With all the talk of GM-Chrysler mergers, many have lost sight of the fact that automakers hold strategic talks with each other on a regular basis. Of course, GM talks grab the spotlight, thanks to the sheer size of the company. But Chrysler is by far the more interesting story. The Detroit News reveals that Chrysler’s owners Cerberus Capital began entertaining offers from a number of firms within a year of acquiring the Pentastar brand. In addition to the now much-speculated-upon GM talks, Cerberus has also met “in recent months” with Renault-Nissan, Fiat and Tata, in hopes of pulling Chrysler’s fat from the fire. Unfortunately, we aren’t getting many details on possible tie-up strategies. Nissan-Renault talks certainly revolve around platform-sharing in the short-term, although Carlos Ghosn is said to be “dispassionate” on the subject of closer ties with Chrysler. “I think that initiatives, in terms of alliances, are frozen for a very simple reason: Everyone is scared of credit crunch and cash problems,” says Ghosn. And that’s really the issue. There are plenty of second- and third-tier global automakers that would enter platform and capacity sharing agreements with Chrysler, but nobody wants to break out the checkbook for an equity position. Especially considering Cerberus expects to retain a stake in Chrysler in the event of a sale. Why buy a failing firm in this market when your cash could be better spent on new product?
Category: News Blog
Remember how much people (OK industry wonks) sneered at the Honda Pilot and Ridgeline for being unibody designs descended from a minivan, which in turn was based on the Accord sedan? Well, Honda made some money on their trucks while the making was good. And now, along with everybody else, not. But while GM’s busy closing factories, Honda’s reaping the rewards of its investment in flexible manufacturing. They’re scaling down production of slow-selling Pilots and Odysseys, making room for more Accords. And they don’t need the United Auto Workers permission to do it. [The Wall Street Journal chronicles the swap.] The main U.S. Accord plant in Ohio will build more of the suddenly hot four-cylinder version. Honda also plans to cut back on Accord imports from Japan. One might think all this would be a plus for America’s balance of trade, but maybe not… Back in the day. the transplants used the U.S. to crank-out the new hotness, while letting Asia carry-on with the old. The new Honda Insight/Prius-fighter will be built in Japan.
Technically speaking, a spiff is an immediate payment to a sales person for a cha-ching. But you get the picture: GM is adding a one percent bonus for any of its dealers that [somehow] manages to shift certain ’09 models (i.e. not the new, still mythical Camaro). “The so-called marketing stimulus payments will be made six months after a vehicle is sold,” Bloomberg reports, upping the New York Times and Wall Street Journal’s recent run of “unnamed sources” by one. “It will be computed from the base-model invoice price, said the people, who didn’t want to be identified because the plan hasn’t been made public.” The come-on is extremely important for GM’s cash flow, or lack thereof; the automaker books a vehicle as “sold” when it ships it to the dealer. So what are we talking here? “Dealers would receive hundreds of dollars per vehicle under the GM program. For instance, the payment would be $166 on a GMC Sierra pickup truck and $549 on a Hummer H2 SUT sport-utility vehicle, according to base-model invoice prices of $16,623 and $54,940, respectively, listed for the 2009 models on Edmunds.com, a provider of automotive information.” But not THE provider. And it’s all caps for HUMMER bub– and no sales. Hey waydaminute! Do they even make those things anymore? And if so, why?
Does anyone edit Jerry Flint’s columns? And yes that’s a trick question. If I were the editor in question, I would sit in awe of any curmudgeon brave enough to argue that GM deserves an extra long root in the federal taxpayers’ trough by admonishing readers that “we should remember Percy Bysshe Shelley’s poem.” Ozymandias? That particular poem is about hubris and inevitably of death and decay. And yet our man Flint’s uses the work to suggest that U.S. taxpayers should bail out General Motors because we don’t want a great empire to, uh, decay and die. Here’s the deal: we owe them. “I have a long memory,” Flint opines, synapses firing like mad. “I remember World War II, when the president of GM– his name was William Knudsen– headed the successful effort to build our great war production machine. GM helped save America then.” That would be the same GM that aided and abetted the Nazi war machine. “I remember the great GM pay, pensions, health care and dividends that made life good for millions of Americans.” And the union corruption, intransigence and feather-bedding that made GM a sitting duck for transplant attack. But wait ’til you hear what Flint has to say about GM’s current management. You’re not going to want to miss this. Right after the break.
Automotive News [sub] brings us the story of Earl Stewart, the Florida Toyota dealer who is waging a one-man war on dealer fees. Born into the car sales business, Stewart noticed one day that his children did not share his love for the family business. Asking his son why he didn’t want to sell cars, Stewart says “He told me he thought car dealers sometimes have a dishonest image. And I had to admit he was right.” After a battle with colon cancer, Stewart decided to make changes in how he conducted business. The first step was removing the $495 “dealer fee” his store had charged, dropping profits by some $200 per unit. But since dropping the fees, he has seen business at his dealership double, and Stewart has been reborn as an anti-dealer-fee crusader. Taking the fight to the radio, television and his blog, Stewart has alienated other dealers who say he is simply advertising his own business. “The world doesn’t need Robin Hood anymore,” one anonymous critic told Stewart. “What we also don’t need is a one-man show trying to run down every dealer on the planet for the good of his own profits.” After attempting to make dealer fees illegal in Florida, and suing another dealer for slander, Stewart still believes in his principles… and his business model. “I know a lot of guys out there depend on these dealer fees — especially right now when the economy is so bad,” says Stewart. “But I did away with them, and my business got better. I can be proud to talk to my kids about what I do for a living. That’s important to me, and it’s important to my sons.”
Autocar‘s Steve Cropley doesn’t discuss the US market much, focused as he is on European happenings. But the man who called Rick Wagoner’s take on ethanol “crisp and lucid” (and blacklisted our own Robert Farago from Autocar’s pages back in the day), now agrees that a US automaker will almost certainly cease to exist. Unfortunately, his belief in this inevitability is borne not of clear-sighted analysis of Detroit’s predicament, but of a deep and abiding love for all things GM. Speculating on rumors of a possible GM-Chrysler hookup, Cropely suggests that Chrysler should go down and be subsumed by the General. “My own impression,” writes Cropely, “is that, even when times are as tough as this, a GM led by Rick Wagoner and the fine teams that he’s assembled, stands a better chance of making the cars we’ll need tomorrow than what I’ve seen of the modern, Cerberus-controlled Chrysler. All GM needs is time to implement its bold plan followed by some faith from car buyers.” But Cropely’s analysis is not all GM fanboyishness. “The Chrysler marque itself stopped meaning very much to me 20 years ago,” intones Cropely. “I mean, who cares if the Voyager and PT Cruiser live or die?” [Note to Steve: they are dead, and nobody cares.] Picking Chrysler to go belly-up is hardly a bold claim at this point, and arguing that GM is the firm to fix it is beyond absurd. Still, add another post-Detroit Three pundit to the Cassandra list.
“These are incredibly unusual times,” GM Chief Executive Officer Rick Wagoner said today at the 100th anniversary celebration of Harvard Business School in Boston. “All the sudden, somebody blows the whistle and credit stops flowing. It really requires you to say, `Let’s think about this business one more time.'” Oh, go on then…
The autoblogosphere is on fire with talk of the CAR Magazine’s photos of the McLaren P11. The mid-engined F430-fighter has had a tough development so far, and McLaren is probably trying to get some positive coverage for its ambitious project by leaking images to CAR. But we, the chattering enthusiasts, have to ask ourselves what we’re getting so excited about. Though CAR has “Photoshop experts” to confirm that the images are “real” many bloggers have failed to report that the images are of a clay model. No mirrors, door handles or any other street-legalizing kit is shown on the models, meaning many changes are still to come. Also, CAR reports (on the third page in) that the “early styling buck” pictured has yet to receive treatment from recently-hired ex-Fiat styling chief Frank Stephenson. This means the production model should (if Stephenson is to earn his money) look considerably different than what is currently being shown. And then there’s the issue of the motor. Mercedes is playing silly buggers with McLaren, refusing to hand over the AMG 6.2 liter V8 that McLaren wants, possibly due to an Aston-Martin engine deal. In other words, we know basically nothing about the P11. It may not be what you want to hear, but dammit, it’s the truth.
If you harbored any doubts that Toyota is attacking the soft underbelly of its chief American rival, General Motors, this should eliminate them. Toyota Financial Services (TFS), one of only two AAA-rated auto credit companies, is launching the Toyota Rewards Visa®. Like GM’s card, ToMoCo’s Visa creates rewards points that can be redeemed when purchasing a vehicle from a Toyota delaership. Unlike GM’s card, ToMoCo’s plastic points are also redeemable towards service, parts and accessories. Card holders get five points for every $1 spent at Toyota dealerships, and a buck a point for everything else. There’s no limit to the amount of points a card holder can amass. Points are redeemed at one percent (e.g. $2500 worth of groceries equals $25 down at your Toyota dealer). There’s no annual fee, and a zero percent APR for the first six months. After that? Seems that depends on you. Well, your credit rating.
Like the gas price spike that helped launch the current industry death spiral, nobody saw a possible D3 bankruptcy coming. Well, outside of this little corner of the internet, anyway. But with the mainstream media catching wind of what we’ve been crying in the desert for years now, a number of well-known industry analysts are coming around to the notion that America may not have three big automakers anymore. Jalopnik’s Ray Wert was ahead of the (adjusted) curve, bellying up to the TTAC line (sorta) yesterday. Today, none other than Danny Howes of the Detroit News is playing Cassandra-come-lately as merger and bankruptcy rumors take industry-watchers by storm. To be fair, Howes isn’t blind to Detroit’s sins, and his columns have been taking an increasingly alarmist tone for some time now. But until this week he’s faced the strings and arrows of outrageous fortune with brave face and stiff upper lip. No longer.
We’ve just received a copy an email sent by Ford’s Todd Lamb to dealers in his sales district. The missive from The Blue Oval Boy to FoMoCo’s Texas and Oklahoma dealers contains good news for beleaguered stores in the Lone Star and Sooner states. The automaker is reducing its wholesale floorplan rates by .5%. The move is in stark contrast to GMAC’s moves back in August, when the lender raised floorplan rates for GM stores by the same amount. At the same time, Ford’s decided NOT to raise their lending standards. “Unlike GMAC which announced that it will no longer finance customers with credit scores lower than 700, Ford Credit will maintain its’ [sic] consistent financing standards.” Will this offer Ford a competitive advantage? Probably not. But Lamb is nothing if not an optimist: “There’s plenty of reasons to be positive!” If you’ve got a second, we’d love a list, Todd. Full email after the jump.
In a country of a billion souls, where billionaires waft in their Quattroportes alongside whole families in Chang’an Altos, justice is not easy to come by. The absolute power of China’s central government is two-sided sword: capable of rapidly enacting transformative change, but also equally capable of drawing the instant ire of hundreds of millions. Thus, to deal with a boom in car ownership and its attendant congestion issues, Beijing has turned to the only fair method of government to force drivers from the road: a lottery. Yesterday, Beijing’s government announced that cars with license plates ending in 1 or 6 would be banned from the road for a day. And just like that a fifth of Beijing’s 3.5m (and counting) cars were off the road. Autocar reports that tomorrow numbers 2 and 7 are next.
In March 2007, Florida firefighter Christopher M. Baird started getting traffic citations, after the E-PASS toll transponder in his wife’s SUV failed. Although Baird had kept his address properly updated with the Department of Motor Vehicles, officials mailed a stack of sixteen tickets to the wrong location. Baird first learned of the problem while trying to renew his car registration. Despite the lack of proper notice, he was given no chance to be heard on the matter. Instead, Baird was forced to pay $1448 in fines to renew his vehicle registration and was hit with 48 points against his driving license, resulting in an immediate suspension. In April, Circuit Judge John Galluzzo found the actions of toll road officials “outrageous.” He ordered Baird’s money refunded and license reinstated, and extended his ruling to all toll violation tickets issued to motorists in Seminole and Brevard counties– as long as they held a valid toll transponder account. And then…
What’s with Ford and these quality studies? Not for the the first time, Ford has commissioned its own study on relative vehicle quality– you know, initial vehicle quality– and come out on top. Ish. You know; a “statistical dead heat.” Or, to be more or less precise, “With a combined average of 1,284 things-gone-wrong (TGW) per 1,000 vehicles during the first three months of ownership, Ford’s domestic brands improved 8 percent versus last year. This performance is statistically equivalent to the 1,250 TGW level of Honda/Acura and Toyota/Lexus/Scion.” Of course, you have to read all the way to the end, and Google a bit, to see that this PR exercise is Ford-subsidized. “The 2008 model-year GQRS survey, conducted for Ford by RDA Group of Bloomfield Hills, Mich., solicits feedback on vehicle trouble and customer satisfaction from owners of all major makes and models after three months in service.” [JD Powers’ Initial Quality Survey results here.] Anyway, it’s all for one, and One Ford for all: “This is One Ford at its best,” claims Bennie Fowler, Ford group vice president, Global Quality. “It’s taken thousands of people continuously working together with laser-like focus every day to boost vehicle quality for our customers to [just about] the top of the pack.”

Recent Comments