Category: Editorials

By on April 21, 2007

They were both gorgeous, in that all-American wholesome, sexy, energetic way. Voluptuous, but athletic. Heartland traditional, but ready for a good time. Exhilarating and accelerative. And they were both mine to do with as I pleased. So why was I, a healthy young man, having a problem? Read More >

By on April 20, 2007

chevrolet-camaro-concept2.jpgWhen Car Czar Bob Lutz told the world that GM was putting the Zeta platform on hold, it was the second time the rear-wheel drive (RWD) program had been chopped. Two years ago, GM killed Zeta for being too pricey. Less than half a year later, the RWD program was resurrected; working with GM’s Holden division supposedly made it feasible. When Bob announced GM had second thoughts about its second thoughts, he blamed the double volte-face on government fuel economy and emissions legislation. In fact, there’s both less and more to this decision than meets the eye. 

First, understand this: the regulations in question have yet to be finalized, let alone codified. While politicians have discussed the possibility of increasing federal CAFE (Corporate Average Fuel Economy) standards, no changes have been made. And while the Supreme Court has ruled that the EPA (Environmental Protection Agency) can/should regulate carbon emissions, any such action must first go through a lengthy process of debate, drafting and implementation.

Bottom line: any GM carping about government interference is preemptive/speculative. And there’s nothing about the regulations that prohibits the development of fuel-efficient RWD cars through alternative propulsion, displacement-on-demand, turbo-diesels or any number of technological solutions. In fact, GM’s decision to kill Zeta may have less to do with government regulations than commercial realities.

On January 9, 2006, GM announced they were going to build a rear-wheel drive Camaro. The automaker took considerable heat for being late to the RWD party. The fifth-generation Ford Mustang had been on sale for over a year; the fifth-generation Camaro wouldn’t arrive until (model year) 2009. GM also announced the ’09 Chevrolet Impala would switch to the Zeta platform to take on the Chrysler 300 (which also arrived in ’05).

At first glance, the Mustang and 300 were worthy targets. But, as pundits warned at the time, the Mustang and 300 were niche products— big niches, but niches nonetheless. Their stellar sales success occurred within an untapped market with limited potential growth.

Recent sales data has vindicated the soothsayers. In the last two months, Mustang sales have dropped 15 percent. Year to date, 300 sales have tanked by 22.8 percent. Both market segments– rear-wheel drive gas guzzling nostalgia-mobiles and big-ass RWD American sedans– have cooled. There is little reason to believe that GM’s “new blood” will re-ignite sales.

Zeta’s crib death could well reflect the fact that it isn’t worth the cost to develop the RWD platform for the North American market– where it would have to be produced in much larger numbers at a much lower price-point than down under (where Holden lives). Holden is still getting the Zeta platform, and the Canadian-built RWD Camaro will debut as planned, but it looks like Zeta is an evolutionary dead end.

No matter what the reason, GM has spent a lot of money NOT to build a car. And the hit to their bottom line could well be ongoing. Changing plans for the next Impala pretty much force the next design to be a “refreshing” of a car that's hardly a world-beater. 

Replacements for the Impala et al will have to wait for plan L (or thereabouts). With development times as slow as GM’s, continuity has to be job one. GM hasn’t just lost a couple of cars– they’re back to square one in their single most important car class in their most important market.

Just before Bob’s Zeta obituary (officially it’s “on hold”), the company revealed the Beat, Trax and Groove micro-concept cars. The “triplets” were nice enough small car designs, but they were nothing but pretty skins. GM gives away very little to the competition in terms of styling. Their weak point is running gear.

If GM had revealed a new global platform and matching engine, which could have worn any of the skins shown (heck, they could build them all, haven’t they seen the Scion xA/xB?), THAT would have been a suitable replacement for the ill-fated Zeta platform. Instead they gave us an ageing Emperor wearing new clothes, riding a wooden horse. 

I’m not ripping GM for dumping RWD. The question of which wheels are driven isn't nearly as important as some pistonheads believe. Nor am I all that concerned about who's responsible for GM's expensive start – stop development process. The real problem is that Zeta’s demise leaves GM’s car cupboard looking distinctly bare for another three to four years.

In the short term, GM will serve-up the Pontiac G8, updated Cadillac CTS, hybrid Saturn Aura, new Chevrolet Malibu and Camaro, a couple of over-engined Buick variants and the inherently unprofitable Astra. It's not enough. The automaker needs some revolutionary/evolutionary new small and mid-sized cars. Unfortunately, they need them NOW. If Lutz and Co. took the wrong path three years ago, once again, GM is doomed to continue offering too little, too late. 

By on April 19, 2007

toyotatundradeliveries2.jpgIn a speech in Cape Town, South Africa, Robert F. Kennedy put a phrase into common usage by declaring "There is a Chinese curse which says, ‘May you live in interesting times.’" Lexicographers now say Kennedy made it up. But if it was true, you could argue that Toyota’s been cursed. While critics focus on the automaker’s recent experiences with recalls, leaked memos, NASCAR additives and misleading ads, pickup trucks are where things are starting to get scary.

Toyota’s new Tundra has been giving the automaker a rare case of the heebie-jeebies. Beancounters budgeted building the brand’s spanking new San Antonio truck plant at $850m. Due to last-minute changes and higher than expected material costs, the final tab ballooned to $1.28b. The executive who oversaw the cost overruns at the Tundra assembly plant, Hidehiko "T.J." Tajima, returned to Japan to assume Toyota's corporate social responsibility activities.

More worryingly (at least for a company as immensely profitable as Toyota), the San Antonio truck plant’s production schedule wasn’t in synch with their engine plant in Huntsville, Alabama. At the insistence of Toyota’s sales and marketing soothsayers, the first new Tundras to pop out of the cattle chute were supposed to contain 5.7-liter V-8 engines (so that the company could boast horsepower ratings that meet or beat the domestics’). But the big engine's production wasn't scheduled until mid-year.

For a company know for being as efficient as the Borg, this must have come as something as a rude surprise. Fortunately for Toyota, the engines were put into production in time.

Then The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration crash tested the new Tundra. The new vehicle only managed four stars in the frontal crash test. While not a bad rating per se, the Tundra’s domestic opposition– Ford F-150, Dodge Ram and GM Silverado– are all five-star rated. Again, it showed a chink in Toyota’s supposedly unassailable armor.

Most recently, Automotive News reported that Toyota flubbed the product mix coming out of San Antonio. Toyota had underestimated demand for the double cab and CrewMax, while overestimating demand for the lower-priced, standard cab base model. Consumer demand for Huntsville’s 5.7-liter V8 engine also outstripped supply. 

Toyota’s miffed model mix put them in the novel and unenviable position of having to offer rebates on a brand new model to move the metal. Just weeks after launch, pickup truck buyers could take advantage of incentives up to $1500 on the slow[er]-selling base Tundra.

"We didn't come to the prizefight with all our tools," admitted metaphor-mixing Ernest Bastien, Toyota's vice president of vehicle operations.

While domestic supporters may smirk at the new Tundra’s teething troubles, no one should mistake them for a lack of commitment. When Toyota first entered the U.S. market their products were not competitive. Rather than retreating, they learned from their mistakes and came back with better vehicles. Toyota is now arguably the world's premier mass market automaker and, soon, the largest as well.

In any case, the new Tundra is hardly DOA, or even “struggling.” In March, Toyota dealers unloaded 13,196 Tundras. Year-to-date, that’s a 12 percent increase over the old model’s numbers. Toyota predicts that new model sales will gather momentum in the summer, going on to achieve the planned 200k annual pace.

Toyota can offer such optimistic predictions with confidence because they are going to do whatever it takes to make it happen. Currently, Toyota offers Tundra buyers low interest financing, $1k trade-in assistance for early lease termination (on a previous generation Tundra) and $1-2k dealer cash incentives, depending on model. If that doesn’t work, more attractive offers will follow.

In other words, those who point at the Tundra incentives as a sign of weakness have got it exactly backwards. They are an indication of the automaker’s resolve to offer whatever financial lures are needed to hit its stated sales goal.

Lest we forget, The Big 2.5’s fortunes have descended to the point where they depend on pickup truck sales for their survival. For Toyota, a big deal is no big deal. Last year, the Japanese automaker’s U.S. sales rose 12.5 percent, helping generate a $13b profit.

This brings us back to the “interesting times” curse and the ToMoCo’s previously stated need to "manage Detroit's decline." If Toyota launches a major price war against the domestics’ high-profit pickups this summer, the damage to GM and/or Ford's profit margins could well be fatal. In that case, there could be some kind of anti-Toyota backlash from either the U.S. government or (worse) consumers.

Toyota knows this. As strange as it sounds, would they hang fire to protect the domestics? That die was cast when they built the San Antonio factory. 

By on April 19, 2007

tocmpcom.jpgIn a recent study of new vehicle owners, Ford products came second in "overall initial vehicle quality." According to Ford's PR release, Honda took the top slot, while Toyota and Nissan tied Ford for second (although Toyota actually beat Ford by three points). Yes, well, it turns out The Glass House Gang paid for the report, which mirrors the format of J.D. Power's Initial Quality Survey (IQS) without reproducing the results. Last year, JD's mob ranked Ford fifteenth in Initial Quality, one place beneath the industry average, nine places behind Honda and eleven places behind Toyota. Anyway, who cares?

Define quality. Is it design, durability, longevity, reliability, fit and finish, snob appeal, something else or a combination of these factors? How do you– or should I say "one"– calculate the relative importance of any particular attribute? Is reliability really the sine qua non of quality? Is longevity more important than fit and finish? Given the subjectivity of the term, it's virtually impossible to determine a vehicle's intrinsic "quality."

Back in the ‘70's, slipshod assembly, dubious dynamics and instant rust were the status quo. Any car good enough to win a quality award stood out from the crowd. Today's cars are the best-assembled, most defect-free, longest-lasting vehicles ever produced. Claiming a car rolling off one assembly line is higher quality than one coming off another assembly line is like claiming the Pacific Ocean will make you wetter than the Atlantic.

While pistonheads tend to fixate on minute differences between vehicles, the majority of the public are well aware that current mainstream motors offer roughly similar looks, performance, mileage, packaging, reliability and safety. Strictly speaking, Ford and other mass market automakers are selling mediocre products. To cut through the clutter and create a reason to buy one loaf of white bread over another, manufacturers use IQS studies to proclaim they're offering higher-quality mediocrity than the competition.

Quality is supposed to be a differentiator, something that shows that one item is superior to another in one or more aspects. The Ford-financed survey– and Detroit's continual harping about "the perception gap"– reflects the fact that many manufacturers don't get it. They're still stuck in the "Hey, give us a chance! We're just as good as the other guys now!" mentality. When the average person determines whether or not a vehicle is a quality product, they're not looking for "as good as." They're looking for "the best."

To achieve that, today's automakers must produce profound reliability AND sweat ALL the small stuff. Our reviewers have been continually criticized for continually criticizing the quality of a given car's plastic surfaces. Yet the look, feel, shape and smell of a vehicle's polymer's reveal a great deal about its overall quality. Just by prodding the dashboard, even a layman can tell if he or she's sitting in a beancounted beater or an upmarket luxobarge. Same goes for closing a door, or listening to the radio, or pressing the gas pedal.

Yes, it's a challenge to create the highest possible quality at a specific price point. But that's the challenge all automakers face. And in today's hyper-competitive automotive market, there's simply no margin for error. MINI's IQS scores took a beating when they introduced the car without cupholders. Many pundits asked, has it really come to this? Yes, it has.

Anyway, if automakers were truly interested in determining the quality of their products, they'd survey owners long after the new-car honeymoon had ended. They'd ask for feedback on reliability, fit and finish, repairs, out-of-pocket expenses, performance and how well the vehicle held up overall. If the buyer no longer owned the vehicle, they'd find out why their customer got rid of it.

After collecting several years' data, they'd know more about their vehicles' quality than any IQS would ever tell them. This information would be far more relevant to the consumer than knowing that car A averaged 0.043 fewer defects when new than car B. If a manufacturer came out on top of this kind of survey, they'd have something to brag about. And it would be interesting to see how their IQS ratings correlated to their "real world" results after a few years.

I have no idea why manufacturers haven't embarked on a project like this. The only reason I can think of: they don't want to take a beating from the reality stick. They'd rather go on blithely believing surveys that tell them their brand-new cars look, feel and act brand-new than watch their self-aggrandizement shrivel to nothing in the face of cold, hard data.

I know I'm tilting at windmills here. But it's high time the manufacturers stop hiding behind bogus quality ratings and start producing vehicles that are designed to be class leaders in every aspect. Then they wouldn't need contrived crutches like initial quality surveys. The product would sell itself and customers would be lining up for more.

By on April 18, 2007

wfbfcom.jpgYesterday, Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez did something unusual: backpedal. The South American Bush basher “clarified” his opposition to an agreement between the U.S. and Brazil to promote ethanol production. Chavez claimed he objected to the development of corn-based ethanol– not Brazilian sugar cane-based ethanol. Echoing last month’s interminable diatribe by Fidel Castro, Chavez condemned America’s energy policy, declaring that "taking corn away from people and the food chain to feed automobiles is a terrible thing."

According to Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva, it doesn’t matter which organic source you use for ethanol production. Speaking at a two-day South American energy summit, da Silva rejected any notion of a food–fuel conflict. "The problem of food in the world now is not [a] lack of production of food. It's a lack of income for people to buy food… No one is going to stop planting rice to plant biofuels."

Perhaps. But one thing is for sure: America’s newfound love for ethanol is creating some major political and economic side effects.

Here at home, U.S. farmers are planting corn like crazy. And why not? This year’s ethanol subsidies will easily eclipse the $6b Uncle Sam doled out in ‘06. This despite the fact that corn-based ethanol take a great deal of energy to produce– from petrochemical-based fertilizers and pesticides to processing plants hooked into their local electricity grid to gasoline powered tractors and delivery trucks. In fact, it takes a lot of old-fashioned energy to create ethanol, and millions upon millions of gallons of water.

In any case, the rapid increase in American ethanol production is having a worrying impact on America’s food supply. Even though the “ethanol boom” has swelled American cornfield acreage from 78 to 90 million acres, federal ethanol mandates are still driving up prices. With corn futurologists eyeing the six billion gallons of corn-based ethanol slated for production this year, the price of corn has risen dramatically.

The price of beef, pork, poultry, breakfast cereal, Coca-Cola and other corn-based products are set to rise accordingly. This situation is not about to get any better. In January, President Bush set a goal of 35 billion gallons of domestically-produced alternative fuels by 2017. While companies are spending billions to try to figure out how to produce fuel from cellulosic (plant) waste, corn is still king. If U.S. corn-based ethanol production doubles or triples, corn prices will skyrocket.

Or not. Ironically enough, at the same time that corn prices are rising, ethanol prices are declining. If the margins disappear, so will the “ethanol boom.” No wonder there’s already a federal tariff on imported sugar cane-based ethanol– which President da Silva is lobbying the Bush administration to abandon. Given the corn-growing states’ political influence in Washington, there’s not much chance of that happening anytime soon. 

Nor is there likely to be any change in the policy allowing automakers to calculate their E85-compatible vehicles’ mileage based on an entirely theoretical fuel economy (you try and find an E85 pump). Just as federal ethanol mandates inflate corn prices and distort the market, the E85 loophole inflates automakers’ CAFE (Corporate Average Fuel Economy) numbers and violates the spirit of the law. Oh, and supports the sale of gas guzzlers, which increases our dependence on foreign oil. Oh, and a Stanford University study published today suggests that increased ethanol use would harm the ozone layer. 

Meanwhile, American ethanol demand has diverted surplus (i.e. federally subsidized) corn from foreign export. The change is causing food price inflation as near as Mexico, and as far away as China and India. While you could argue that the U.S. doesn’t “owe” foreign countries a vast supply of cheap corn, the political fallout isn’t good. Castro’s theme– the Yankees care more about running their SUVs than feeding the poor– is no boon to U.S. foreign policy.

Ironically, America’s ethanol push is based on a desire to reduce U.S. dependence on foreign oil, to free the country from the necessity of undesirable political entanglements. American ethanol production could inadvertently alienate more of the world’s population than the war in Iraq.

In fact, the whole alternative fuels policy is full of such bizarre contradictions. Environmentalists who embraced biologically-derived ethanol as a “clean” alternative to carbon-based energy would do well to consider the enormous rainforest destruction caused by Brazil’s ethanol industry. The current rate of deforestation will have a more profound effect on greenhouse gasses than the planet’s vehicular emissions. 

The contradictions inherent in America’s ethanol production highlight the need for a comprehensive U.S. energy policy. If the U.S. is going to find a way to manage the political, environmental and economic implications of our energy production, delivery and consumption, we need to take a rational and independent look at ALL the alternatives– from Alaskan drilling to nuclear power to corn-based ethanol production. Otherwise, greed and hypocrisy will stymie any effort– however noble– to create any genuine change.

By on April 17, 2007

buickbombsiteorg2.jpgFifty years ago, GM’s engineers and designers worked overtime to create a radical new economy or “compact” car. Its mission: take on the VW Beetle and a host of European imports flooding the U.S. market. The 1960 Chevrolet Corvair flopped in its intended role. Nevertheless, it went on to become one of the single most influential American cars ever made. Its legacy can still be seen around the world.

The Chevrolet Corvair was a space efficient, low-slung compact with a six-cylinder air-cooled engine. The rear engine promised a low center of gravity, light unassisted steering, superb traction and balanced braking– all the same qualities that Porsche had been cultivating successfully for years. Budget-minded American driving enthusiasts were thrilled.

ralph.jpgUnfortunately, the design came with intrinsic liabilities: poor heating, a complex (read: expensive) alloy engine, oil leaks and distinctly un-American handling qualities (read: oversteer). It was the last quality that attracted the attention of a consumer crusader named Ralph Nader, who highlighted the Corvair in his seminal tome “Unsafe at any speed.”

The Corvair was not intrinsically unsafe. As long as owners maintained the eleven pound differential between its front (15/19lbs) and rear (26/30lbs) tires, the Corvair’s handling remained friendly and innocuous. But Americans were (and are) not known for monitoring their vehicle’s tire pressure. Gas station attendants of the time had a mantra: “24 pounds all around.” They became unwitting co-conspirators in the Corvair’s fall (spin) from grace.

calconnectcom22.jpgWith incorrect tire pressures, a rapidly cornering Corvair driver could easily find the vehicle’s back end heading towards the front. The average US driver was simply not prepared to handle that eventuality. Could GM have done more to avoid the oversteer stigma? Yes. GM saved six dollars per car by not making the front anti-sway bar standard. And who knows how much (little) the effective rear camber-compensating spring adopted in 1964 cost.

In 1972, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration issued a report exonerating the Corvair from Nader’s accusations. It arrived too late. Chevrolet had deep-sixed the Corvair seven years earlier. Even without the safety controversy, Chevy knew Ford’s highly conventional Falcon was about to eat their lunch. What’s more, GM’s beancounters had proclaimed that the Corvair was too expensive to make profitably (setting a pattern for small car thinking that continues to this day).

In the fall of 1959, Chevrolet was already cooking up Plan B: the 1962 Chevy II. Utterly conventional (and boring), the bigger Nova was the real anti-Falcon, and the route to compact-car profits. Which left a question: what to do with the Corvair?

hubcapcafe.jpgThe answer was the Corvair’s enduring U.S. legacy: the sporty Monza coupe. The model debuted at the 1960 New York Auto Show, complete with bucket seats, a higher output engine and a four-speed manual transmission. The Monza was an unexpected home run. In 1960, Chevy hastily assembled 14k Monzas. By 1961, the Monza dominated the Corvair line-up, and single-handedly created the market for popular-priced American-made performance cars.

But creating a market is not the same as exploiting it. Lee Iacocca’s seminal Mustang did that. Turbocharging and quad-carb induction couldn’t overcome the little six’s limitations against cheap V8 power. The Chevrolet Camaro was quickly pressed into action.

Meanwhile, the clean, elegant and highly-original 1960 Corvair initiated a styling revolution. In fact, it would be difficult to overstate the Corvair’s impact on European automotive design. Before the Monza, Europe was overdue for a new design lexicon. Even the conceptually-revolutionary 1959 Mini still wore the styling language of the early/mid fifties. The Corvair’s influence on subsequent European small and mid-size cars was unrivaled and unprecedented.

nsuprinz.jpgSome were blatant rip-offs: the NSU Prinz/1000, Hillman/Sunbeam Imp, Simca 1000, ZAZ-966, Panhard Dyna Coupe. Others were merely profoundly influenced: Fiat 1500, Lancia Fulvia, VW 1600 L Coupe (“the German Monza”) and a host of other early-mid sixties cars around the globe.

Yes, most of these models were narrower and taller than the Corvair. But the Corvair’s strong, high belt-line crease, its clean and inward curving lower flanks, airy green-house, under-cut front and strong rectilinear lines make its influence easily identifiable– even today.

Take a look a BMW 5-Series. That strong horizontal crease-line running unbroken from front to rear has long been BMW DNA, but it’s a genetic transplant from the Corvair. BMW’s renaissance (and styling DNA) is based on their mid-sixties sedans and coupes, including the popular 2002. Their design elements scream “Corvair”.

shoreynet2.jpgThe timelessly elegant, superb handling 1965 Chevrolet Corvair was built past the Camaro’s 1967 intro– just so General Motors would not be seen to be buckling-in to Nader and other detractors. But tightening emission and safety standards had sealed its fate; the Corvair died a quiet death in 1969.

Mustangs, Camaros, BMW’s. Not a bad legacy, for such a star-crossed little car.

By on April 17, 2007

njstateauctioncom.jpgEvery year over ten million vehicles pass through U.S. auto dealer auctions. This decades old free market has always been dependent on you, the consumer. Dealers will bid up those models that are popular with buyers, while those with a limited audience are stuck in what’s commonly called ‘wholesale heaven’. This is a place where thousands of unappreciated and unloved models go until the market dictates otherwise. Over the course of time, consumers dictates the winners… and the losers.

Over the last few years, The Big 2.5 have been downsizing their domestic production capacity to match falling demand, and compensate for their decision to wean themselves from low-profit fleet sales. Enormous assembly plants that once produced hundreds of thousands of new vehicles are now shuttered. The theory: as production sinks, new car prices will eventually hold firm and profits will follow. Unfortunately, the latest patchwork of new product has already come apart, and the domestics' market share continues its seemingly inexorable slide.

There are three main causes for today's used car glut. First, the manufacturers shut off the supply spigot late in the game. Thanks to restrictive union contracts and timid management, carmakers failed to ‘chase down’ falling demand early or aggressively enough. The failure created an ongoing surplus of used cars.

Second, again, The Big 2.5’s market share for new cars is still falling and they’re still failing to match supply to new car demand. Banking unsold inventory and embracing badge engineering has lead to hundreds of thousands of vehicles that consumers do not know or care about.

Finally, Toyota, Honda, and Hyundai have remained fiercely loyal to the idea of building brand identity and limiting supply when the market dictates. This devastates the profitability of the domestics, who are stuck with an over-sized dealer network and a “stack ‘em high and sell ‘em cheap” sales strategy.

This endless stream of unpopular and largely unknown new cars– and the sales incentives that inevitably follow– has created a significant benefit for the U.S. consumer: a depreciation curve that makes lightly used cars a fantastic deal.

In the early days of zero percent financing (late 2001), experts estimated that every $1k in new car sales incentives resulted in a $400 decline in the price of a two-year-old version of the same vehicle. By the time employee pricing came to the forefront (the following summer), the hit to used car prices was closer $600.

Many dealers peg the current depreciation rate at around $750 per $1000 in new car incentives. For your neighborhood used car dealer, their late model inventory now has a depreciation curve that’s nearly as steep as a new car vehicle’s. As a result, there are literally tens of thousands of unsold low mileage cars churning from dealership to dealership. 

The bottom line: a brand new Mazda Miata with all the options sells for around $27.5K. As of April the eleventh, the Average Auction Wholesale (AAW) on a 2006 Chrysler Crossfire with 3,945 miles was also $25k. Not that many consumers would cross-shop the two roadsters, but a Crossfire that stickered for over $45k a year ago now costs the same as a new Miata.

In the last 60 days, a savvy buyer could also pick up a low mileage 2005 Mercury Milan, Pontiac G6, Mercury Grand Marquis, Cadillac Catera, Buick LaCrosse, Ford Freestar or Volvo V50 for around the same money as a brand new, 2007 Kia Rio. That’s cheap.

You may notice these models are the unloved off-spring of over-stretched or neglected brands. The selection and price reflects a new reality: manufacturers have created a perfect storm of overproduction, fleet sales, model inflation (dozens of new nameplates debuting every year), limited marketing resources and bad branding. Though they’ve been available for years, models like the LaCrosse, Montego and Outlander are falling through the cracks, and into used car depreciation Hell.

Plenty of consumers “get it.” As vehicle reliability has increased, more people are buying used– but still not enough to outstrip supply. And yet still, the new cars keep coming.

Smaller new car dealers in larger metropolitan areas are getting whacked by these economics. For every Carmax, Team (formerly AutoNation) and Sonic Automotive Group that expands its operations, a dozen independent dealerships fall by the wayside. Never mind the mainstream manufacturers’ decisions to “rationalize” (i.e. cut) their dealer networks. The growing used car market is forcing hundreds of family-owned new car dealers to either accept competitor buyouts or simply close shop. 

For TTAC readers who understand that depreciation is the single largest cost of automobile ownership, or who simply want as much car for the money as they can afford, used cars rule.

As for what you should pay, go to the “completed items” section on Ebay and look for a car that’s roughly equivalent to the apple of your eye. You’ll find a price that’s usually a bit higher than wholesale, but lower than the inflated retail values you’ll find at Edmunds and Kelly’s Blue Book. There’s your starting point.

Call or email a few dealerships and bargain hard. You’ll soon see that the old 80/60 principle for a two-year-old model (80% of the life for 60% of the original selling price) is now closer to an 80/40 split. 

It’s proof positive that the free market has spoken. Until and unless mainstream manufacturers can better match supply to demand and learn to produce fewer, more distinctive models, their new cars will continue to make one to two-year-old models cheaper and better values. It’s a virtuous circle– for you.   

By on April 16, 2007

silverado07.jpgBeware the Ides of March! OK, relax. The sales figures are in for Julius Caesar’s final month. While it's hard to find new ways to say "GM, Ford and Chrysler sales are sinking while Toyota's eating their lunch" month after month, it's not impossible. How about this: The Big 2.5 look more and more like Lawrence Edward Grace Oates (to Toyota’s Roald Amundsen). “I am just downsizing and may be gone for some time.” Anyway, the more things change, the more they change the same.

Compared to last March, GM sales sank four percent, Ford’s plunged nine percent and Chrysler Group’s tumbled 4.6 percent. Overall, domestic vehicle sales were down 3.7 percent— against the backdrop of ToMoCo's 11.7 percent sales gain. Despite Toyota's seemingly unstoppable ascension (managing Detroit's decline is still job one), there were a few reasons to be cheerful.

Pre-divestiture Chrysler watched The Dodge Boys move 32 percent more Calibers than last year, proving that their macho SUV-lite has legs. Less explicably, Charger sales galloped ahead by 40.8 percent. And thanks to the runaway success of their new four door, Jeep Wrangler sales scrabbled ahead by 63.8 percent.

The Ford Fusion continues to gain traction; sales are up 47.5 percent over last year. Capitalizing on the small car surge, Chevy sold 53.1 percent more gas-sipping Aveos in March ‘07 than in March ‘06. At the other end of the CAFE spectrum, Expedition sales rose 27.8 percent while Suburban sales were up a gargantuan 73.3 percent.

March on March, import sales were up 17.5 percent. Mazda came in with the lion’s share; the Ford sub’s sales rose by 47.9 percent. Mitsubishi showed a healthy 22.3 percent increase. Stalwarts Toyota and Honda clocked 15.6 and 13.6 percent increases, respectively. It would’ve been an even more dramatic import victory if not for Scion (down 23 percent), VW (down 15.3 percent) and BMW (MINI tumbled 5.1 percent).

For the most part, inventory levels declined across the board. Only two Fords exceeded the magical 90-day supply mark: the Mark LT (101 days) and Montego (95 days). Chrysler has recovered from the sales bank fiasco; only low volume models (Viper, Crossfire, Sprinter) are languishing on lots. That’s aside from the 117-day supply of Jeep Compasses, up 11 days from February.

While GM averages an 86-day vehicle supply, GMC has a 149-day supply of Canyons and a 125-day supply of Sierras. Chevy dealers hold 102 day’s worth of Silverados and 101 day’s worth of Colorados. Saturn lots are clogged with 214 days’ worth of IONs and Pontiac dealers are feeling the Vibes for 129 days. Meanwhile…

The average Toyota had a 46-day shelf life. Nissans disappeared in 67 days. Even last month’s lot queen, the Mazda B-series truck dropped from a 229 to a 183-day supply. Once again, the Honda Fit led the pack with just 13-day's supply ready for sale.

In sales per dealer (SPD), Toyota once again topped the chart, up 39 sales to 175 SPD. Surprisingly, Ford averaged more SPD than Chevy (57 vs. 52). At 38 SPD, Dodge led the way for Chrysler Group. In contrast, Mercury dealers moved seven units apiece. Once again, Buick set the floor, averaging only six sales per dealer.

Three manufacturers saw full-size pickup sales increase from February to March: Ford (up 16.2K), Dodge (up 9.6K) and Toyota (up 3.5K). After a healthy jump from January to February, total sales of GM’s newly- launched GMT900 pickups decreased by 4.7K units in March.

Considering increased Sierra and Silverado inventory levels, and a sales decrease against its competitors’ increases, this could be an early indication of serious problems to come. Unless GMT900 pickup truck sales pick up or GM cuts production, we’re looking at a significant summer clearance sale. Any price reduction would likely be met in kind, leading to the beginning of the end for full-size pickup truck margins (as previously predicted here).

At the same time, domestic manufacturers have been slow to offer suitable alternatives to their larger and more profitable trucks. It may be too late to regain lost ground. In March, domestic light truck sales sank 4.8 percent while more economical imported light trucks rose 18.3 percent. GM’s small pickups—the Canyon and Colorado– fell by 14.6 and eight percent respectively. Toyota’s Tacoma is up 16.5 percent.

Taken as a whole, March’s sales figures indicate that the domestics are still struggling to stem the transplants’ ceaseless onslaught. The trend toward downsizing also continues, although perhaps not as radically as some have predicted. 

Next month, TTAC’s launching some new methodology. I’m trending sales for selected vehicles from The Big 2.5 and Toyota in four different categories: Passenger Cars, Full-sized Trucks, Truck-based SUVs, and Car-based CUVs. I’ll post graphs showing the comparative results along with data from the same time last year. This should give us greater insight into sales trends across brands and models.

By on April 15, 2007

black-ttac-mouse-pad2.jpgSomeday you’ll boast “I read TTAC before reading TTAC was cool.” Back when the website looked like a parked URL site. When reviewers had to pretend to be new car buyers. When the TTAC’s “take no prisoners” editorial stance was diss-missed as AWAKitude (Anyone With A Keyboard). Back before the site threw auto show Bacchanalia for its loyal readers paid for by firewalled advertising, branded merchandise and TTAC Buyer’s Club car sales. Rewind to now and you’ve got some work to do. Yes, you.

First, get off your literary ass. Your comments have demonstrated your ability to kill, crush and destroy misguided, misinformed and mentally misaligned malcontents. As Rafiki would say, it is time– to move your passionate intellectual insights from our award winning comments section (if there was such a thing) onto TTAC’s editorial pages.

TTAC now publishes some ten 800-word articles per week: seven rants and three reviews. Our site stats indicate that you read most everything we publish. Don’t you know it’s karmically dangerous to snipe at our work without once putting YOUR fully-fledged ideas about the automotive industry in the cybernetic cross-hairs? Email Managing Editor frank.williams@thetruthaboutcars.com for TTAC's Writers' Guidelines.

Write a rant. Start by turning your “WTF were YOU thinking?” comment into a fully-fledged rip-post. Or write about something that’s been pissing you off since Wheels were Hot. Contrary to popular belief, there is no TTAC “party line.” Want to start a GM Recovery Journal? Game on. Think Greens are a bunch of hypocritical proto-fascists? Tell the world. Consider global warming a more dangerous threat than the Mustang GT500? Just check the topic with Frank (for duplication and libel), and then let loose the canines of conflict.

I know: you’re not a professional writer. No sweat; your passion is enough. All but a handful of our scribes are gainfully employed doing other things. Ask the guys and gals who pour their heart and soul into their work for this site: I’m a kick ass editor. If you can write something halfway decent, I’ll Hunter S. Hemingway your text until it goes from zero to apoplexy in one paragraph. And you have the right of final approval.

Next, buy some TTAC swag. Remember those stupid rock and roll T-shirts you bought, feeding the band’s cocaine habit just to prove how hip you were to total strangers? Well it’s time feed our writers’ beer budget just to prove how hip you are to total strangers. The TTAC logo may look a bit like a prison tat, but the motto kicks ass. Show me another license plate frame that flaunts your knowledge of a dead language (hint: “the truth conquers all”), refers people to a way cool website and doesn’t advertise some skanky car dealer.

TTAC T’s are excellent quality and so not gaudy. The TTAC mug tells the world you’re no mug. The mouse pad asks the rats what they’re made of. Yes it’s expensive stuff. But TTAC can’t lose on the deal (no inventory costs), we make a few bucks per purchase and you’re not that pimply-faced teenager who depended on his/her parent’s largesse to make a bold counter-cultural statement. And if you can think of another deeply desirable item we should be selling, share it with the group below. (Check back on our selection from time to time.) 

Speaking of sharing with the group, you’re an automotive alpha. Friends, family, co-workers and bored strangers on flanking bar stools depend on you for car buying advice. Eventually, we’ll have all the info they need to buy a car. Eventually, you can hook them up with an independent car broker through the TTAC Buyer’s Club. Meanwhile, email a link.

In fact, anytime you read something on TTAC that makes you eject coffee out your nose, email the TTAC link. By the same token, anytime you read a review or rant that makes you wonder what ignorant mind could assemble such fetid tripe, email the TTAC link. And anytime you leave your cubicle to go to the can, come back and email a TTAC link.

In the last five years, TTAC’s explored strange new viewpoints. We’ve sought out controversial ideas and sacrificed sacred cows. We’ve boldly gone where Edmunds, Car and Driver and The Detroit News have never gone before. Now it’s your turn. Write for us. Buy from us. And tell the world that TTAC is here. Tell them we’re hungry for the truth.

The bard said small curs may not be regarded when they grin; but great men tremble when the lion roars. I say I'd rather face a single lion than a really determined pack of curs. Anyway, you do your part to increase our ferocity and we’ll do ours. Fair enough?

By on April 14, 2007

On a sunny February morning I left my family behind, hitchhiking west out of Baltimore. By Ohio I was barreling through a night-time blizzard in the cab of a semi. I reached Iowa the following morning. It was ten degrees; I needed to stop and warm up. California would have to wait. Read More >

By on April 13, 2007

tesla2.jpgWord, Excel, Acrobat Reader, Photoshop, Powerpoint… The computer programs you depend on are filled with bloat: unused features that hog your hard disk, crowd the CPU and drain your laptop’s battery– without adding to the action on the screen. Ditto SUVs. They are extraordinarily capable vehicles whose unused features guzzle gas, add weight and drain oil from the ground. In both cases, slimming down has few downsides– save the psychological. And therein lies the tale. 

Just as there’s a cadre of computer users who know how to pip a file in CP/M, there’s a small slice of SUV/CUV/pickup owners who use their vehicles to their fullest. Clearly, obviously, most don’t. Instead they defend their vehicular choices by citing seldom-seen scenarios: towing equipment they don’t own, forging through storms they know they’ll avoid, and surviving crashes that have yet to occur.

Thankfully, drivers are wising up. Whether their change of heart’s been stimulated by the rising price of gas or environmental consciousness, they’re figuring out that sitting on several tons of metal to move a couple of humans from points A to B is silly. That’s why they’re looking for alternatives. Which is also why I’m disappointed with the Tesla Roadster.

In a world crying out for energy efficient transportation solutions, Tesla’s battery-powered sports car is a dead end. The Tesla is a toy that tries to combine the benefits of megapowered supercars with a warm ecofriendly buzz. This does not compute. The future of automobiles (self-movers) is energy-lean and speed-restrictive.

To perform adequately, all current electric vehicles (EVs) rely upon a light-weight frame. By using a featherweight Lotus as a donor and reducing its heft with carbon fiber, the Tesla Roadster attempts to maximize speed, acceleration and range. Even with no luggage or extra passenger space, it still illustrates the old saying, ”Fast, good and cheap. You can’t have all three.”

At the same time, the Roadster’s mass x velocity function makes the EV a pretty dangerous place to be should you experience sudden, involuntary deceleration (think early 1960s Formula 1 racer). Yes, Tesla is trying to work around those "challenges.” But the end result won’t change: a ludicrously expensive (if fast) EV with serious range and safety issues.

Maybe the work on the Tesla Roadster can create spin-off benefits for more energy efficient EVs. Tesla is already shopping their batteries around to other EV manufacturers (probably looking to share their high development costs). If that makes you think the future is filled with EVs zipping around silently at Roadster speeds, you can banish the thought.

There are far better ways of using stored energy than driving Hell for leather in a lithium-ion equipped Tesla Roadster powered by a consumer electric grid.

The other day the French pushed a TGV (a.k.a. bullet train) to 574 km/h (357 mph). I heard the news about the French train speed record while automobiling (self-moving) behind a tram. A poster on the rear of the tram said ”I can replace 1.5 km of cars.” We can fight for unrestricted travel as much as we want, but our assumed right to be part of that 1.5 km long line is about to be seriously restricted.

If nothing else, global warming is a political reality. Most automobile companies realize that the legislative move to reduce cars’ carbon footprint will have– is already having– a dramatic impact on what we drive, how we drive, and where we will be allowed to drive it. As the French prepare to cover Europe with TGVs, and the European Union considers legislation imposing mandatory carbon offsets for air travelers, it’s naive to believe that cars will continue to represent untrammeled freedom.

A period is coming where self-moving will again be considered a privilege, not a right. Where the cost of self-moving will have to be paid for on the spot, as a function of energy efficiency and estimated long term environmental impact. Available energy will be channeled to where it will deliver the most work per unit. You’ll be charged accordingly for less efficient energy use.

In other words, the days when you paid Southwest Airlines or Ryan Air prices to move will soon be a thing of the past. Which only makes sense. The party's over. We’re running out of oil. Both society and the individuals enjoying its protection must wake up to the throbbing skull reality of this situation, and face a new dawn.

Despite California Governor Schwarzenegger's pronouncement that "We don't have to take away the Hummers or the SUVs or anything like this," there is no Tesla-like cake-and-eat-it-too solution. Developing technology won't let you drive a fundamentally inefficient vehicle the same way you do now using alternative propulsion. Everyone in the energy food chain– from energy producers to daily commuters– must take on the challenge of using energy with the skill of rocket scientists, accounting for every calorie. The end result will be spectacular, and effective.

By on April 12, 2007

compass.jpgOnce upon a time, a loafer-wearing businessman buried the front end of his rented Oldsmobile in a dune on the barren southwestern point of Galveston Island. I retrieved my Jeep Liberty and drove it to the Olds across a sea of tidal dunes carved into the coast like three foot swells; the Liberty loped from crest to crest in a spray of sand. Within minutes, I dug out enough of the Olds’ front bumper to affix a strap and pull the trapped car onto smooth packed beach. So how does this Jeep lover rate the prospects for the new 2008 Jeep Liberty? D.O.A.

Codenamed KJ, the current Jeep Liberty came to market in 2001 as an ‘02 model. In the U.S., its introduction overlapped production of the ancient, outgoing Jeep Cherokee by about six months. It was a sensible move; dual production kept the assembly lines running and assured the new Liberty a soft launch to major league success. The Liberty has been America’s best selling compact SUV since 2005.

The redesigned 2008 Liberty, code named KK, will roll off the assembly line this fall. Looking to revive the Cherokee’s now legendary styling, the KK is shaped like a brick on wheels. Aficionados have dubbed the new Liberty a mini-Commander (Lieutenant Commander?). In case you’re wondering, that’s about as far from a compliment as a Jeep lover can get without dropping the F-bomb. The Commander, an unmitigated sales disaster, is being quietly dropped from Jeep’s multi-model roster.

But questionable looks aren’t the only reason why the Liberty’s segment-leading success will soon be over. The new Liberty is destined to be a dud because the existing Patriot and four-door Wrangler Unlimited will cannibalize its sales.

To test my suspicions I turned to L.O.S.T. (Liberty Owners Special Team). Most of this club and web forum’s members are apex users; they modify their cute-faced grocery-getter with lift kits and larger, knobbier tires and take them to places that SUV critics say SUV owners never go. The members’ antics prove that the current Liberty’s solid frame, low gear transfer case and stout-hearted rock crawlin’ engine make it a “real” Jeep.  

Granted, this hardcore owner group’s behavior doesn’t represent the mainstream suburban Liberty owner. But L.O.S.T. members are living the dream that draws all of the lifestyle wannabes to the brand.  I submit that their leading-edge opinion is a good bellwether of the platform’s future. So I polled their website’s visitors about the new Liberty’s place within Jeep’s lineup.

Although the survey was unscientific and the sample population small, the results were decisive. By a factor of two to one, L.O.S.T. members said they prefer the new four-door Wrangler Unlimited over the forthcoming KK Liberty (62% Wrangler, 29% Liberty).

No surprise there. Most of these owners purchased their Liberty because it’s the best compromise between off-roader and family taxi. Now that the Jeep Wrangler’s ride has been greatly improved and can plausibly seat four passengers, it can pull double duty. And so it will.

Again, most Liberty owners are not mud-plugging militants with dirt, grease and blood under their fingertips. The model’s sold to well manicured urban and suburbanites seduced by the Jeep’s round-eyed headlights and smiling bumper; buyers so smitten by the Liberty’s cuteness that they ignore the harsh ride, heavyweight handling, cramped quarters and horrendous gas mileage.

Those days– and sales– are numbered. The new Lego-shaped Liberty has the cuteness quotient of a shoebox. Of course, such stylistic determinations are subjective. But beholders with an eye for sassy will more likely find Jeep’s own Patriot or even [dare I say it] Compass more suitably adorable. Furthermore, the non-jeep Jeep twins are less expensive and more fuel-efficient. They’re better “cars.”

And consider this: Jeep now sells seven models in the U.S. The situation is so confusing that the brand’s American website has a widget to help a Jeep buyer “find the vehicle that best matches your needs by selecting your preferences from the filters below: Price Range, Seating Capacity, Towing Capacity.” Select the $20k to $30k price range from the drop-down menu and… all seven models remain highlighted.

Put another way, a customer with $25K burning a hole in their pocket can purchase a Patriot Limited AWD, Liberty Limited, Grand Cherokee Laredo or Wrangler X. How’s THAT for model overlap and price point confusion?

Jeep is generally regarded as the Pentastar’s crown jewel, the one brand that’s survived its German owners’ neglect and mismanagement relatively unscathed. As the Commander and new Liberty prove/highlight, DCX has somehow found a way to kill the golden goose. They’ve diluted the brand’s carefully crafted off-road image while failing to produce a credible competitor to Toyota’s RAV4 or Honda’s CR-V. If anyone wonders why Chrysler’s on life support, well, there’s your answer.

By on April 12, 2007

g5.jpg"It was at the point where if you extrapolated that trend line out, you could see where that trend line hit the ground.” No, GM Car Czar “Maximum” Bob Lutz wasn’t referring to his employer or a bad flight in his L39 Albatros combat jet. Maximum Bob was reflecting on his infamous “damaged brand” assessment of Buick and Pontiac at the ’05 New York auto show. So how’s tricks? "They're still not where we'd like them to be,” Lutz told the Detroit Free Press, “but the vital signs have at least turned up.” In other words, they’ve gone from flatline to comatose. Nice one Bob.

In the last two years, GM has unleashed (if that’s the right word) a slew of models designed to defibrillate Buick and Pontiac. GM’s former “excitement” division unveiled the badge engineered Torrent SUV and G5 coupe, the Oprah-glorifying G6 (sedan, coupe and convertible) and the “My kingdom for a trunk” Pontiac Solstice. Buick attempted to find a pulse with the Lacrosse, Lucerne and Enclave.

When the Free Press pressed Lutz on the results of this product push, Lutz admitted that both brands have seen sales declines and trotted out GM’s excuse du jour: “cuts in rental fleet business.” Maximum Bob then insisted that Buick’s and Pontiac’s new models have helped both brands “gain traction.” Huh?

Once again, Lutz is flying blind. Comparing ’05 to ’06, Buick’s total production numbers sank 7.6 percent. In the same period, Pontiac production slipped 6.7 percent. In the first quarter of this year, Buick sales are down 30.3 percent. Pontiac’s first quarter sales have faltered 6.7 percent. If these brands are gaining traction, it’s in a distinctly backwards direction.

So, where do Buick and Pontiac go from here? Since he first assumed control over the GM Empire’s product plans, Maximum Bob has touted “fun to drive” rear-wheel drive cars as The Second Coming of General Motors. Although only one of Buick and Pontiac’s last seven models is RWD (the Solstice), each brand was due to receive a brand new RWD model– until Tuesday.  

That’s the day The Chicago Tribune reported that GM has suspended development of its RWD automobiles. "We've pushed the pause button,” Maximum Bob told journos. “It's no longer full speed ahead." MB’s mixed metaphors highlight General Motors’ abject inability to stay ahead of the product curve, or, if you prefer, get its shit together.

Maximum Bob revealed that the decision to stick with front-wheel drive (FWD) vehicles stems from proposed federal legislation that would mandate a 30 percent increase in automotive fuel efficiency by 2017. According to Lutz, "We don't know how to get 30 percent better mileage from rear-wheel drive cars.” Which raises two questions: why not and this is news?

Instead of leaving it at that and heading home in his G5 (jet, not Pontiac), Maximum Bob trotted out the same old foot dragging arguments GM's used since the federal government first got in the CAFE business: consumer expense and "you're killing me!" Without citing any internal or external studies, Lutz claimed the new regs will cost GM an additional $5k per vehicle, which they’ll have to pass on to the consumer. This, of course, is a bad thing.

"Rather than buy new, people would hang onto their old cars,” Lutz warned. “We could eat the five thousand dollars, but that would put us out of business."

I won’t bother you with Maximum Bob’s ensuing remarks about CAFE credits and global warming, which were about as factually accurate and politically correct as Don Imus’ summation of the Rutgers women’s basketball team’s hairstyles and freelance income. Suffice it to say, Lutz said GM has postponed its final decision on whether or not to completely abandon RWD cars until the U.S. government legislates CO2 emissions and revises CAFE regulations.

The implications of Maximum Bob’s remarks beggar belief: the world’s largest automaker, a vast commercial enterprise that’s hemorrhaging both money and market share, is taking a “wait and see” approach to new product development. Privately, the new product line managers for Buick and Pontiac (and Chevrolet, Hummer, Saab, Saturn, Cadillac and GMC) must be shaking their heads in dismay, if not despair.

Now you could say that GM’s decision to kill– sorry “pause”– its RWD program is the right thing to do. You could also argue that continuing down the wrong road is almost as stupid as choosing the wrong road in the first place. And you’d almost be right.

The truth is GM’s Board of Bystanders pays the automaker’s executive leadership tens of millions of dollars to make, at most, five critical decisions per year. If their Car Czar got this one wrong– moving towards RWD “fun” over front-wheel drive frugality– what else have they screwed up? I could give you a list. For now, I’ll just say this: the worst is yet to come.

By on April 11, 2007

2006-stccestate.jpgTime and time again, automakers flush with cash decide to grow their business by expanding their model lineup. Which is a bit like trying to improve a gourmet meal by adding more menu choices. That’s not to say brand extensions can’t be done, and done well. Volvo’s XC SUV’s were a logical and successful addition to the company’s safety-themed vehicles. But a performance tuned Volvo station wagon or sedan? Uh, no. At long last, the company has reached the same conclusion— for all the wrong reasons.

Automotive News (AN) confirms that the 2007 R-Series Volvos will be the last of the breed; Volvo’s dropping performance variants from its roster. According to Volvo NA’s executive vice president of sales and retail ops, continuing to spend money on R model development, marketing and sales doesn’t make financial sense. “For the return we get,” Doug Speck told AN, “It just wasn't good enough."

Ya think? When Volvo launched the “R” sub-brand, the company estimated that 2500 examples would find buyers in the North American market on a yearly basis, helping to deliver 7k sales worldwide. Scanning AN's account of the R sub-brand's cancellation, it's clear Volvo’s been busy re-writing history downsizing their R-badged expectations. Volvo claimed it built the business case for the barking mad R-Series based on total annual sales of 3800 units. In any case, the automaker fell well short of the marque.

Last year, Ford’s Swedish subsidiary shifted just 1098 S60Rs and 538 V70Rs. As today’s V70R review indicates, there isn’t much wrong with the product itself. The problem is that “performance” and “Volvo” go together like “Porsche” and “towing capacity.” Oh wait, the Cayenne. Yes, well, the point remains the same: even great products can’t surmount a brand’s inherent limitations. At least not for long.

As Al Reis and Jack Trout wrote in their classic marketing tome “Positioning,” “the mind rejects new information that doesn’t ‘compute.’ It accepts only that new information which matches its current state of mind. It filters out everything else.” For a brand positioned in the consumer’s mind as “the ultimate driving machine,” an M-tuned 3-Series makes perfect sense. For a brand best known for protecting your family from death, a V70R is an anomaly, a cynical and forgettable joke.

While I’m delighted that there were 1098 perverted pistonheads who “got it,” it’s deeply worrying that it took Volvo’s marketing mavens 12 years– from the launch of the bright yellow T-5R wagon in 1995 to this week– to understand that building a high performance Volvo (not to mention racing it) was the branding equivalent of wearing a speedo to a PTA meeting.

Equally worrying: Ford’s hard-nosed beancounters– rather than Volvo’s executive stewards– killed the R division. In fact, Volvo CEO Redrik Arptold told AN that his employer isn’t abandoning the afterburner-oriented enthusiast market. They’re simply “deleting the moniker.” For evidence that Volvo is still interested in “fun-to-drive cars,” Arptold misdirected the reporter’s attention to the forthcoming C30 hatchback and S80 V8. "We are working on the next phase,” Arptold said, “but it will not be immediate."

Fans of the Volvo’s corporate mothership can only hope. Although Mazda’s Zoom-Zoom campaign and “fun-to-drive” products are successfully transforming the Japanese automaker’s economy car image, Volvo and Land Rover are Ford’s only truly coherent car brands. Ford is everything and nothing, Lincoln is everything and nothing with extra chrome, Mercury is nothing and Jaguar was something (and now isn’t). With environmental consciousness hemming in Land Rover, Volvo is the company’s best hope.  

While there will always be pistonheads up for accelerative and handling hotness, no one wants to die. Truth to tell, the only vehicle category that doesn’t jibe with Volvo’s built-in brand promise to preserve your genetics is… sports cars. Which means Volvo’s growth potential is virtually unlimited– provided they put this R business behind them and keep their eye on the Nerf ball. If Volvo continues to devote every possible resource, every last krona, to maintaining the company’s lead in passenger car safety, they will thrive.

So Redrik, where’s the Volvo minivan? When Ford ditched their Freestar (Windstar? Deathstar?), I felt sure they were clearing they way for a Volvo minivan, a machine that would easily conquer all before it. I mean, what Mom wouldn’t buy a Volvo minivan? Ford Flex? Yeah right. And yet Volvo’s boss is pleading with the world not to slip back into the “old” idea of boring Volvos. Because? Honestly, I don’t have a clue.

If Volvo plays its cards right, it could replace Ford. Seriously. When Ford and its amorphous product line goes belly-up, the conglomerate is free to sell– or not sell– anything they like. Which brand has more oomph in Ford’s portfolio (if not at the driven wheels) than Volvo? None.

By on April 10, 2007

tribbles2.jpgAt last week's DaimlerChrysler stockholder meeting, a man named Ekkehard Wenger stepped up to the microphone and said his piece. "For nine years you have been sitting on this scrapheap called Chrysler. Nobody has learned anything. To call this a sale is a euphemism. If you pay for the garbage man to empty the dustbin, does that mean you have sold something to the garbage man?" While calling Chrysler a "scrapheap" is a bit harsh– the American automaker supported Mercedes for several years when the Germans were losing money– one wonders how Kirk Kerkorian feels about being called a garbage man.

Captain Kirk surprised quite a few people last week. The incipient nonagenarian beamed down the only private bid for Chrysler thus far: $4.5b, with $100m in cash up front in return for exclusive bidding rights. Kirk's play marks his second attempt to take over Chrysler; a sequel to his ‘95 "I'm with Lee" (Iacocca) tour. While that financial foray failed, Kirk became Chrysler's largest stockholder. He secured a place at the board room table for his beancounter extraordinaire Jerry York. 

In 1998, Daimler-Benz acquired Chrysler. Despite a financial bonanza, Kerkorian expressed his displeasure with the so-called "merger of equals" as billionaires are wont to do: he sued DaimlerChrysler for $2b. Kerkorian claimed Daimler-Benz had deceived investors, misrepresenting a corporate takeover as a partnership. He lost the lawsuit, appealed and lost again.  

Kerkorian expressed his displeasure as billionaires are wont to do: he tried to take over General Motors. After buying huge quantities of GM stock, Kirk secured a place at the board room table for his beancounter extraordinaire Jerry York. When GM rebuffed Kerkorian/York's plans for reform and rejected a suggestion to merge with Renault-Nissan, the Lion of Las Vegas cashed in his chips, sent Jerry home and called it a day. 

Spying Chrysler's upcoming dissolution, Kerkorian is hoping the third time's a charm.  In carefully worded letters from his pet Yorkie to CEO Dieter Zetsche and the DCX Supervisory board, Kerkorian outlined his USP (Unique Selling Point). If they'll deliver Chrysler unto Kirk he'll offer the UAW and Chrysler's senior management "the opportunity to participate… as equity partners in the transaction." 

In a statement released last Friday, Tracinda Corporation (Kerkorian's corporate front) described a Kerkorian-controlled Chrysler where "all the parties share equitably — with no one group (including ourselves) trying to gain an unfair advantage over the others." 

For their part, the Germans are understandably leery of Kirk's intentions. Lest we forget, just three short years ago, Mr. Kerkorian was dragging DCX to court to answer fraud charges, which cost DCX tens of millions of US dollars in legal fees. 

Given Kerkorian's "strip and flip" history with other acquisitions, the United Auto Workers (UAW) is suspicious that Kirk's ode to consensus masks the man's intention to slice the company to ribbons. UAW Local 7 president Dale Hunt asked, "What changed his mind from breaking it up to wanting to keep it together, and now all of a sudden he wants to get involved with the union?" 

Maybe it's got something to do with DCX' assertion that they won't sell to someone just because their bid was worth a few extra dollars. (As if.) The Germans have dictated that two other considerations must be addressed by bidders: preserving workers' benefits and ensuring Chrysler's long-term health. 

That's gonna be a bitch. Chrysler's new master will inherit almost $17b in healthcare liabilities. Kerkorian and Co. are trying to resolve the issue by asking the UAW for healthcare concessions in return for [a purported] 10 percent equity stake in the company, plus a seat on the board.  

Or not. UAW President Ron Gettelfinger vehemently denies participating in any discussions with Kirk's mob.  Last Friday, in an interview with Detroit radio host Paul W. Smith, Big Ron stated, "I've had no discussions with anybody from Tracinda, and I don't recall anyone in our organization talking to them. We've had no discussions in this regard." 

If Kerkorian wants to pull off this deal, he'll have to mend fences with Big Ron's constituency- and fast. Every Chrysler bid is likely to include provisions for UAW concessions. If Captain Kirk wants his money to rule the day, he needs more than a promise to give the UAW an equity stake. As always, a procession of armored cars stuffed with cold hard cash should do the trick. 

Additionally, Jerry York had better start putting in a lot of overtime kissing ass on the DCX board.  With a ten year history of animosity to overcome, Tracinda's main men may be about to learn the meaning of an old military expression: "Don't shit in your own mess kit." 

Neither DCX nor the UAW have shown any interest in Kerkorian's offer.  With competition including one of Chrysler's biggest suppliers (Magna) and a former Chrysler COO (Cerberus' latest hire, Wolfgang Bernhard) this looks like strike three. 

Recent Comments

  • Lou_BC: @Carlson Fan – My ’68 has 2.75:1 rear end. It buries the speedo needle. It came stock with the...
  • theflyersfan: Inside the Chicago Loop and up Lakeshore Drive rivals any great city in the world. The beauty of the...
  • A Scientist: When I was a teenager in the mid 90’s you could have one of these rolling s-boxes for a case of...
  • Mike Beranek: You should expand your knowledge base, clearly it’s insufficient. The race isn’t in...
  • Mike Beranek: ^^THIS^^ Chicago is FOX’s whipping boy because it makes Illinois a progressive bastion in the...

New Car Research

Get a Free Dealer Quote

Who We Are

  • Adam Tonge
  • Bozi Tatarevic
  • Corey Lewis
  • Jo Borras
  • Mark Baruth
  • Ronnie Schreiber