Conventional wisdom says never buy a car the first year it's on the market, whether it's a brand new model or a redesign of an existing one. TrueDelta's latest quarterly results say… it depends from whence cometh the car. The 2008 Honda Accord, Nissan Rogue and Mercedes C-Class, for example, all boast a better than average repair rate. On the other hand, GM. Last year, the GMC Acadia and Saturn's Aura and Outlook showed higher than normal repair rates. So far this model year, they're lower than average rates. The cycle is repeating for the 2008 Cadillac CTS (2.5 times the average repair rate) and Saturn Vue (1.5 times the average). TrueDelta developer Michael Karesh sums it up thus: "For GM, rough launches appear to be the rule rather than the exception." So the next time GM CEO Rick Wagoner and Co. feel like mouthing-off about the "perception gap" supposed afflicting their narrow-minded non-customers, they should visit TrueDelta (and/or TTAC) for some cold, hard truth. if we don't say so ourself. Which we do.
Category: News Blog
Industry Week's David Blanchard offers an analysis of Just In Time (JIT) manufacturing's dangers, from Boeing's delayed Dreamliner to Motown's supplier woes ("woes" as in torpedoes aimed straight the mothership's hull). Blanchard says JIT is fine in theory. "Some Japanese automakers have done quite well with that type of win-win relationship, often symbolized by the idea of the keiretsu, or joint partnership. The Detroit Three automakers, on the other hand, apparently see greater promise in pursuing lose-lose relationships… Look at the relationship (if you want to call it that) between Chrysler and one of its Tier One suppliers, Plastech, who had fallen on hard times. Rather than offering assistance to a key supplier, Chrysler canceled its contract with Plastech, which not only led Chrysler to temporarily shut down production at four assembly plants, but also caused Plastech to file for bankruptcy protection." While that's not the way it went down– Chrysler bailed and bailed until it bailed– Blanchard's wider point is valid. "The key word in supply chain management is management, and when relationships aren't managed properly (or at all), then there really isn't much of a supply chain. What you've got instead is a mad free-for-all, and ultimately, a lot of unhappy customers." And, we might add, employees, shareholders and dealers.
As the size of your car insurance bill indicates, there's been a lot of research into the mechanics of whiplash injury. The resulting active headrest technology is way cool, but problems with pain and prolonged recovery persist. ScienceDaily reports on a Swedish insurance claims study that followed 1000 whiplash car insurance claims. The Nordic researchers found that sufferers' expectations for a good or complete recovery correlated with a lower rate of pain and disability six months later– even when controlling for the severity of the pain. Mind over matter? We don't mind if it doesn't really matter. Why not keep your hopes up the next time your ABS-equipped car gets smacked by someone else? [Caveats: study enrollment was based on insurance claims, so unreported minor fender benders as well as outright fatalities are excluded, possibly skewing the results. Study was completed between 2004 – 2005 in Sweden, so results may not be applicable to you. Lack of [decent] headrests, adverse driving conditions in third world countries and other variable may increase your risk. Reading TTAC for medical advice may cause certain side effects, including persistent cynicism, nasal beverage ejection and compulsive commenting. Should symptoms persist, see your medical professional.]
In my imagination, GM execs start every major meeting cranking-up the Talking Heads' "Burning down the House" and dancing in that awkward style peculiar to drunk 50-somethings at the latter part of their daughter's wedding. In real life, they probably exchange worried glances over highly polished tables every now and then and continue their "work" with grim, monotone determination. Well here's an arched eyebrow for you guys: The Wall Street Journal reports that GM CFO Ray Young is "open to raising additional financing to weather the auto industry's current downturn and other challenges facing the company" at the same time that he "remains confident in its liquidity for 2008." I love a mixed message in morning. Smells like… bankruptcy. "If the current adverse economic conditions persist or deteriorate further we would consider a wide range of actions," Mr. Young said. On Ray's To-Do list: "opportunistically" tapping credit markets, including funding sources in the U.S., selling "noncore" assets and/or "reprioritizing" its capital spending. Question: what credit markets? GM credit ratings sucks. Cerberus' struggles with Chrysler have polluted the private equity pond and GM's already spending $2b on interest payments. What non-core assets? GM's already sold off everything it's got of any real value. And what do you mean by "reprioritizing" cap ex? Cutting back on product development? And I wonder why this article neglected to mention the newly released information that GM's cash burn for the year is estimated at $8b– and counting. $24b (claimed liquidity) – $10b (float) – $8b (current cash burn) – ? = C11. [thanks to jthorner for the tip]
The AP [via Yahoo] brings news that the UAW local representing GM's Ontario, Ohio metal stamping plant has given notice of their "intent to strike" this Thursday at 10am. Ontario makes hoods, doors, fenders and floor pans for several GM cars and trucks. Previously, GM plants in Warren and Grand Rapids threatened strikes but settled at the last moment. The UAW workers at Lansing Interiors, however, made good on their threat; the supplier's been on strike almost three weeks, pulling the rug out from under GM's Lambda crossover production (Outlook, Acadia, Enclave). Is the United Auto Workers (UAW) subjecting GM to a death by a thousand cuts? What's the point of negotiating a national contract if every plant covered by the agreement goes out on strike over "local issues?" Union Prez Big Ron Gettelfinger says that the Ontario and other strike threats "are about local contract issues and have nothing to do with American Axle." Yeah right. Most analysts see the GM strikes as an attempt to keep GM's feet to the fire, to force the automaker to bail out/buy out American Axle's union members. Whatever the reason, it will be a long time before GM starts making trucks again. In case anyone's wondering.
The Globe and Mail reports that the International Energy Agency (IEA) has cut its 2008 forecast on global demand for oil. Don't worry, the IEA says demand will still grow. But not by the aforepredicted 1,233,000 barrels per day (BPD). The new figure: 1,030,000 BPD. The 230k BPD adjustment was attributed to softening demand for oil in the USA (still the world's largest consumer) and world-record oil prices. I wonder if those two factoids are connected… Anyway, the news comes as oil futures hit $126.40 per barrel on Monday. Hedging its oil futures bets, the IEA notes that "sustained weakness in European consumption" and "reassessment of fuel subsidies in countries such as Indonesia may create more downside risks." If their predictions come to bear, it'll be a simple affirmation of market principles. That said, if oil prices go down, the consumer will be the last to see it.
Buried in a CTVnews.ca story about the upcoming launches of the Ford Flex and the 2009 F-150: Ford's view of the future. Reporter Jeremy Cato spent some QT with Ford execs (including FoMoCo CEO Big Al Mullaly himself) to find out if there's a future in their Ford. Once again, Ford's top brass tout their forthcoming product revamps to predict a return to operationally profitability by the last financial quarter. In that vein, Ford intends to release models that will be "polarizing" for most consumers. Huh? "That's is exactly what we want," proclaims the Flex's design chief. By the end of the article, Cato remains unconvinced that the Flex will be relevant. (Not everyone can– or should– be Chris Bangle.) Cato declares that all Ford's marketing-speak, brand sell-off and quality initiatives are essentially Big Al's push to turn Ford into Toyota. You know: one global brand, a solid reputation for quality and billions in profits posted like clockwork every quarter. Yeah. that one. Meanwhile, The Blue Oval Boyz concede a porno style loss for the fiscal year. Yes, "it will be a big one."
GM's Rick Wagoner clone, Fritz Henderson, recently told the AP's Tom Krisher that the U.S. auto industry is in a recession. (Insert "Duh!" here.) Regular, non-lobotomized reader of Frank Williams' By The Numbers series would have come to that conclusion two months ago. Fritz trots out the usual explanations for GM's woes: "troubled housing market, tight credit and higher gasoline prices that are sending consumers from trucks to cars at a rate much faster than the company has ever seen." The last part is particularly odd and GM-centric, because the truck-for-car swap hits GM a lot harder than Toyota or Honda given each company's respective product mix ratios. Fritz then goes on to confirm what many have speculated: "The 11-week strike at parts supplier American Axle and Manufacturing Holdings Inc. has had only a minimal effect on the company's retail sales, largely because it had built up a large inventory of pickup trucks and sport utility vehicles at a time when the market shifted to smaller vehicles." By minimal, of course, Fritz means $800m in lost EBT (earnings before taxes, which in this case, is sales to dealers) as the AP diligently reminds us. Be careful Fritz, $800m here, $800m there, and pretty soon we'll be talking about real money.
Regular readers should know by now that Autoblog Green will say nice things about anything that it considers "green enough." But as chic as it may be at the moment, the "green at all costs" posture has its downsides, particularly when you end up saying that the demise of the Bajaj three-wheeler is "unfortunate." Then again, maybe there really is something to be said for third-world three wheelers, because now ABG is all thrilled about the prospect of another pedicab special, this time from Thai firm Tuk Tuk, hitting the US market. The Tuk Tuk is currently undergoing EPA and NHTSA testing to see if the mainstay of Bangkok's taxi industry is ready for U.S. sales. And yes, for those who must know, the two-stroke engine which gave the Tuk Tuk it's goofy name is staying in the developing world where it belongs, to be replaced for American duty by either a 200cc or 650cc liquid-cooled four-stroke. It will be offered in a variety of body styles, for passenger, cargo or truck duty. The three-wheeled oddity may even be offered with an LPG drivetrain, which is sure to have the eco-friendly ice cream vendors lined up around the block.
We've reported that Delphi was a little tardy on making its required pension contributions. Some $323m short, to be precise. Even so, Delphi said it wouldn't be transferring its obligations to the Pension Benefit Guarantee Company (PCBG). The Detroit News reports that the PBGC is switching into proactive mode. "We will act forcefully to protect Delphi's pension plans," the PCBG's director warned. "Especially in light of the company's decision not to seek renewal of its pension funding waivers." Charles E.F. Millard ain't just whistling Dixie. "We will draw down certain letters of credit and keep liens in place on the company's assets until Delphi has successfully emerged and made its pension plans whole." As Delphi won't be seeking an extension of it's pension-funding obligation waiver from the IRS, the PBGC will cash some $173m in Delphi credit when the deadline expires (23rd of May). Delphi spokesfolks say the company "expects to be able to meet its pension funding strategy through a combination of cash contributions and transfers of certain unfunded pension liabilities to a plan sponsored by GM." Delphi's skipped $2.3b in pension contributions since declaring bankruptcy in 2005. At the end of 2007, the former GM parts division was carrying an unfunded pension obligation of $3.3b. So who's gonna end up with that hot potato?
Automotive News [sub] reports that Opel is moving upmarket. It's GM's attempt to "democratize technology" and emphasize their Euro-brand's "traditional German manufacturing attributes." The new strategy is designed to move Opel away from its image as "the European Chevrolet"– so that Chevrolet can become the European Chevrolet. "Opel and Chevrolet will be bookends with a clear position for both," GM-Europe President Carl-Peter Forster promises. "Over time, we will emphasize Opel's German heritage, engineering and design." But don't worry: GM plans to keep the German domestic affordable. "We are not talking about a premium price for Opel," Forster said, "but a one percent to three percent increase is foreseeable." Design, technology and image are all part of the brand touch-up– not, Forster insists, a "reinvention." Yes well, Europe is facing a premium small car glut as Fiat, MINI and others seek full-sized profits from compact cars. With GM dependent on overseas sales to keep the wolf from the door, Opel had better hope this gambit pays off.
It ain't easy being a small independent sportscar maker. Just ask Spyker. The Dutch firm lost $110m and a Formula One team last year. While Lotus knows exactly what hard times look like, they reversed the curse by eschewing flashy F1 campaigns in favor of a profitable technical consultancy and contract manufacturing (including the Tesla Roadster). The Motor Authority reports that Spyker and Lotus are facing the future under the umbrella of a "Parts and Platform Commonality Agreement." Lotus will source parts and assist in the design of forthcoming Spyker C8 Aileron and D12 Sports Utility. Spyker will… pay for it. The two firms have worked together in the past; Spyker considered buying Lotus back in the day. With a Lotus-fettled Spyker at the top end of the market, is there still room for a new Lotus Esprit? No.
California's Air Resources Board (CARB) has been a Detroit boogeyman for some time, occupying the angry, bitter section of auto exec's hearts (normally reserved for the UAW and the folks who control Japan's currency). But The Detroit News reports that tensions may be easing between the industry and the the California cloudchasers. CARB Chairwoman Mary Nichols told reporters at the Society for Automotive Engineers (SAE) Government/Industry session that the board is considering modifying California's emissions controls to become regional, rather than statewide rules. Details are still emerging as to what exactly just what the Hell that means. And that means the thaw in relations is largely rhetorical, with the industry accepting that CARB regulations are basically unstoppable and CARB reaching out to quell manufacturer and dealer concerns. "We can have a national fuel economy policy and still allow California a role as a laboratory for innovative approaches to reducing carbon dioxide emissions," says Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers President Dave McCurdy, stressing that a national approach is better. Nichols, for her part, says the regulations will entail only "a small increase in costs" and "a little bit of creative repackaging." Meanwhile, Green Car Congress reports that California's Pavely regulations would reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 41 percent more than new CAFE standards, if applied nationally. How great is that?
As U.S. politicians respond to the imperative "Do something, anything about all those soccer moms driving around while yakking on cell phones (except my wife, of course)," it looks like we ain't got game. According to the country cell phone bans list, use a cell phone whilst driving in New Delhi, India– hands-free or no– and you're looking at prison time. But do all these legal strictures actually increase road safety? The Wall Street Journal [sub] reports that many researchers have concluded that the only deterrent that makes a difference is the New Delhi solution. The New York Times [reg] recently reported on work from Carnegie Mellon saying that even listening on a hands-free cell phone impairs drivers as much as knocking back a few beers. Nobody seems to talk about the safety benefits of cell phones including calling AAA for help with a flat tire, calling 911 to report accidents, reporting road debris before someone gets hurt or calling in drunk drivers. Perspective people, perspective.
The problems at Chrysler are immense: lackluster products, development cutbacks, a hugely bloated dealer network, cash flow issues, you name it. And don't forget Chrysler Finance. Although the former cash cow is now behind the veil of private ownership, the lender is in deep doo-doo. Not as deep as GMAC's ResCap. If GMAC's mortgage unit goes down, it'll take GMAC with it, and, potentially, sink GM. Even if GMAC somehow makes it though this incipient recession, GM's supplier problems– including the unresolved strike at American Axle and the ongoing debacle at Delphi– are looking more and more like a Gordian knot making love to a black hole (thank you Jonny). In fact, taken as a whole, GM's problems are worse than they were in late 2005. Oh, did I mention that the window for Chrysler owners Cerberus to sue Daimler for fraudulent conveyance ends in early August? Folk, it’s getting ugly, and we're not even calculating Ford's woes or the simple fact that Detroit's manufacturing jobs are leaving the country. We will be here through these dog days. When the excrement hits the air re-circulation device, just remember: we told you so. And we will take no joy in what happens next.
Recent Comments