Category: Editorials

By on April 23, 2005

Public transportation is a disgusting aberration fueled by cancer juice and liberal lies.  Not.Cars are sexy, techy and cool. These simple facts tend to obscure any objective analysis of their utility. Like the Space Shuttle or my imaginary clerical staff, if it's sexy, people find a way to justify their love. So it's no wonder that T-TAC's resident pistonhead Robert Farago creased the outside of the envelope when he claimed that cars are the green choice, and labeled public transportation a disgusting aberration fueled by cancer juice and liberal lies.

Not so. Farago's rant relied heavily on a study by Roger Kemp of Lancaster University (UK). Mr. Farago claimed that the study proves that cars are more fuel efficient than trains. Unfortunately, a closer read of Mr. Kemp's study finds that BOTH the train AND the car cited in the study were diesels. The automobile used for comparative purposes was a 1.9L Teutonic miser of a VW, with four passengers on board.

The average US car carriers just 1.6 passengers.  That sucks. Mr. Kemp's argument on passenger-miles-per-gallon falls further into disrepute when applied to the United States. As opposed to the 55 mpg four-up VW, the average US car carries a gruesome 1.61 passengers at 18 mpg. That's nearly ten times worse than the VW studied– even discounting aerodynamic drag from activist bumper stickers.

Farago's rhetorical reliance on the ultra-cleanliness of new cars is also interesting, but irrelevant. The average US car is more than nine years old. As for his off-hand analysis of bus loading, it's impossible to rebut where there are no facts. At the same time, it's important to note that US trains and buses are far cleaner and more efficient than those in the UK. For a quick comparison of respective air quality standards, visit London, walk around for two hours, and pick your nose.

I swear officer, I had no alternative.  Of course, that's an entirely subjective measure. Perhaps it's best to leave the air quality debate for others and return to Mr. Kemp's own words about efficiency: 'These findings only apply to long-distance journeys, and then only under an unrealistic assumption of uncongested conditions…. the vast majority of journeys… will remain much less environmentally damaging if we take the bus or train– and use our cars only where no alternative exists.'

Does this mean cars an unforgivable indulgence of a declining civilization, blindly crouched at the vomitorium while locusts mass on the horizon? No. Sometimes, especially in rural or suburban areas, they're the best-– or only-– option. And like Mr. Farago, I love them. But there's no denying that much of what we do with them is stupid.

Who's paying for all this private transportation stuff?  The pubic.As a car enthusiast, it breaks heart my heart to see a WRX STi idling next to me for an hour on the Beltway, like a leopard chained to a cement floor, or, worse, abandoned for 20 hours out of the day. Commuting trips-– and they're most of the trips we make-– are the wrong place for cars. Hell, I'd ship myself to work if I could. Since FedEx has proven to me they can't be relied on in this capacity, I use the next best thing: the DC Metro. And I'll try to make you, too.

Farago claims that environmentalists want to use a "political, moral or financial sledgehammer" to "bludgeon" you out of your cars. I don't. But I am sick of paying for them.

Amtrak is an inexplicable zombie corporation hideously mutated by pork-barrel politics, but train travel has its place in the transportation matrix.My taxes bought the road you're idling on and the troopers and snow plows and medevac flights that come with it; as sure as they bought the El train blowing past you on the left. More than $40 billion per year in the next highway bill, not including state taxes. I also work on a volunteer rescue squad, cutting you out of, and where possible, patching you up after innumerable wrecks, gratis. (Admittedly, sometimes a non-metaphorical sledgehammer is required.)

Overall, that's fine. The government pays for train tracks and air traffic control, too. A free, modern nation has to allow free movement throughout the country, and this can only be privatized so far. The costs associated are immense; we have to spend public money to get people places. My problem comes when we do it stupidly.

We do a lot of bad mass transit; Amtrak is an inexplicable zombie corporation hideously mutated by pork-barrel politics. In a giant country, long-distance rail travel really can't be more than a curiosity. But done right-– regional rail lines, commuter trains, car sharing services, intelligently-scheduled buses, carpooling facilities and HOV– public transit makes things cheaper and cleaner for everyone. Leave your cars for the places they make sense and produce fun.

Bottom line: I'm keeping my car, and you can have yours. But I'm not voting for $600 million for an eighth commuter lane for us all to drive to, park on, and swear at each other. I'd rather drop my "financial sledgehammer" on a fast intercity train, where I can have a quiet coffee and read through some studies-– before I post them on the net.

By on April 19, 2005

It could be worse.  It could be a NYC commuter train.You ever get the feeling that you should be riding on public transportation? Me neither. The only time I'm tempted is when I need to travel long distances– oh wait, airlines still count as private transportation don't they? Right. Let's try that again. The only time I'm tempted is when I need to travel from one city to another city that's more than 300 miles away, but less than 500 miles away. And now that Amtrak has pulled the entire Acela Express fleet offline to repair cracked brakes, well, it's no sale.

Of course, I certainly understand people who use public transportation for commuting. Well, maybe not understand, but at least sympathize. Even in America, Land of the Free, Home of No-Money-Down, not everyone can afford a car. The hassle and expense of parking is also a fearsome disincentive for auto ownership. But what I can't understand, at all, on any level, is why people give credence to the factually flawed logic used by environmentalists to promote public transport.

In your dreams, bus boy.These days, air pollution provides the greens with all the justification they need to sanctify public transport and crucify cars. Now that global warming has been accepted as fact and attributed to automobiles– in much the same way that creationists concluded that the Great Flood is responsible for the layered deposit of dinosaur bones– public transportation has become the only politically-acceptable way to reconcile mobility with ecological responsibility. Anything else is not just bad; it's morally reprehensible.

Well that's just plain wrong. First of all, let's take a closer look at buses. Nice idea, buses: lots of people, one engine. Divide the amount of pollution by the number of people inside. If the resulting airborne badness is less than that of a private passenger car's pppm (pollutants per passenger mile), the greens have an entirely rational platform from which they can vilify the car (not THEIR car, THE car).

Global warming or another day, another dollar? Oh wait. Buses aren't always full. In places where car travel isn't penalized by taxes, parking or congestion, they're hardly ever full. Come to think of it, city buses only achieve maximum capacity during peak operating hours. So do we make our calculations based on average occupancy for an average bus? Or do we stack the deck in the tree-huggers' favor and analyze a bus stuffed to the gunnels with disgruntled commuters? What about fuel quality and maintenance issues? What about getting on with it…

Can't. Here in the US, it's diesel [bus] vs. gasoline [car]– which is like comparing apples sprayed with 8-phenyl-mercurioxyquinoline with organic oranges. As Mr. Elton has pointed out, diesel is one dirty bastard of a fuel. Your average US diesel engine spews more cancer-causing particulate matter into the air than a dozen chain smokers, or a hundred Ford Explorers for that matter. By contrast, today's gas-powered cars are so clean-running you can no longer start the car, close the garage door and kill yourself. When it comes to airborne pollution, cars rule, buses fool (almost all the people all the time).

Powerful it is, clean-running and fuel efficient it ain't.What about trains? Forget about trains. They may fit a huge number of [theoretical] passengers but they're usually propelled by The Mother of All Diesel Engines.

OK, let's pretend carcinogenic particulates aren't important and consider fuel efficiency instead. Professor Roger Kemp of Lancaster University [UK] compared British commuter trains' energy efficiency with cars' and discovered that trains are far more fuelish than our four-wheeled friends. It was such a wash that the Editor of Modern Railways magazine felt compelled to write: 'I know this will generate howls of protest, but at present a family of four going by car is about as environmentally friendly as you can get'.

Small, clean, fast and fun.  Now that's what you call a commuter special. The result jibes with a study performed by Automotive Advisers and Associates of Hilden, Germany. The group discovered that trains consume 60% more energy per person transported than cars, and take up 200% more public space per person transported.

I'm sure that there are entire universities of well-educated greens out there ready to shoot holes in the above. Their first line of attack will be that the analysts are guilty of bias (which could NEVER be said about environmental campaigners). After that, they will claim that the US situation is not comparable to Europe (which is true: we're less densely populated). Finally, they'll gloss over the reality of the situation and say that public transport offers the POSSIBILITY of greener travel. You know, hybrid engines, hydrogen fuel cells, that sort of thing.

But here's the deal guys: you lose. Not only is private transportation cleaner and more fuel efficient than its public equivalent, people prefer it by a huge margin. So any attempt to use a political, moral or financial sledgehammer to bludgeon people out of their cars and into trains and buses is ultimately doomed to failure. If you really believe cars are planet killers, either continue to clean up their tailpipe emissions or… walk. But you walk alone.

By on April 15, 2005

OnStar: fear sells. OnStar's radio ads are powerful stuff. The 30-second documentaries– featuring real life rescue coordination by OnStar staff– jerk more tears than Terms of Endearment and The Divine Secrets of the Ya-Ya Sisterhood combined. The fact that you can summon the same emergency crew by punching 911 into you cell is neither here nor there. After hearing an OnStar rep soothing a toddler crying "Momma's passed out", you'd gladly get a second mortgage to pay for their emergency coverage.

Considering the ads' impact on OnStar's takeup rate, the General's plan to translate the radio spots into a series of 30-minute TV infomercials makes perfect sense. Provided the producers keep it real (in the best 'based on a true story' TV tradition), the marketing campaign will be a sure-fire hit. You can almost hear new customers choking back the tears as they relay their credit card number to their toll-free friends.

The Saturn VUE: Mom puts People First-- well, her children. But the OnStar effect doesn't end there. The service's commercial success has infected the rest of The General's marketing staff. The safety bug has gone viral.

A recent TV ad for the Saturn Vue highlights the pathology. In this flawlessly executed vignette, a young woman admits that she bought a Saturn SUV because impending motherhood shifted her priorities towards safety (and away from imports). While exploiting maternal paranoia is a no-brainer for admen aiming at the family car market, the commercial is a major change in Saturn's branding. If the TV ad is anything to go by, 'The People's Car Company' is now, simply, 'Deathbusters'.

GM's got your back, and wants your cashBut wait! There's more! (NOW how much would you pay?) In a recently unleashed national TV campaign called 'Only GM', fresh-faced children tell viewers how their lives were saved by GM safety features (including OnStar). The odd thing about the ad– other than a strong sense that the pint-sized "survivors" were carefully rehearsed– is that it touts GM's entire model line-up. It's not just Saturn that keeps you from experiencing the last word in personal depreciation. It's GMC, Pontiac, Hummer, Saturn, Buick, Chevrolet, Cadillac and Saab.

Well how about that: GM as Volvo, times eight. Cynics might point out that the majority of GM's safety features are either federally mandated or late to market (e.g. their SUV anti-rollover technology). But there's no doubt that GM's multi-divisional we-got-your-back shtick represents a significant shift in The General's marketing focus. (Just having a focus is pretty big news for GM.) What's more, there's no reason to believe a division-wide safety campaign wouldn't work. It's OnStar's "Field of Nightmares" writ large: if you protect them, they will buy.

Badges!  We don't need no stinkin' badges!   The ads– the first multi-marque General Motors campaign since tail fins went out of fashion– may also reflect a sea change in GM's overall corporate strategy. (Just having a corporate strategy…) Maybe the big guns have finally listened to all those critics who've condemned the automaker for badge-engineering its divisions' identities into oblivion. Rather than mounting a hugely expensive effort to re-delineate its brands through new product and marketing, perhaps The General has simply thrown in the towel. Are we about to see GM fold all its divisions into one?

Yes, it sounds dopey. But why would GM suddenly announce that it's going to affix the corporate logo on ALL of its brands' products? Will a Corvette owner gain street cred when onlookers clock that his favorite phallic symbol was built by the world's largest car company? Will a Hummer piss off more tree-huggers by virtue of its dual branding? Nope. So what's the point? If you discount the move as a morale booster for financially challeged stockholders, GM's big badge boom is a tacit acknowledgement that the whole multi-brand thing is a dead flow chart walking.

Or do we?Think about it: Ford is the other big multi-divisional carmaker, and look how THEY'RE doing: Lincoln's a joke, Mercury's the punch line, Jaguar's a drain, the rest of the boutiques are irrelevant and the mainline brand is slouching towards Bethlehem. BMW and Mercedes have only one subdivision apiece (MINI and Chrysler) and they sell millions of cars in every imaginable market segment. In short, all those analysts calling for GM's dissection could be punditing in the wrong direction. The answer to GM's perilous financials could be consolidation.

Let's face it: these days, only die-hard pistonheads care about brand history. We live in a world where a Chevy can be a re-badged Korean or Australian import, where a Sky or Solstice will fly out the door regardless of the badge on its butt, where a Chevy Silverado and a GMC Sierra are all pretty much of a muchness. So why not drop all pretence of brand differentiation, reduce costs across the board and sell all 40-plus products under the GM banner? As OnStar proves, sensible and safe aren't always the same thing.

By on April 10, 2005

'You want excitement from the 'Excitement' division? Try to get this thing to turn in a sharp corner.'Unbelievable. GM’s lost the plot, they’re losing the game and now they want to take their ball and go home. After automotive critic Dan Neil ripped apart the new Pontiac G6 GT and called for an executive putsch, The General pulled its $10M adspend out of the Los Angeles Times. While you can’t begrudge GM’s right to place—or not place—its money where it chooses, the decision to pull the plug on the Times displays an unappealing combination of arrogance and petulance. To wit: GM spokesfolk defended their action by saying that the review (and other GM-related coverage) contained “factual errors and misrepresentations”—without providing any specifics. So there. Nuh.

GM’s version of The Wizard of Oz‘ “pay no attention to that man behind the curtain” routine is good for a few laughs. It’s always fun to watch the rich and powerful act like victims. Nevertheless, it’s a worrying situation. The General’s muscle-flexing will certainly have a dampening effect on the already obsequious US automotive press. The ripples will be felt from the biggest buff books to the smallest local supplements. Even the blogosphere and ad-free sites like this one will sense the heat (if nothing else, we depend on manufacturers for access to test models). With the threat of retribution lingering in the air like sulfurous gas, the truth is bound to suffer even greater indignities.

'...someone's head ought to roll, and the most likely candidate would be the numinous white noggin of Lutz.'  The press’ silence on this story is deafening. Ironically, this lack of coordinated response actually works against the automotive media; leading the public to the not-so-wrong conclusion that lapdoggery towards the big advertisers is the norm. I’ve said it before: the press’ greatest asset, perhaps its only asset, is its credibility. If the car media doesn’t stand up for Neil, if they don’t defend the principles which they claim govern their profession, they risk losing their readers’ respect, and thus, affections.

At the same time, GM’s vindictiveness will hurt GM’s bottom line. The move against the LA Times catapulted Neil’s column out of pistonhead backwaters into the national consciousness. By doing so, it focused yet more attention on the generally piss-poor performance of GM products vis-à-vis their competitors, as well as the likelihood that the General may axe two entire divisions. Buyers who’ve long suspected that domestic automakers try to hide their products’ mediocrity behind a wall of hype and ad spend—consumers who don’t want to buy a car from a brand that might disappear—now have even more reason to shop Toyota.

'Interior styling: The GT comes with comfortable leather-lined bucket seats, nicely bolstered with heaters. I like the soft grip on the hand brake. That exhausts my praise for the interior.'GM’s assumption that the general public would side with big business in a fight against a lone (not to say rogue) journalist also raises serious doubts about the company’s understanding of PR. The proper response to Neil’s criticisms was obvious: demand that the Times publish a detailed refutation of the charges leveled against the company and the G6 GT. At the very least, when GM pulled their ads, their objections should have been made clear. But no. As far as the public is concerned, GM’s action was designed to punish the Times for doing what newspapers are supposed to do: report the truth. News flash to GM brass: people LIKE newspapers. And they don’t like bullies.

Of course, GM couldn’t really offer a point-by-point reply to Neil’s review because the G6 sucks. Oh wait, Neil didn’t say that. With uncharacteristic reserve, the Pulitzer Prize-winning critic called the G6 “uncompetitive.” If GM doesn’t agree with this assessment, if they can’t read their own sales figures and come to the same conclusion, they are in deep, deep denial. At the risk of sounding as obvious as an alcoholic’s friend during an intervention, lashing out at the LA Times doesn’t change anything. The G6 is still mediocre. GM is still in deep shit. The General’s assertion that it’s being unjustly persecuted doesn’t make it so.

'This is an uncompetitive product, an assertion borne out not by my say-so but by sales numbers. When ballclubs have losing records, players and coaches and managers get their walking papers.'Both domestic carmakers and car hacks need to wise-up. Until and unless the automotive press puts their readers’ interests first, advertisers will have them over a barrel. Until and unless GM faces the truth about its products, they will keep making boneheaded, self-defeating and futile attempts to protect their increasingly illusory reputation. Meanwhile, send dan.neil@latimes.com an email. Let him know that his short-term prospects are a lot better than GM’s.

By on April 3, 2005

Pontiac: going down in flames?

When The Donald calls aspiring apprentices into the boardroom to determine which one to fire, I’m always hoping for a miracle. I want him to can ALL of them. My feelings about GM are identical. When GM Vice Chairman Bob Lutz hinted that he’d axe Buick or Pontiac if the divisions didn’t “gain traction,” he ignited a debate over which of the General’s lackluster brands deserved death. The answer is, of course, all of them.

General Motors was born as a conglomeration of independent car companies. In the beginning, all of GM’s acquisitions maintained their own distinct mechanical, design and marketing identity. Despite the imposition of centralized control in many strategic areas (e.g. choice of suppliers), each sub-brand remained true to its niche. Exactly when, how and why the structure fell apart, or became one big amorphous mass of poorly made product, is not as important as the fact that it has.

Vauxhall Lightning spawns Saturn Sky.  Corporate synergy or corporate sloth? GM’s eleven brands—Buick, Cadillac, Chevrolet, Holden, Hummer, GMC, Opel, Pontiac, SAAB, Saturn and Vauxhall—are virtually interchangeable. You could rebadge a Vauxhall Lightning and call it a Saturn Sky; or a Holden Monaro and call it a Pontiac GTO; or a GMC truck and call it a SAAB 9-7X. Those are just the real-world examples. How about the new Cadillac STS as a Buick, or the Hummer H3 as a GMC? And that’s without mentioning the elephant on the assembly line: platform sharing.

GM’s brands bring new meaning to the words “product overlap.” Pontiac GTO or Chevrolet Corvette? Chevrolet Cobalt or Saturn Ion? Saab 9-5 or Cadillac CTS? The divisions might have better luck competing with non-GM brands if they weren’t so busy competing against each other. As a result, whenever one of the eleven non-identical twins tries to make a case for itself, it unintentionally demeans a fraternal partner. GMC’s claim to be “professional grade” makes Chevrolet seem amateur. Hummer’s “like nothing else” makes Buick seem common. And so on.

Is there room for Saturn in Saab's state?The marketing departments may beg to differ, but their campaigns don’t. Pontiac still touts itself as GM’s performance division—at the same time that Cadillac emphasizes its products’ supersonic speed. SAAB’s ‘State of Independence’ exhorts buyers to go their own way—while Saturn continues to chase iconoclastic buyers. And here’s a compare-and-contrast from Hell: Chevrolet’s marketing strategy for its full-size pickups vs. GMC’s.

The situation reminds me of Coca-Cola’s plight in the 70s. When the competition started offering strange and marvelous soft drink variations, Coke responded by introducing a wave of new flavors: Coke, Diet Coke, Cherry Coke, Diet Cherry Coke, Caffeine Free Diet Coke, etc. The bottom line? Add all the sales of all the new Coca-Cola sub-brands together and … the company LOST total market share. Am I the only one who sees a parallel with GM, which is responding to their diminishing slice of the US car market by introducing a flood of new products?

More products = less sales?  Whatcha gonna do Bobby?Vice Chairman Lutz could axe a couple of brands, figure out what the remaining ones are supposed to be, erect some Chinese walls and—like Hell he could. Thanks to decades of bureaucratic bungling, craven UAW appeasement and intra-departmental intrigue, GM has neither the will nor the skill to kill the omnivorous cancer devouring it. There’s only one thing for it: sell off all of the brands.

GMAC Finance is the only solidly profitable part of the entire multi-billion dollar corporation; everything else is either limping along, a dead loss or a loss leader. Dump the car and truck making side of the equation and GM becomes instantly profitable. What’s more, under independent ownership, each division would be leaner, meaner and quicker on its feet. Think about the breakup of AT&T, and the highly competitive, hugely profitable baby Bells it spawned…

If the Hummer brands gets bogged down, why can't it be someone else's problem?Even if a liberated division’s new ownership WASN’T entirely independent, even if some other multi-national car-making goliath bought up, say, Hummer, and ran it into the ground, well, so what? As a GM stockholder, I’d say “better them than us”.

The idea of being wrenched from the corporate tit is not bound to please GM’s employees and suppliers. Most sensible financial analysts would view GM’s dissolution as an improbable corporate Krakatoa: a violent, tectonic shift signaling the end of big business as we know it.

Of course, these are the same sensible people who don’t buy GM products anymore. They buy Mercs, Toyotas, BMWs and other vehicles made by companies who don’t try to juggle eleven balls at the same time. If these experts want to feel GM’s seismic rumblings, all they have to do is look at their own driveway. Even the Donald would savor the irony.

By on April 1, 2005

The 1936 120 Junior Packard marked the beginning of the end for the luxury car maker. Once upon a time there was a luxury car manufacturer in America. The company virtually owned the luxury car business, both at home and abroad. Their cars were the gold standard for expensive cars, and rich and powerful people the world over bought and used them. They easily sold more luxury cars in America than most of their competitors combined. Their reputation for engineering innovation and excellence was unsurpassed. All of the best custom body builders clamored to make special show cars for them, in hopes that they could make it into the sales catalogue this company published every December.

Then came hard times. The stock market bubble popped. Thousands of people lost their jobs. And, the market for luxury cars started to dwindle. To make matters worse, the company's major competitor in America started to build bigger and more luxurious cars, and developed a reputation as a true engineering innovator in their own right.

Even the 'Goddess of Speed' couldn't help Packard recover its rep.Top managers, many of whom had been with the company for decades, agonized about what they should do. To do nothing was to ensure that the company would spend all of their savings and go out of business in a few years. The answer, they decided, was to build a car that would sell for substantially less than their traditional luxury models. Thus was born the Packard 120, in 1936.

The 120 was, by all accounts, a pretty nice car. It was powered by a smooth straight 8 engine, and it carried the traditional Packard grill and radiator ornament proudly. But it was no custom built luxury car, just a mass-produced, medium priced vehicle, a Packard one could buy for the price of an Oldsmobile or a Buick. The sales success of the 120 saved the day for Packard, and the company managed to stay in business for another couple of decades. The underpinnings of the 120 provided the basis for many Packard models, like the Clipper and the infamous bathtub Packards of the early 50s.

The 1934 Packard Super 8 Club Sedan.  Now THAT'S what I'm talking about!But the day that ordinary people could afford a Packard marked the end of the company as a viable luxury car manufacturer. Packard's demise as America's luxury car was guaranteed when the town's richest banker glanced out the window of his chauffeur-driven Packard as he left the estate, only to see his gardener arriving in a Packard. In just a few years, Cadillac overtook Packard in luxury car sales, and wrested the crown of American luxury away from Packard for good.

Fast-forward 60 years, to the 2005 North American International Auto Show, in Detroit. Lincoln, reeling from a 50% drop in sales over the last 5 years, announced the new Lincoln Zephyr. Priced to compete with the Nissan Maxima and the Toyota Avalon, the Zephyr is the lowest priced Lincoln (inflation adjusted) ever offered. While the Zephyr appears to be a very nice medium priced car (it is, after all, made from a Mazda 6) it faces some pretty tough competition. The Zephyr, like the Packard 120, will allow thousands of new owners to sail down the road behind a Lincoln grill and hood ornament. If it sells well, Lincoln will make some money, but at what cost to the Lincoln brand? Will the average hip-hop artist still want a Lincoln Navigator when he sees the bartender at his favorite club drive up in a Lincoln Zephyr?

The Lincoln Zephyr: yet another nail in the brand's coffin.Lincoln's Town Car is already suffering under the onslaught of a revitalized Cadillac and a host of other tough luxury car competitors. Once the car of choice for stretch limo converters, it is rapidly being displaced by the new Cadillac DTS. The Lincoln LS, aimed at the BMW 3 series, is failing, despite offering a V8 to the 3 series 6. The Navigator is in a fierce sales duel with SUVs from Porsche (Porsche!), BMW, Lexus, Land Rover, Cadillac and others, and the Aviator appears never to have lifted off the runway. Moving the Lincoln brand downscale threatens the viability of these products even more.

It is rare that a luxury carmaker recovers from flirting with downscale products. Packard never recovered, and Cadillac, after the unfortunate Cimarron and Catera, discovered that it takes many years and many billions of dollars in new products, to begin to turn around a cheapened image. Jaguar is in the process of discovering this, in the wake of the X-type debacle. Even Infiniti found that cheapening the brand caused it to lose all value in the US.

The 1936 Zephyr, a Lincoln by nature, but not by name.Ironically, the first Zephyr, in 1936, was Lincoln's answer to the Packard 120 and the LaSalle. It didn't carry the Lincoln name, just as LaSalle didn't carry the Cadillac name. The value of the Lincoln name wasn't squandered on a medium priced car, and lived on in the first Lincoln Continental, and a host of other fine cars.

By on March 30, 2005

 The DUB Edition™ Dodge Charger RT: proof postive that bling is a dead trend stunting.I've been wondering about the future of urban car culture for some time. How can its adherents sustain interest in an automotive genre based almost entirely on big wheels, retrofitted TV's, new upholstery and presidential window tint? Extreme examples are still eye magnets, but they're beginning to seem a bit… limited. Sure, car nuts of all stripes are capable of endlessly obsessing over the smallest details– body colored engine braces, taillight covers, tire treads, miniscule horsepower upgrades, etc. But there's only so much you can do to make a car look like a pimpmobile. In general, and in specific, it's been done.

There are unmistakable signs that the urban car culture is weakening. Scan the formerly blingtastic celebrity car mags and you'll find that a lot of famous faces are leaving their supercars well enough alone. Whether this restraint reflects the celebs' assimilation into America's conservative elite, or a simple case of depreciation appreciation, it deprives street car culture of some its most distinguished proponents. As a celebrity-fuelled movement– unlike ground-up car cults like the Japanese tuner scene– the gangsta look loses momentum every time a Foxy Brown poses next to a stock Lamborghini or Bentley.

 And while we're at it, what makes this car's design so different from stock? Wheels, tint, lowering. Is that enough?You can also clock the flagging interest in bling mods on TV. Funkmaster Flex once earned his living by creating extravagant wheel, ICE and fabric alterations for celebrities' contemporary SUV's. These days, his crew applies much of their transformative powers to older American metal, lightening the color palate away from ghetto-fabulous black, delving into the mechanical minutia and leaving the Playstation in the playroom. Some of the finished machines wouldn't look out of place at a muscle car concours.

MTV's "Pimp My Ride" has also abandoned hard core gangsta chic. A recent edition transformed an old VW bus into a clean, contemporary-looking surfer's wet dream. Considering the number of blingless gizmo grafts– built-in pool tables, pop-up signs, toasters, etc. — the producers could justifiably change the show's name to "Sharper Image my Ride". Urban car culture simply couldn't offer a large enough palate for TV's insatiable maw.

The Saleen S7, star of Rapper 50 Cent's 'Candy Shop' video, sans modifications.Music videos also reflect the fact that the spinner culture has spun out. The big guns have moved on; Rapper 50 Cent's "Candy Shop" features a stock Saleen S7. Granted, the soft core promotion showed the half-dollar dude sleeping in a black-hole-black 645Ci with wafer thin tires and aftermarket wheels, but it wasn't his dream ride. In any case, music videos now showcase exotic whips that were born wild, rather than made that way.

DUB is the exception that proves the rule. The magazine still soldiers away, resolutely Old School, preaching the gospel of mesh grills, suede headliners and 22" wheels (double Dubs). And why not? Bling's the thing that makes their cash register ring. The company is busy reaping the financial rewards of bringing branded black automotive culture to the, dare I say it, white masses. Predictable as it is in every detail, the DUB Edition™ Dodge Charger RT will be a sure-fire hit amongst mainstreamers, who trust the "experts'" taste and prefer fully warranted, turnkey bling.

4-bling_copy_1.jpgOf course, OEM success is a sure sign that bling is a dead trend stunting. What good is looking like a gangsta if the yuppie next to you looks like one too? Lest we forget, automakers from Chrysler (300C, Charger) to Mercedes (CLS500) to GM (HHR) are selling more and more cars with built-in bling. The wilder the design, the greater the degree of pre-existing product "individuality", the lesser the need for ANY modification, urban or otherwise. It would be hard to imagine a DUB edition Chevrolet SSR.

Like the rest of the blingmeisters, DUB ain't dumb. They know their days are numbered. Hence, there's a subtle shift in the company's emphasis. The DUB edition Chrysler 300C package includes a sports exhaust and a power-boosting chromed air intake. Like the rest of the urban car culture, the magazine is searching for a way to take the bling ethos in a new direction.

Sterling silver speedo anyone? Hello?Mind you, it's highly unlikely that performance is the new black. Despite the urban car culture's predilection for Ferraris, Lamborghinis, AMG Mercs and other high velocity metal, driving the cars fast is entirely beside the point. It's all about slow-speed status projection, or, to use the old-fashioned term, cruising. Which leaves the scene with… what? BIGGER wheels? MORE mini-TV's? Diamond-encrusted steering wheels? Sterling silver speedometers?

Well, yes. In the long run, urban car culture will either gradually disappear into the wider car scene, as the mainstream audience loses interest, or mutate into something new and extravagant. My money is on the latter. Now that minority buyers have found an automotive design language of their own, it's only a matter of time before they re-invent and re-invigorate it. The sheer bravado of bling, its irresistible energy, can not, WILL not be denied.

By on March 29, 2005

The Jeep Wrangler: you can't kill it with a stickDetroit execs have been too quick to sell the idea that consumers' clocks have struck midnight and turned the hardcore small SUV and pickup party into a pumpkin. Ask any domestic automaker, and today's smart truck money is almost exclusively on the crossover market. And while it's true that all-wheel-drive softroaders are hot, the notion that Americans won't pony up for a charismatic, purposeful body-on-frame compact is utter nonsense. The segment's erosion has far more to do with a dearth of compelling product than it does with the rise of alternative classes.

Need proof? Look no further than Jeep's evergreen Wrangler. Despite underpinnings hewn from Woolly Mammoth tusks and a convertible top that only a masochist could love, it continues to sell smartly year after year, decade after decade. In fact, its sales have actually been trending UPWARD as of late– no doubt thanks in part to the overdue addition of Jeep's Unlimited model (and the brand's ever-present cult of personality).

Why can't Detroit see it?  Nissan's revamped Xterra proves that a basic, hardcore compact SUV still flies out the showroom.Of course, not every vehicle possesses Jeep's iconic style and enviable lineage. But that hasn't stopped Nissan from doing a decent trade in its Xterra. Based on a then-aging Frontier pickup, the first generation model quickly capitalized on the unrealized demand for an authentic 'purist's' SUV, almost in spite of itself. Overlooking more cheap plastic rattles than a Tic-Tac factory, those much-coveted 'extreme-sports' types lined up, smitten with the Xterra's beefcake visuals (jungle-gym roof rack, first-aid kit tailgate blister, etc.). Freshly bulked up, the second-generation Xterra remedies its predecessor's deplorable on-road manners and exiguous power allotment, all while fortifying its off-road credibility.

Sadly, the best a domestic compact truck intender can hope for these days is Ford's moth-eaten Ranger and General Motors' instantly-dated Colorado/Canyon twins. Loyalists looking to trade-in their old examples have been understandably reluctant to shell out for what amounts to dent-free versions of what they already own. It comes as little surprise, given Ranger's oatmeal-like constitution and appearance. GM's duo manages better, but suffers from a poorly conceived engine range and interiors exuding more plastic flashing than Anna Nicole.

The Dodge Dakota: not exactly a compact SUV (but an excellent way to stay dry)Worryingly, there's little relief in sight. Bill's boffins continually push afield a Ranger replacement, and GM's ColCan is still too light on calendar pages to receive a meaningful upgrade. Worse still, neither appears to be anywhere close to introducing a hardcore demi-ute. Of course, flag-wavers still have Dodge's Dakota and Durango, but their available V8s are thirsty and less powerful than competitor's V6s, and neither remotely says 'compact.'

Which brings us to the Japanese. Once-dormant Nissan has moved closer to fine with its confident new Frontier. Formerly a knock-kneed, oddly styled also-ran, Nissan wisely plugged its Titan full-sizer into a Xerox machine set on 'Mini-Me,' resulting in a powerful and competitive midsize offering.

The 2004 Ford Bronco concept truck: a missed opportunity to fight back against Japanese importsAnd while Toyota's long been guilty of misunderstanding the needs of the American truck buyer (the too-small T-100 begetting the too-small Tundra, etc.), that's no longer true. The Tacoma now impresses with its configurability and segment-defining power and refinement. What's more, the forthcoming FJ Cruiser signifies Toyota's intention to transcend its reputation for trafficking solely in the safe, sanitized, and reliable. If its throwback off-roader arrives cheaply enough, expect a colossal hit.

It didn't have to be this way. Ford's delectable derv-burning Bronco concept went down a storm at the 2004 NAIAS, and should've been fast-tracked for production immediately. However (and somewhat predictably), Dearborn lacks suitable drawers in its hamper for the SUV, and the Bronco remains mired in feasibility studies. At last word, Ford's Brazilian-built EcoSport platform is under consideration, but such rumblings lack promise. An old school off-roader masquerading atop a car-derived monocoque? Umm, no.

The V6-powered Toyota FJ Concept, coming to a showroom near you soonLest we forget, in 2002, Dodge's M80 concept promised to put the 'body' back in 'body-on-frame.' Retro-steeped yet forward thinking, John Opfer's design was enthusiastically received by press and consumer alike, but the much-discussed 'shrinking small pickup market' shriveled Dodge's cojones in the end. Pity, as it would've made for a nifty little SUV, too.

It's tragic. The Big Three desperately need solid-selling small trucks to boost their CAFE figures and improve their lot among younger buyers. As it stands, the Ranger and Colorado lose ground minute by minute, their numbers propped to competitiveness largely via incentives and fleet sales. Dodge is the closest domestic to righting its ship, but remains well adrift.

Look: just a few years ago, most execs completely wrote off rear-wheel-drive family sedans, station wagons and hatchbacks. DCX's wildly successful 300 and Magnum, along with BMW's MINI illustrate that the right products write their own demand curves, statistics be damned. It's a shame Detroit remains oblivious to the latent sales potential in the small 'true' pickup/SUV segments, because their competitors aren't likely to make the same mistake.

By on March 17, 2005

The Ford Five Hundred features a CTV transmission. Why?I can't figure out the appeal of the Continuously Variable Transmission (CVT). Currently featured in the new Ford 500 sedan, the transmission system consists of a pair of cones and a steel drive belt to transfer power. The CVT offers a continuous ratio change (similar to changing gear with a standard manual or automatic) by varying the diameter of the cones, without a step in ratios like a conventional automatic transmission. While conceptually simple, the actual hardware is tremendously complex and expensive. What's more, supporters' claim that the CVT increases economy and performance simply doesn't bear close scrutiny.

Proponents claim that the CVT offers superior mileage by providing a higher overdrive ratio than other transmissions. (Overdrive is another way of saying that the engine turns slower than the driveshaft, which is typical of all modern automatic transmissions.) In the case of the Ford 500's Ford/ZF unit, the overdrive ratio is .41:1. In other words, the engine turns 4/10s of a revolution for every turn of the driveshaft. That's considerably greater than the .69 overdrive ratio of the conventional automatic transmission on offer.

In theory. In practice, the Ford CVT's ratio is 5.41:1; which is a much lower final drive ratio compared to the same car with a conventional automatic. The result is an overall ratio of 2.2:1 in the CVT car vs. 2.3:1 in a car with an autobox. The overall relationship of engine speed to wheel speed is nearly identical.

At 70 mph, the tach needle would point to the same number, no matter which transmission was installed. When cruising down the expressway, the engines in both cars would be going the same speed, doing the same amount of work, and thus getting the same mileage. The comparison remains valid at any cruising speed over about 30, where the automatic transmission is in overdrive.

It's a similar situation for off-the-line acceleration. The CVT has much less torque multiplication, but a lower-geared final drive. The Ford uses a torque converter between the engine and the gearbox to further increase torque multiplication at launch. Since Ford uses torque converters with the same torque multiplication (effectively the same as a gear reduction), the overall ratio between the engine and the wheels is the same. With the same gear ratios, the cars will have the same acceleration, no more and no less.

The CVT's main claim to fame is that it keeps the engine at a constant speed, either the most efficient or the most powerful, while accelerating. In the days when engines had narrow power bands and peaked torque curves, this may have been more than a theoretical advantage. But today's engines have torque curves as flat as Kansas, and power curves to match. And today's automatic transmissions have five or six geared speeds, usually with only about 18-25% ratio differences between ratios. In other words, modern engines have essentially the same amount of power or torque over a relatively wide RPM range, and today's automatic transmissions have a narrow enough ratio spread between their gears to use all of the torque and power that the engine produces.

Every transmission suffers internal power losses, but internal losses in the CVT's hydraulic control system are higher than that of a conventional automatic transmission. The hydraulic control systems have to operate at higher pressures or flows, to squeeze the steel cones on steel belts, diverting more energy from the engine and leaving less to move the car. Since the CVT's torque converter is similar to the conventional transmission, internal efficiency of the CVT is lower. This hurts the CVT's ability to deliver the promised higher mileage.

The CVT also requires special, expensive fluid to withstand the heat and pressure demands, and scheduled oil changes. In fact, all things being equal, the CVT has no performance, economy or reliability advantages over a more conventional system. But this equation doesn't include ergonomic factors, which put the CVT at a distinct disadvantage.

It's clear that people aren't comfortable driving a car without transmission shift 'feel"; they like to know when their transmission is in "low gear" or 'high gear'. Obviously, a seamless CVT transmission doesn't transmit this kind of information. As a result of customer feedback, Audi felt compelled to programmed their CVT to have steps, just like a conventional automatic transmission. This made drivers feel better, but defeated the CVT's original purpose.

Of course, I'm not the only one who fails to see the rationale for a CVT. After having invested millions in new technology and a new plant, rumor has it that Ford is about to discontinue the CVT option from the 500, writing off their investment before the model year has properly begun. The move would be a hugely expensive about-face, but it's the right thing to do.

By on February 10, 2005

The 2003 Aston Martin AMV8 concept, designed by Ian Callum When Jaguar unveiled its "Advanced Lightweight Coupe" (ALC) at the Detroit Auto Show, the stakes couldn't have been higher. The concept car had to mollify exasperated Ford bean counters, already thinking the unthinkable. It had to burnish the brand's fading reputation for jaw-dropping design and innovative engineering. So, at the precise moment when Jaguar needed a major hit to rescue the brand from oblivion, the company reveals… a copy of an Aston Martin.

Anyone who can't see the resemblance between the Jaguar ALC and the 2003 Aston Martin AMV8 concept vehicle and/or the Aston Martin DB7 Vantage, anyone who couldn't guess that the same man designed all three cars, is either blind or… no, that's it. They're blind. Compare the rear haunches, rectangular rear windows and curvy side glass. Note the identical front and rear overhangs. The Jag's shape, stance and detailing are so obviously Aston that the only thing stopping Aston from suing Jaguar is the fact that Ford owns both companies.

The 2005 Jaguar Advanced Lightweight Coupe concept, designed by Ian Callum.Granted, the number of Americans who'd recognize an Aston Martin is smaller than the number of Aston owners who slap on Aqua Velva. Despite the British marque's recent production ramp-up, Astons are still as rare as those hot dog shaped vehicles Oscar Mayer used to run. And let's face it: many stunning cars "borrow" heavily from previous designs. (Jaguar's XK120 and BMW's 1940 328 are automotive doppelgangers.) So it's possible that the ALC's derivative design would find a receptive audience despite its provenance. Ah, but what KIND of audience?

Elderly. Don't be fooled by all the talk about the ALC's aluminum construction and the plan to stuff higher-powered versions of Jag's feisty V8's under the hood. The prototype's size virtually guarantees that Jag's new two-seater will be another triple-XK: a pricey GT rather than a credible 911-fighter. As such, the ALC will appeal to the XK's current audience: high-maintenance women of a certain age and warm climate males more interested in their car's impact at the country club valet stand than its ability to make short work of an open road.

The 2000 Jaguar F-Type concept.  Sigh.In case you missed the point, the XK drop-top outsells the coupe in the US by more than two to one. Of course, at this point, Jaguar would be forgiven for taking any customers it can get. The X-type fizzled, the S-Type bombed, the XJ is barely holding the fort and the current XK has been around since, gulp, 1996. Still, by devising an XK replacement that's aimed straight at the [weak] heart of an ageing market, Jag could eventually do an Oldsmobile, and die with its core supporters.

It's sad. Jaguar keeps chasing Mercedes SL's and Lexus sedans with wood, leather and snob appeal. If Jag's management truly understood the marque's heritage, they'd know that Jaguar should be building simple, striking motor cars that can best the AMG, M, S and V's of the world. They'd also direct Callum and Co. to ash-can the whole black-tie luxury limo look in favor of something elegant that looks fast standing still. Think Ford GT, with class.

If it feels good from here, all is forgiven.  If not, not.Meanwhile, Jaguar needs a car on the opposite end of the scale to generate cash and attract a younger clientele. (The mini-me XJ clone, the X-Type, was so not it it's funny.) The ideal solution would be a small, fast sports car with terrific handling, superb ride quality and looks that scream "Faster Pussycat; Kill, Kill, Kill!" If a Jaguar roadster hit the $35 – $40K sweet spot, it would fly off the forecourt fast enough to whisk the salesmen's' toupees right off their heads.

That car was the Jaguar F-Type. The brand saver was deep-sixed because someone at Jaguar figured The Blue Oval's cash would be better spent developing diesel versions of Jaguar sedans for DERV-crazy Europeans. Huh? Modern diesel engines may match or exceed the performance capabilities of their gasoline counterparts, but they literally stink of penny-pinching practicality. If the market calls for a frugal Jag, well, the market's wrong. Take away the Jaguar's animal roar and you're left with a Mercedes. (At best.) A Jag that doesn't deliver pure, unadulterated driving pleasure is about as alluring as a Hummer that can't go off-road.

And that's why Jaguar is in such deep shit. They keep putting grace over pace and getting their ass kicked all over the place. Sure, I might be wrong. Despite its unmistakable Astonness, the ALC might turn out to be a proper Jag. It might have delicious steering feel, fantastic handling poise, huge horsepower, monumental torque and a world-beating interior. If so, the cat will have lost one of its lives, but survived. If not, it's time to euthanize the old tabby.

By on February 5, 2005

keys1.jpgWhy aren’t mechanical skills taught in driver’s ed anymore? Aspiring motorists learn obscure signage, passing safely (an oxymoron to any parent) and when to pay their motoring taxes. But basic automotive maintenance is a total no show. In my home state, a new driver can get a learner’s permit or driver’s license without having the slightest idea how to check their car’s oil or change a tire.

It’s a shame. Our schools teach our kids how to cook, use a laptop and avoid sexually transmitted diseases. Today's techno-savvy teens can whip-up an omelet, send batch emails from Starbucks and open a condom one-handed, but they don’t know how to keep their car running smoothly and safely. They consider automotive maintenance and repair something their hopelessly nerdy Dad does, or something that happens when their parents [arbitrarily] interrupt their freedom by sequestering the car at the local dealer.

This glaring omission can be traced back to the modern cars’ increasing reliability. Even before Cadillac’s zero-maintenance Northstar engine appeared, manufacturers had been Hell-bent on eliminating any non-cabin customer-to-car interaction. The Japanese have been particularly zealous in this regard, and successful; drivers no longer expect anything to go wrong with their cars. Ever. In fact, reliability has come to mean inviolability: hood and trunk locks are protective shields against "amateur" interference.

keys2.jpgThis mechanical dumbing down has gone over the top. For example, more and more cars are being fitted with run-flat tires. The technology completely eliminates the need to know how to fit a spare; which is just as well as there usually isn’t one, and if there is, most young drivers wouldn’t know where to find it or what to do with it when they did. Electronic oil gauges are also becoming the norm, virtually eliminating the need to be able to find or use a dipstick.

Once upon a time, automotive mechanical skills were passed from father to son, mother to daughter, friend to friend. Now, much to my amazement, I’ve yet to meet a teenager who knows anything about their car other than how to hook-up their iPod. Recommended oil? Pass. Battery location? Dunno. How to tell when the brakes are wearing out? Nope. The enthusiasts amongst them want NOS and coffee can exhausts, but they have no idea where or how to affix the parts to make them work (other than the local tuning shop). We’ve lost an entire generation to the microchip mentality: if it’s broke, replace it.

keys32.jpgObviously, no car is 100% reliable. Even a Toyota can fail when you least expect it. If you’re paranoid or believe in Murphy’s Law (or both), the breakdown will inevitably occur in the most dangerous place possible (e.g. a busy highway at night in the rain, or the part of town where tow trucks refuse to respond). It’s also obvious that we can no longer rely on the government, schools or the social network to impart mechanical skills to young drivers. Which means it’s down to us, the “car nerd”, to teach our genetic inheritors the basic repair and maintenance skills they need; before their ignorance kills, injures or strands them in the middle of nowhere.

So how do you broach a subject that your children find about as trendy as Herb Alpert and his Tijuana Brass? Cunning and subterfuge. Choose a day when their social schedule is either relative empty or completely full. Run the car’s battery flat, let the air out of a tire, pull a bulb from the tail lights, remove a fuse, extract a wiper blade and hide the keys under the spare. Then gently inform your hormone charged loved ones that they’re not going ANYWHERE until they learn how to take care of the car.

Start with something simple. Hand them the tire iron and ask them what it’s for. (If necessary, duck.) Then have them change that flat tire. Remember: laziness makes people clever. Don’t end up changing the tire for them. Next, move on to the engine compartment. Get them to open the hood (trickier than it sounds), check the oil, refill the windshield washer fluid, locate the battery, and so on. Then watch them replace the wiper blade, headlight bulb and fuse. Finish with the jumper cables to get the whole thing started.

Once you’re satisfied that your children can take care of family car fundamentals, you’ll sleep a little better at night. You can go back to worrying about that guy your daughter is dating, instead of worrying about that AND whether the car will make it home.

By on February 5, 2005

      Cadillac's Northstar V8: zero maintenance for the first 100kWhy aren't mechanical skills taught in driver's ed anymore? Aspiring motorists learn obscure signage, passing safely (an oxymoron to any parent) and when to pay their motoring taxes. But basic automotive maintenance is a total no show. In my home state, a new driver can get a learner's permit or driver's license without having the slightest idea how to check their car's oil or change a tire.

It's a shame. Our schools teach our kids how to cook, use a laptop and avoid sexually transmitted diseases. Today's techno-savvy teens can whip-up an omelet, send batch emails from Starbucks and open a condom one-handed, but they don't know how to keep their car running smoothly and safely. They consider automotive maintenance and repair something their hopelessly nerdy Dad does, or something that happens when their parents [arbitrarily] interrupt their freedom by sequestering the car at the local dealer.

   That white box in the right hand corner is the battery, Dude.This glaring omission can be traced back to the modern cars' increasing reliability. Even before Cadillac's zero-maintenance Northstar engine appeared, manufacturers had been Hell-bent on eliminating any non-cabin customer-to-car interaction. The Japanese have been particularly zealous in this regard, and successful; drivers no longer expect anything to go wrong with their cars. Ever. In fact, reliability has come to mean inviolability: hood and trunk locks are protective shields against 'amateur' interference.

This mechanical dumbing down has gone over the top. For example, more and more cars are being fitted with run-flat tires. The technology completely eliminates the need to know how to fit a spare; which is just as well as there usually isn't one, and if there is, most young drivers wouldn't know where to find it or what to do with it when they did. Electronic oil gauges are also becoming the norm, virtually eliminating the need to be able to find or use a dipstick.

The fact that there's a website for this stuff is reason enough to teach your children what to do in an emergencyOnce upon a time, automotive mechanical skills were passed from father to son, mother to daughter, friend to friend. Now, much to my amazement, I've yet to meet a teenager who knows anything about their car other than how to hook-up their iPod. Recommended oil? Pass. Battery location? Dunno. How to tell when the brakes are wearing out? Nope. The enthusiasts amongst them want NOS and coffee can exhausts, but they have no idea where or how to affix the parts to make them work (other than the local tuning shop). We've lost an entire generation to the microchip mentality: if it's broke, replace it.

Obviously, no car is 100% reliable. Even a Toyota can fail when you least expect it. If you're paranoid or believe in Murphy's Law (or both), the breakdown will inevitably occur in the most dangerous place possible (e.g. a busy highway at night in the rain, or the part of town where tow trucks refuse to respond). It's also obvious that we can no longer rely on the government, schools or the social network to impart mechanical skills to young drivers. Which means it's down to us, the "car nerd", to teach our genetic inheritors the basic repair and maintenance skills they need; before their ignorance kills, injures or strands them in the middle of nowhere.

So how do you broach a subject that your children find about as trendy as Herb Alpert and his Tijuana Brass? Cunning and subterfuge. Choose a day when their social schedule is either relative empty or completely full. Run the car's battery flat, let the air out of a tire, pull a bulb from the tail lights, remove a fuse, extract a wiper blade and hide the keys under the spare. Then gently inform your hormone charged loved ones that they're not going ANYWHERE until they learn how to take care of the car.

Start with something simple. Hand them the tire iron and ask them what it's for. (If necessary, duck.) Then have them change that flat tire. Remember: laziness makes people clever. Don't end up changing the tire for them. Next, move on to the engine compartment. Get them to open the hood (trickier than it sounds), check the oil, refill the windshield washer fluid, locate the battery, and so on. Then watch them replace the wiper blade, headlight bulb and fuse. Finish with the jumper cables to get the whole thing started.

Once you're satisfied that your children can take care of family car fundamentals, you'll sleep a little better at night. You can go back to worrying about that guy your daughter is dating, instead of worrying about that AND whether the car will make it home.

By on February 2, 2005

 Enthusiasts born since 1975 may not believe it, but General Motors was once the world's automotive style leader. Under designer Harley Earl's direction, the General's products attained an unparalleled level of artistic achievement. Cars like the LaSalle, '55 Chevrolet and the early Corvettes embodied Earl's genius, and made the competitor's products look dated, clumsy and awkward.

When Earl retired from GM in 1958, his spirit lived on for at least two more decades. You can see his influence in the 60's Pontiacs and 70's Corvettes. And then, well, considering the styling of GM's vehicles in the last couple of decades, old Harley eventually began to spin in his grave. How such a style-led company could release a vehicle as ugly as the Pontiac Aztek or the 2000 Impala is anybody's guess. But, maybe, just maybe, the great man's spirit is back in GM's design studio. Consider the Buick LaCrosse…

 The LaCrosse is a striking yet subtle design. Its surface development is nothing less than superb; the transitions from one plane to another are wonderfully harmonious. The creases in the LaCrosse's rear quarters add enough visual tension to keep the large surfaces from appearing merely bulbous, and they add length to what is actually a fairly short car for a mid-sized sedan.

Notice that the LaCrosse's rear door cut-line stops short of the wheel opening. This detail ensures that panel misalignment– a virtual certainty when building a mass-produced car– doesn't cut into the line of the wheel opening, creating an awkward disruption in the curve.

 The LaCrosse's basic proportions are also perfectly judged. The A-pillars are aimed, in side view, right at the front wheel centers. If the A-pillars are too far forward (e.g. Chrysler LHS), the car looks like it's tripping over its wheels. If they're too far back (older Mercedes E-class), the car looks too formal to be a modern car. This detail seems to have eluded many designers, perhaps because of the need to be trendy and different, rather than inherently pleasing.

The C-pillar relationship to the rear wheels is equally important. Again, the LaCrosse gets it just right. The C-pillar's visual center and the rear of the roof are supported by the center of the rear wheel. This positioning gives the roof the visual support it needs to look strong. Too far back (Ford 500 and lots of other cars), and it looks like the designers skimped on the wheelbase. Too far forward, and the car looks stretched.

 The mass of the roof plays off perfectly against the mass of the rest of the body. If the side glass is too short, a car looks like an armored pillbox (Chrysler 300). Too tall, and the car looks small and weak (early BMW 2002). A car needs a certain amount of body mass to look healthy, and the Buick achieves the perfect balance.

If a car's wheel openings are centered above the center of the wheels, the car looks like it is about to go off-roading, like the Ford 500 and F150. If the car sits too low on the wheels, it looks like an amateur custom job, like the majority of SEMA's tuner cars. The LaCrosse's wheels are ideally positioned: centered in the wheel openings. And the LaCrosse's tires are the correct diameter to fill the openings; no wimpy, under-tired econobox here.

Back when Harley Earl was boss, GM cars had no exposed fasteners, no visible joints between body panels, no raw edges of sheet metal. Even the gas caps were hidden on most models, lurking behind trick taillights or license plates. Today's government rules prevent the gas cap from disappearing, but in every other way, the LaCrosse lives up to the standards Harley Earl set forth those many decades ago. There isn't an awkward detail in the entire body. Of course, if Harley Earl was really in charge, the LaCrosse would have had three portholes in each front fender, and the Park Avenue would have four. Maybe next year…

While the LaCrosse's overall design still looks like a Buick, there are many elements, especially in the greenhouse, that are vaguely evocative of a refined and updated Taurus. Looking at the Buick, it's easy to imagine what the Ford 500 should have been– rather than the amateur Audi copy it became.

The LaCrosse's TV ads reflect the car's sense of refinement and understatement. No crazy driving on isolated, curving roads (closed course, professional driver, don't sue us if you try it and it goes badly), no tearing through the wilderness or splashing through mud puddles. No, the Buick LaCrosse is simply shown along with a beautiful, mature woman in a variety of subtly suggestive poses. Yes, Harley Earl is back at the Buick studio, and not a moment too soon.

By on January 28, 2005

 I read somewhere that less than two percent of Americans own a passport. As someone who spent 18 years abroad, I can fully understand the average citizen's reluctance to experience the joys of surly service, high prices, questionable hygiene and murderous Muslims. Still, as a journalist covering a multi-national industry, I do my best to keep an open mind about other lands, other cultures– or at least ignore them as best I can.

And then Steve Sutcliffe goes and writes a review of the Ford F150. The feature was called "Meet the world's best-selling vehicle: it's got a 292bhp V8, rear-wheel drive, rides like a 7-series and you can fit half your house into it…" The Autocar rant is a perfect example of Europe's view of America, illustrating the combination of hatred and envy that drives our so-called allies to subvert American foreign policy at every turn.


In his piece, Mr. Sutcliffe wastes no time exposing his anti-American prejudice. In the first paragraph, he states that the F150 appeals to two audiences, "those who don't take life too seriously (which is fine), or those who have so much fresh air between their ears they wouldn't even know how to spell global warming, let alone understand the threat it may pose to our species."

For those of you too stupid to know when you're being called stupid, Mr. Sutcliffe shares a commonly held European belief that the average American– including President Bush– is as dumb as toast. This basic precept gives Mr. Sutcliffe the freedom to criticize American automobiles even as he enjoys them. They're stupid but fun. The reason why the author gives "people who don't take life seriously" a free pass is equally clear– at least to those familiar with Mr. Sutcliffe's predilection for high-speed automobiles whose mileage figures rarely crest single digits.

The hypocritical, condescending scribe's opening salvo also betrays the perspective that global warming is a fact, vehicles are responsible, America has lots of low mpg vehicles, so America (more than anyone else) is killing the planet. Mr. Sutcliffe spells it out even more directly, saying he couldn't possibly endorse the F150 "in an era of giant tsunamis washing away thousands of people on the other side of the world and extreme weather events rapidly turning into ordinary weather events far closer to home".

Of course, it's a bit of a stretch– linking an earthquake-created tsunami and the UK's notoriously miserable weather to America's love affair with a pickup truck– but don't expect any of Mr. Sutcliffe's compatriots to disagree. The UK's political mainstream is rabidly anti-car, taxing personal transportation with unrestrained zeal in the guise of protecting the planet from harmful emissions. Going against the grain would risk alienation from the college-educated chattering classes, of which journalists are a founding member. Better to embrace miserly, unsafe econoboxes, blame the Americans and be done with it.

It's paragraph three, we're still not anywhere near a review of the Ford F150's character, and Mr. Sutcliffe is turning nasty, rejecting his own argument that the US' environmental irresponsibility is down to our mental limitations. He wonders if the Ford truck is "the biggest irrelevance on four wheels and conclusive proof that, by and large, Americans aren't just mugs but thugs in ecological terms." This before even driving the thing.

When Mr. Sutcliffe does begin his actual road test, he can't help but like the F150. This is the envy side of the equation. Quite rightly, he praises the pickup for its ride, steering, acceleration and agility. His adoration is such that he begins to make excuses for the F150's popularity, citing the usual sop that American drivers have "vast amounts of space" and cheap gas. The fact that the F150 sells well in US states smaller than the UK, and that the UK is an oil-producing nation, doesn't appear on Mr. Sutcliffe's editorial radar.

Of course, such flattery must be tempered, which creates the kind of comical love – hate tension you can see throughout European culture. "Despite its impressive ability to do pretty much whatever you ask it to do on the road, we do not, never have, and never will NEED a vehicle like the Ford F150 cluttering up our world." As one of Mr. Sutcliffe's countrymen said so succinctly, methinks he doth protest too much.

The article concludes by stating– again, twice– that the F150 is not for the UK because the roads are more congested, petrol is more expensive, and "our lawmakers (thankfully) have a fair bit more between their ears." And then he doffs his cap and says "no hard feelings, y'understand?" Speaking as a patriotic American who was black-listed by Mr. Sutcliffe, I'm afraid it's not that easy. These days, if you can't play nice, America isn't going to play nice either. You have been warned.

By on January 25, 2005

The Mazda6 Sportswagon has MORE cargo room than a Tribute.  Try telling that to SUV-crazed consumers. Raging against SUV's is still all the rage. Despite the vehicles' continued popularity, the auto industry has heard the drum beat. And so they're developing and marketing eco-friendly alternatives to America's super sized SUV's. While none of these new vehicles will liberate the US from its dependency on foreign oil or scrub our skies clean, you gotta give Detroit credit for boldly going where they really don't want to go. And the results are not as dynamically dull as you'd imagine….

"Sports wagons" are an excellent example. The acceleration, braking, and handling of today's station wagons make SUV's look like yesterday's station wagons. Extreme machines like Audi's blistering S4 Avant, Mercedes E55 AMG estate and Dodge's Magnum SRT-8 will not only embarrass every SUV on the road, but many thoroughbred sports cars as well. Granted: the sports wagons' cornering abilities are limited by their extended wheelbase and gross curb weight. But none of them sports the SUV's 'tipping over truck' icon on the driver's visor. Nuff said?

The Freestyle XUV: Ford forecourts remain fireproof.Sports wagons also provide more 'utility' than all but an epic few SUV's. Compare the racy new Mazda6 Sport Wagon with the Mazda Tribute SUV. With the rear seats folded down, the Mazda6 sports wagon's carrying capacity is within 10% of the Tribute SUV's cargo room. With the seats up, the Mazda6 wagon actually has MORE schlepping space than its SUV cousin. And the 6's lower lift-over height makes it easier to load. As the average family's toting needs involve 2.5 children, groceries and alcohol– rather than soccer teams, Harley's and armoires– the sports wagon is almost always as practical as a mid-sized SUV.

So, sport wagons are an ideal SUV extraction device for drivers with stuff to carry who like to drive. Only one problem: the vast majority of US automotive consumers couldn't care less about driving pleasure. They view corners and curves as obstacles to the next piece of dead straight interstate or pancake flat parking lot. American SUV drivers want lots of room, a cushy ride, (perceived) safety and a high vantage point. Sport wagons fail on all but one of those criteria.

Marge Simpson's SUV: no friend to tree rats-- er, squirrels. To appease the increasingly rabid anti-SUV lobby, automakers went back to the drawing board to create a whole new and exciting acronym: the "XUV" or "cross-over vehicle". The bastard child of the station wagon and SUV, the XUV is typically based on a car platform. Compared to an SUV, it's more reasonably sized, fuel efficient and stable in emergency maneuvers. And, if it all goes horribly wrong, the XUV's lower bumpers and lighter weight means there is less chance of turning the other car into a crushed soda can. The XUV is safer for you, safer for me, more eco-friendly and fits into a parking space smaller than Africa.

And… no sale. Jeep's by-the-numbers Grand Cherokee SUV currently outsells the Chrysler Pacifica XUV by more than two-to-one. Ford's Freestyle is still new to the market, but the safe money is that Ford's X-formula– a tall, bland-looking wagon with lots of room, a cushy ride and a high vantage point– ain't exactly setting the forecourts on fire. Mercedes' upcoming R Class XUV and BMW's much-anticipated "we-swear-it's not-a-minivan" minivan hopes to provide the missing ingredient: status. But it's far from a done deal.

Holy Ozone Batman!  When will we tax the polluters properly?While XUV's can do everything most people demand of an SUV, they lack one important attribute: the image of power. Remember Marge Simpson cruising behind the wheel of her "squirrel-crushing, deer-smacking Canyonero"? Bingo. That's what the SUV craze is REALLY about. A decade or so ago, when soccer moms started moving into rough-riding SUV's, they already had vehicles with lots of room, cushy rides and a high vantage point. They left their minivans because they weren't macho enough.

The truth is clear. American drivers will not abandon their SUV's to appease their (or someone else's) sense of environmental responsibility, even if presented with a perfectly reasonable alternative. The only way to stimulate a mass SUV migration is to charge a stiff federal tax on all new vehicle purchases proportional to the chosen vehicle's tailpipe emissions (already done overseas). Or Uncle Sam could add an annual environmental restitution fee to gas-guzzlers' price tags.

Of course, the chances that a federal government Hell bent on across-the-board tax cuts will penalize SUV drivers are the same as the odds of a Grand Cherokee beating an Audi TT around a race track. Instead of weaning Americans off of SUV's, Uncle Sam has elected to wean SUV's off of fossil fuel. By the 2007 model year, the minimum Corporate Average Fuel Economy (CAFE) for light trucks/SUV's will be raised (drum roll please)… 1.5 MPG. Sure, it's a start. But so is that hole in the ozone.

Recent Comments

  • Lou_BC: @Carlson Fan – My ’68 has 2.75:1 rear end. It buries the speedo needle. It came stock with the...
  • theflyersfan: Inside the Chicago Loop and up Lakeshore Drive rivals any great city in the world. The beauty of the...
  • A Scientist: When I was a teenager in the mid 90’s you could have one of these rolling s-boxes for a case of...
  • Mike Beranek: You should expand your knowledge base, clearly it’s insufficient. The race isn’t in...
  • Mike Beranek: ^^THIS^^ Chicago is FOX’s whipping boy because it makes Illinois a progressive bastion in the...

New Car Research

Get a Free Dealer Quote

Who We Are

  • Adam Tonge
  • Bozi Tatarevic
  • Corey Lewis
  • Jo Borras
  • Mark Baruth
  • Ronnie Schreiber