Category: Editorials

By on May 5, 2007

It was a successful launch, and I was going for the record books. The 534 cubic inch Ford V8 bellowed and roared through the two short pipes exiting under my feet. The wide-open Holley four barrel noisily sucked the cool morning air. The air-scooped hood rose and dropped on the passenger side with each banging shift, a visual testament to massive torque. As my speed approached record territory, I had my hands full keeping the snorting beast under control. I glanced down on the big round speedometer and confirmed my victory: ninety miles per hour. Read More >

By on May 4, 2007

frtiz2.jpg"We have a continued sense of high urgency." Last Sunday, I ressurrected auto industry analyst Mary Ann Keller’s 2005 call to GM to face its problems with “a sense of urgency.” Yesterday, GM’s CFO reassured analysts and reporters by seeing Keller’s heightened mental state and raising it a Mel Brooks. High urgency? What the bleep is that? Whatever it is, it better be the management equivalent of Viagra.

"Our business is not generating the kind of returns we expect,” Fritz Henderson told the money men and journalistic jackals, announcing a 90 percent drop in GM’s first quarter earnings (from $602m to $62m). Ya think?

At the risk of overthinking this, I find it a bit strange that Fritz said GM’s not getting the returns they “expect” not “expected.” I take that to mean there’s an ongoing discrepancy between management expectations and market reality, in a “what the Hell do we do now?” kinda way.

Just in case we hadn’t quite grokked the overarching irony of GM’s circumstances, while Fritz was busy yap dancing, Car Czar Bob Lutz told a hack that GM’s on-again, off-again, on-again, off-again Zeta platform cars are on again. Maybe. Meanwhile, GM's [theoretical] world-beating small car is still stuck in global limbo.

Despite ongoing product confusion, results from GM's overseas operations (net income up $264m to $304m) indicate that it would be relatively smooth sailing for the corporate mothership if it weren’t for the gaping hole in its side known as the North American automotive unit (GMNA).

Although GMNA's first-quarter net losses narrowed from $292m to $46m, Fritz [rightly] credited structural cost savings. In other words, we’re cutting our way to prosperity! Only, you know, not. But hey! GMNA's revenue per vehicle (RPV) rose by $1,064!

Yes well, in a perfect world, an uptick in small car sales would have lowered the number. While GM is selling larger, more highly contented vehicles, they're flogging fewer of them (sales down 9.5 percent in April, 100k fewer vehicles sold during the quarter). And the revenue figure doesn’t include the cost of the additional content. In fact, the actual cost per vehicle could well be rising faster than the RPV.

Addressing the subject of sinking sales, Fritz flagged the fact that GM’s rental fleet cutback accounted for 60 percent of the automaker's reduced throughput. U.S. retail sales were “only” down four percent. Yes but– sales of the vehicle carrying the hopes of a nation the company– the refreshed Chevrolet Silverado pickup– tumbled 7.2 percent.

And things are about to get even trickier. GM’s urgently high— I mean “highly urgent” CFO acknowledged the United Auto Workers (UAW)-shaped storm clouds gathering on the increasingly bleak horizon. Fritz played the “we’re all in this together” card.

“We have to continue to make significant improvements,” Henderson admitted, continuing the automaker’s unspoken policy of not speaking about long- or short-term targets. “That is on our minds as we go into collective bargaining, as well."

As predicted, GM’s almost about to gonna sort its union problems at its Lordstown and Fairfax factories. This proto-success returns the Delphi UAW UXB (unexploded bomb) to its rightful position under the Chairman’s chair.

To prepare for a UAW payoff at their bankrupt former subsidiary and mission-critical parts supplier, GM's allocated an additional $100m (up to $500m) for the first year of any Delphi deal. They've also increased the ongoing estimated cost of a Delphinian solution by an additional $100m per year (now $100m – $200m per year). And they still insist they're going to save $2b on parts costs over the next five years. (Someone should tell Delphi's private equity owners.) 

Short term, the Delphi problem pales in comparison to the ongoing disaster over at their GMAC finance unit. Thanks to sub-prime loan implosion, their former cash cow has turned into a vampire bat.

This quarter, GM’s 49 percent share "earned" it a $115m loss. (GMAC dividend RIP.) Fritz took a stab at singing the sun will come out tomorrow, but his heart wasn’t in it. ”When you're in the midst of the kind of maelstrom we're in with nonprime, I think it's important to take it quarter by quarter.” And take it like a man.

Bottom line: with its continuing cash conflagration, GM needs to start selling a whole bunch of profitable vehicles in North America, and soon. Goldman Sachs analyst Robert Barry isn’t optimistic. He told Automotive News that GM’s NorAm results were weak "given that we are at the peak of GM's product cadence."

Barry may not know the half of it. According to TTAC’s Deep Throat, as bad as GM is doing overall, it’s far worse on the coasts. In particular, California is becoming more and more of a GM-free zone. That situation needs sorting now, in a super highly urgent way.

But how? As long as Toyota is the price leader and GM has to discount its vehicles to sell, GMNA can only hope for breakeven or slightly better. And face much, much worse.

By on May 3, 2007

vader.jpgIn the Phantom Menace, Anakin Skywalker stands in front of the Jedi Council. Master Yoda senses that Skywalker’s fear of losing his mother is clouding his mind. “Fear is the path to the dark side,” Yoda pronounces. “Fear leads to anger. Anger leads to hate. Hate leads to suffering.” And there you have it: the story of the merger between Daimler-Benz and the Chrysler Corporation. Witnessing much suffering, we are.

Like Anakin, every Daimler-Benz CEO has been afraid of losing his metaphorical mother. In other words, they’ve been scared that Daimler-Benz will fall prey to a hostile takeover. In 1984, Daimler-Benz CFO (and later CEO) Edzard Reuter decided that the only way to keep Daimler-Benz independent was to grow to the point of indigestibility.

At the time, Daimler-Benz had huge cash reserves. They could have easily survived a complete failure of one or two new model lines. But Reuter believed that the market for Daimler-Benz products wasn’t big enough to accommodate poison pill-scale growth. So he decided to diversify.

Reuter mined Daimler-Benz’ cash mountain to buy numerous aerospace and technology corporations. Unfortunately, his acquisitions were bottomless pits. Reuter burned so much cash during his regency that Daimler-Benz’ 1995 stock price had fallen 12 percent since the fateful day he’d assumed control in 1987– despite a wildly successful Mercedes brand.

In 1995, Reuter floated away on his golden parachute, creating corporate lebensraum for his successor, Jürgen Schrempp.

Schrempp soon sold every major business that wasn’t part of traditional automaking. When he finished de-acquisitioning, Daimler-Benz was exactly where it was ten years earlier, only poorer.

By this time, the global car industry was in the throes of massive consolidation. BMW, GM and Ford were buying-up once storied marques. FIAT was on the ropes. Toyota’s epic growth was continuing. Industry analysts were predicting that the international automotive market could only sustain five independent car manufacturers by 2005.

And then Deutsche Bank, Daimler-Benz’ long-time majority shareholder, announced it was dumping its stake in the German automaker. If Yoda would have been present, he could easily have sensed the fear within Schrempp.

Schrempp decided that Daimler-Benz had act upon of the old Italian saying: il pesce grande mangia il più piccolo. Daimler-Benz had to eat someone else not to get eaten.

Honda topped the list. Still smarting from its ill-fated tie-up with Britain’s Rover Group, the Japanese automaker was deaf to Schrempp’s overtures. So Schrempp started negotiations with/for Chrysler.

At the same time, Ford approached Daimler-Benz about a possible tie-up. When the Ford family made it clear that a takeover (Ford over Daimler-Benz) was the only acceptable scenario, Schrempp pulled the plug on the negotiations. After all, Chrysler had announced “game on.”

Daimler-Benz paid $36b for the American automaker, called it a merger of equals (a.k.a. “a wedding in heaven”) and breathed a sigh of relief. They singularly failed to notice a disturbance in the force.

One year later, on March 10, 1999, it all started to go downhill. That was the day DCX’ Board of Directors rejected DaimlerChrysler’s plan to take over the world Nissan. Schrempp wanted it. Nissan wanted it. But Schrempp was too afraid unable to push his plans through the Jedi Council DCX’ Board of Directors. 

Renault ended up buying Nissan. Under the leadership of Carlos “The Slasher” Ghosn, the two companies formed the most successful merger in recent automotive history. Schrempp was left shaking his head, knowing that Nissan could have provided Chrysler with the high quality small cars it needed for the U.S. market (a task now left to DaimlerChrysler’s less-practiced Chinese partners).

Still hungry for a Japanese partner, DaimlerChrysler bought Mitsubishi, a wounded manufacturer with plenty of production problems. This decision lead to the second important date in the history of DaimlerChrysler’s failure: April 22, 2004.

On this fateful day, Daimler-Chrysler’s Board of Directors decided to end any further financial help for its ailing Mitsubishi brand. Schrempp had staked his reputation on making Mitsubishi work. It needed a massive cash infusion. But the force was weak with that one.

After the Board’s rejection of his request, Schrempp’s days were numbered. By the end of 2005, he finally stepped down, taking with him the grand global “vision” that was supposed to fuel the Daimler Chrysler merger.

By the time this epic episode faded to black, DaimlerChrysler’s stock price stood at sub-‘95, (pre-Schrempp) levels. Now it’s Dieter Zetsche’s turn to clean up the mess that Schrempp left behind. And when he’s finished, Daimler-Benz will be where it was 10 years ago, only poorer.

According to the official numbers, CEO Reuter and Schrempp’s delusions of grandeur successful attempts to prevent a Daimler-Benz takeover burned through some $60b of Daimler-Benz’ money, although the unofficial estimate place the amount as high as $120b. And it ain’t over yet.

Let’s just hope Dr Z is not afraid.

By on May 3, 2007

audi50002.jpg

[Update: this article has been updated and re-published here]

When I first heard about the Audi “sudden unintended acceleration” segment on CBS’s 60 Minutes in 1986, I knew immediately that they were blowing smoke. Literally.

A few years earlier, I was part of a TV crew shooting an educational program. Legendary race-car driver Parnelli Jones was the guest celebrity. The producer offered to take us to lunch in his 1976 Cadillac Fleetwood Brougham. We hopped in. Parnelli took the wheel.

Parnelli fired up the Caddy’s big V8, dropped it in gear and floored it- with his other foot on the brake. The left rear wheel lit up in a screeching howl; the car was soon engulfed in a cloud of acrid smoke. The Caddy didn’t move an inch- obviously. And neither did Parnelli, glancing at the wincing producer with his wicked grin. I had assumed (wrongly) that race-car drivers grew up eventually.

The experience seared in a lesson in basic automobile physics: brakes are always more powerful than engines, even when they have 500 cubic inches (8.2 liters). Too bad we didn’t have our cameras running. We could have made a graphic rebuttal to 60 Minutes’ fraudulent destruction of Audi.

Let’s set the scene. It’s 1984. Audi sales had shot up 48 percent on the strength of their new aero-dynamic 5000, the hot new weapon in the perpetually-escalating suburban driveway status war. It was a stunning piece. Audi was on a roll.

Suddenly, the war turned bloody. Moms in runaway Audi 5000’s were mowing down their little kids in the driveway and pinning granny against the far garage wall.

This hadn’t happened with the Olds Cutlass Supreme Coupe, the “hot” suburban car Mom traded in for her Audi. The German car certainly felt different. Unlike the Olds’ wide push-bar brake pedal– that some Americans still operated with their left feet– the Audi had that weird, small brake pedal, kinda’ close to the gas pedal.

And these Audis had a mind of their own. No matter how hard Mom pushed on the brake pedal, the Audi kept on going, right through the garage door. This despite the fact that the little five-cylinder mill only cranked out 130 horsepower. And the top-notch four-wheel disc brake system probably could generate well over 600 g-force horsepower.

Apparently, the brakes were failing at exactly the same moment that the gas pedal decided it had a mind of its own. Perfectly plausible, at least to the 60 Minutes crew.

About as plausible as ignoring the police report of the most dramatic victim on the show, Kristi Bradosky, who ran over her six year old son. That report said “Bradosky’s foot slipped off the brake pedal onto the gas pedal accelerating the auto.” Denial isn’t just a river.

Ed Bradley’s 17 minute “investigative report” aired on November 23, 1986. Between interviews of the teary-eyed “victims” (drivers) of unintended acceleration swearing their feet were on the brake pedal, CBS showed a clip of a driverless Audi lurching forward on its own.

Viewers didn’t see the canister of compressed air on the passenger-side floor with a hose running to a hole drilled in the transmission. An “expert” had rigged the Rube Goldberg device to shift the big Audi into drive and, like any automatic-equipped car, move forward (unless the brakes are depressed).

The clip was blatantly deceptive AND totally irrelevant. Nobody claimed driverless Audis were taking off and killing kids. Mom was always at the wheel, pushing the 5000’s “brake” pedal with all her might.

In 1989, after three years of studying the blatantly obvious, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) issued their report on Audi’s “sudden unintended acceleration problem.” NHTA’s findings fully exonerated Audi and some other implicated foreign makes.

The report concluded that the Audi’s pedal placement was different enough from American cars’ normal set-up (closer to each other) to cause some drivers to mistakenly press the gas instead of the brake. 60 Minutes did not retract their piece; they called the NHTSA report “an opinion.”

A flood of lawsuits was already washing over Audi, not to mention a tsunami of bad publicity. Audi took a questionable stance: they didn’t blame the drivers for the problem, even after the NHTSA report came out. Hey, the customer’s always right, and we sure wouldn’t want to make our American customers look stupid. Anything but that.

So the German automaker took it on the chin. Audi sales collapsed, from 74k units in 1984 to 12k by 1991. The timing added insult to injury; sales fell during the same years when Lexus arrived to battle for the hearts and wallets of America’s up-scale consumers. The Japanese autos quickly became the new suburban driveway prestige weapon.

Audi’s wanna-be-Lexus drivers launched a class action suit charging lost resale value. No wonder the brand almost abandoned the U.S. in 1993. It’s a killer market.

By on May 2, 2007

tahoehybrid.jpgThe hybrid hype has finally reached Detroit. This fall, the gi-normous GMT900-based GMC Yukon (a.k.a. the Chevrolet Tahoe) will offer optional dual-mode hybrid engine technology. Next year, Chrysler will follow suit with a hybrid Durango/Aspen. Both automakers promise 25 percent better mileage on the highway. Chrysler is claiming a 40 percent increase in the city. GM promises a 25 percent urban gain. Happy days are here again! You’ll soon be able to have your SUV and afford to drive it too! And cool the planet! Or, you know, not.

While the idea of a full-size hybrid SUV may send California’s Governator into a muscle flexing frenzy, one doesn’t have to read too carefully between the lines to see the abject futility of this venture. Let’s crunch a few numbers.

According to our friends over at the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), the Yukon/Tahoe twins burn gas at the non-PC pace of one gallon every 16 miles in town, and once every 21 miles on the open road. Chrysler’s most efficient V8 uses gas at a buttock-clenching 14/19 mpg. 

To fix this sales sucking situation, GMC and Chrysler have equipped their big rigs with Prius-like (though proprietary) dual-mode hybrid technology. At low speeds and light loads, the hi-tech SUV’s can move forwards (or backwards) via electric power, internal combstion or some combination thereof. At high speeds or heavy loads (i.e. drag racing with a bass boat behind), the hybrid's batteries assist the engine. Add regenerative brakes and displacement-on-demand cylinder deactivation and away you go.

Surely all this ground-breaking technology will provide significant efficiency improvements and fuel cost savings. I don’t know about you but I’m thinking, what, mid to high 20’s? That kind of improvement might even give the SUV genre a new lease (five year loan?) on life. No sir.

For those of you who haven't done the math yet, the hybridified GM and DCX SUV’s are set to eke out a paltry 19-20mpg. And that’s city driving, where hybrids typically shine.

The enemy, of course, is weight. Just as you can’t make a silk purse out of a sow’s ear, you can’t turn a gas hog into silk pajamas (or something like that). Although GM is retrofitting the hybrid Yukahoe with aluminum components to compensate for 300 lbs. of batteries, it’s more or less a wash. The SUV’s will still weigh in at nearasdammit 5000 lbs. (or more depending on drivetrain).

Bottom line: a 25 percent improvement on not much ain’t a whole lot. But it is something, right?

“We have to think hard about the consumer who buys vehicles like the Dodge Durango and the Chrysler Aspen,” prevaricates Mark Chernoby, who’s just one letter away from having the world’s worst name for a VP of Advanced Vehicle Engineering. “These are people who want to have hauling capability.”

OK, but how many people who really need 8900 lbs. of towing capacity are gonna fork out a bunch more money for a vehicle offering few more mpg’s– especially when there's a lot full of heavily discounted non-hybrids lazing around?

Yes, here we go again: the “hybrid premium.” Forking out a couple of thousand bucks extra for hybrid tech has got to be pretty low on your average SUV buyer’s “to do” list. Buyers who previously owned full-sized SUV’s as status symbols (and got religion down at their local pump ‘n pay) have either left the genre already or can’t wait to do so. And any Chevy, GMC, Dodge or Chrysler dealer who thinks he’s going to see Prius drivers wheeling into his lot to trade-up to a hybrid SUV is plumb crazy.

It’s no surprise that the domestic automaker’s first serious hybrid offerings have arrived in SUV form. SUV’s are cheap to build, the factories and suppliers are already in place and they’re the automakers’ highest profit product. Besides, genuine clean sheet designs are extremely expensive and risky propositions. Better to stick with what you know. 

But American consumers will quickly see that boosting SUV gas mileage by 25 percent is nothing more than porcine lipstick application. If gas prices crest four bucks a gallon this summer, this insight will only require of femtosecond of consumer decision making. The odds that gas prices will trend downwards enough to lure large numbers of SUV buyers by the fall, when GMC unleashes their hybrids, are smaller than the Honda Fits, Nissan Versas, Toyota Yari and Chevrolet Aveos many of SUV refugees are now driving (no, really).

By the same token, Chrysler will enjoy the privilege of watching GMC fail to sell their hybrid Yukahoes before they open the gates on gas – electric Aspangos. Perhaps DCX (or whomever) will learn by example and not spend precious advertising and marketing resources on this ill-advised makeover. Maybe they’ll build a hybrid-powered 300C instead, to help revive that line’s flagging sales. Who knows? Maybe gas pigs can fly.

By on May 2, 2007

pontiac-montana-sv62.jpgSix months ago, this website published its Ten Worst Automobiles Today (TWAT) awards. While the resulting publicity pretty much killed our access to press cars, it had to be said. As we ready ourselves for readers' '07 TWAT nominations and the eventual awards dinner (yes, you're invited), let's see how last year's "winners" have fared since TTAC named and shamed the Ten Worst Automobiles Today.

10.  Chevrolet Aveo: alive and, uh, well  

"In the case of this captive Korean import, you pay little and get even less."  

Driving a Chevy Aveo5 was like pedaling a bicycle through a Hell's Angels' motorcade: slow, noisy and frightening. And yet, since scoring a TWAT, consumers have shown their desperation for cheap, high-mileage vehicles (and their ignorance of TTAC's editorial wisdom) by sending sales up 53%.  

9.  Lincoln Mark LT: fading fast

"The Mark LT is a rolling testament to Dearborn's short-term, suicidal reliance on bean-counted engineering."

In 2006, Lincoln unloaded about 1k florid F-150’s per month. Only about 700 customers per month are currently looking at $9800 worth of first year depreciation, minus a $4k rebate. Still, anyone who loves their LT isn’t likely to care. At least not yet.   

8.  Saab 9-7x: doomed

 "You know what I hate most about the Saab 9-7X? It's a Chevy Trailblazer with the ignition key between the seats."  

Badge-engineering this mutant must be a low-cost proposition; GM's still building 9-7x's despite selling fewer than 500 per month. The model will surely die with the rest of the Trailblazer clones in 2010, to be replaced by the 9-4X. With Saab's DNA DOA, can another TWAT be far behind?

7.  Subaru B9 Tribeca: struggling for survival

"The fact that the B9 is also slow, thirsty and cramped proves that repulsiveness can be more than skin deep."  

Tired of TTAC-inspired sniggering and lackluster sales, Subaru is about to modify the Tribeca's infamous "flying vagina" grill and slot-in a bigger engine. The B9-no-more (if it ever was) will still be as ugly as current sales figures. Subie sold just 3606 examples in the first three months of ‘07, down 22.8% from last year's miserable total. We reckon it's only a matter of time…

6.  Chevrolet Monte Carlo: dead

"The Chevrolet Monte Carlo is a wrong wheel-drive engineering joke from the late ‘80's." 

The darling of the NASCAR set heads for the big pit stop in the sky this June. Dale Jr. fans need not despair. Chevy has a brand new set of Impala SS decals ready to plaster on NASCAR's generic "Car of Tomorrow." How great is that?

5.  Hummer H2: doomed

"While the H2 doesn't come with hair plugs, it tells the world that the man behind the wheel has a small penis, or brain, or both." 

When gas prices went up, H2 sales went down– 27% from last year. Quelle surprise! With the smaller, less hideous H3 on the market, the H2 is destined for retirement.

4.  Chrysler Aspen: DOA

"It's a perfect example of the old adage ‘Just because you can do something doesn't mean you should.'"

A huge, thirsty, expensive, poorly-built, Pacifica-faced SUV based on the Durango, one of the worst-selling SUV's on the market? I'll take two. Meanwhile, Chrysler sold just 7244 Aspens in the first quarter of '07. The just-announced hybrid Hemi Aspen won't do diddley to ressurect this stillborn syllogism. 

3.  Buick Rendezvous: dead 

"The Rendezvous embodies everything that's brought GM to the brink: penny pinching, brand dilution and chronic neglect."  

GM is shutting down the plant where this minivan-based SUV is manufactured. The dubiously port-holed Enclave replaces both the Rendezvous and Ranier (a Chevy Trailblazer with the key on the ignition column, right where God intended).

2.  Jeep Compass: struggling

"The Compass stomps all over Jeep's reputation as America's purveyor of authentic off-road vehicles."  

When a company known for “Trail Rated” off-roaders bases a vehicle on a front wheel-drive family car, only L.L. Bean fashion victims need apply. Apparently, there aren’t a whole lot of buyers answering to that description. At the start of April, Jeep had a 117-day supply of the not-so-cute-ute languishing on their lots. 

1.  GM Minivans: dead

 "For their… cancerous effect on not one but four GM brands and their abject inability to hold a candle to their foreign-owned competition, GM's minivans earn The Truth About Cars' accolade as the worst vehicles currently for sale in America."  

These vans were so bad they caused their manufacturer to abandon an entire market segment. After this year, they're toast.

Speaking of toasts, in six months time we'll be raising our glasses to TTAC's 2007 TWAT award winners. It's too early to tell if last year's survivors will make it onto this year's list. But it's not too early to begin thinking about which vehicles will become one of TTAC's Ten Worst Automobiles Today.

[NOTE: TTAC is not asking for official TWAT nominations at this time.]

Click here for all articles about the '06 TWAT Awards

By on May 1, 2007

4sq2.jpgSometime between the sale of the first Model T and now, the automobile business has come to represent all that is wrong with sales, marketing and advertising. According to the surveys that track respect for professions, automobile salesmen are bottom feeders, swimming just above the mud with politicians and marketing folk. Do new and used-car dealers deserve such scorn? Absolutely. The truth about car dealers lies far closer to the stereotype than what they’d like you to believe.

I used to produce TV commercials for a chain of Texas dealerships. On my first shoot, I noticed a quarter on the asphalt. Naturally, I bent down to pick it up. “What are you doing?” the cameraman whispered. The sales reps had “seeded” the lot with pocket change to stop customers from literally running away from an approaching car salesman. 

Virtually every TV ad I made highlighted misleading or downright deceptive “offers.” How about a new Ford F-150 for $10 a day? While $300 a month IS ten bucks a day, dealers use this psychological ploy to lure low-income customers who would balk at a higher (though empirically equal) number. It gets worse from there. How about a special offer?

Fancy a Dodge Caravan SXT minivan for $19 a month? Bob Saks Dodge of Farmington Hills is happy to oblige – as long you put $1999 down and lease a 2007 Dodge Ram 1500 SLT Quad Cab for $179 a month. And work for Chrysler. With A Tier credit. And already lease a Chrysler, Dodge or Jeep vehicle. And pay all taxes, destination and “acquisition fees” and other “routine charges” on both vehicles. And don’t drive either vehicle more than 10,500 miles a year.

Then there are mega-clearance sales. The dealer has trucked in (at great expense!) a lot-load of used cars (starting at only $99!). “No offer will be refused!” “Every application will be accepted!” “Agents are on-site to accept your financing!”

To avoid arrest, the dealer only has to have ONE vehicle for $99 on his lot on the first day of the sale. Obviously, this loss leader will be gone before you get there –  if it even existed and you'd even want it.

Customers falling (and falling and falling) into the bad credit category get loan shark rates and/or an extremely limited selection of beaters to buy. True: the dealer doesn’t refuse any offer. They just never promise to accept any offer. And so it goes: amazing deals married to astounding fine print.

And speaking of credit scores, do you know what yours is? If a salesman reappears from the Finance Guy’s lair and tells you your credit score leaves something to be desired, if he’s inadvertently downgraded your credit, your payments will go up, right along with the dealer’s profits. Strange that.

Those zero percent finance offers sound great, but you're often better off with a higher rate. If you factor in the rebates on offers— which are not available to zero percenters— it’s usually true. Bottom line: If you’re paying $199 a month on a $35k car, there's a reason. Eventually, inevitably, somehow, you’re going to have to pay off the principal.

To hide this fact, dealers play Three Card Monte with the three major transactions involved with buying a car: selling your old car to the dealer, buying the new car and financing your purchase.

As seen on “The King of Cars” reality series (and dealerships throughout America), the salesman divides a piece of paper into four squares: trade value ($3k for your trade-in guaranteed!), price, down payment and monthly payment. He fills out the boxes with some insulting numbers and then encourages you to focus on the monthly payment – forgetting the fact that he’s stiffed you on your trade-in and listed the highest possible “price.” 

If you insist on a higher trade-in value, he’ll bump up the price, down payment or monthly payment. If you say the starting price is too high (i.e. wrong), no problem! The monthly payment goes up. Up, down, move it around. Numbers are “dragged” from one box to the other. The deal doesn’t get much better, but it's made to look more acceptable.

At some point, the Sales Manager strolls in and says he can do the deal for $10 or $20 or $30 more than the monthly payment on the “four square.” Bingo! The dealer just added another $1k – $3k (over five years) profit to the “deal.”

The battle lines are drawn. The dealers have created an adversarial relationship with customers. They’ve armed themselves with every dirty trick in the book and they have experience, time, and greed on their side. You are but a lamb to the slaughter; an “up” that becomes a grease pencil mark on a tote board, and with any luck, another checkmark on their way to “Salesman of the Month.” Caveat emptor, pal.

By on April 29, 2007

gmtroika2.jpgAfter Rick Wagoner “woke up” to the news that Toyota had replaced General Motors as the world’s largest automaker, GM’s CEO fired-off a post-Empire email to his execs. Rabid Rick admonished The General’s generals to stay focused on “further reducing our still huge health care cost disadvantage versus Toyota and other non-U.S. based manufacturers.” So Mr. Wagoner’s major dodos must sell the union on a “huge” health care cutback at the same time that regulatory filings reveal that the boss pulled down $10.2m in fiscal ’06 and just received a $370k increase to his base pay for '07 (regardless of results). Good luck with that.

You might’ve thought the prospect of life or death contract talks with the United Auto Workers (UAW) at both GM and Delphi would have convinced GM’s Board of Bystanders that austerity begins at home. Nope. They rubber stamped a CEO compensation package that makes a mockery of any reasonable concept of performance-related pay and insures the continuation of management – union conflict. If you need proof that it’s [lack of] business as usual at GM, well, there’s more.

In the same email, Wagoner was quick to assure his execs of that his “steady as she goes” management of GM’s decline continues apace. “Our sales and marketing strategy requires patience," Rabid Rick explained. "But it's working, and we need to stick with it.”

Putting aside the fact that only the most optimistic analyst could stretch the definition of the word “working” to cover GM’s ongoing financial losses, cash burn and inexorable market share slide, this forbearance-requiring strategy has taken a few knocks as of late.

We’ve already covered GM’s start – stop – start – stop Zeta platform program. Any hope that GM would carve itself a niche as a provider of large, comfortable, reasonably fuel efficient rear-wheel drive sedans (a.k.a. traditional American cars) is now in the automotive equivalent of cryogenic suspension. More worrying, the much-need refresh of GM’s small car platform is now stalled amidst union strife at their Lordstown factory.

On Friday, GM stopped tooling and other preparations for their Delta update. The move supposedly came after the UAW decided to dig in its heels over changes designed to make Lordstown more like a modern manufacturing facility and less like a feudal fiefdom. According to an unnamed Automotive News source, local negotiations to remove janitorial and truck unloading jobs from union control and limit overtime fell apart when the national union stepped in and said “No.”

For their part, the UAW claims they pulled the plug on the agreement after learning that GM had decided to postpone development of the new Delta vehicles. The dispute has widened to include GM’s Fairfax facility, tipped to produce the new Epsilon 2-based mid-sized Malibu— another vehicle upon which GM’s passenger car hopes depend. Same deal: contract talks suspended, tooling stopped, or vice versa.

Either way, on the face of it, this is old school stuff. In the run-up to national contract talks, GM threatens to take work away from the UAW. The UAW threatens to strike. GM execs blink, pay off the union and call their stock brokers with the glad tidings.

There’s not a shred of doubt in my mind that GM and the UAW will resolve this dispute in the traditional manner– save minor window dressing spun as “Historic Union Givebacks II." If Rabid Rick had the balls to stand up to the UAW or the charm to seduce them, he would have– should have– done it by now.

It’s almost inconceivable; GM’s playing what the British call “silly buggers” with the UAW and critical future vehicles when they’re hemorrhaging market share, depleting their remaining cash hoard and just passed a psychological watershed that set off alarm bells in every nook and cranny of GM’s bloated Byzantine bureaucracy. I’m sorry; the Toyota tipping point SHOULD have called GM’s multitude of minions to battle stations, but didn’t.

When will GM’s Management and its Board of Bystanders develop what longtime GM watcher Mary Ann Keller called a “sense of urgency?” In case you’ve forgotten, Ms. Keller sounded the alarm back in November 2005, when Toyota first passed GM in the U.S. market (if you remove fleet sales from the equation). At the time, Keller was convinced GM would act to address its flawed fundamentals because, well, it had to.

One wonders what Ms. Keller made of GM Car Czar Bob Lutz’ reaction to the Toyota coup. When a reporter confronted Maximum Bob with the news that GM's global reign was over, the well-paid and pensioned executive issued a terse response: “So what?”

And then Lutz, Wagoner and the rest of GM’s management went back to work, implementing a turnaround strategy devoid of stated targets or a deadline for a return to profit. If the definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again expecting a different result, then that's just plain nuts. 

By on April 28, 2007

In my early twenties, I went through jobs like a teenage girl trying on clothes at Abercrombie & Fitch: truck driver, actor, gardener, cook, bus driver, bicycle mechanic, painter. And that was just in the sales rack. My ADD extended to a seemingly endless succession of girlfriends. In fact, the only continuity in my life was my VW bug, a slow and steady anchor in those turbulent times. Read More >

By on April 26, 2007

07edgeccrossover.jpgIn 1997, Kiwi film director Lee Tamahori brought playwright David Mamet’s words to the silver screen in an Alec Baldwin/Anthony Hopkins vehicle called The Edge. Ten years later and David Mamet lensed an ad campaign for a crossover utility vehicle by the same name. Mamet’s trademark dialogue takes center stage, pitting the Blue Oval’s most important cute-ute against the upscale competition from Germany (BMW X5) for speed and Japan (Lexus RX350) for quietness. Does Mamet’s champion edge out its pricier rivals? Duh.

As the first ad’s fast-talking protagonists suggest, the Ford Edge is .2 seconds faster to 60mph than a BMW X5. And, as the same wisecracking thirty-somethings conclude in the second ad, internal Ford testing proved that the Edge’s interior is tighter lipped than the Lexus RX350.

True story? Not quite. In an echo of the Ford Fusion ads, where Car and Driver “helped” FoMoCo compare an all wheel-drive Fusion against a front wheel-drive Camry and Accord, The Glass House Gang has stacked the deck in their favor.

Mamet’s [not gay] guys could make their claim because the Ford vs. BMW drag race pitted the Edge SEL AWD– the optional four wheel-drive version– against BMW’s entry level all-wheel-drive 3.0si X5. In fact, the Edge AWD’s .2 second margin of victory is actually something of a coup for Germany; the least powerful X5 has 900 lbs. more SUV to lug and 25 ft.-lbs. less grunt with which to do it. 

As for quietness, listen closely. The ad’s characters say that the Edge is more silent than the Lexus in “a quiet test.” That’s “a” as in one test. While the Ford product has a lower decibel count at highway cruising speeds, the same can not be said about its NVH (Noise, Vibration and Harshness) during acceleration or stop starting around town.

To paraphrase the original P.T. cruiser, you can fool some of the people all of the time but not Art Spinella. The president of CNW Marketing Research argues that the ads will be extremely effective at getting consumers’ attention, but not generating sales. “Nobody goes out and buys a Ford thinking they’re getting a BMW”. Nor should they; which raises another problem.

Anybody remember Lincoln? Hello? Lincoln is supposed to be Dearborn’s Bimmer beater, not the blue-collared Blue Oval. Lincoln’s website lists both the Lexus RX and BMW X5 as the MKX’ direct competitors. Unfortunately, Lincoln’s badge engineered Edge adds extra luxury, a.k.a. weight. Bottom line: the X5 3.0is hits sixty from rest 0.3 seconds faster than the Lincoln. 

According to Barry Engle, GM of Ford Division marketing, they compared the Edge to the X5 because buyers typically trade in bigger buck whips for Ford’s CUV. That’s an encouraging sign for Ford, but disheartening for FoMoCo. Mamet’s marketing mavens seem the have forgotten basic economics. When the corporate mothership is struggling to keep its head above water, the higher profit, lower volume brand is a more appropriate flotation device.

Truth be told, FoMoCo needs to start banking bucks, fast. Yesterday’s first quarter results indicate that Mulally’s minions are getting closer to meeting their metrics, but they’re so far not out of the woods that they’re still deep in them.  

Through March ‘07, the Blue Oval’s bean counters pocketed some $400m in NorAm cost savings– and still posted losses of $614m. Optimistic analysts will cite Ford’s reductions in staff, improved revenues and the successful jettison of PAG pieces (namely Aston Martin) and ACH (Automotive Components Holdings).

Realists will notice North American operations scuttled $172m more than last year and that revenues are already down $1.6b (from $19.8b to $18.2b). And there’s still a multitude of moribund metal littering over 4000 U.S. Ford dealer lots.

The Fusion/Milan/MKZ triplets and cute-ute crossover twins continue to be hot items, but the rest of the metal is actually repelling costumers. Ford can now lay claim to having the oldest fleet in the biz. The Powers at J.D. report that only four percent of Ford owners traded in their old whips for something new from Dearborn. Translation: Ford is still losing almost half of their already shrunken client base. The world’s new number one automaker– and many others– are stealing Ford’s customers. 

Industry analysts predict Ford’s April’s sales to sink again from last year. They expect the Big 2.5 to be hit hardest.  Continued construction slowdowns are eroding truck sales quicker than California’s sedimentary cliffs.

By on April 26, 2007

060206-london-observations-2-thumb.jpgWarren Buffett, CEO of Berkshire Hathaway holding group, is the world’s second-richest human. Buffett’s no stranger to the transportation sector, having mopped up profits with Geico, Forest River (RV’s), McLane Company (foodstuff distribution) and the XTRA Corporation (semi-trailer renting and leasing). Berkshire Hathaway recently took a ten percent stake in the railroad company Burlington Northern Santa Fe Corp. Warren Buffett’s seen the future.

The future will have fewer trucks and a lot more rail carriages. Fewer people and goods will travel by road. Cars will be smaller and cleaner. People will use them less. Diminishing oil supplies and increasing demands upon this declining resource (especially with the explosive economic growth of fomerly third world countries like China) will make it so.

And if that doesn’t do it, concerns about global warming, clean air and healthy living will. In fact, a few years from now, anyone cranking up an internal combustion engine close to children will be hauled out of the car and forced to suck his own exhaust—and then plant a tree. OK, maybe I got a little carried away there, but you get the idea: The Energy Lean Age is here.

While Americans are just waking up to the enormous implications of this shift, their European counterparts have been living it for almost a decade. For a quick look at America’s future, let’s hop over to the capital of The Land of Hope and Glory.

In February 2003, London introduced a Congestion Charge for motorists entering the heart of the City. Currently, motorists entering the Congestion Zone must pre-pay an eight pound ($16) fee. If they forget, they’ve got to pay $20 before midnight on the following day. If they miss that deadline, but pay within two weeks, it’s a $50 fine. After that, it’s $200. Remember: this is PER DAY.

London is now looking to modify the charge to change the automotive mix. To that end, Mayor  Ken Livingtone’s administration is set to introduce ”Emissions Influenced Charging.” Cars entering the City which emit up to 120g/km CO2 will pay nothing. Cars emitting 121-225g/km CO2 will stump-up the current charge. Cars emitting more than 225g/km CO2 will fork over £25.

A Range Rover Sport entering London will cost its driver a staggering $50 a day. On the flip side, if your car is small and clean, you won’t have to pay for the privilege of using London’s roads (any more than you already do through petrol taxes). You’ll also get a Politburo-style fast-track through town during rush hour and special parking areas.

Other European cities and towns are contemplating similar moves. (As you’d imagine, Germany’s Green Party is all over this one.) Meanwhile and additionally, there’s a growing move towards emissions-based ”road pricing,” a pay-per-mile scheme that monitors driver behavior via a GPS tracking device or number plate recognition cameras. Since 2005, German trucks pay between €0.09 and €0.14 ($0.12 and $0.19) per kilometer depending on their emission levels and number of axles.

The road pricing debate is fierce; critics on the left attack it as a regressive tax, while critics on the right warn it will stifle economic growth. Even so, road pricing’s environmental component has given the concept a huge boost. It’s clear European governments are bound and determined to use dramatic (not to say drastic) measures to skew the automotive market towards smaller and more fuel efficient vehicles.

It seems highly unlikely that the widening rift between activist European governments pushing carmakers to go small and clean, and the American government’s relative tolerance for gas guzzlers, will remain forever. Whether it takes a cataclysmic economic shock, or a gradual increase in gasoline prices, or environmental concern/lobbying, the U.S. will eventually move more in line with the European model. And begin adopting European ”energy lean” solutions.

Meanwhile, Japanese and European-based automakers are busy building cars that conform to this political paradigm. You can also count on the Chinese accelerating production of the cars GM Car Czar Bob Lutz derided a few years ago, when he told the world that ”Rich people don’t care about the price of gasoline.”

Whenever Bob looks at a large car, he would do well to think of a spitoon. That’s how popular large cars with internal combustion engines will be a few years from now. And they’ll soon be just as gone as spitoons– unless they somehow manage to become Energy Lean and Air Clean large cars.

Which is why Warren Buffett’s moving his money to trains and evaluating other green energy alternatives, including electric cars. Trust me. Mr Buffett knows a sure bet. (He may even sell his shares in NetJets one day.) You better hope what’s in your garage is Energy Lean by then: the second hand value of voracious landcruisers will drop in inverse proportion to Berkshire Hathaway’s spectacular investment  history.   

By on April 25, 2007

astro.jpgIn 1996, the Toyota Camry was about to become America’s best-selling car. To protect the Taurus’ five year reign, Ford ramped up sales to Hertz Rental Car. The strategy worked– for a year. Despite the catastrophic effect on the Taurus’ resale value and image, despite selling off Hertz, Ford still relies on fleets to maintain economies of scale. As do the rest of The Big 2.5, who use fleet sales to mop up extra production, earn new money for old rope and blow out their sales stats. While Detroit knows fleet sales are slow motion suicide, their moves to curtail the practice are not as convincing as they could– or should– be.

That’s because the fleet market’s a double-edged sword. Again, fleet sales keep factories humming– plants whose restrictive union contracts make running them less expensive than not running them. Fleet sales also enhance cash flow and prop up quarterly numbers. On the other hand, selling hundreds of thousands of cars at or below cost throws retail residuals off a cliff, destroys the perceived value of a product and gives a false impression of how well both car and company are doing. 

Over the last few years, The Big 2.5 have all admitted the truth of that equation. They’ve publicly declared their intention to wean themselves off the “easy money.” GM claims they’ve trimmed their fleets sales over the last two years, walking it down by 11.2 percent. Although Ford and DaimlerChrysler have also promised to follow the same path, they haven’t. In that same two-year window, Ford’s rental sales have increased 12.3 percent. DCX’ fleet sales have climbed by a staggering 35.3 percent. And it’s getting worse.

From September 2006 to February 2007, Chrysler (division) offloaded 48.5 percent of its total sales to the fleets, while 32.1 percent of The Dodge Boys’ sales went to the same market. And even though GM overall has cut back on fleet sales, 44.9 percent of Pontiac’s and 29.6 percent of Chevrolet’s total sales ended up in fleets. Ford (the division) off-loaded fully one-third of their total sales to the fleets, with half of that number going to rental companies.

If you deduct fleet sales, Chrysler (division) sold just 147K vehicles over the last six months– which ain’t great but sure beats Pontiac’s 96K retail units. Subtracting fleet action, Chevy’s sales drop to 742K. The math also reveals that Ford (division) placed just 676K vehicles into retail customers’ hands. With this many vehicles still flowing into the fleet market, destined to reemerge at auctions, Chrysler, Pontiac, Chevrolet and Ford will have a tough time convincing retail customers to pay full whack for vehicles facing epic depreciation.

Detroit “gets it” but can’t quite “kick it.” For example, the Pontiac G6 (GM’s fourth best selling car) is now flooding the fleet market. According to Jim Hall, AutoPacific’s VP for industry analysis, GM is trying to replace the Chevrolet Malibu’s fleet sales with the G6. The goal: resuscitate the Malibu’s residual values ahead of the refreshed model’s launch. “You don’t want a brand new model to lose money in resale."

At the same time, Chrysler’s used the fleet market to divest itself of an embarrassment of 2007 Town & Country minivans and Sebrings, and disappear that pesky sales bank that attracted so much media and stockholder attention. But the mid- to long-term effect of Chrysler’s used car tsunami cannot be avoided, either by current Chrysler owners or the corporation itself. 

All that said, The Big 2.5 ARE, however haltingly, cutting back on fleet sales. And the imported and transplanted automakers are taking up the slack. Kia’s fleet sales are up 60 percent over last year (the Optima is proving especially popular with rental agencies). Nissan reports a 45 percent increase in its fleet sales, while Toyota’s contribution to airport rental lots and other fleet repositories is up by 30 percent. 

In case you’re thinking the newbies are headed for a fleet enema to rival The Big 2.5’s, Kia promises to restrict fleets sales to 12 to 15 percent of total ‘07 sales. Nissan won’t allot more than eight percent of its overall sales to fleets, with a maximum of 10 percent of any given model’s sales destined for that end. Toyota says they’ve never sold more than nine percent of total U.S. sales to fleets, and never will.

Flexible factories are the best way to solve The Big 2.5’s production vs. demand dilemma without the cost of shutting down hugely expensive assembly lines. Yet Detroit’s maddening bureaucracy, older plants and less-than-flexible workforce make implementing that approach… problematic. This leaves The Big 2.5 in a bad place: they’re damned if they do, and damned if they don’t. To paraphrase Oscar Wilde, when it comes to fleet sales, Detroit can resist anything except temptation.

By on April 24, 2007

rick_wagoner.jpg“Our goal has never been to sell the most cars in the world.” For those who’ve been following GM’s fall from grace, this statement– following the revelation that GM has ceded its "world’s largest automaker" title to Toyota– probably comes as no surprise. Or maybe it does, because it arrived via Toyota spokesman Paul Nolasco. Or maybe it doesn’t. Toyota achieved this monumental victory by focusing on a process that led to a goal; whereas GM has been all about the money, for quite some time. And therein lies the tale.

You don’t need to compare long and short term business plans to understand the difference between Toyota and General Motors; although if you did, GM’s recent inability to devise a coherent platform strategy or develop a world class economy car would certainly give you pause for thought. All you have to do is sit in a few cars.

You can argue that the relative quality of GM's interior plastics don’t make no never mind. You could say that a four-speed gearbox is plenty of cogs, given their robust engineering, adequate performance and reasonable mileage. You could prevaricate over pushrods or defend GM's value-for-money vis-a-vis the competition. You could conclude that there isn’t any significant, appreciable difference between a current Toyota and an equivalent GM product. Not now. Not anymore. And you’d be wrong.

Don’t take my word for it. In the first three months of this year, Toyota sold 2.348m vehicles. In the same period, GM sold 2.26 million vehicles. All of these buyers had a choice. They chose Toyota over GM because they believed the Toyota product was superior. Yes, “believed.” Even if the “real” difference between a Toyota and a GM product exists entirely in their minds, well, it's still a product-related reality.

Automaking is not the French Revolution. GM can’t simply tell car buyers to forget the past, history starts here. No wait, here. OK, here. Consumers remember their past experiences with an automaker’s products. Just as a carmaker can build a reputation with years of consistent quality and service, bad quality and lousy service can destroy it by the same process, only faster.

Which is just as it should be, and exactly what GM has done. After years of alienating customers with shoddy, non-competitive products and indifferent (or worse) treatment, they’re reaping what they’ve sown. It’s a perfect example of a free market in action, or, if you prefer, simple Darwinism.

Here in the world’s biggest automotive marketplace, GM has provided a textbook example of de-evolution. When I started the GM Death Watch in April ’05, the company had a quiver full of domestic products ready to counter all those lingering bad vibes and “progress” its turnaround.

Including badge engineered products, GM launched the Saturn Sky, Aura and Outlook; Pontiac G5, Torrent and Solstice; Buick Enclave and Lucerne; Chevrolet HHR, Hummer H3 and Cadillac DTS. They updated the Chevrolet Tahoe, Suburban and Silverado; GMC Yukon and Sierra; and Cadillac Escalade.

While some of these models have created a buzz in the U.S. market, none has generated the predicted, mission critical market share uplift, or a return to profitability. How could they? With an estimated 7123 dealers for eight brands selling 42 models, no one model can possibly make up for the dogs, or significantly elevate earnings.

Meanwhile, in the same time period, Toyota has launched two new models: the Yaris and the FJ Cruiser. They’ve updated the Camry, Avalon, Tundra, RAV-4 and Lexus IS, ES, GS and LS. Toyota has less on its plate, and so (arguably) makes it better and (inarguably) keeps it fresher.

Why wouldn’t they? With 2422 dealers for three brands selling 30 models, the company has the development money, marketing budget, healthy dealer network and low cost structure it needs to stay ahead of the pack.

Make no mistake: Toyota knows exactly what it’s doing. It will continue on its current trajectory until GM’s world domination is a distant memory. Not that The General’s destruction is their goal. As company spokesman Nolasco said, "We simply want to be the best in quality. After that, sales will take care of themselves."

The truth is GM has cleared a path for Toyota. GM blurred its once proud brands through botched badge engineering, and then tried to fix the problem by adding brands rather than retrenching. Its fate was sealed. Given that GM’s now wearing two straitjackets– one with a union label and one enshrined in U.S. dealer franchise law– it cannot escape the consequences of its arrogance and short-sightedness. All that’s left is the unraveling.

By on April 24, 2007

newepasticker.jpgThe Environmental Protection Agency’s current Federal Test Procedure (FTP) for city mileage was originally designed to represent a typical trip on Los Angeles streets. The test– codenamed FTP-72– begins with a cold start from 70 degrees. It then runs for 7.5 miles at an average of 19.6 mph, with a peak speed of 56.7 mph (from a short freeway segment). The EPA Highway Fuel Economy Test (HWFET) starts with a warm engine, runs for 10.26 miles, averages 48.3 mph, and peaks at around 60 mph. Does anyone in the real world drive like that?

Obviously not. By the ‘80’s, the EPA was deluged with complaints that its gas mileage estimates were entirely unrealistic (i.e. hopelessly optimistic). In 1984, the EPA reacted by lowering estimates across the board to “more accurately reflect driving styles and conditions.” The government agency trimmed EPA window sticker stats by 10 percent for the city, 22 percent for highway. This overdue amendment helped consumers feel more confident about calculating their fuel costs (and driving skills).

Thanks in part to the huge discrepancy between the EPA’s fuel economy estimates for hybrid-powered cars and their real world mileage, test procedures have been refined again.

For ’08 model vehicles, the EPA numbers will provide “in use” figures based on a combination of the old tests and new tests. The new procedures will incorporate faster speeds (up to 80mph), greater acceleration (up to eight mph per second), warmer outside operating temperature (including air conditioner use) and colder outside operating temperatures (including heater and defroster use).

The industry fully (and rightly) expects the new testing procedures to lower EPA “in use” mileage estimates even further, especially for hybrid drive cars like the Toyota Prius that benefit from “gentle driving” in the city cycle. Meanwhile, we can still glean some interesting information from the EPA stats.

Although it’s not well known, the EPA keeps two sets of books for public perusal. Pistonheads can scan both the government’s official EPA numbers for all cars certified for the U.S. and the raw test results. But wait; there’s more! The EPA also provides a given model’s engine displacement, engine revs in top gear, inertia weight (test weight for the EPA test) and dynamometer resistance settings.

University of Michigan physics Professor Marc Ross has developed formulas that can crunch the EPA’s dynamometer resistance readings to compute the amount of drag in pounds for speeds between 45 and 55 mph. Working with his equations, a math-minded motorist can predict a vehicle’s EPA gas mileage under a variety of test and non-test conditions. 

For example, the 2007 Avalon has inertia weight of 3875 lbs. At 50 mph, with its 3.5-liter engine turning at 1555 rpm, the Avalon generates 91 pounds of drag. Bottom line: the Avalon achieves 39.6 mpg on the HWFET test– as compared to 31 mpg on the window sticker.

The 2007 Five Hundred has a 4000 lbs. inertia weight. At 50 mph, with its 3.0-liter engine turning at 1520 RPM, the soon-to-be Taurus generates 105 pounds of drag. Bottom line: 37 mpg on the HWFET test– as compared to 29 mpg on the EPA window sticker.

Theoretically, the Five Hundred achieves 35.3 mpg at 55 mph, 30.4 mpg at 65 mph, and 22.6 mpg at 85 mph. The Avalon gets 36.2 mpg at 55 mph, 32.1 mpg at 65 mph, and 24.8 mpg at 85 mph.

The Avalon’s lower-profile aerodynamic shape and bigger engine make it more frugal than the Five Hundred. (Five Hundred owners pay a price for Ford’s decision to make the Volvo-based model tall and boxy to attract SUV buyers.) With its smaller engine, the Five Hundred is also slower than the Avalon– which has been slated for not being fast off the line. Both vehicles have tall gearing to aid fuel economy.

Toyota doesn’t use pixie dust or a magic carburetor to get better mileage than the Five Hundred. Toyota achieves better fuel efficiency because of the choices its creators made between looks, room, fuel economy, acceleration and drivability.

With revised EPA testing procedures leading to lowered fuel economy figures, with revised CAFE legislation mandating higher required fleet fuel efficiency averages, the pressure is on for automakers to produce more– and more popular– higher mileage vehicles. Only there’s a loophole.

According to the official EPA website, their new “in use” stats will “not affect the CAFE calculation for purposes of determining manufacturers’ compliance with the CAFE standard.” In other words, the new CAFE averages will continue to be based on the old EPA tests. Well how about that?

By on April 23, 2007

06_07_4runner_ltd2.jpgSo here we are, trying to convince American motorists to abandon their SUV’s for smaller, more fuel-efficient vehicles, to do their bit to reduce global warming and eliminate the need for messy military entanglements. And along comes a scientific study from a reputable independent organization that concludes that you’re safer in an SUV than a passenger car. Nuts.

You remember that debate, don’t you? Back before carbon dioxide was a planet killer, before hurricane Katrina sent the price of gas soaring, before the Iraq war got old, the anti-SUV crowd focused their attention on safety. They highlighted the “us vs. them” SUV vs. car death match, where the guy with the morally indefensible vehicle won the right to play again. Which was unfair but true. And still is.   

Last Thursday, the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) released the results of a study examining death rates for drivers of 2001 to 2004 model year vehicles involved in crashes from 2002 through 2005. The results were rated by deaths per million vehicle years (DMVY).

The IIHS’ separated the vehicles into eight categories: cars, sports, luxury, specialty, station wagons, minivans, SUV’s and pickup trucks. The “deaths by body style” stats were conclusive. According to the report, large and mid-sized 4WD vehicles (47 and 59 DMVY) are safer than cars classified as mini (148), small (103), midsize (71), large (81) and very large (61).

The IIHS report also listed the vehicles with the highest and lowest driver death rates. Of the 16 “worst” vehicles rated, cars occupied 12 slots, while SUV’s garnered four places on the list (a 75 / 25 percent split). Of the 15 “best” vehicles, five cars (33 percent), seven SUV’s (47 percent) and three minivans (20 percent) made the grade. 

That said, the IIHS study rated both small and very large SUV’s appreciably more deadly than mid-sized and large SUV’s. And there are as many ways to spin interpret the IIHS data as there are media outlets happy to avoid the logical, distinctly non-PC headline “SUV’s Safer than Cars.”

CBS News compared the "death rates in passenger vehicles with similar weight" and came to a different conclusion: "Cars Still Beat SUV's In Safety." The Detroit News report avoided any SUV vs. car comparisons. Reuters touted the Ford F-150’s huge safety gains. Consumer Reports focused on the importance of driver behavior, rather than vehicle design: 

“Care should be taken when evaluating this data because there are driver factors (such as demographics and region) that might greatly affect the fatality rates per model. We believe models that appeal to a more careful driver tend to have a lower fatality rate than those that attract a more risk-prone driver.”

While it's easy to understand how the Nissan 350Z made it on the IIHS black list, it’s hard to think of Kia drivers (Spectra fourth, Rio sixth) as “thrill seekers.” No, the simple, unavoidable, inconvenient truth is that both the pro and anti-SUV campaigners were right: physics rule the day.

Corroboration comes via the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s (NHSTA) 2005 crash stats. Measuring driver fatalities in all types of crashes, SUV's were 5.2 percent safer than passenger cars. And it’s no fluke. In 2003, SUV’s out-protected cars by 5.3 percent. In 2004, the figure climbed to 6.1 percent. In 2005, it rose to 6.6 percent.

Again, there are many ways to interpret the data. If you measure non-driver fatalities, or rollover crashes, the picture changes. But there’s plenty of evidence to confirm what common sense suggests. In 2005, SUV occupants were twice as safe as passenger car occupants in front, side and rear crashes. 

The safety gap is bound to widen. Thanks to rising gas prices and changing consumer tastes, inherently dangerous jumbo-sized SUV’s are either history (e.g. Ford Excursion) or fading fast (e.g. Chevrolet TrailBlazer). Buyers of full-sized SUV’s are migrating towards smaller, lower riding and safer car-based SUV’s (a.k.a. CUV’s). And NHTSA legislation mandating electronic stability control in all SUV’s will yield significant safety gains. 

None of this is good news for environmental campaigners, most of whom favor government intervention to “persuade” Americans drivers to exchange their SUV’s for small, frugal and more dangerous vehicles. Still, one should never underestimate the zealot’s power to surmount scientific results. If SUV’s were outlawed, there wouldn’t BE a safety gap. More people will die from global warming than small car crashes. Etc.

To a certain extent, the pro-conservation, anti-SUV crowd has already won this debate, as witnessed by the fact that so few media outlets are willing to raise the safety vs. fuel economy issue. Well, consider it raised.

[Click here for IIHS report or here for USA Today's simplified chart.]

Recent Comments

  • Lou_BC: @Carlson Fan – My ’68 has 2.75:1 rear end. It buries the speedo needle. It came stock with the...
  • theflyersfan: Inside the Chicago Loop and up Lakeshore Drive rivals any great city in the world. The beauty of the...
  • A Scientist: When I was a teenager in the mid 90’s you could have one of these rolling s-boxes for a case of...
  • Mike Beranek: You should expand your knowledge base, clearly it’s insufficient. The race isn’t in...
  • Mike Beranek: ^^THIS^^ Chicago is FOX’s whipping boy because it makes Illinois a progressive bastion in the...

New Car Research

Get a Free Dealer Quote

Who We Are

  • Adam Tonge
  • Bozi Tatarevic
  • Corey Lewis
  • Jo Borras
  • Mark Baruth
  • Ronnie Schreiber