it: the beater gave us glorious mobility.

Writing this, I cast occasional glances out the window where falling petals from a neighboring crab apple tree are busy blanketing my 1997 Dakota pickup truck.  A picturesque scene perhaps, but it only serves to emphasize how long it’s been since the Dodge truck last moved.  A wheel bearing that needs replacing accounts for its current state of immobility.  It isn't a huge or costly job, just another addition to a lengthy list of future household expenses which must, alas, await additional income. 

I'd rather not add up what I’ve spent on this vehicle over the past six or seven years.  One (not me) could probably think of it in terms of groups of matching appliances, exotic Caribbean trips, home renovation projects or a normal, sane person's retirement savings plan.  Somewhere in the last couple of years, I crossed that invisible line between conscientious vehicle maintenance and obsessive compulsive custom hobby. This leap, of course, necessitated buying something that I could actually drive, you know, when I need to. A beater.

That’s why I purchased a Mazda 323 for less than the price of the tires that encircle my pampered pickup's custom rims. The Japanese sedan isn't much to look at (a statement that could also have been made fourteen years ago when it was new).  But $20 in regular fuel keeps it running between two paychecks.  It doesn't sulk if I forget the date of its last oil change. It slugs through the worst that winter can dish out and starts unfailingly during cold snaps. Snow hasn't stopped it yet, although deep ruts slow it down. It chugs along determinedly, with little-engine-that-could stoicism. Stalling and unexpected drifting displays are not part of its repertoire; unlike, I might add, its prima donna pickup counterpart.

The onboard Hanes manual has proved useful as an impromptu cushion when the sagging driver's seat suspension becomes a little too relaxed for sustained driving.  As familiar as an old glove, the beater’s interior offers no-frills comfort.  When I discover my nephew's cuisine– half a cream cheese bagel stuck to the seat back– I snicker, instead of a gasp in horror and rush to the car spa.  The nondescript carpeting bears witness to countless Tim Horton's spilled on shared road trips.  With the hatch flipped up and the seats flopped down, the beater’s cargo hold has played host to dogs and horseback gear, bags of grain, a set of spare tires, assorted building materials and a mountain bike.

My beater may not be pretty, but every scuff, scrape, dent and spill tells a story.  That should be enough reason to remember those oil changes.  But no, we tend take our beaters for granted– until that sad day when they simply aren't up to their humble, but essential task. Then, we have a decision to make. Unfortunately, despite years of faithful service and unfailing reliability, the scrap yard is usually the final destination. Perhaps one day Barrett-Jackson will tout compacts and K-cars as the new cool and beaters will earn their just reward.

By on July 27, 2006

crash222.jpgCruising into Newport in Maserati's Quattroporte (review to follow), I watched a Mitsubishi Starion drive straight through a stop sign and slam into the side of a BMW 3-Series sedan.  Despite my reputation for unbridled, acid-tongued cynicism, my first thought was the same as yours: is everybody all right?  After ascertaining that the meat wagon wasn't a life or death issue (at least as far as I could tell), and that plenty of gawkers had stopped to gawk, my second thought was less charitable: if I pull over as a witness, how long would it cut into my 24-hour test drive?  And then I saw the Starion driver get out of his relatively unmolested POS and check his front fender for damage and I felt an enormous urge to stop, jump out and clock the guy.  So my question is this: how do we get these stupid bastards off our roads? Better (i.e. not speed-obsessed) enforcement?  Higher driving standards?  How about any driving standards?  I'm not saying anything about the Starion driver's ethnicity, but why are some states giving driving licenses to illegal immigrants who can't speak English?  What the Hell kind of driving test doesn't require enough English literacy to read a warning sign?  Your thoughts?

By on July 27, 2006

storm.jpgAccording to GM, happy days are here again.  Profits are up, costs are down and the company’s turnaround plan is on track.  The automotive media have swallowed The General’s spiel hook, line and sinker.  The financial markets are ready, willing and able to view The General’s second quarter losses through the automaker’s prism of perpetual positivism, sending GM’s stock price to its highest level since last October.  Well folks, it ain’t necessarily so…

First, let’s not forget that a $3.2b dollar loss is a $3.2b dollar loss.  Sure, if GM hadn’t bought out 34,410 UAW workers’ contracts, it might’ve made a $1.2b profit.  And if my grandmother had wheels, she’d be one of those trolley cars that GM removed from city streets in the 40’s.  More to the point, GM’s US market share is still in decline, down 3.1% from last year, to 24%.  Until and unless that changes, the “one time charges” related to production downsizing won’t be enough.  Or, if you prefer, they signal the beginning of a trend, not the end.

So if things are so bad for GM, where did all the profit come from?  As TTAC’s Deep Throat has pointed out, GM’s public promise to wean itself off fleet sales, to boost residuals and transaction prices, isn’t being born out at the sharp end.  In the second financial quarter, GM sold at least 120k high content units to rental fleets.  The General also sold their new LWB GMT-900 SUV’s to dealers, which carry fat margins.  [NB: In this case, “sold” means shipped to dealers.]

And then there’s accounting. For the second financial quarter’s statement, GM made some pension calculation adjustments, reduced their warranty charge (lowering their warranty reserve fund on the supposition that their vehicles are getting better), booked some workers costs (which previously appeared as expenses) against previously charged restructuring costs and benefitted from a strengthening Canadian dollar. 

In fact, if not for the GMAC dividend of $900m, GM’s cash position wouldn’t have changed.  So while it looks like The General’s making earnings, cash generation from operations isn’t getting better.  GM still has an inventory problem at its dealers, which isn’t going to go away without massive incentives.  And thanks to hundreds of thousands of “zero percent financing for anyone with a pulse” deals, the loan rate buy down is probably on the order of several thousand dollars per vehicle. 

Pistonheads have a better grasp of the situation than the bean counters.  They know GM has failed to produce a runaway best seller (or sellers) to replace their [once] hugely profitable SUV’s.  They know that it’s business as usual down at their local Buick, Chevy, Cadillac, Saab, Saturn, GMC and Pontiac dealer— at least from a product point of view.  From a financial perspective, there’s been a huge change.  Again, GM’s dealers have been writing bad paper; lots and lots of bad paper. 

It’s Mitsubishi redux.  The Japanese manufacturer’s US fortunes foundered on the rocks of easy credit, when hundreds of thousands of borrowers defaulted on their loans.  There is every reason to believe GM’s bad paper will also spontaneously combust, leaving dealer lots stuffed with vehicles no one wants and a big old hole in their accounts receivable.  The practice may appear better than offering large discounts on slow selling GM products.  But if you think about the implications of writing bad loans in the medium to long term, it isn’t. 

There are other dark clouds on the horizon. GM watchers seem to have forgotten about bankrupt auto parts supplier Delphi.  While most industry wonks discount the possibility of a strike– now that GM’s paid thousands of Delphi’s UAW workers not to work– there’s still an August drop deadline for union – management agreement, and no agreement.  At the same time, we hear ominous rumblings that other GM suppliers may not make it out of Chapter 11. And while analysts have hip-hip-hoorayed GM’s job cuts and plants closures, they would do well to remember that reducing production in the third financial quarter will create a significant drop in revenue. 

Meanwhile, the list of assets GM put on the line for its new secured credit facility should give GM boosters pause for thought: “certain” North American accounts receivables, unspecified vehicle inventories, the entire Saturn brand, its Canadian operating unit (plants and property) and 65% of GM de Mexico.  In short, The General has wandered into the pawn shop with a large list of assets to secure credit it once enjoyed on the back of its income.  Add GM’s dicey cash position and the situation doesn’t fill me with $30 a share confidence in the company’s future.  But hey, that’s me.

The real bottom line is that GM is a car maker.  There’s only one way out of their current death spiral: produce enough vehicles that people want to buy at a price that makes the company enough profit to stay in business.  It still ain’t happening.   

             

By on July 26, 2006

Z06.jpgWhatever else you can say about the Chevrolet Corvette, it isn’t a halo vehicle. Yes, it beats the Hell out of anything in its class and out bang-for-the-buck’s the big boys. But there’s not a single enthusiast driving around in an Impala SS thinking, "Oh yeah — I got the same AC vents as a 'Vette." In terms of appearance, the Avalanche resembles the Corvette about as much as Paul Giamati looks like Keira Knightley.  Contrast this with the Porsche Carrera GT. Despite the astronomical price gap between the GT and an entry level Boxster, the family face is intact and the underlying product philosophy is identical: speed, handling, fun.  That’s why it’s time for GM to use “America’s Sports Car” as the basis of an entirely new division– with Nissan.

Here's my pitch: merge The Jackal’s finest whips with Rabid Rick’s meanest metal.  Pull every Nissan and GM two door with a powerful front-mounted engine driving the rear wheels into a new Nissan/GM performance division. Sitting atop the heap: the 7.0-liter Z06.  Even without considering the stroked, supercharged 650+ HP "Blue Devil," the Corvette has finally surmounted its “also ran” status to achieve respect and admiration (unlike, say, the Aveo).  If ever a car deserved its own brand, if ever a model possessed the gravitas needed to carry a new company on its broad shoulders, it’s the Corvette. 

Half a rung below the mighty Vette: Nissan’s GT-R (nee Skyline).  The upcoming Japanese supercar may lack the Vette’s historical importance, but its gonzo performance rep would give the new division added glory.  And it would provide an answer to Porsche's exhaust-fed, AWD Turbo. A low-weight two-seater with 450hp driving all the wheels and a Nürburgring-fettled chassis equals major craziness. In fact, the GT-R might deliver enough performance to rival the Z06. Hang on; two cut-price uber-cars on the same team competing in the same niche?  Damn straight.

This is where the new division would have to be smart. They mustn’t neuter their model lineup to fit some rigid stepped marketing strategy, Zuffenhausen-style (i.e. the most powerful Cayman has less power than a stripped 911). Let all the division’s cars be their own mighty selves. With both the Z06 and the GT-R in the same showroom, GM/Nissan would offer performance-minded consumers a one-two punch that few contemporary carmakers could counter. The rest of the sports car ratpack would have to take the threat seriously.

Of course, the tricky part is deciding what to sell further down the food chain. The Chevrolet Camaro and the Nissan Z are natural enemies– unless the Z is re-fashioned to resemble a baby GT-R. Nissan’s versatile FM platform is already set up to handle four wheels a 'turning (think G35x and FX).  Re-engineering the Z to put power at all four corners wouldn’t require a major investment.  A $30k AWD Z could do some damage to entry-level Boxster and Z4 sales. But wait!  There’s more!  The new division could bring out a twin-turbo Z, cranking out 350 to 380hp, stoking fond memories of Nissan’s early 90’s whip.  It could be the ultimate budget supercar– or at least throw down the G-force gauntlet to the nutso Mitsubishi EVO and Subaru WRX STi.  

The Camaro is less complicated proposition. GM/Nissan’s boffins could wedge an unadulterated, unmolested and unrestricted LS2 engine into a stretched FM chassis (M45 showing the way) and stick with the prototype's show car good looks. A 505hp LS7 powered line-topping Camaro would follow quite nicely, thanks. A $40 -$45k bitchin' Camaro ain't gonna cannibalize Corvette or GT-R sales any more than Boxsters and Caymans eat 911 orders. Furthermore, while no Shelby GT500 customers would seriously consider a Z06, they’d be all over a Camaro with a Z06 engine.  

To round out the new Corvette Division, GM/Nissan would of course need a variant of the "Hey, that looks like fun" Solstice GXP, both in hardtop and convertible form. If they added the normally aspired Solstice into the mix, the performance brand’s lineup would run the gamut from $20k entry level cars to world-beating supercars. Two of them.  Hell, the new division could go for broke (hopefully not literally) and bring back the mid-engined Fiero to take on the Lotus Elise.

For the next 90 days, Rabid Rick and The Jackal are obliged to explore possible “synergies” between the two car making, continent-straddling giants. Instead of nudge-nudge wink-winking about “unused plant capacity” and pretending that the UAW doesn’t exist, these two [non-Nissan] titans should stop playing kiss – chase, combine forces and create something world class.  Separately, GM and Nissan both make great sports cars. Working together, they could make the best.  Forget all that talk about corporate synergy. What these companies need is sinergy.  A brand new Corvette Division would provide the sex-on-wheels halo both companies need.

 

By on July 26, 2006

Hummer-H221.jpgIn 1988, Simon Bond published that seminal work, 101 Uses for a Dead Cat.   It pissed off cat lovers, became a best seller, and spawned a number of “101 Uses for (fill in the blank)” books and articles.  Today we’re faced with an even more haunting problem.  The streets are crawling with SUVs driven by rap star wannabees and soccer moms afraid they’ll get bogged down in a mall parking lot somewhere.  It won’t be long before the junkyards are overflowing with the rusting hulks of these once-proud symbols of excess and poseurship.  So the question plaguing mankind today is, “What do you do with a dead SUV?”

By on July 26, 2006

Prius2222.jpgWhen the Toyota Prius first came out, I drove one around West Virginia.  When I pulled into a gas station, the owner sauntered out, all curious-like.  “What’s that?” he demanded.  “I never seen one of them before.”  It’s a hybrid, I explained.  You can run it on either the electric motor or the gas engine, or both of them together.  “They ought to have a switch,” he said. “So you can run it only on electricity.”  So much for my Harvard degree.  The guy was way ahead of me.

Toyota should be all over the plug-in hybrid electric vehicle (PHEV) concept like stink on bumwad.  Perhaps their unintentionally non-commercial experience with the all-electric RAV4 EV put them off the concept.  They probably figured that a mainstream motor requiring nightly recharging would be as popular as a compact Cadillac diesel with 8-4-0 cylinder deactivation.  Still, Toyota’s beginning to get with the program— as are Ford, DaimlerChrysler, George Bush and every green-leaning op-ed columnist.  Appropriately enough, the change of heart’s down to a small group of Californians long derided as rich hippies with too much time on their hands. 

These much-maligned Left Coasters are engineers and entrepreneurs rallying around an e-banner called CalCars.org .  They’ve been known to spend an extra $10k to $12k per car to add plug-in capability to their hybrid transportation.  They plug in their Prius at night, charge a special set of drive batteries, roll out of bed and commute and/or run errands entirely on amps.  Their modified Prius won’t fire up its internal combustion (IC) engine until they’re doing 35, provided they stay light on the throttle. 

Obviously, a PHEV isn’t going to help drivers with an 80-mile, 80-mph commute.  But it works for me.  Once every weekday, I loop around the local post office, gym, hardware store, Radio Shack, dentist or whatever.  Give me a range of 35 in-town electric miles and I’m there.  If I deplete my plug-in hybrid’s batteries, I’ll simply go to gas and carry on.

The PHEV eliminates the fatal flaw of electric cars: limited range.  If your commute is reasonably short, plug the puppy in at work and motor back home with a full tank of volts.  You probably won’t need to fire up the IC engine until the weekend trip to Vegas. Based on the American driver’s typical daily runs (they average seven miles each), a PHEV could deliver 100 mpg or more.  People who ride Vespas do half as well.

Toyota’s standard it-won’t-work whine: the Prius’ nickel-metal hydride (NiMH) battery puts out lots of power for a short time.  It wouldn’t survive daily deep discharge/recharge cycles.  In fact, Japanese and Euro-spec Prii have an electric-only switch, so owners can move their hybrid to the other side of the street [in accordance with local parking laws] without having to start them up, apparently.  That said, a Prius won’t even travel a mile on its standard internal battery.  Bottom line: a useful plug-in hybrid requires a lead acid “energy battery,” which are notoriously heavy and short-lived. 

At first, CalCars’ hackers circumvented this limitation by installing a secondary set of lightweight lead-acid batteries, originally intended for electrical bicycles.  They’ve since moved on to lighter, longer lasting (and more expensive) lithium-ion batteries.  The secondary batteries don’t put out a whole lot of power, but it’s enough to chug a light car along for an hour or two.  Of course, you need controllers and wiring to make it all work.  But as they say, if it was easy, everybody would be doing it.

Spare batteries in the trunk, homemade wiring, thousands of dollars per car for electronics, a week’s DIY work… of course the PHEV makes no sense.  But I suspect Toyota, Mercedes or even GM could make it a lot more sensible.  Hey, don’t tell me a society that can develop the Ionic Breeze air purifier and sell expensive pills to reduce stress-induced belly fat can’t invent better batteries…

Yes, I know: electricity comes from “somewhere" and arrives complete with its own environmental costs.  But one huge factor in electricity’s favor— and why it will supplant both gasoline and hydrogen as the power source for future cars— is that amps and volts already have a perfectly good transportation and supply infrastructure: power lines, household wiring and extension cords.  No other source of alternative energy starts with such an obvious advantage.

Best of all, electricity comes from a wide variety of existing, plentiful, independent, domestic sources: coal, nuclear, natural gas, hydro, garbage, even solar and wind power.  Worse comes to worst, I could even recharge my plug-in hybrid vehicle’s batteries by hooking it to my Exercycle, since it’s actually an alternator that provides variable resistance when I pedal.  Try that with diesel, fuel cells, hydrogen, fusion or Kryptonite.  Clearly, the PHEV is a shockingly good idea.

By on July 25, 2006

Aston V8.jpgAll cars should have a V8.  For one thing, the modern eight cylinder engine is inherently balanced; it has completely overlapping power impulses.  In other words, one cylinder fires before the previous cylinder has finished contributing, creating a much smoother power delivery with fewer impulses. That’s why a V8 can use the same drivetrain components as a much smaller four cylinder engine with half the displacement.  There is no need for secondary balance shafts, and no unpleasant vibrations to annoy the passengers and reduce the life of the exhaust system and other accessories.  It’s the smoothest engine configuration money can buy.

In contrast, inline four cylinder engines are inherently unbalanced.  Because of the geometry of the crankshaft and rods within the engine, fours shake in both the horizontal and vertical planes.  There’s only one way to mitigate the effect: add unbalanced shafts to create counter-vibrations. This “fix” adds weight, complexity and cost.  Even so, the inherent vibrations from a four cylinder engine wreak havoc on accessories and require extra mass in all the mounting brackets and related parts.  In fact, by the time a four cylinder engine is tamed, it weighs and costs almost as much as a V8.  And the customer still suffers the noise and vibration penalties that come from skimping on cylinders. 

V6’s also have inherent imbalances, though not nearly as severe as a four. Depending on the block angle, V6 engine operation creates vertical or horizontal forces.  The most sophisticated V6 engines also have balance shafts, again adding to complexity, cost and weight.  Fives, threes and twos have even worse vibrations, some beyond simple analysis.  V10’s add the vibrations of two five cylinder engines together, which is better at some speeds, worse at others.  Turbocharging or supercharging four or six cylinder engines to get to V8 power levels simply adds more complexity and weight to an already challenged engine design, and sacrifices the low end torque of a naturally aspirated powerplant.  (Just ask Mercedes’ AMG division, who’ve recently switched from supercharged eights and sixes normally aspirated 6.3-liter V8's.)

Odd numbers of cylinders, like three or five, are inevitably the result of cost-cutting.  Sometimes there’s no time or money to tool for a smaller engine, so a few cylinders are lopped off an existing engine.  That’s why GM’s lackluster small pickup trucks and the Hummer H3 sport a five cylinder engine. Ten cylinder engines, currently deployed in Vipers and some Dodge and Ford trucks, are another cost-cutting move.  Engine not powerful enough?  Add two more similar cylinders and call it good.

The provision of V12 engines in luxury cars is even more perverse.  V12’s are no smoother than a V8 and add (you guessed it) weight, complication and cost.  While that may be the manufacturer’s intent, it still makes little engineering sense. Jaguar gave up on V12’s a while ago.  Aston Martin passed on their V12 to offer a V8 in their latest car.  In fact, thanks to the V8’s relatively light weight, good power output and compact packaging, the engine configuration is, belatedly, making gains in the European market.  BMW, Mercedes, Volvo and Audi all offer Euro-spec V8 passenger cars. 

Once you’ve committed to a V8, there are a lot of reasons for making it a pushrod.  A single camshaft simplifies a lot of things, and the narrow heads associated with pushrod engines allow greater flexibility in vehicle packaging. Thus smaller cars can enjoy a V8 engine.  Before the outraged techno-comments start dropping at the feet of this post, it should be noted that the most powerful racing engines in the world are pushrod V8s, with two valve heads to boot. Some of the fastest cars you can buy in America have pushrod, two valve V8’s. The Chevrolet Corvette is only the most prominent example.

So why don’t all cars have V8’s?  The answer lies in marketing, rather than engineering.  Marketing has declared that V8 engines are best suited to high-end, high performance cars, while the masses should get by with “economical” fours and sixes.  The public now believes that V8 means bad mileage.  The opposite is true– at least potentially. Mileage depends on two factors: the weight of the car and how fast you go.  Engine size and cylinder count have little to do with it.  Of course, bigger engines encourage people to accelerate and drive faster, but that’s not the engine’s fault.  And new technology is mooting the V8 as gas-guzzler argument.  Multi-displacement systems (a fancy way of saying that four cylinders go on vacation when not needed) have the potential to dramatically increase V8 mileage under light load conditions.

In short, for pistonheads at least, the five saddest words in the English language are still “I could’ve had a V8”.

By on July 25, 2006

dino2.jpgForbes has just released another in their never-ending series of ten-best lists– a feature which stretches credulity, interest and patience. To wit: the latest list trumpets the ten best cars for single people.  Being a perennially unattached person, my index finger only managed to hover over delete. Oh man… "Best Car For Eco-minded Singles: Toyota Prius Sedan." No, really. But one item intrigued me: "Best Car For Boosting Your Sex Life"  Aside from looking like an uncircumcised penis, I can't think of anything even remotely sexy about BMW's M6 Coupe.  But there are some drop-dead gorgeous cars on both the new and used market.  What car(s) do you find sexy?  More to the point (so to speak), can a car get you laid?  And if it can, is it really a good idea to share your precious bodily fluids with a sexual partner who's turned-on by your taste in whips?  

By on July 25, 2006

005462222.jpg“Back to the Future” is Hollywood fluff, but the movie has its moments.  When Marty McFly takes his 1985 vintage nuclear-powered Delorean to Dr. Emmett Brown’s 1955 alter ego for repairs, “Doc” looks at the car’s complicated electronics and snorts “No wonder it broke down.  It was made in Japan.”  “What are you talking about?” McFly corrects.  “That’s where all the best stuff comes from.”  The throwaway line perfectly illustrates the sea change that's swept the American automobile industry during those crucial 30 years. 

From 1955 to 1985, Japanese manufacturers completely reinvented themselves.  They went from being producers of cheap, copycat products famous for near-instant obsolescence, to makers of high-tech, value-driven products built to last.  There was an equal, opposite and horrifying corollary to this astounding transformation: American manufacturers more or less switched places with their Japanese counterparts. Despite domestic carmakers’ gains in product quality over the last two decades or so, the perception that domestic cars are inherently inferior to their foreign competition has become deeply ingrained in the American psyche. 

But all is not lost.  Not to coin a phrase, there is a way forward.  To reverse the reversal, here’s what America’s struggling automakers need to do…

Can the discounts  I remember watching GM’s “employee discount for everyone” commercials and thinking how they reeked of desperation.  I figured the next step would be to have a line of UAW workers gnashing their teeth and rending their clothes as they begged me to please, please buy an American car.  This summer’s discounts may be less prominent, but Detroit's still using price as the primary way to sell cars and trucks.  The emphasis on cash gives consumers the impression (rightly or wrongly) that price is all the automakers have to offer.  They might as well run an ad campaign that says “Chevy: When you can’t afford anything better.”  

There’s only one way around these discounts: realistic sticker prices and no haggle pricing.  This two-pronged approach would send a message to the American heartland that GM, Ford and DCX are serious about value– and their customers' confort level.  If the vehicles aren’t selling, reduce the price.  

Make inexpensive cars that people want to buy  We’re not talking about “cheap” cars.  The domestics need to make beautiful-looking, sensibly-priced automobiles that don’t feel like automotive purgatory.  The mini-whips should have dramatic interiors made from quality materials.  They need convenient touches that make people think they’re getting superb value for money.  Theses entry-level vehicles also need sophisticated powerplants and superior dynamics.  And they need to be updated every two to three years.

Toyota and Honda clawed their way to the top following this strategy; it worked once, it’ll work again.  Yes, the Big Three’s labor and legacy costs make it nearly impossible for them to make money on small cars, but they’ve got to reclaim this territory at any cost.  The traditional domestic buyer is getting older, and competition for the middle and upper market is equally fierce.  If Detroit wants a future, they need a secure a toe-hold at the bottom of the mountain, and claw their way back.  

Innovate!  Detroit is so busy cranking out “Me too” vehicles that it’s hard to believe that the American car industry was once the pinnacle of fresh automotive thinking.  Where are the striking designs, or new directions?  What about diesels?  Detroit could build small, clean-burning turbo diesels that get near-hybrid levels of fuel economy (especially on the highway, where hybrid mileage sucks).  Right now, VW has the diesel car market pretty much to itself, but GM, Ford and DCX could one-up the competition by offering small, efficient diesels in their entry level cars.  The company’s could also offer the TDi diesels in small trucks, creating a unique product for the North American market. 

Attack reliability  If, in fact, Detroit is building cars that are as reliable as their “foreign” competition, they should offer a 10-year/100,000 mile warranty.  (If, in fact, they aren’t, they have even more reason to provide the coverage.)  A long warranty would go a long way towards convincing consumers that Detroit’s vehicles are the mechanical equal of Toyota or Honda.  Of course, it could cost the “domestics” a fortune, but there’s simply no cheap and easy way to win back consumer confidence.  The Big Three need to make existing and potential customers believe that they care about more than just collecting monthly payments.  

Clearly, Detroit is stuck in a time machine.  Retro designs like the Mustang and HHR might get people into the showrooms, but they won’t save Ford and GM from Chapter 11.  (DCX is doing better, but they face the same reckoning.)  If the Big Three can’t make customers confident about Detroit’s future, their image will remain stuck in 1985.  And if that happens, they’ll soon be history.  

By on July 24, 2006

dunk.jpgMy favorite car name of all time is the Honda Life Dunk.  But I can fully appreciate pistonheads whose taste in automotive monikers runs more towards the aggressive (Mercury Marauder, Plymouth Fury, Aston Martin Vaquish), animistic (Dodge Viper, Pontiac Firebird, Ford Mustang, Reliant Kitten) or snoberific (Buick Regal, Dodge St. Regis, Buick Park Avenue, Chrysler LeBaron).  As Chris Paukert noted in a previous TTAC editorial, automakers have submerged the [formerly] mission-critical name game into a watery alphanumeric soup.  The inanity of this approach is exemplified by Ford's decision to rename the Lincoln Zephyr the Lincoln MKX, and instruct its dealers (as of today) that the vehicle is not to be called a "Mark X" but an "em kay ex."  Are car names inherently better than simple numerical designations? What's your favorite and least favorite car name? Would a Ferrari F430 or Jaguar XK120 by any other other name be any more or less memorable or desirable?  

By on July 23, 2006

silver_bullet_8002.jpgI’ve looked at this TTAC paid subscription thing seven ways to Sunday.  After more than four months, I still can't make it work.  According to the vast majority of web-savvy TTAC’ers, this is no bad thing.  Your advice has been steadfast: accept advertising.  So when Federated Media Publishing offered to run TTAC’s advertising business for 40% of gross, I looked into it.  My contact, Bill Brazell, assured me that TTAC’s editorial independence would be sacrosanct.  Yeah, right.  And then I read the fine print…

2.2 Review of Potential Advertisements.  When FMP locates a potential buyer for all or part of an Available Advertising Space subject to an Availability Notice, FMP will send Author a notice (an “Advertising Review Notice”) to the email address specified on the Author Information Sheet.  Each Advertising Review Notice will identify the buyer, the nature of advertisement the buyer wishes to place, the time period(s) during which the advertisement would run, and the price the buyer has offered to pay for the advertisement.  Author will promptly respond to each Advertising Review Notice received and will indicate to FMP whether or not Author approves the proposed advertising described therein.  

Advertising sucks.  But it’s become clear that I can’t “gate” the TTAC community (sub it up) without losing the majority of current readers and, far worse, the possibility of new ones.  Truth be told, if Federated Media Publishing hadn’t contacted me, that’s the way I would have gone, come Hell or lost visitors.  But I don’t have the energy or financial resources to make it work, and I really do believe that the Fed’s different from the packs of jackals who’ve attempted to hijack TTAC in the past.  To wit, another part of the contract gives me the right to restrict certain types of advertising, advertising categories and named advertisers.  And then there's Federated Media Publishing’s “Author Mores:"

Authors who join the FM network of sites hold these values in common:

– Voice and Point of View: Strong voices and intelligent points of view drive robust conversations.

– Accuracy: Some FM sites are journalistic in nature; others are not. Regardless, FM sites strive for accuracy regarding items we post as facts.

– Community: Weblogs are conversations, not lectures. The community that gathers around each site is the essence of its value, and we treat that community accordingly. We listen and respond to feedback, and incorporate it into the way we manage our sites.

– Responsibility: We take our role in the community we serve seriously, and feel responsible for our own words. When we make mistakes, we correct them. We do not seek to use our sites maliciously.

– Transparency: We err on the side of disclosure to our readers. If we have an interest in something we’re writing about, we disclose that interest. We are as transparent as we can be about our site’s statistics, practices and policies.

Bottom line: TTAC needs money, if only to pay our writers a fee [more] commensurate with their time and talent.  So I’ve decided to bite the bullet and sign-on with the Fed.  I formally declare right here that I will never let advertising compromise TTAC’s editorial.  At no point, now or in the future, will we pull our punches to please commercial sponsors.  By now, I hope you’ll take me at my word.  If not, well, by my deeds I shall be known.   

OK, now, TTAC needs some help.  First, we need a car booker: someone who can liaise with automotive manufacturers’ press departments to secure test vehicles for our far-flung editorial team.  (I lack both the charm and the time for the gig.)  The job’s best suited to a pistonhead who doesn’t have a “real job,” who doesn’t require a “real salary” or any “any” benefits.  They need to be organized enough to remember who got what when, who’s getting what when (and where) and what we need to get for whom when and where.  I’ll pay a stipend (for now) for each vehicle booked, plus all phone expenses.  It’s an ideal job for someone who wants to get into automotive PR (baby Darth?).  

We also need a racing correspondent, for NASCAR or any other major race series.  There’s a lot of baseless hype and shady corporate shenanigans in mainstream motorsports, and I’d like TTAC to deal the inside dope.  Obviously, the pay sucks, but the glory is infinite.  If you’re interested in either position, use the contact button and email me your qualifications. Meanwhile, thanks again for your support.  I promise TTAC will continue to lead the crusade for honest and passionate automotive journalism.  I won’t let you down.

By on July 22, 2006

spanky.jpgWhen I got my driving license, I couldn’t vote.  Legal drinking was a distant speck on the horizon.  But I didn’t care.  I was captain of my own ship, master of my own destiny.  Within a few months, the parental units provided regular access to the family hatch.  I treated this gift as a matter of life and death, because, well, it was.  By that time it was clear that my friends’ driving habits were the greatest threat to my continued existence.

I’m not saying I was the most capable or responsible driver extant.  I admit I sought answers to important questions relating to the time / space continuum; like whether or not a Honda Accord with nearly six digits on the clock could do the ton.  I planned my experiment carefully, selecting a deserted stretch of four-lane highway just outside of town for the daring deed.  Give me a crash helmet and a stick of Beecham’s and I’d have been Chuck Yeager.  I didn’t break the sound barrier, but I did peg it at 95. 

In contrast, my classmates tested the upper limits of their ancient chariots between stoplights.  Only the inherent limitations of their mounts (family sedans and old econo-hatches) slowed their progress.  Other traffic didn’t figure.  To accept a ride from one of my speed-crazed, hormonally-charged peers was like playing Russian roulette with half the chambers loaded.  Fortunately, the brevity of the city confines limited the possibilities for automotive immolation.  Unfortunately, our city was a small island in a sea of country roads, with endless opportunities to accel.  

For those Boomers and Gen X’ers who came of age in a small mid-western town, the term “vamping” will bring back instant memories.   For those of you who grew up in the burbs or amongst high-rises and belt highways, vamping was the fine art of launching a vehicle into flight over a bump.  It was a relatively simply matter of blood, guts and a pair of lead feet.  Find the right bump, back up a bit and go for it.  As for the landing, well that WAS the tricky part.  God help you if another car happened to be driving in the opposite direction. 

There were more than 600 kids with licenses at my school, perhaps 2000 in the city.  No one knew exactly who was riding this dark thrill-ride until they failed.  And more than one did.  Perhaps the knowledge that I was leaving for college after graduation kept me from vamping it up.  Then again, that didn’t seem to stop my college-bound friends’ pursuit of “air time.”  One particularly brazen pair of associates managed to mangle three cars between them.  Two of the autos snuffed it in single car accidents.  The other required a joint effort, in what became a famous “experiment.”

 As in all towns, Springfield had a teen hangout: Quik & EZ (yes, we thought it was pretty funny too).  This less than salubrious edifice sat on a corner, connected to a large strip-mall parking lot by a short, steep ramp.  Despite the brief distance from the ramp to the street (perhaps 50 feet), our two heroes managed to drive their Nova onto the ramp at 50mph; enough to catch that elusive air.  Emboldened by the accolades, the driver decided to perform their automotive stunt show in the opposite direction.  Hitting the 45 degree parking lot connector at over 50 miles an hour, their car never actually touched the ramp.  It flew from one lot to another, bottomed out, spun 180 degrees in a shower of sparks and plowed over an electric transformer. 

Our heroes pulled themselves out, performed a quick inspection and discovered that the bottom of the car was fairly well fused.  The car “looked like a canoe”.  Since the police hadn’t showed (yet), and home was only two miles away, they decided leaving would be a good thing.  They piled back in and headed home, shedding parts the whole way, driving into local legend.

For those who survived and got something faster; the next level was thrashing around the two-lane out by the lake.  That road had lots of curves, little police presence and plenty of trees capable of cutting a Firebird in half (I saw the pictures).  One particular stretch saw fatal accidents in three straight summers; proof of the road’s automotive allure and our local drivers’ courage/stupidity. 

 My luck ran out at the end of my senior year; I was rear-ended by a Sable in a driving rainstorm.  For the next four years, my automobiling was restricted to summers and holidays; delivering Pizzas or heading out of town to boss hick kids and JD’s through cornfields.  My first set of wheels would be a graduation “gift” of the sort that gave Trojans nightmares, but that, my friends, is another story.

By on July 22, 2006

E85juice222.jpgShould America be fuelling its vehicles with corn-based E85?  Now there’s a question worthy of public debate.  Meanwhile, the question’s been settled.  E85 is coming to a pump near you, whether you like it— or use it— or not.  The political momentum behind the fuel is enormous, including huge CAFE (Corporate Average Fuel Economy) credits for manufacturers that build vehicles that will never see a drop of corn juice.  In fact, the production and distribution of E85 involves a strange mix of politics and economics which could well lead to a dead end.  Following the money may make your head spin, but it's high time to separate E85 facts from the politically correct fug of obfuscation. 

First of all, corn farmers aren’t getting rich off of E85.  America produces 11 billion bushels of the yellow foodstuff every year.  More than half of the US corn crop goes to feed animals, mostly cattle and pigs.  Much of the rest is used for corn syrup, oil, plastics and even heat.  What’s left gets exported.  The US ethanol industry’s growing appetite for corn has reduced our exports somewhat, but there’s still plenty left over after we’ve exhausted every possible domestic use.  So corn prices remain low.

Or high.  Despite the over-abundance of American corn, the US federal government subsidizes the price— paying farmers the difference between the crop’s fair market value and $2.50 a bushel.  This price support ensures that corn farming remains profitable, so the US doesn’t have to buy corn on the global market.  You might think the federal subsidy would assure profits for farmers and low input costs for ethanol producers, but you’d be wrong.  Enter the middleman… 

Unlike sugar cane (the source for Brazil’s ethanol), corn is a seasonal crop.  Corn is also expensive to transport, making it difficult for farmers to sell directly to distant buyers.  At the same time, most corn farmers lack the storage capacity needed to stockpile their Biblically bounteous harvest.  No surprise then, that there’s an entire industry devoted to buying grain from farmers, storing it and shipping it to other buyers. 

Obviously, there’s a nice little price bump involved.  Grain middlemen seldom pay more than about $2 per bushel to buy corn; they can then get $2.50 to $3 for that same bushel on a futures contract.  Ethanol plants are even willing to pay a little more, since they know they’ll sell every drop of fuel they produce.  The upshot of all this agricultural to-ing and fro-ing: ethanol producers are stuck with a raw material cost that rarely drops below $2.50 a bushel, no matter how much corn is grown, stored or shipped.

Thus, a gallon of ethanol requires roughly $.75 of corn.  That may seem like a compelling cost structure for an alternative fuel– especially when compared to this week’s crude oil price of $1.40 per gallon.  But E85’s ancillary costs are far higher.  First, ethanol is more expensive to produce than gasoline (i.e. it takes more energy to make fuel from corn than oil, and energy ain’t cheap).  Second, thanks to the phaseout of octane-enhancing MBTE gasoline additive, demand for ethanol far exceeds supply.  Third, ethanol’s transportation costs are astronomical. 

Unlike petroleum-based gasoline, ethanol is too corrosive for existing pipelines.  That means E85 has to be transported by truck or train.  Unfortunately, America’s trains are busy hauling billions of tons of coal from mines to power plants.  The railroads are adding locomotives as fast as manufacturers can build them (bet GM’s sorry they sold their locomotive business), but they’re all dedicated to moving a material that provides a larger, steadier business that's less hazards than schlepping ethanol.  So, for now, E85 distribution is pretty much restricted to trucks.

The bottom line is clear: E85 production is dependent on a crop whose costs are more or less fixed at a permanently high level.  E85 may be eco-sexy and an all-American source of fuel (provided you discount the petrochemical products used to fertilize and insect-proof the corn crop and power the vehicles that harvest, process and haul the corn around), but its current production costs make it an economically dubious alternative to “cheap” gas.  And that’s without considering the fact that E85 yields about 20% less “bang for the buck” than gas.  Unless the price of gas soars another dollar or so, or increased supply drops the price of ethanol by a like amount, E85 will struggle to provide a cost-effective alternative to its imported competition. 

The fundamental economics of the E85 business ensure that the fuel is– and will remain– a product whose future depends more on politics than the “free market.”  Of course, there’s nothing inherently wrong with that.  If we’re serious about energy independence, the US government could intervene to make E85 more viable. Uncle Sam could build a national network of E85-compatible pipelines, or remove taxes from E85, or add taxes to gas, or end corn subsidies, or, well, lots of things.  Meanwhile, the people who’ll benefit most from E85 are the people who move the raw materials to the ethanol plants and the finished product to the consumer.   

 

By on July 21, 2006

concrete corn2.jpgWith only 750 American gas stations providing the corn juice for flex-fuel vehicles, there's more E85 hype than E85.  Which is the point collegiate road tripper Mark Pike and his cohorts over at kicktheoilhabit.org decided to make by attempting an E85-only trek across the North American landmass in flex-fuel Crown Vic supplied by the bad mo fo's at FoMoCo.  In the PR sense, the trip's a hit.  Pike's Vic has garnered a bushel of free publicity for the supporters of fuel coming from Billy Ford's "heartland."  Of course, the socio-polticial issues surrounding E85 production, transportation and provision are only slightly less complex than the home assembly instructions for a Bowflex Versatrainer. [Read Mark Hasty's post on E85 economics on tomorrow's TTAC.]  A quick call to Mr. Pike revealed that the flex-fuel campaigner is a bit of a piker in terms of the fine print, but props are due.  The most socially responsible thing I ever did during my college vacation was making sure that my empties were placed in a proper trash receptacle. 

Recent Comments

  • Lou_BC: @Carlson Fan – My ’68 has 2.75:1 rear end. It buries the speedo needle. It came stock with the...
  • theflyersfan: Inside the Chicago Loop and up Lakeshore Drive rivals any great city in the world. The beauty of the...
  • A Scientist: When I was a teenager in the mid 90’s you could have one of these rolling s-boxes for a case of...
  • Mike Beranek: You should expand your knowledge base, clearly it’s insufficient. The race isn’t in...
  • Mike Beranek: ^^THIS^^ Chicago is FOX’s whipping boy because it makes Illinois a progressive bastion in the...

New Car Research

Get a Free Dealer Quote

Who We Are

  • Adam Tonge
  • Bozi Tatarevic
  • Corey Lewis
  • Jo Borras
  • Mark Baruth
  • Ronnie Schreiber