Category: Editorials

By on June 10, 2007

synergy.jpgIn 1993, Toyota began developing a radical gas-electric hybrid vehicle called the Prius. With gasoline at historic lows, internal company documents gave the concept a five percent chance of commercial success. In May 2007, the Prius was America's sixth best selling passenger car, with 24k units. Toyota also just passed the one-million-hybrids-sold milestone. Toyota deserves a raspberry for the worst internal forecasting ever, and an award for one of the most successful new-car launches in automotive history.

Needless to say, the Prius' success is not without controversy. The Japanese hybrid has a more polarizing influence on pistonhead opinion than any other vehicle made save its philosophic nemesis, the Hummer H2. Compare the gas-swilling in-your-face Hummer's rumored demise with the Prius' rise up the sales charts, and there you have it: a snapshot of American's shifting priorities.  

You also get a glimpse of Toyota's branding expertise. While the Japanese automaker continues its assault on the domestic pickup truck and SUV market (creating much of the animus alluded to above), the Prius is still a perfectly defined product within Toyota's existing brand identity: reliable frugality.

The Prius is such hit that it's now a household name; consumers interchange the word "Prius" with "hybrid" in the same way that they ask for a Kleenex. The last automotive product to pull that off was the Jeep– some fifty years ago.

Toyota's 80 percent share of the total U.S. hybrid market has had the Xerox effect on its competitors. Their hybrids are either flying beneath the radar (Nissan Altima hybrid), eating crumbs off Toyota's table (Ford Escape and Mercury Mariner hybrid) or retreating from the field of battle (Honda Accord hybrid).    

Honda's move comes despite the fact that the company's Insight hybrid was first to market in 1999. While Honda will continue to fight for gas-electric market share with their "mild" hybrid Civic, they're putting their high-efficiency eggs in two new baskets: a new Fit-class hybrid and clean diesel engines for their existing model range.  

Pundits often argue that Toyota stole a march on its competitors by creating a hybrid with unique sheetmetal (as opposed to hybrid-powered versions of existing products). Well, the Prius has had such a dramatic halo effect that consumers now associate the technology with Toyota's entire lineup. Hybrid Camrys are currently outselling hybrid Civics by 50 percent.

Toyota's success with the technology has forced all the other global players to put their nose to the hybrid-powered grindstone. Mercedes and BMW bought into GM's sophisticated (read: expensive) two-mode hybrid drive. Buyer's remorse may be setting in; the Germans are now focusing on developing their own mild-hybrid technology.

The shift reflects a realization that competing with Toyota mano-a-mano with full hybrids is a sucker's bet– especially as the Prius v3 looms. (Toyota is targeting a 20 percent efficiency gain.) The other factor is simple cost-effectiveness. Mild hybrids yield a greater return on investment.

Whereas a full hybrid demands a [ballpark] $2500 production premium, micro and mild hybrids start at $700. When combined with other technologies such as direct injection and full valve control, the mild hybrid seems a far safer proposition. BMW's revised 1-Series– complete with start-stop engine management, valve control and direct injection– shows a 20 percent fuel efficiency improvement over its predecessor.

In short, Toyota's competitors are hedging their bets, looking for less risky across-the-board fuel efficiency solutions.

The market is bi-furcating: "real" hybrids (which the market increasingly interprets as Prius/Toyota) and micro/mild hybrids (traditional models sold on their over-all moderate efficiency gains, rather than "gee whiz" technology).

And where does this shifting market leave Toyota? Dual propulsion, full-speed ahead!

Despite the fact that Highlander Hybrid sales are down 23 percent year-to-date (just over 3k units in May), the company has publicly stated that every one of their models will have optional Hybrid Synergy Drive within a few years. They've also committed the company's vast technological resources and production expertise to reducing the cost of their hybrid system by some 50 percent.

Toyota is playing a powerful hand. If they can achieve their cost-reduction target, they'll be selling more sophisticated (and more efficient) full hybrids at roughly the same price as the rest of the industry's mild hybrids. And if Prius v3 is significantly more efficient than its predecessor, the model will maintain its role as Toyota's hybrid halo-bearer.

In any case, the Prius is now a fully fledged four-wheeled corporate emblem. And Toyota has announced a family of Prii, including a station wagon and a smaller city car. The hybrid pro-con arguments can go on endlessly in their (internet) vacuum. Toyota took a huge gamble with the Prius. It's paid off at the bottom line, and looks set to do so for many years to come.

By on June 9, 2007

06lincolntowncar.jpgThe “tumblehome” is the narrowing of a car’s profile from its beltline to its roof. This design trick creates a sleek, visually trim appearance without losing interior space. The tumblehome was once a hallmark of American automotive design, gracing evocative machines like the Plymouth Barracuda, Buick Riviera and Ford Thunderbird. In today’s Minivan-esque sedans and family-truckster CUVs, it’s hopelessly out of fashion. Now that Ford’s axing the Lincoln Town Car, it time to ask: should Detroit let this proud, once popular design tradition go quietly into that long good night? 

Born as a separate model in 1981, the big Lincoln earned its crust as a pillow soft luxobarge, complete with a waft-compatible 5.0-liter V8. In 1990, the Town Car lost its angularity and gained [rear] air suspension. In '95, the interior received a much-needed makeover. In '98 and and '03, more cosmetic tweakery attempted to keep the flame alive. In the last four years, it's been flickering.

The last 2007 Lincoln Town Car rolled off the Wixom, Michigan assembly line on June 1. Ford's moving production to its St. Thomas, Ontario, Assembly Plant, where The Blue Oval builds the equally iconic Crown Victoria and it’s (over-priced) sister, the Grand Marquis. Come 2009, the formerly American-built Lincoln-branded keeper of the Yank Tank flame will either meet its Motown maker or get a sorely-needed reskin. 

This do-or-die decision comes as the people in charge of writing Ford’s 104-year history are busy drafting Chapter 11, as The Glass House Gang try to sell a range of cars without a shred of American swagger. MK-what? Life on the Edge? Born again Taurus? Have you driven a Ford lately? Forget about tumblehome. It’s tumble down.

Obviously, I come not to bury the Town Car, but to praise it– even though our own William C. Montgomery calls ye olde Panther chassis “a relic of a bygone era when big clumsy sedans were the cultural SUVs of the highway.” Even though the old fogies at LincolnsOnline have turned against the current, beancounted Town Car.

Fair enough, but the Lincoln Town Car is also the automotive embodiment of what’s been right with American automaking since the Eisenhower administration. It’s a large-and-in-charge machine with endless comfort, stateside style, mechanical reliability and time-tested (and how) durability. 

Not convinced? Plenty of people are. In fact, the Town Car’s been a FoMoCo cash cow for over twenty years. In 1985, Lee Iacocca noted that the model netted Henry's mob over a billion dollars annually. While Ford was in its [first] pre-Taurus dire straits, it was the venerable Lincoln Town Car that kept them afloat.

Ironically, the Town Car’s financial success sealed its fate. Ford siphoned-off the model’s $10k-per-unit revenue to purchase a Jaguar-shaped black hole and an English off-roader company, and then starved the Town Car of development. Is it any coincidence that Ford’s and Lincoln’s sales declined as Toyota’s and Lexus’ rose?

When the rest of the world abandoned the body-on-frame sedan, the big Lincoln soldiered on, still banking profits for the company that spurned it. Its customers have remained faithful, even as Ford pursues an ill-advised agenda of world car synergies.

In short, preserving the Town Car isn’t about a bunch of nostalgic pistonheads embracing the last American land yacht. It’s about Ford’s seizing the chance to invest in a proven nameplate with a proven long-term revenue model. With some creative engineering, a new Town Car could return both the model and marque to major glory.

There are plenty of reasons why a re-engineered Town Car could provide a base from which to revive the entire American big car genre. For one thing, it could embody distinct and distinctive American style.

Pundits said the Chrysler 300C marked the return of the great American sedan. It did (selling well) and it didn’t (no one moved the ball forward). A new Town Car could lift the styling from the 2002 Continental Concept, complete with suicide doors (cough, Ford Flex), and boldly go where gangsta Cs and gussied-up Camcords fear to tread.

For another, Americans love to waft. While it’s hard to defend a 29-year-old automotive platform, it’s not impossible. The Town Car [still] represents the quintessential straight-line style of motoring. Ditch the Panther’s rear solid axle, install the Explorer’s slow-selling 292hp V8, add a six-speed slushbox and the new Town Car could make some serious imperious progress. 

Of course, this is all fantasy. Dearborn's current management team insists that a Volvo-based Ford with the Taurus/Sable/MK-whatever moniker on the trunk will save the company's skin. More absurdly, The Blue Oval Boyz  continue to believe that throwing money at Jaguar’s problems will pay off. Does Ford need a better Volvo-Taurus?  Should they ditch Jag? Sure. But the Lincoln Town Car should be part of the way Fordward.  

Saving the Town Car isn’t a moral obligation; it’s a brand faithful growth strategy in an increasingly competitive market. To think that Americans loyal to the last rolling tribute to the American Sedan will praise the Town Car’s un-American (alphanumeric) replacement is a sad, twisted joke. Following the Lincoln brand’s badge-engineered downward spiral, this joke only brings smiles to your local Lexus dealer.

Even in neglect, nobody does the American sedan better than the Lincoln Town Car. And nobody ever will.

By on June 9, 2007

Buying my first new car was a lot like losing my virginity: it was unplanned, impulsive and quick. Even though it didn’t turn out exactly as I might have expected, I certainly don’t regret it; it was an inevitable rite of passage. There has to be a first time. At least the glow of satisfaction lasted longer (with the car). Read More >

By on June 8, 2007

truck.jpgThe political right likes to claim that the mainstream press has a liberal bias. These self-appointed media watchdogs see a cadre of left-leaning fascists looking to manipulate popular opinion, to infringe on individual freedom by stripping law-abiding citizens of their God given right to own guns, smoke, pray in public, eat supersized fatty foods and drive gas-guzzling CO2–belching behemoths. In truth, the American press isn’t red, blue, pink or green. It’s yellow.

Once upon a time, journalism was considered a public service. The news media was owned by beneficent potentates; men who cloaked their more obvious commercial enterprises in the sanctimony of servicing our “right to know.” When technology fractured the audience, when news was made to stand on its own, it suddenly became more of what it was all along: a business. 

The news media’s unshackled economic motives have amped-up their insatiable desire to be seen, heard and/or read. To that end they cater to our basest instincts with stories about all sorts of human extremes: fires, fanatics, fatalities and most important of all, anything urgently threatening. 

Even before the news media lost their dignity, they perpetuated pervasive paranoia. My childhood was haunted by visions of nuclear attack, food shortages and dwindling oil supplies. These stories eventually gave way to dark tales of nuclear disaster and Y2K meltdown. 

Thankfully, all of these perceived calamities are still largely theoretical. Food is produced in abundance, oil supplies have grown and Japan and France have demonstrated that nuclear power is safe and the Internet lives! And so new villains have arrived, most prominently terrorists but including the automobile.

While it pains me to even partially vindicate Detroit’s anti-media paranoia, it’s certainly true that automobile manufacturers have been victimized by willfully ignorant, self-righteous muckrakers. As ttac.com contributor Paul Neidermeyer recently recounted, the Chevrolet Corvair and Audi 5000 were both torpedoed by bogus safety concerns perpetuated by self-anointed safety campaigners (Ralph Nader and CBS).

Other popular models have fallen prey to absurd exaggerations of risk, provided without any discussion of context, scientific analysis or mitigating factors. Was the Firestone tire-clad Ford Explorer inherently dangerous? What does that mean anyway? The fact that over half the Explorer rollover deaths involved passengers who didn’t buckle their seat belts escaped the media’s limited attention.

Clearly, this trend has progressed to the point where the news media feels free to demonize the automobile in general, and vilify anyone who dares drive anything other than a [get-out-of-PC-prison-free] hybrid.

How many times does the media use the words “oil addiction” to describe our habit of driving our children to school, commuting to work, buying the things we need to survive and keeping the American economy healthy for ALL of us?

SUVs are regularly portrayed as the sole province of selfish, clueless, amoral Americans. The companies that provide these vehicles are cast as foot-dragging Neanderthals who, ironically enough, cater to their customers’ basest instincts.

Never mind that the news trucks schlepping their high-tech equipment are about as fuel efficient as a Sherman tank, or that the news helicopters that hover over televised tragedy burn more fuel than an entire fleet of Hummers.

And why is it OK to treat a normal, commercially vital activity like driving as if it’s some kind of criminal act? Global warming! And if global warming is the problem, American drivers are the cause. Oh, sorry, did I say “if?" I mean, “because.”

In case you hadn’t noticed, today’s news media never misses an opportunity to remind us of the “fact” that our vehicles’ fossil fuel combustion is creating greenhouse gasses that will hasten an increase in global temperatures that threatens our species’ survival.

Vehicle-induced global warming is a fact because a lot of scientists say it is– even though a large number of reputable scientists say it isn't. Woe betide anyone foolish enough to question global warming in the press; they're served-up as a crank or right wing nutcase.

Ten years from now, after a decade of declining ocean temperatures (as forecast by the National Hurricane Center), we’ll look back and wonder why people bought the paranoid pseudo-reality of global warming. Of course, by then the tragedy industry will have invented some new automobile-related threat to keep us riveted with fear.

Fascination is the key. The news media is afraid to tackle the tough questions relating to our cars because they believe the public is fundamentally stupid. They’re scared that their audience will take one look at a more complicated truth and switch off. If the information gatekeepers don’t simplify issues (e.g. SUVs suck), Americans will lose interest.

I like to think they’re wrong; that drivers can go beyond sound bites to engage in a proper debate on important issues related to our automotive activities. With your help, we’ll find out.

By on June 7, 2007

07annualmtg_95232.jpgLast year, the Ford Motor Co. lost $12.7b. The company is carrying $188b in debt. Its bonds are non-investment grade. It’s got to the point where less than one in ten American analysts recommends the former blue chip stock. In fact, by any measure of financial health, Ford is knocking on death’s door. So why did Alan R. Mulally leave Boeing to heal The Blue Oval– aside from the $45m plus transferred into his bank account? Mulally is an engineer, a man who can’t resist taking something apart and trying to put it back together better. Or, if you prefer, Humpty Dumpty.

Mulally is looking at a lot of broken eggs. Ford’s dealer network is obese, its product line lags, UAW negotiations loom, healthcare costs outpace kudzu and the corporate culture is a capitalistic tribute to the Kremlin. But to an engineer, all things are simple. To solve even the most complex problem, just break things down into their smaller components, then repair, reengineer and reassemble. Simply put, simplify! 

That is, after all, how Ford made its bones. Crazy Henry designed simple cars that were easy to operate and maintain. He built them on simple assembly lines, with simple jobs that were easy to master.

Mulally understands how things work (or don't, as the case maybe.) Upon installation, he called for a company-wide audit to find ways to cut costs and complexity. Those auditors are just now sending in their reports.

They’re discovering (surprise!) that Ford wastes an obscene amount of money on unnecessary duplication. For example, The Blue Oval builds its products on no less than 30 engineering platforms. In contrast, Honda has six platforms and Audi has four. Sure, these companies don’t manufacture a vast variety of cars. But they make money and Ford doesn’t.  But wait! There’s [lots] more! No two of the vehicles Ford builds upon these 30 platforms share seat rails, springs, hood hinges and God knows what else.

Last January, Ford announced Sync, a voice-command system for phones and MP3 players. The company will start rolling out the new (soon-to-be-obsolete but that’s another story) technology in the fall– but not on Volvos or Land Rovers. The system is incompatible with Volvo and Land Rover’s existing electronics– even though the Swedish and British marques haven’t really been “foreign” for over a decade. 

Analysts call it Balkanization. Ford has four disparate operating units around the world, each with its own costly management team, research and development staff and production facilities. This wouldn’t be a problem if they shared, which they don’t.

No wonder Mulally recently read his execs the Riot Act: "There's no global company I know of that can succeed with the level of complexity we have at Ford." 

Mulally knows that streamlining production and development is like finding money. Audi was formed on this principle; the Volkswagen Group hangs onto the principle like grim death. By the time this century hits its early teens, Audi’s new modular MLP platform will be the one ring to rule them all. 

Lotus is vending their version of a universal platform: Versatile Vehicle Architecture. While not known for mass-production, Lotus is very adept at selling its services, and they’ve had a fair amount of interest in the technology. And why not? Automotive research and development costs are not receding. It costs about $1b to create a new platform, why not do it once or twice, instead of 30 times?

But even as Mulally the engineer strives to simplify Ford’s design, engineering and production process, once again aiming to replicate Toyota’s methodology (as he did at Boeing), Ford’s entrenched bureaucracy is hard at work, striving to keep things comfortably labyrinthine.

"The managers take refuge in the structure when things get tough,” Allan Gilmour, Ford’s now-retired Chief Financial Officer and Vice Chairman told BusinessWeek. “Rather than innovate or try new ideas that seemed risky."   As the popular management expression says, “Culture eats strategy for lunch.” One wonders if the engineer in charge of Ford gets it. Perhaps so. Mulally has pow-wowed with Gilmour twice since taking the reins. And Mulally ain’t no dope. 

Last September, Mulally’s underlings told him the Focus loses Ford roughly $3k per sale. "Why haven't you figured out a way to make a profit?" he asked (demanded?). The suits explained that Ford needs to sell lots of Foci to maintain its corporate average fuel economy (CAFE) ratings, AND that the car is made in a high-cost UAW factory. "That's not what I asked," he replied.  

There's an old engineer’s adage: you can have something good, on time or under budget. Pick two. Mulally's about to test the theory’s inverse. When you're out of money and, as your competitors jack-up their existing efficiency, out of time, can you still create something good? The answer is painfully simple.

By on June 7, 2007

portlandmuseum.jpgOn Tuesday, Detroit's top execs made another pilgrimage to Washington, D.C. The Detroit News reported that the troubled troika all arrived at Capitol Hill in fuel-efficient vehicles as a "symbolic gesture." Mulally belted across the Beltway in a Ford Escape hybrid. Wagoner wheeled up in a hybrid Saturn Aura. And LaSorda made the scene in a flex-fuel Town & Country minivan. Of course, none of these vehicles are their makers' most frugal cars. However, we can't have America's automotive aristocrats getting off their fuel-sucking private corporate jets and jumping into a run-of-the-mill Aveo, Focus or Caliber, now can we?

The hypocrisy is stunning. Lest we forget, when the Toyota Prius first whirred into view, Detroit dismissed the gas-electric hybrid vehicle as a meaningless PR stunt. And now, two out of three American automotive magnates cloak themselves in hybrid hype to convince Washington they're down with the whole hi-tech gas-saving thing. You know; now that they want some help competing on a "level playing field" with those tricky transplants. Again. Still.

Of course, this kind of running-on-empty automotive gesture is hardly restricted to Michigan's golden parachute-clad corporate con artists. No Hollywood star worth his or her Oprah confessional would dare show up at a red carpet event in a gas guzzler. They leave their multi-thousand-square-foot homes, heated pools and garaged exotics to make the scene in the latest hybrid or electric trendmobile- just in case anyone questions their environmental credentials. 

Likewise, politicians. Last month, Senator Barak Obama harangued the Detroit Economic Club with a scathing condemnation of the U.S. auto industry. The Democratic Presidential hopeful accused The Big 2.8 of unconscionable foot-dragging on CAFE standards. According to the man who would be President, Detroit's "spending millions to prevent the very reform that could've saved their industry" and "spending their time investing in bigger, faster cars." 

Almost as soon as Obama's anti-Detroit bombshell hit the PR newswires, hometown reporters revealed the inconvenient truth about the pol's garage, filled as it was with a Chrysler 300C. The Senator duly ditched his Hemified whip for a Ford Escape Hybrid.

No surprise there. The Missouri-made Escape Hybrid and its corporate clone (the Mercury Mariner Hybrid) are the politicos' gesturemobiles du jour. When she's not being ferried about in an armored Cadillac or Chevy Suburban, Hillary Clinton (well, actually, hubby Bill) drives a refrigerator-equipped Mariner Hybrid. John Edwards and Al Gore both keep the planet cool (warm?) with their Escape Hybrids. 

At least that's what their PR folks say. One wonders how much time our democratically-elected leaders spend in these cramped hybrids in lieu of the limos, SUVs and staff cars that transport these prodigious pork barrel purveyors around town, and block the streets around Capitol Hill.

And onto those storied streets drove Rick, Alan, and Tom, trying to neuter legislation designed to force them to build more fuel-efficient vehicles, like the ones they were driving. The heads of GM, Ford and Chryslerberus know they can't stop increases in the fuel economy standards. All they can do is minimize the federal minimum so they can keep selling more profitable gas guzzling trucks and SUVs have the time they need to engineer more fuel-efficient vehicles, like the ones they were driving. 

Rick Wagoner more or less admitted that the mandatory fuel economy gig was up. The GM lifer told long-suffering GM stockholders that it was time to move on to the other bulges in the Gordian knot strangling The General. "It looks like… it's very likely there will be increases in CAFE… Let's make sure that we also fix the real problems while we're doing that."

By "real problems," Rick was alluding to his company's [self-inflicted] unsustainable cost structure and ongoing failure to maintain domestic market share- problems shared by his friends indeed.

So… bad boys, bad boys, whatcha gonna do? More specifically, what the Hell are you doing in DC when you should at home figuring out how to build products consumers want to buy at a price that makes you enough money so you can sort this out yourself?

Of course, Detroit's corporate lions prefer maintaining the status quo and jetting to Washington on someone else's dime. They're old pros at pressing the flesh at the center of an enormous bureaucracy; a bureacracy that sees nothing wrong with running-up massive debts, mortgaging their constituents' future to protect their own short term interests.

If CEOs Rick Wagoner, Alan Mulally and Tom LaSorda wanted to make an effective symbolic gesture, they should have driven from Detroit to Washington and back in an Aveo, Focus, or Caliber.

By enduring 1000 miles in those noisy, cramped, cheap cars– byproducts of their bean-counted design and engineering processes– they'd tell the world that their very best fuel-sipping products are good enough for government work. How appropriate is that?

By on June 6, 2007

x07ch_im0092.jpgLast month, I field tested a new methodology for analyzing the American car market. Reader feedback on TTAC’s month-by-month sales charts of “key” U.S. models was overwhelmingly positive. Your most excellent comments and insightful methodological suggestions were noted, logged and, where possible, incorporated. OK, so, May car sales were the highest so far this calendar year. Without further ado, here’s how our 19 models floated within this rising tide.

Passenger Cars

Taken as a whole, U.S. passenger car sales showed a sharp upturn in May. The Chevrolet Impala , Chrysler 300 and Toyota Camry all rebounded from their April dip. Ford did not share in this good fortune. After climbing steadily, Fusion sales dropped below 2006 levels for the first time since last November.

The Camry’s still the segment leader, but the Impala’s coming on fast. The mid-sized Canadian is now selling more briskly than it did during GM’s epic “fire sale for everyone” back in 2005 and was GM's best-selling passenger car in May. That said, GM lavished $1500 in incentives on the Impala– the highest amount they offer on a Chevrolet passenger car. 

Pickup Trucks

For the first time since February, Silverado sales have topped last year’s levels. The good news comes with a minor caveat: GM is still producing and selling the “Classic” (non GMT900-based) Silverado, a cheaper model that’s buoyed by $2k to $3K rebates and dealer incentives. Still, the new model’s leading the charge.

Meanwhile, assisted by massive incentives (up to $5K rebates plus dealer incentives) the Dodge Ram also bested last year’s number. Chryslerberus is planning a redesigned Ram for 2009 with diesel engines across the board. They’ll most likely increase the incentives to keep current sales from tanking in anticipation of the new model.

Ford's F-Series continues to show lower sales than in previous years. Look for Ford to add to its $3k rebate as the Glass House Gang fight to keep their perennial best-seller at the top of the sales charts.

Tundra sales showed another record month. It remains to be seen if the model’s camshaft problems will damage the Tundra’s momentum, or if Toyota’s rep for bulletproof build quality will reduce the issue to a minor bump in the road.

In any case, the Toyota’s entry into a declining market has had the anticipated effect: pickup truck margins are down across the board.

Truck-Based SUVs

Tahoe and Explorer customers shrugged off high gas prices. Tahoe’s May sales have remained steady for the past three years. Explorer sales reached the highest level since last September.  

Dodge and Toyota weren’t so lucky; Durango and 4Runner sales both continue their downward trajectory. The Durango has practically flat-lined in the mid-4K range, while 4Runner sales are the lowest they’ve been since last October.

Small SUV/CUVs

CUV sales split into two distinct camps: the old and the new. Sales of the elderly Chevrolet Equinox and Chrysler Pacifica fell well below those of previous years. If Chevy and Chrysler want to remain competitive in this hot market segment, they have to hit refresh in a big way, and fast.

Sales of the recently refreshed Ford Escape and Toyota RAV-4 rose sharply. The more boldly grilled Escape hit an all-time high in May, with the gas – electric hybrid model accounting for 14 percent of the total. RAV-4 sales were up by more than 2K units over last month, and against the same month last year.

New Models

All three of the new-for-‘07 models I’m tracking showed increases in May. The Jeep Compass rebounded slightly above last month’s performance, but still remains below the curve for the year. The GMC Acadia continues almost straight-line steady growth. After an inexplicable dip last month, Ford Edge sales are back, and they ain’t bad. 

Total Sales

GM, Chrysler and Toyota all saw higher sales in May than in April, and with higher sales than May ’06. Even though Ford showed an increase from April, they still remain well below the previous years’ sales levels. (For cumulative sales YTD, click here: GM, Chrysler, Ford, Toyota .) But the numbers mask a worrying development. 

In spite of The Big 2.8’s pledge to wean themselves from incentives, they haven’t. In May, GM’s incentives rose 6.1 percent (year on year) to a $2,950 per vehicle average. Ford’s incentives rose by 4.6 percent to $4,040 per vehicle. Chrysler's incentives soared by 7.1 percent to an average of $4,178 per vehicle. (Toyota’s incentives averaged $1,140 per vehicle.)

This does not bode well for Detroit. In 2006, GM and Chrysler’s North American operations lost an average of $1,436 and $1,072 respectively per vehicle. Ford lost a whopping $5,234 per vehicle.  In contrast, Toyota and Honda made $1,200 on every vehicle sold. The greater Detroit’s incentives, the lower their profits. Or, let’s face it, the greater their losses. It’s still early daze, but 2007 is turning out to be a “make or break” year for The Big 2.8.

By on June 5, 2007

loco.jpgGM had an excellent May. Despite the title of this series, I’m not going to dwell on the fact that The General’s ten percent year-on-year sales increase is actually a rebound from a disastrous May ’06 (overall sales are still down 3.2 percent compared to the first five months of last year). And I won’t bother pointing out that the majority of GM’s one percent market share gain came out of Ford’s two percent market share loss. Or that GM’s “rising tide lifts all boats” progress pales in comparison with the sales tsunami that Toyota’s [still] riding deep into the American heartland. No I want to focus on debt.

GM is carrying a monumental amount of debt. Forbes pegs the stat at $445b, against a market capitalization of $17b. General Motors has so much debt that even their high-flying foreign divisions know it’s hammer time (“You can’t touch this”). Only a major recovery in the black hole known as GM’s North American market can hope to pay off the interest on the company’s loans– never mind reduce the principal, break even or, Heaven forfend, bank a surplus. 

Less than fifty years ago, General Motors had no such burdens. It was one of the world’s largest multi-national, multi-industry conglomerates. The company was so big and so rich it spent all its energies extending and embellishing its status. GM had so much money swilling around its corporate coffers it made money loaning its money to other people.

Those days are long gone. While auto industry pundits focus on the fading fortunes of GM the carmaker, it’s important to remember that virtually all of GM’s ancillary businesses– from refrigerators to airplanes to defense research to locomotives– have been de-acquisitioned. More recently, GM's been jetisoning bits of its core business, from shares in foreign automakers to the entirety of their [now bankrupt] parts provider Delphi.

The full list of items included in GM’s epic family silver sale is too long to provide here. Suffice it to say, in the 15 months to January 2007 alone, GM shed $17b worth of assets. Last month, the corporation hocked their remaining 49 percent share of their GMAC financial unit for $4.1b. Allison Transmissions is next to go. Aside from a few under-the-radar bits and bobs, there’s literally nothing left to sell. (Would YOU buy Saab?)

So it’s on to the plastic! Last Wednesday, GM replaced $1.1b in convertible securities with new unsecured convertible notes. As we reported previously, GM plants and machinery have also been “monetized.” Not to put too fine a point on it, the quintessential American automaker has reacted to the violent contraction in its Empire by going into eyeball level debt. Their dynastic dreams are history (literally). Servicing the debt is Job One.

In the last decade, only two profit engines have been able to perform that life-sustaining task: North American truck sales and GMAC. Now that GM’s pawned its remaining piece of GMAC, the golden goose is dead. High margin pickup trucks and SUVs are the last great hope for bailing out the artist once known as the world’s largest automaker. 

While GM's PR machine trumpeted May’s rise in full-sized truck sales, America’s once profitable pickup truck and SUV market continues to contract. Last month, for the first time since 2002, U.S. dealers sold more cars than trucks. Cars accounted for 51.4 percent of all new vehicle deliveries. Aside from the $5k+ incentives GM’s piling on its slow-selling vehicles to staunch the truck-shaped wound, here’s the really scary bit: transplants scarfed-up 61.4 percent of last month’s 804,196 car sales.

Strangely, the Dallas News reports that GM is planning to increase production of the Chevrolet Tahoe, GMC Yukon and Cadillac Escalade at their Arlington, Texas plant in August. Either GM’s planning a major new incentive campaign in July or they’re stockpiling product for a United Auto Workers’ strike. No matter; there’s little expectation that SUV sales can generate the gi-normous profits that management squandered to get them into this mess.

On the face of it, everything’s going to be all right. GM will use the debt/cash to complete its turnaround plan, and then reduce its debt. But first it's got to placate (i.e. pay off) its former workers over at Delphi. And do something about (i.e. pay off) that union guy in Canada who’s watched too many episodes of Dallas ("I’m gonna bring Ricky down, if I have to destroy GM to do it!"). And fund their on-again, off-again, on-again, off-again, on-again range of rear wheel drive-cars. And, perhaps, pony-up a bil or so for the new “Beta” small car platform.

GM’s “We Heart Debt” strategy has topped-up their bank account to git ‘er done (even if it don't). But here’s the problem: they’re tapped out. If there’s a cash-related setback– be it a union strike, gas price spike or a big rise in interest rates– that’s it. Chapter 11. What are the odds?  

By on June 4, 2007

satnav2.jpgIt’s hard to believe global positioning satellite (GPS) technology was once the sole purview of the U.S. military. It’s equally difficult to comprehend how James Bond’s first in-car tracking device thrilled pre-pubescent boys. These days, a luxury car without a satellite navigation system is like a luxury car without dual-zone climate control. Still, it’s a pretty pricey item that’s bound to bite you in ass at trade-in. So should you listen to your oleaginous salesman and tick that option box?

The tech market is a fickle mistress. That way cool RAZR phone that cost $500 and a two-year contract is now as precious as a Pet Rock at a garage sale. Ask any hapless fool that made a high-end high tech purchase a couple of weeks before a product refresh hit the market— they know the pain of instant 60 percent depreciation (worse than buying a new Chevy). 

Product cycles for factory-fitted satellite navigation units aren’t quite that rapid, but they ain’t slow neither. Sat nav units' display screens and memory– the highest cost parts– are getting cheaper and better, fast. At the same time, operating systems have moved from CD to DVD to memory chip, while the user interface has progressed from 2D to semi-3D, heading towards “street view” and God knows what else.

If you think that’s been a quick change, handheld sat nav units are evolving twice as quickly. It takes carmakers time to spec, design, test, manufacture, fit, ship and sell new devices– never mind clearing the whole schmeer with legal. Portable GPS manufacturers have fewer technical hurdles and a MUCH smaller bureaucracy. In fact, products from companies like Garmin, Michelin, Maxtech and TomTom (not to mention phone and PDA-based sat navery) are making brand new in-car systems obsolete before they’re even launched.

Thanks to the Original Equipment Manufacturers'' (OEMs') slow tech turnaround, by the time a customer comes to sell a car equipped with a factory-fitted sat nav system, the clever route guidance gizmo is not worth the silicon it’s printed on. Or, if you prefer, somewhere around $500.

That’s the average used car sat nav premium, and that’s not good. Not when you consider that an average built-in sat nav package costs the new car buyer a whopping $2k+ (not including tax). Of course, that’s the manufacturer’s suggested retail price (MSRP); the invoice cost is about $400 to $500 less.

That's a decent chunk of change for a hard-pressed salesman or car dealer. Working our way back up the food chain, the in-car sat nav system costs automakers at most a sixth of its MSRP, even with all the frills. So it’s no surprise that carmakers, dealers and salesmen are all pushing built-in sat nav systems on the consumer.

Now that portable sat nav units are making a financial mockery of their car-bound cousins, and  even wealthy new car buyers are shunning built-in GPS units as a money-losing proposition, the car cartels are fighting back in the great tradition of “keep screwing the customer as long as you can.” It’s called bundling.

Fancy a Mark Levinson 14-speaker 330-watt Premium Surround Sound Audio System in your Lexus GS430? Excellent choice! But you can’t have it without satellite navigation, and forking out $4230. Want a rear back-up camera and park distance control radar in your BMW X5? That’ll be the $2600 “Technology Package,” with DVD-based, voice-activated, real-time traffic computing satellite navigation.

There’s a flip side as well. If you JUST want sat nav, plenty of automakers force you to purchase a passel of luxury options before you’re allowed to buy it. The Chevrolet Corvette only offers sat nav on the $5k 3LT trim level, which includes a fancier standard sound system, head-up display, memory package, heated seats, power telescoping steering wheel and universal home transmitter [whew].  

While not as reprehensible as safety option bundling bullying, this sort of “take it or leave what you really want” sat knavery will only continue for so long, as the value of factory-fitted systems continues to plummet and customers get stiffed at trade-in time. 

The practice also faces pressure from the declining cost of sat nav systems, which will make them available in a wide range of mass market motors, which will eliminate sat nav’s “premium” patina. Toyota recently announced it will offer “entry-level” sat nav in some of its models, with a lower resolution screen, without voice activation. 

It’s only a matter of time before factory-fitted satellite navigation will eventually go the way of the FM radio and CD player; it’ll be a low-cost standard feature. Manufacturers are already searching for The Next Big Thing: a new “must have” luxury that commands the same premium. Meanwhile, unless you’re a neat freak who doesn’t like anything stuck to the windshield, leave that sat nav option box unchecked and buy a portable unit.

By on June 3, 2007

chevycitation.jpgAs TTAC’s GM Deathwatch approaches the mid-century mark, its detractors continue to justify their scorn by mocking its episodic tally. I look forward to GM DW 1346, they scoff. Others of us understand that this chronicle would have reached that number already if RF had begun when some of us first realized GM was doomed. For me, that recognition arrived via the GM X-Body. 

My first car was a two-door 1965 Ford Galaxie 500, which sank in a lake (don’t ask). My second was a Ford Econoline-150 van (go figure). When I dropped a rod in the L6, it was time for a new set of wheels. As I earned my daily bread by playing drums, I needed transportation for same. To choose a suitable steed, I started reading.

In 1980, the buff books were all a-twitter about GM’s fabulous X-Body platform. From its front-wheel drive and transverse engine to its “sleek styling” and “intelligent hatchback design,” they were deeply smitten. Even Popular Science did a multi-page spread, complete with foldouts. I hadn’t seen that kind of print-gasm since Hugh Hefner put a staple in Marilyn Monroe’s navel. 

So I bought one: a white bread 1980 Chevrolet Citation.

At first, I loved it. I waxed it weekly, parked it carefully and drove if with what was known at the time as TLC. Like grains of sand in a Speedo (not that I’ve ever worn one, but you get my drift), little by little, little things started to annoy me.

When TTAC launches its Ten Worst Automobile Dashboard Designs Launched Ever, the Citation’s vertically-mounted radio will top the list. The rest of the Citation’s interior defined cheap for all time. But my real problem with the X-Body lay with that overlooked part known as a heater core.

I was returning from a gig in the wee hours, just behind an elderly couple in the inside lane. A van was weaving towards us. I took evasive action: brakes, steering, the works. The van hit the other sedan head-on at about 40 MPH, in an age before airbags. I ran up over the curb to avoid the collision. The van’s driver tossed a cooler aside before passing out. The whiskey it contained soaked into the grass.  

I ruined two tires and rims. Little did I know that my troubles were only beginning. Anti-freeze began dripping onto my front seat passengers' feet.

Let me pause a moment to give you some salient facts about GM X-Body heater cores. First, they were made of plastic. Second, when they broke, they dripped anti-freeze on your passenger's feet (you may have guessed that already). Third, you had to pull the engine to replace them. Fourth, they cracked if you looked at them cross-eyed.

My post-accident heater core replacement was destined to be the first of THREE heater cores I had to insert in that… that… car. Either GM never issued a recall/service bulletin or Mr. Goodwrench decided to keep those encoded Ren Cen messages to himself.

What’s more, my slavish devotion to maintenance did nothing to stop the Citation’s body from rusting out after just three years. It looked like a chemo patient with bedsores.

As a young, struggling musician, my budget didn’t include frequent car repairs. What I once regarded as an engineering marvel, I eventually realized was a poorly-designed, poorly built (but exquisitely marketed) steaming pile of crap. I was a step beyond “leading edge,” early adopters. I was a “bleeding edge” pioneer. 

Eventually, the early 80’s economy turned south. I had to relocate and find a new line of work. I was hired by a multi-national corporation as a medical diagnostic machine installer with a six-state territory. They gave me a company car.

I thought, “This is it! My chance to finally get away from GM’s misbegotten products!” Yes, well, my boss ordered a 1984 Chevrolet Celebrity station wagon.

My Citation sat idle for a year while I drove the snot out of the Celebrity. When my job was “downsized,” I relocated, driving my Citation through a Texas gully washer. The X-body finally gave up the ghost in Fort Worth, where I had it towed to a service station.

I replaced the Citation with a used Chrysler K-car (hey, I’ve always been a sucker for an American sob-story). Unsurprisingly, I forgot all about the Citation. One day, the service station called and asked me if I wanted it fixed or sold for parts. I told them to sell it and send me a check if they made any profit.

I never heard from the gas station again. And GM never heard from me– or a million other me’s– again. I knew then that any car company that would dare sell such a poorly engineered automobile would only survive as long as people didn’t know that someone else made a better product. They do, so it won’t.

By on June 2, 2007

tundra2.jpg Japanese society is known for its rigid social stratification. Depending on the listener’s relative status, there are four ways to say “this is a book." Individuals within this system are well aware that anyone who moves upwards from their "natural" place in the pecking order risks ridicule, jealousy and attack. Hence the ancient Japanese proverb: “The nail that sticks out gets hammered down." Automotively- speaking, Toyota is the tall nail these days, and boy, is it getting hammered.

Earlier this year, Toyota passed General Motors as the world’s largest automaker. Last month, Toyota’s U.S. operations ended Ford’s 76-year reign as America’s second biggest automaker. If you’re wondering why Toyota hasn’t celebrated these accomplishments with a bit of good old American swagger, see paragraph one. The Japanese carmaker knows it’s in the crosshairs. For now, the company figures that silence is the better part of valor. 

The problem is simple: Toyota’s reputation exceeds them. The automaker is famous for building vehicles that never break, rust, fail or fall apart. Automobiles that are so well-built they’ve stood the old ‘70’s idea that “made in Japan” means cheap on its head. Toyota’s reliability rep is so strong that a disgruntled aircraft owner recently evoked the company’s mythical mechanical prowess on an internet forum: “I want Toyota to make a single engine piston [airplane].” 

For some time, domestic supporters have been trying to tell American consumers to stop drinking the Toyota Kool Aid. Citing independent surveys, they claim The Big 2.8 have narrowed the quality gap to the point where it’s statistically meaningless, making the discrepancy a matter of [misinformed] perception. More to the point, they say the Japanese company is no stranger to product delays and recalls, and mechanical issues. Which is true.

While Toyota’s design, parts and production process remains second to none, carmaking is such a vastly complex business, and Toyota such a vast enterprise, that mistakes are inevitable. No carmaker– or car– is perfect. Toyota’s recent problems with the new Tundra pickup’s defective camshafts illustrate the simple fact that shit happens– especially when you’re building a new product in a new factory using new suppliers.

Still, there’s no question that Toyota’s rapid expansion in the North American market is giving the company growing pains– or should I say, continuing to challenge the storied Toyota Production System. Ironically enough, Toyota is suffering from a perception gap. Their quality problems are not significantly worse than before, but the company’s newly assumed tall poppy status makes them seem so. Simply put, people are paying attention.

Well, the media is, as witnessed by the relatively prominent play given the Tundra screw-up. That said, it would take at least a decade of crap Toyota products and bullet-proof Detroit metal to reverse the curse. And no matter what The Big 2.8 do or don’t do, Toyota is not about to let its products suffer from endless rounds of mechanical mishaps and expensive recalls.

Toyota is taking radical action to sort out its North American quality woes. The company is currently retraining ALL of its North American assembly workers. This “back to basics” course is designed to identify and correct defective working practices and highlight the need for increased front line vigilance. At the same time, Toyota is devolving decision-making powers and back office support from its Erlanger, Kentucky headquarters to regional centers in California and Texas.

Anyone who thinks Toyota will ease-up on its commitment to product quality, brand integrity and customer satisfaction is delusional. The automaker is nowhere near the peak of its global or national ambitions, and they know exactly what they have to do to get there. And make no mistake: Toyota’s current production problems are NOT a reflection of corporate hubris. They're a direct result of their desire to keep a low profile. To avoid the hammer.

How’s this for an inconvenient truth: building vehicles abroad would be the easiest way for Toyota to assure product quality and increase profits. They refrain from doing so for political reasons. The Japanese automaker knows that their top dog status makes them the logical scapegoat for failing American automakers. Planting factories on U.S. soil at least partially protects them from the slings and arrows of outraged patriots.

Speaking to Automotive news, management guru Jim Womack went further. The co-author of a seminal book on Toyota’s lean, mean production machine claims that the American political landscape makes it difficult for Toyota to be Toyota.

"The short-term rate of expansion in the States is not being driven by long-term judgment about what is truly best for the business as a business," Womack said. "Rather, it's being driven by an assessment of what is necessary for the company due to short-term politics.

“Toyota is terrified that it will be blamed for the collapse of Ford and the potential collapse of Chrysler, followed by GM."

If you were wondering how such a successful automaker could have such a paranoid corporate culture, it's best to think of Toyota's psychology as the reverse of Abraham "hierarchy of needs" Maslow's aphorism. When you're a nail, everything looks like a hammer.

By on June 2, 2007

Mercedes SL’s were as thick on the ground as mascara on an over-the-hill movie star. The teenaged scions of the local glitterati drove brand new BMW 320i’s and VW Cabrios. A red Ferrari 308 GTB was de-rigueur for the up and coming producer. If you simply HAD to have attention or score the prime valet-parking spot, a Rolls Royce Corniche convertible was the winning ticket. And what was I driving down Rodeo Drive? A beat-up 1968 Dodge camper-van. I looked like Jethro in “The Beverly Hillbillies”. Except that I actually was poor. Read More >

By on June 1, 2007

ny_naura_bart_stupak22.jpgLast week, the U.S. House of Representatives passed H.R. 1252. The sternly titled "Federal Price Gouging Prevention Act" established penalties for people who hoik-up gas prices to take "unfair advantage" of U.S. consumers during an "energy emergency." The Right condemned the act as stealth nationalization of the American oil industry. The Left condemned the bill for not going far enough to rein in Big Oil. So, is H.R. 1252 a well-intentioned congressional misfire or part of a great political swindle? Yes.

Representative Bart Stupak is the sponsor of this affront to common sense and economic reality. In case politically-insensitive voters were motoring under the impression that price gouging has a relatively minor impact on current national gas prices– as compared to, say, the effects the laws of supply and demand– Stupak was ready to set them straight and sort it out.

"[Americans] want relief at the pump," Stupak proclaimed. "And that is what we are doing."

Stupak was also happy to add the requisite spin to his sham cause-and-effect conundrum. "Every member [of the House] has a choice: side with big oil or side with consumers who are being ripped off at the gas pump."

Stupak's act would punish individuals and/or corporations that charge "unconscionable" prices for gas and other petroleum distillates. Corporate violators would be subject to up to $3m in civil fines, and $150m in criminal fines.

Adding karmic payback to the deal, any fines collected would be used to "provide assistance under the Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program administered by the Secretary of Health and Human Services."   

Despite Stupak's legislative zeal, the political Left isn't happy with H.R. 1252. For one thing the act only applies after a Presidential declaration of a renewable, thirty-day "energy emergency." "In other words," complains the Corporate Crime Reporter blog, "almost never." 

The Director of the Public Citizen non-profit consumer advocacy organization is equally disgruntled. Tyson Slocum says H.R. 1252's "unfortunate language" proves that the oil industry "still holds sway over the Democratic Party." The Rhode Island native predicts more symbolic jabs. "Are you going to see the Democrats taking big swings at Big Oil? No."

At the other end of the political spectrum, former Nixon speech writer, economist, actor and game show host Ben Stein used his Yahoo! Finance column to pronounce the Federal Price Gouging Prevention Act de facto pricing control. 

"This regulation could be triggered by actions that are basic to the free market," Stein railed, for exampling rising gas prices due to shortages caused by war or natural disasters. (As if.)

"In the most elemental terms," Stein opined, "the Stupak bill punishes oil companies when the free market is working as it should, allocating supply by means of the price system." 

In Stein's estimation, drivers unable to find gasoline at times of crisis would suffer most from the bill's powers, not high-paid corporate big-wigs. Of course, the Executive branch was down with that.

"This bill could… bring back long gas lines reminiscent of the 1970s," the White House warned. "Gasoline price controls are an old– and failed– policy choice that will exacerbate shortages and increase fuel hoarding after natural disasters, denying fuel to people when they most need it."

Political posturing aside, the act has enough holes to accommodate several hundred thousand tankers of premium-priced petrol.

The bill proscribes selling gasoline or petroleum distillates at "unconscionably excessive" prices that "[indicate] the seller is taking unfair advantage of the circumstances related to an energy emergency to increase prices unreasonably." The act does not define "unfair advantage" or "unconscionably excessive."

The proposed law stipulates that federal investigators must prove that its violators did "grossly exceed" a 30-day average pre-emergency price, or "grossly exceed" prices of competing sellers.

Without a proper definition of "gross excess," the law would leave federal prosecutors and courts almost as powerless as they are now (which is not powerless at all, but that's another story). 

Stupak's bill also instructs the feds to pause and ponder conditions attributable to local, regional, national or international market conditions, and "additional costs, not within the control of that person, that were paid, incurred, or reasonably anticipated by that person, or reflected additional risks taken by that person to produce, distribute, obtain, or sell such product under the circumstances."

Let's face it: any lawyer who couldn't beat Stupak's rap needs a new profession. That said, despite its inherent inanity, H.R. 1252 is a brilliant piece of legislation.

Democrats are sending President Bush a bill so fundamentally bone-headed that the Commander-in-Chief has no choice but to veto it. The Dems can then accuse the GOP of being Big Oil puppets during the upcoming national election cycle. Democratic candidates can also take credit for trying to protect you, the American people, from price gouging by the evil oil companies during times of crisis.  

In truth, they've done nothing of the kind. 

 Click here to view HR 1252 in its entirety.

 Do you think gasoline price gouging requires federal intervention?

By on May 31, 2007

The American Automobile Association recently calculated the average cost of driving a car. News flash: your automobile is devouring your children’s college fund to the tune of 52.2 cents per mile. Multiply that number by 15k miles and decades of driving, and automotive ownership costs make Ivy League tuition seem like a bargain. Thankfully, you can lower your cost of ownership (of the car) with three strategies. Each one will put a nice six figure dent back into your savings account, and a big fat smile on your face whenever you turn the key.

The first strategy is conservation: spending as little money as humanly possible. Automotive conservationists aren’t motivated by performance, comfort or snob appeal. All they want to do is get from Point A to Point B while keeping as much money in their pocket as humanly possible. They want to save in the showroom, at the pump, after service and at trade-in time.

Conservationists are, by their nature, small car aficionados. They’re willfully oblivious to the fact that small cars are an SUV’s accidental toe jam. They happily endure cramped quarters, sloth, low status and any of the other so-called downsides of owning a small, “boring” car. They concentrate on their econobox’s purchase price and operating costs.

Conservationists are big fans of Kia, Hyundai, Suzuki, Subaru and, of course, Honda and Toyota. They’re value junkies who scour the value of used cars before they even think about buying a new one.

To become a conservationist, find someone who drives a small, cheap, boring car who can tell you how much they spend on their car per month AND annually. Internet owners’ forums are an invaluable resource. Just register on a site dedicated to an inexpensive small car (“Cheap bastard” ought to do it) and post a thread asking “How much does it cost to run your X?”

The second strategy is endurance.

When most folks think of a car that last forever, they think of an old Volvo or Mercedes. That’s so last century. These days, most every automobile built can crest 100k miles without much trouble. In fact, 150k is the new 100k: the way point that tells an owner that he or she’s found a machine that can go the distance. Which is, let’s face it, one of your cheapest possible ownership options.

Frugal endurers are closet conservationists. They tend to pay cash up front (they consider monthly payments and interest charges an automotive fashion victim’s sin tax) for two-year-old or older cars.

They’re looking for vehicles blessed with [documented] factory-approved maintenance that have passed the “is it a lemon?” threshold. They look for unloved, low-spec models. Depending on their dedication, they’ll happily forgo such basic comforts as air conditioning and power door locks.

As endurers aren’t looking to trade in their wheels (i.e. they plan to run the vehicle into the ground), they couldn’t care less about their purchase’s short-term residuals. It’s all about keeping the car going, to get to those “cheap miles” at the end of the [hopefully] epic ownership period. And that means fastidious maintenance, extended warranties and celebrating the inevitable wear-and-tear.

To benefit from endurers’ sagacity, buy the most reliable car you can and hold it as long as possibly can. Period.

Mule trading is the third money saving strategy.

Mule traders buy from used car auctions. They buy whatever vehicle [they believe] will hold its value in the retail market. Due to a fickle public and sinister depreciation curves, many mule traders skip the way cool late model stuff and go for ‘sleds;’ vehicles that cost $5k or less. They drive em’, fix em’, sell em’, rinse and repeat.

Of course, not all mules are broken down beasts of burden. There are plenty of hot (though inexpensive) used cars available at auction that will protect the mule trader’s money (e.g. the Mini Cooper, Scion Xb, and Honda Fit). After anywhere between six months to 18 months, the traders simply sell the vehicle to a dealer, who uses them as high profit ‘finance fodder.’

The mule trader takes on the depreciation risk on the assumption that today’s hot new car will be tomorrow’s hot used car. The keen-eyed mule trader gets a higher trade-in value for the car, the dealer receives a larger profit off the financed vehicle.  Everyone wins– save for the poor bastard with the hot car and large monthly payment.

Whether you reduce your overall automotive operating costs by conserving cash, fixing costs (endurer) or taking advantage of automotive fashions (mule trader), there’s always an opportunity to save a chunk of change on your motoring expenses. The challenge: determining which mindset best suits your budget, skills and time. As Patek Phillipe’s ads used to say, choose once but choose wisely.

By on May 29, 2007

scorpiohuh.jpgOnce upon a time, American stage magicians would assume Indian-sounding names, don turbans and claim to have mastered the mysteries of the Indian subcontinent. Automaker Mahindra & Mahindra (M&M) looks set to revive the country’s rep for astonishing feats. While industry pundits are busy anticipating Chinese automotive exports, M&M are about to sell their products stateside, preparing to enter America’s value-for-money, entry-level market. Will it be magic or a massacre?

Ironically enough, the brothers Mahindra got their start by adapting an American product to the Indian market. After WWII, they set up their namesake company to franchise Willys Jeep production for India’s surface-challenged roads.

Mahindra & Mahindra eventually dropped their American partner, built their own SUV and expanded into light duty trucks, three-wheelers and pickups. The company now operates eight Indian production facilities, 49 sales offices and 780 dealers.

Last year, the Indian conglomerate– including telecoms, financial services and property development– banked roughly $39b in revenues. (For comparison, BMW’s revenues for the same period were around $64b.) In recognition of their size, solidity and importance to the Indian economy, Mahindra & Mahindra is set to replace motorcycle maker Hero Honda Motors on the Bombay stock market’s 30-stock sensitive index (a.k.a. Sensex) in July.  

M&M may be a force to be reckoned with in India, but Automotive News ranks them number 34 on their list of global vehicle makers. All in, Mahindra produces fewer vehicles per year than Ford [still] sells F-150s. No wonder many auto analysts have discounted the Indian tiger’s chances of successfully cracking the world’s largest automotive market– especially when weighed against the aspirations of the Chinese dragon.

Yes but– China’s joint partnerships remain focused on the epic struggle for market share within their friendly neighborhood military dictatorship. Meanwhile, M&M is gearing-up for international expansion.

Earlier this year, Mahindra joined forces with Renault / Nissan to build India’s largest automotive production facility. The Indo – French operation is a flexible factory, looking to produce 50k vehicles this year. M&M claim the plant has sufficient capacity to increase throughput to 400k vehicles per year.  

Two weeks ago, the automaking duo released a local version of Renault’s “world car.” It’s unclear how the Logan DLE 1.5-liter dci will fare against the almost identically powered industry leader, the Ford Fiesta 1.4-liter Duratorque ZXI. But the 547,064 IDR ($13,476) Logan undercuts the popular Ford by around 90k IDR ($2217). In a country with a $979 annual per capita income, that’s a compelling difference. 

The cut-price Logan may well join Mahindra and Mahindra’s Scorpio as another value-priced product doing battle outside its home market.

Five years ago, Mahindra began selling their diesel and petrol-powered SUV to Malaysia, South Africa, Russia, Italy, France, Spain, Portugal and Western Europe (where it’s known as the Goa). Sales and reviews have been strong; the vehicle is now in its second generation, complete with a Lotus-tuned suspension. M&M believe the Scorpio and its derivatives are ready to fulfil their American ambitions.

The Indian carmaker is no stranger to the U.S. market. After severing an eight-year franchise agreement with International Harvester in 1971, Mahindra and Mahindra began building their own line of tractors. In 1994, M&M started selling farm machinery in the United States.

With US assembly facilities in Tomball, Texas and Calhoun, Georgia (and a third site under construction), the company estimates it will sell 10k tractors this year. And M&M is no cheapo tractor builder. In 2003, their U.S. ops received the Deming Application Prize for Total Quality Management; the only tractor company to achieve this honor.

To sell their automotive products stateside, Mahindra turned to Global Vehicles. The Georgia-based company is notorious for trying– and failing– to import the Romanian-built Cross Lander. Global v2 says they’ve sold 160 Mahindra dealerships for $125k apiece. They’re looking to add another 340 M&M dealers by the end of this year, with sales starting in early to mid ’08.

Last month, 500 potential M&M dealers gathered in Atlanta to see the Indian automaker’s five-model U.S. line up: a two-door pickup, two four-door trucks and two five-door SUVs. 

Mahindra’s expected to price these products in the low 20’s. Their SUV will butt heads with Hyundai’s Tuscon ($17k – $22k) and Kia’s Sportage ($16k – $22k). Unless the Indian machines bring a raft of standard features and a matching warranty to the party, it’ll be an uphill battle. M&M’s small pickup will encounter far less resistance, as American and Japanese automakers have neglected and/or abandoned the segment.

M&M’s secret weapon: diesels. All five US products will offer an optional diesel engine. Renault’s oil burners are some of one of the best in the biz: torquey, smooth and frugal. If Mahindra found a way to make their diesel powerplants U.S.-compliant, their products will find a ready audience, and establish a beachhead in the world’s most competitive automotive market. Now THAT would be some trick.

Recent Comments

  • Lou_BC: @Carlson Fan – My ’68 has 2.75:1 rear end. It buries the speedo needle. It came stock with the...
  • theflyersfan: Inside the Chicago Loop and up Lakeshore Drive rivals any great city in the world. The beauty of the...
  • A Scientist: When I was a teenager in the mid 90’s you could have one of these rolling s-boxes for a case of...
  • Mike Beranek: You should expand your knowledge base, clearly it’s insufficient. The race isn’t in...
  • Mike Beranek: ^^THIS^^ Chicago is FOX’s whipping boy because it makes Illinois a progressive bastion in the...

New Car Research

Get a Free Dealer Quote

Who We Are

  • Adam Tonge
  • Bozi Tatarevic
  • Corey Lewis
  • Jo Borras
  • Mark Baruth
  • Ronnie Schreiber