Category: Editorials

By on October 6, 2006

iosis_x_006222.jpgFirst the good news. For the first time in eight long months, George Pipas, Ford's man in the crosshairs Manager of Sales Analysis, could deliver glad tidings to anxious stockholders and stakeholders. September retail and fleet results reveal that sales of Ford’s cars and truck were up when compared against the same month in '05. Although FoMoCo’s sales increases didn’t come anywhere near Toyota’s dramatic advance, the Detroit-based automaker bested cross-town rivals GM and Chrysler by a considerable margin. And the hits keep happening. 

Ford’s Explorer explored territory it hasn’t seen since August of last year (up 22%), and the gargantuan Expedition enjoyed more attention too. Demand for the Hecho en Mexico Fusion fueled a sedan sized fiesta at the Blue Oval to the tune of a 5.3% gain.  These increases were enough to nudge Dearborn’s market share to 16.5%, more than a half point better than last September. With the cross border crossover poised to make its debut, FoMoCo enters the final quarter on an upturn with old metal moving and new metal buzz.

Now the bad news: Mulally’s much maligned motor company isn’t out of the woods yet. A closer look at the numbers indicates that little has changed. Fleet sales still bolster 26% of the movement. And while 74% retail composition is nothing to sneeze at, the fact that those sales are heavily incentive laden, is. Cash on the hood and no interest loans for anyone with a pulse continue to be the way fordward. October is truck month and as Toby Keith sings the praises of the venerable F-150, White Trash With(out) Money can drive the country star’s favorite whip off dealer lots and still have cash left to go “Get Drunk and Be Somebody”.

Inventory currently sits at around 650k units, and the fall season means model year closeouts. To make room for next year’s lot litter, 0% financing is being offered on all non truck vehicles, save Mustang and Fusion. While this will no doubt relieve dealer lots, it does little to help Ford, and will only cripple the profitable Ford Motor Credit unit. To have any chance of survival FoMoCo must deliver on its promise of profitability by the end of the decade. To do that, a “product lead turnaround” is going to need a healthy dose of cash flow. No matter how much metal is moved, virtual loss leaders are not the answer.

A study conducted by Harbour-Felax Group found that incentives and fleet sale discounts cost motor city manufactures an average of 11% in much needed profit. Japanese competition was able to generate an average of $24,289 per car, while homegrown products only put $21,597 back into the pot. Diluted profits translate directly into lost product development. In order to engineer and design market grabbing people movers, Dearborn must turn its knife to sticker play and maintain price points.

That’s not all though. Not only does Ford make less on each vehicle they produce, they also spend more doing so.  It’s no secret that FoMoCo faces incredible cost resistance to profitable production. Health care woes and the union straightjacket ensure that every lost work day results in a $70 per vehicle cost increase. Tack on another $70 each for the extra 16 minutes of break time that every blue collar gets during a shift. Assuming the best case/least likely scenario of perfect attendance by unionized workers, and steady annual sales of 3.1m vehicles, last year’s work breaks alone cost FoMoCo $217m. The money was literally pissed away.

Compared to Toyota, The Blue Oval coughs up an average of $2,165 more per vehicle produced.  Health care advantages, decreased warranty costs, cheaper labour and better use of flex manufacturing ensure that the megalomaniacal Japanese automaker has an immense $6.7b annual cost advantage over its competition in Dearborn. Note: Ford’s production capacity won’t reach 100% until 2008. Add to that the aforementioned 11% revenue lost from fleet sales and incentives and it becomes clear how difficult a job Alan Mulally has ahead of him.

Unfortunately, The Way Fordward 3.0 will fail. The cuts were too little too late. Despite the attempt to balance a projected 14% market share with right sizing production cuts, most analysts agree that Ford has a 0% chance of achieving profitability on three million annual units. Going Fordward, a product-led turnaround will require enormous amounts of cold hard cash. Given the current state of affairs and the fact that buyout packages will drain the corporate coffers throughout the first three quarters of next year, rising costs will eat the development cash, and take much of Ford’s hope with it.

In short, year-on-year post-Katrina and fire sale comparison aside, the mistakes of the past will continue to haunt FoMoCo for years to come.  The truth is in the numbers, and as we know, numbers don’t lie.

By on October 5, 2006

lucerne.jpgThe ‘Sclade re-started it, the Navi went with it and the C made it official: bling is king. What began as an urban tuner phenom– modifying domestic SUV's with flashy wheels, “presidential” window tinting, an infestation of video screens, a stereo powerful enough to make rap music even more painful than it already is (to me), etc.– has become industry practice. One need only glance at the new Escalade, Navigator and Aspen’s gleaming prows to see that bling now comes standard. And thank God for that.

While it’s tempting to give white middle-aged Detroit executives mad props for accepting and adopting urban flava, what choice did they have? The bling thing went ka-ching pretty much about the same time SUV sales started swirling around the toilet bowl. More to the point, why should they care? Quite rightly, the execs saw the financial value of a trend– any trend– that celebrates the most profitable examples of their most profitable genre. If customers want to paint Motown’s premium barges bright red and carpet their insides with two inch thick shag, who gives a shit? Nothing– not even good taste– can interrupt Detroit’s “move the metal” mantra.

Detroit quickly– OK, eventually built on the blingery. They peeped the billions of dollars lavished on their trucks’ aesthetics and creature comforts and decided to grab as big a piece as possible. Your ‘Sclade now comes straight from the factory with wikkid dubs. A Chrysler Aspen can be yours swathed in “Cognac Crystal Pearl” paint. And up-specced Navi's arrive pre-blinged with an “Audiophile” stereo that pumps out enough bass to bruise your sternum– from outside the truck. And if the manufacturer can’t help you transform the not-so-sublime into the entirely ridiculous, their dealers sure as Hell will.

And now we hear that this year’s SEMA (Specialty Equipment Market Association) convention in Viva Las Vegas will feature eleven heavily modified Buick Lucernes. “We want the Lucerne and the event to move Buick into a new audience,” Buick rep David Dorovitz told Brandweek mag. That’s a bit like Brooks Brothers announcing they’ve created a line of ladies’ lingerie, but you gotta admire Davey's street-flavored chutzpah. From Tiger Woods to Krayzie Bone in one giant leap. Wow. Again, what exactly does Buick have to lose? (Remember: they paid TTAC to junket it up in Canada.) Anyway, respect.

And warning: danger Will Robinson! The whole point of automotive blingery and tunery is to display your unique sense of style. Just ask the ex-heads of one of the thousands of super-cool clothing brands that rose and fell like Alan Shepard’s Freedom 7 spacecraft: as soon as “your” style hits the heady heights of mainstream acceptance, it’s headed for the drink. Less poetically, when Wal-Mart’s got it, millions of people don’t want it. Of course, for a while millions of sheeple do, and Wal-Mart makes a fortune. So, again, you can’t blame Detroit for minting money by bringing it to the masses. But there is a wider lesson to be learned: the best way to avoid fashion-based obsolescence is to create products worthy of modification.

I know: SUV’s suck. Gas, that is. But the genre found its way into the urban culture’s heart because they best reflect the American spirit: bigger is better. This website has long argued that Detroit should do what it does best: big, comfy rear-wheel drive vehicles with a bit of style and plenty o’ waft. OK, they can’t really do much else, what with their penthouse overheads and crazed competition. But now that Buick– Buick— is getting the spizzarkle treatment, what’s the bet that the bling craze will shift focus towards the recently saved Ford Crown Vic and its platform siblings? Or that the Lincoln Town Car will find some new friends? It's time for Detroit to get their rear-wheelers into gear, ready for the boyz in the hood.

Granted: it’ll take a while for the movers and shakers to make the move and shake-off SUV love. The money showered on trend-setting rappers took them into wheels made of unobtainium. (Which they no longer modify, ironically enough.) Style makers lower down on the food chain need some time to regroup. But the freshened Mustang (in all its crap packaged glory) showed the world that there’s still a huge market for traditional American cars. If you doubt that Yank tanks are set for a resurgence, clock the recent development of thoroughly hideous “donks.” (If you have to ask, believe me, you don’t want to know.)

CUV’s and front wheel-drive high-mileage mid-market motors ain’t gonna cut it. Americans like barges. My advice to Detroit: embrace your inner bling. Let the imports do the fuel-efficient, sweet-revving, tight interior thing. Build cars worthy of stunting and flossing. Either that or you’ll be bitching and moaning as your market share goes the way of the pet rock.

By on October 4, 2006

lutz.jpgGM’s September sales figures are out. Despite generous Labor Day incentives, zero per cent financing to anyone with a pulse and an easy year-on-year comparison (GM was in the post-Fire Sale mode last September), vehicle sales are down seven percent. Given GM’s upcoming production cutbacks, there’s only one way sales can go from here: down, taking GM’s declining market share with it. Never mind. According to GM Exec Maximum Bob Lutz, "Whatever our market share stabilizes at in the US— 22, 23, 24 percent— I don’t really care. The idea that GM… has got to get back to 30 percent is a wacky notion with all this global competition we’ve got."

Obviously, Mr. What Me Worry? is a whack job. The fact that the septugenarian ex-Marine has any power whatsoever within GM– never mind his multi-million dollar annual salary, huge pension and Gulfstream perks– tells you all you need to know about GM’s ability to manage itself. At the risk of stating the obvious, shouldn’t the guy who calls [at least some of] the shots for the world’s largest automaker understand that the faster GM’s domestic market share shrinks, the closer The General gets to the tipping point of no return? Call me a weenie (SIR!), but I’d expect an ex-Marine to know when he’s fighting a rear-guard action.

By the same token, you’d kinda hope that GM’s so-called “car czar” would know that The General’s inability to find new homes for their cash cows is putting his employer in a world of hurt. Pardon me for not being a goldfish, but I distinctly remember Mr. Lutz standing on the running board of a new[ish] Tahoe telling the world that GM’s GMT-900’s would take the [declining] market by storm and save GM’s bacon. Well they haven’t. Yukon, Tahoe and Suburban sales are soft, and getting softer. Surely the opposite of success is failure, and the logical response to failure is to acknowledge the damage and formulate a new plan– rather than obfuscation, prevarication and denial.

Top execs like GM marketing maven Mark LaNeve may be happy spinning the dismal parade of declining numbers– claiming that rental fleet sales and limited production are clouding an otherwise bright picture– but the numbers don’t lie. GM is in a death spiral that no amount of “missing” Chevrolet Aveos, Cobalts and Malibus can cure. GM claims its GMT900 pickups are the next next big thing, but they simply can’t create enough cash flow to sustain The General’s distended product portfolio.

In fact, Maximum Bob put his finger on the nub of GM’s problem: the company has lost its ability to fight import owned competition. GM’s September sales results are bad enough, but Toyota’s are far worse– for GM. The Japanese automaker’s sales climbed a staggering 25%. And it wasn’t just parsimonious econoboxes fueling the company’s financial combustion chamber. Year-on-year sales were up for the Sequoia (37.7%), Land Cruiser (1.7%), 4Runner (8.9%), Highlander (16.1%) and RAV4 (93.4%). Bottom line: Toyota’s September SUV sales rose by an average of 54.8%.

The numbers are alarming in extremis. GM's new[ish] GMT900’s have not only failed to sell in absolute terms, they’ve also failed to stem the growing tide of customers abandoning domestic products for import-owned vehicles– on GM's home turf. As for cars… fuhgeddaboutit. “All this global competition” has left The General in a corner, fighting Ford and Chrysler for a dwindling supply of hard core domestic-buying consumers.Unless Ford goes belly-up first, unless GM's new products beat-back Toyota, Honda, Hyundai and the rest of the “newcomers;” the market share stability GM’s Car Czar seeks is almost impossible to imagine.

Meanwhile, reports are filtering in that GM CEO Rabid Rick Wagoner has finally called off the Nissan – Renault alliance talks. This may have a little something to do with new rules enacted yesterday by GM’s Board of Bystanders. The language is a bit convoluted, but the rules make it easier for the Board to remove pro-Renault investor Kirk Kerkorian’s man Jerry York, and prevent Captain Kirk from adding new members. So Rabid Rick’s covered his ass and told Kirk to take a flying leap. As we predicted, things are getting ugly over at RenCen.

The battle for control of GM is just beginning. Kirk is sure to retaliate against GM’s CEO, and The Lion of Las Vegas is nothing if not resourceful. Regardless who ends-up the last man grandstanding, the war's already been lost. GM’s products are falling further and further behind the competition in the sales charts. The recent cuts to the automaker's production and staff will help the bottom line, but they indicate that GM's is fighting harder and harder for less and less. At some point, the company will starve to death.

By on October 4, 2006

firebird_ii.jpgGM Car Czar Maximum Bob Lutz’ recently stated that anyone who thinks that GM will shutter divisions is a “weenie” who doesn’t understand the cost of dealer lawsuits. Yes, well, one day, GM will have to jettison brands. Perceived wisdom dictates that The General should pare itself down to Chevrolet (low end cars), GMC (trucks and SUV’s) and Cadillac (high end cars). As for Saab, Buick Hummer and Saturn, bon voyage!  And then there’s Pontiac. Yes, Pontiac. I believe GM’s product starved “performance” division has the greatest potential of any of its current brands. With great products, Pontiac could go from neglected stepchild to superstar son.

The Solstice roadster is a huge step in the right direction for GM’s excitement division, in every way the ill-fated “new” GTO wasn't (except luggage room). Chiefly, the Solstice is gorgeous. The model also has an entry-level and hard core (or at least harder core) performance variant (GXP). As for the rest of the lineup… meh. G6: a rental car from birth that’s nowhere near as good as the Camry/Accord juggernaut. G5: ditto. Grand Prix: 303hp through the front wheels—who wants that? Torrent: as exciting as a cute ute can get (i.e. not at all). Vibe: a Toyota Corolla. GTO: dead and dead ugly.

So, now’s the time to apply a little art and a little science a la big brother Cadillac. First off, GM should decontent the beJesus out of Caddy’s outgoing CTS, give it Solstice-quality sensuous sheet metal and rechristen it the Pontiac Grand Prix. While the new CTS is due any time now, Chrysler’s 300– made with bits and pieces of the last gen Mercedes E-Class– shows you can get new money for old rope. This home-grown Grand Prix would keep both customers and the UAW happy. The Caddy set up’s rear wheel-drive opens-up the possibilities; can you imagine a Grand Prix Coupe with a 505hp Z06 engine? Eat that, Shelby GT500. More importantly, you’d have a family-priced rear-driver that would steal sales from DXC’s ageing Magnum/Charger/300C trifecta.

Meanwhile, bring on the Firebird! With FoMoCo selling massive herds of Mustangs (August being the best ‘Stang month since 1979), Pontiac needs to flip their cross-town rivals the bird. Release a new Pontiac Firebird with half a dozen variations right off the bat with various degrees of engine oomph. Build it off the Corvette chassis—not the Camaro’s. Most importantly, festoon it with flaming chickens. We love that. Point being: make it as visually exciting as the Solstice. Make it a sports car that people talk about, swoon over and ultimately desire.

Speaking of excitement, where are America's WRX’s and Evo’s? Sure, the Dodge Caliber SRT-4 puts out 300hp, but it’s a front-driver, the chassis is junk and it looks constipated. GM committed a horrible, almost unforgivable gaffe with the Saabaru, charging 5K over retail for nothing more than a badge. (That car should have been the new Vibe.) Correct the mistake. Imagine a small, American wagon with world class performance and handling. People would eat it up. The fat-faced Chevrolet WTCC Ultra that GM recently debuted in Paris would make a vicious Pontiac; assuming they raise the asphalt-scraping chin spoiler a yard. Even if that particular small, muscular car is not the solution, something is. Build it, and boy racers will come.

The world also needs an exciting and sexy fuel-sipper. Sure, you can buy Honda’s Fit – an outstanding car – but it’s just so goofy looking. There’s the Mini, but it’s over-boiled and too much of a statement for many. Most importantly, neither car is American. Instead of taking the lame, Lido way out and importing small, dorky Korean subs, let’s design and build one here. DCX is about to start building the Hornet in China, which despite what WalMart wants you to think, is not America. Moreover, the Hornet looks like an angry filing cabinet. Pontiac, this segment is yours for the taking.

Pontiac can of course choose to do none of the above, stay the course and follow Oldsmobile, Plymouth and Dead-Buick-Walking to the gates of automotive hell, with Lincoln/Mercury bringing up the rear. But that needn’t be the case. Performance divisions, no matter how stale the marketing shtick may be, are good things. Take a gander at Mazda, Ford’s defacto fun to drive brand. With the lone exception of the lame duck B4000 pickup, all of Mazda’s product offerings are at least sporty, if not outright sports cars. From the mutant CX-7 to the perfectly executed Miata, every product serves the driver first, last and second. And Mazda’s US sales are up 5% from a year ago. In a model cycle, Pontiac could be in the same boat, especially if they heed the example of what the CTS-V did for Cadillac; making enthusiasts care about a moribund brand. It’s the fast things that count.

By on October 3, 2006

drucker.jpgPeter F. Drucker grew up in Frankfurt just as the Nazis gathered power. When Hitler was elected Chancellor, the future business guru fled for England, watching the storm clouds of centralized power in his rearview mirror. No wonder the concept of decentralization became one of Drucker’s first and more useful contributions to American business theory. Drucker and his beliefs came to prominence with the publication of "Concept of the Corporation" in 1946. Hard to believe, but the landmark work was based on 18 months Drucker spent studying General Motors.

By 1950, Drucker decided that workers were assets and the corporation was a community. He asserted that humans– not machines, numbers, paper or parts– were the heart of the company. He eventually extended the perspective out of the factory doors out to the customer. Drucker spent a lot of time and other people’s money reminding executives not to forget the customer.

The nature of any business, he argued, is to create a customer. To hunt him or her down and serve them like… um… There is no good metaphor for hunting and serving. Maybe that’s why it’s such a tough dictate to follow. But according to Drucker, follow it you must: the customer is the essence of any successful business, including automotive. Following his logic, a car is the RNA to the essential DNA of those inside. In other words, it’s the people that matter, not the car.

Ironically enough, Volkswagen is a perfect example of a company founded on this “customer as essence” philosophy. Adolf Hitler decided that his working class supporters needed a “people’s car” that could take five passengers to 62 mph for under 1000 Reich Marks. He met with Ferdinand Porsche, owner of the design house Porsche Byro. The Beetle was born. The Beetle became a runaway success and an automotive icon.

Volkswagen’s customers, however, evolved. Post-war, family sizes increased. Consumers became aware of safety and environmental considerations. Volkswagen kept pace with their customers' expectations of performance, comfort and safety by shifting from the spartan Beetle to the increasingly luxe Golf (or Rabbit, depending on your county of origin). The two models have almost nothing in common– except the people you find riding inside. VW stayed true to its middle class customers.

Many decades later, VW re-launched a "new" Beetle. The model illustrates the company's ability to understand their "essence." Rather than create another utilitarian people's car, they released a horrendously compromised package wrapped in "cute" retro-minded sheetmetal. The result appealed directly and powerfully to their existing customers' sense of nostalgia, at a price they could afford. The new Beetle was/is a value-priced fashion statement– the exact opposite of the Bug’s original intent. And a solid sales success because of it.

It seems simple enough: build a car for your customer. Some companies do this very well. As wealthy consumers have children later in life, Porsche correctly figured that a fat, 911-nosed station wagon was just what the “new traditional” Porsche customer needed to cart their dependents and lifestyle equipment. Or, if you prefer, the Cayenne was exactly what their customers' wives wanted their Porsche worshipping husbands to want to buy for them. The Chevrolet Corvette is another machine that's faithful to its maker's essence. Although no longer as affordable as it was, the 'Vette still caters to its [increasingly wealthy] customers' desire for impractical, low-slung, all-American, V8-powered sex appeal.

Volkswagen also supplies us with an excellent example of the converse of the consumer-centric theory: the Phaeton. Though superbly engineered, VW's $70k luxobarge was an answer to a question that none of their customers asked. How far from the young, middle-class family did they park that thing, anyway? By the same token, Saab customers prize nimble driving, clever design and originality. Give them a warmed-over, rebadged Chevy Trailblazer and see what happens. Nothing. Observers of the automotive scene often see an automaker's essence denied (Cadillac BLS) or essence from another planet (Chevrolet SSR). These products– if not the companies who build them– are doomed from the start.

Which is the long way of saying badge engineering is the exact polar opposite of customer engineering. A company may like to build a certain type or style of car, it may be relatively cheap to manufacture. But if the company forgets its essense (i.e. whether or not its existing customers want to pay them for the result), they won't be building cars for long. In short, the person who should be in the driver's seat of any viable car company should be the person who ends up in the driver's seat: the customer.

In 1983, Drucker wrote this epilogue: "Concept of the Corporation had an immediate impact on American business, on public service institutions, on government agencies – and none on General Motors!"

By on October 2, 2006

cs_radargun22.jpgI like to drive fast. I don't think I'm breaking new rhetorical ground to suggest that anyone who likes to drive fast violates the speed limit from time to time. In fact, depending on your predilection for automotive velocity, "from time to time" easily becomes "all the time." There are plenty of ways to justify chronic speeding: posted speed limits are unrealistic (set low to reflect average vehicles' and drivers' capabilities), they're a guideline rather than an absolute indication of safe speed (which don't reflect variable conditions such as weather, road surface, traffic, etc.), they're relatively unimportant (compared to inattentive, reckless or drunk driving) and the vast majority of motorists exceed them anyway. Strangely, the last excuse is the most potent.

It's a bizarre concept for a democratic government: enact and enforce a law which the majority of people don't obey. It gets even stranger when you consider the fact that the majority of citizens support the law that they know they don't obey (hence its creation and continuation). Of course, the speed limit is not the first or best example of this hypocritical happenstance. From 1920 to 1933, America lived under the strictures of the Eighteenth Amendment to the US Constitution. Despite popular support for the "prohibition" against the sale and distribution of alcohol, Americans kept on drinking. In the same sense, American motorists kept driving above 55mph when Richard Nixon's administration used federal highway funds to force the states to adopt a “national” speed limit.

In both cases, arguments for the legislation were logical and coherent. There's no question that alcohol was/is America's most destructive drug, blighting the lives of millions, disrupting our economic efficiency and causing thousands of fatalities. There's also no question that driving 55mph was/is an excellent way to save billions of gallons of imported oil. (I might even spot you the national speed limit's positive effect on highway fatalities– if it were actually true.) But no matter how you slice it, neither law significantly curtailed the proscribed behavior. This made enforcement a horrendously expensive, Sisyphusian task.

One of the key differences between Prohibition and unobserved speed limits is that the latter is self-financing. One wonders if Prohibition might have lasted longer if the government agencies in charge of its enforcement had received the financial fruits of current RICO statutes, which provide for confiscation of criminal assets. In contrast, police who write speeding tickets can use the money to pay for police who write speeding tickets. This being America, it’s not quite that straight forward. Speeding tickets fall under local and state jurisdiction; the revenues generated are often subject to “land grabs” by money hungry local legislators.

In England, it is that simple. The national government has “ring fenced” the money generated by speeding tickets: mandating that local “safety camera partnerships” must spend the revenue from speed enforcement on speed enforcement. This supposedly virtuous circle has led to an explosion of speed cameras, a huge increase in speeding tickets and a very nasty unintended consequence. Just as Prohibition eroded the American public’s respect for law and law enforcement, the United Kingdom’s extremely effective anti-speeding jihad has undermined the public’s respect for the police.

At the risk of alienating road safety-minded readers, many of whom have suffered personal losses from traffic fatalities, the issue of the public’s faith in its police force is far more important than speed-related road safety. When a law criminalizes a behavior practiced by the majority of its citizens, it criminalizes its citizens. When the police rigorously enforce this law, hypocritically enough, the public comes to resent the police. Keep in mind that most people never encounter their police force; speeding tickets written “when I wasn’t really doing anything wrong” do nothing to engender a relationship of mutual respect.

Unlike Prohibition, there is no obvious answer to this state of affairs; you can’t simply “repeal” (i.e. abandon) speed limits. Or can you? If you ask the average Joe if they think police should write speeding tickets only in those situations where a motorist was driving “faster than was safe for the prevailing conditions” you’d have little to no disagreement. That kind of policy would require judicious human enforcement by officers prioritizing road safety, rather than revenue collection. It would be far more expensive that a passive device snapping off tickets to anyone and everyone violating an inflexible, predetermined speed limit.

In the US, the aggressiveness of speed enforcement varies widely. Certain states are now experimenting with speed cameras, blundering straight into the old axiom that those who do not learn from history are condemned to repeat it. Meanwhile, the situation in the UK seems to be reaching some sort of breaking point, with anti-speed camera campaigners gaining public sympathy and support. The country is learning that public policy based on moral posturing, rather than common sense and real world behavior, is doomed to failure.

[podcast is with Paul Smith, founder of the UK's Safe Speed ] 

By on October 1, 2006

john-force-burnout22.jpgWhen Wally Parks started the National Hot Rod Association in 1951 there was no way he could’ve foreseen the sport’s mainstream appeal. The NHRA started out as a small organization that gave pistonheads an outlet for legitimate hoonage, bragging rights and a trophy. It has since become the largest motorsports sanctioning body in the world, offering some $50m in annual prize money.  The original national events held twice annually have given birth to a 23 race North American series.  

As BBC Top Gear presenter Richard Hamond will attest, things get pretty interesting when you’re moving over 325mph. Consider this: the Bugatti Veyron will hit 60mph in 2.5 seconds. A “flopper” hits the century mark in less than a second and doubles that less than a second later. To put that into perspective, take that same Bugatti, put the cruise control on at 200mph and watch a “digger” blow by you from a standing stop over the quarter mile. Pulling the chutes to bring the 30’ rail back to a comprehensible speed generates enough G-force to detach driver’s retinas. The raw power is mesmerizing.

If you’ve never attended a drag racing event, change that, if only for 4.5 seconds. Every motorsport aficianado should experience the sensual experience of 8000 horsepower first hand. It starts with six foot tall belches of nitromethane flame dancing above force fed V8 headers. Utter discombobulation follows. The thrust from that exhaust, coupled with the sonic wave that is two parts Odin’s fury to one part gut punch, makes insides liquefy, eyeballs shudder and lungs… stop. If the race lasted any longer, spectators would explode. The aftershock is a healthy waft of burned nitric acid/propane and methanol vapors that curl nostril hair and make trackside snacks taste chemically charred. Formula 1 cars seem like coffee-canned hot-hatches in comparison.

Nobody personifies the utter insanity of this sport better than Top Fuel Funny Car driver John Force. The fast talking California native is to the NHRA what Michael Schumacher is to Formula 1. After notching his first win in Montreal in 1987, Force has gone on to holeshot the NHRA record books. Force currently sits with an unprecedented 13 championship titles (ten successive fingers got rings between '93 and '02). He's qualified in just fewer than 350 consecutive events and posted 120 career victories. He also owns the top speed (333.58mph) and elapsed time (4.665s) records. AutoSport Magazine has recognized Force with the John Bolster Award for lifetime achievement. Force currently sits No. 2 behind legend “Big Daddy” Don Garlits on the NHRA top 50 drivers list.

As good as drag racing has been to John Force, John Force has been good to drag racing. The excitably loud former truck driver commands droves of loyal fans, who crowd any event where the man does his thing. Force fans litter the stands sporting event sponsored T’s whenever John takes to the staging beams. They cheer madly during his eighth mile burnouts. For those few seconds of racing, it's standing room only.

After a run, the pit area surrounding the Force Racing trailers looks like a shot from Woodstock 2 (without the stage fires). Fans clamber to score handshakes, autographed pictures, cracked crankshafts, pummeled pistons and melted tires from their Mustang-driving blue collared hero. On the rare occasion that John gets beat, the fans begin to leave. The A&E reality TV show, Driving Force, has illustrated Force's effect on the sport, and gathered new devotees to his combination of humility and ambition. OK, that and the fact that the program also chronicles his four daughters' racing careers, and they're not all that hard to look at. 

Anyway, at this year's Indianapolis NHRA Funny Car nationals, the sport once again felt the Force. Despite having the fastest car in his class, the 52nd annual "Big Go" saw Force falter in the first round of eliminations. John took home a paltry $100k bonus bucks, and the benches at O'Reilly Raceay Park soon thinned. But none of the fans walked away disappointed. As always, the NHRA nationals provided the kind of adrenal hit that makes the sport addictive to drivers and fans alike. 

By on September 30, 2006

arton23557.jpgYesterday, Automotive News reported that octogenarian GM investor Kirk Kerkorian is "frustrated with CEO Rick Wagoner's lack of enthusiasm for an alliance with Nissan-Renault." That's like the DEA saying it's frustrated with Bolivia's inability to curtail its cocaine exports. Kirk knows that Rick would sooner pull the ripcord on his [bankruptcy proof] golden parachute than green light a hook-up with the French. Which is why the Lion of Las Vegas responded to Wagoner’s “no deal” comments to the Parisian press by threatening to buy up even more shares in the ailing automaker: to force Wagoner into a corner.

We now know that the Nissan negotiations began after GM Board Member and Captain Kirk crony Jerry York held a secret meeting with Nissan boss Carlos The Jackal Ghosn. Forget strategic alliances and supplier synergies; York simply offered Ghosn Wagoner’s job. Setting aside the outrageous not-to-say-criminal impropriety of a GM Board Member launching a clandestine plot against his company’s Chief Executive Office on behalf of an outside investor, the play finally reveals the intent behind the whole lawyer-enriching GM-Nissan mishegos: to remove Wagoner from the helm of the world’s largest automaker. Period.

If you recall, Wagoner fended-off the initial attack by convincing his boardlings to put him in charge of analyzing the potential of the proposed GM-Nissan-Renault alliance (much like a Bolivian drug lord electing himself president to police drug traffic). At the Paris auto show, Rabid Rick did the pro forma meeting thing with Carlos, announced (again) that GM’s turnaround is on track thank you very much, and then, outrageously and ominously (considering GM’s cash position), suggested Nissan should put a couple of bil on the table. Kirk immediately threatened to buy 12 million more GM shares. Message to Wagoner: don’t fuck with me.

Captain Kirk holds 56 million shares or 9.9 percent of GM’s common stock. He bought the shares at an average price of $31.50. At Thursday’s $33.06 per share closing price, Mr. Kerkorian’s paper profit currently stands at $84m. Upping his stake by 12m shares would cost The Lion of Las Vegas a relatively paltry $400m. The purchase would put his total GM investment at well over 10% or roughly $2.25b. Should he make the move, the additional shares would give Kirk more clout to demand an “independent financial review” of the GM-Nissan-Renault deal. To that end, he’s informed the Securities and Exchange Commission that he wants to change his official status from a passive (!) to an “active” investor.

Obviously, there’s no good reason for Kirk (or anyone else) to buy a chunk of GM based on its long-term future. Despite Red Ink Rick’s steadfast claims that his turnaround plan is kicking in now… no wait… now… oh hang on… NOW, GM’s death spiral continues. Kirk’s inside man Jerry York knows that GM’s new pickups aren’t going to pickup enough business to save the company’s bacon. He knows that GM’s summer of deadbeat love, the company’s increased incentives on products both old and new, their aggressive “book the deal when it leaves the factory” accounting and the negative effect of this fall’s heavily curtailed future production all spell disaster.

York and Kerkorian are also aware that the domestic automobile market is only getting more competitive. The so-called imports make stacks of money in the US because their domestic counterparts are high cost producers who set a floor on pricing. It’s an open secret that Toyota, Honda, Nissan, Hyundai et al. could bury GM/Ford/DCX simply by lowering the prices on their vehicles. Toyota’s new Tundra is a step in that direction that’s bound to show that none of The Big Two Point Five’s products are safe from non-union competition.

All of which tell/reminds us that Kirk’s in it for the money. Hence Kirk’s decision to put Wagoner in a classic you’re fired if you do (hello Carlos!) and you’re fired if you don’t (where’s Carlos?) position. Once Captain Kirk replaces Wagoner, especially if it’s with The Jackal, GM’s stock price will rise. Kirk will cash out and that’ll be that– for Kirk. The General will still be in chaos. Whether or not the Jackal could then recreate The General as a profitable car company– without taking it into Chapter 11– is an open question we may yet see answered.

Things will get ugly if Kerkorian doesn’t get his way. For one thing, GM will have to show good financial results– even if they’re less credible than last quarter’s. GM’s accounting department has been sailing close to the wind for well over a year now. Federal regulators may flex their muscles post-November elections, perhaps aided by Jerry York (providing yet another way to axe Wagoner). In fact, this whole Kirk – Rick thing has become a Detroit death match. Anyone betting on Wagoner better hope that GM’s octogenarian investor forgets to take his medicine, or dies in the arms of Anna Nicole Smith.

By on September 29, 2006

dieter.jpg On April 3, 2005, this website began the General Motors Death Watch. Few industry or media types credited the possibility that the world’s largest automaker could be on the ropes. By this August, when the Ford Death Watch series began, it was clear to all and sundry that GM is in a fight for its life. And, of course, that Ford was in the same position. That left Chrysler as the sole domestic automaker whose fortunes weren’t in deep decline. And then, two weeks ago, Chrysler announced that it will lose $1.52b in the third financial quarter. Does that mean its time for a Chrysler Death Watch?  First, a little history…

After staring down the barrel of bankruptcy in 1979/1980, Chrysler tapped into Uncle Sam’s wallet to make a remarkable recovery. The automaker tossed its moribund product line and milked their new K-car like a prize cow. At the same time, they sought out niches other companies had ignored. The Voyager minivan was a smash hit, and the company’s convertibles revived a dead genre. The ‘93 Ram pickup was another major score. In ’98, Daimler-Benz completed its takeover “merger of equals." With a transfusion of German money, management and engineering, Chrysler’s future looked brighter than ever. The ensuing 300, Magnum and Charger found plenty of willing buyers. Once again “Hemi” was on the lips of power-hungry pistonheads both young and old.

But past lessons– both good and bad– were forgotten. Despite the badge engineered departure of their Plymouth and Desoto brands, Chrysler is once again diluting its appeal by selling cheap imitations of its own products. After building reasonably distinctive, commercially successful vehicles from the same platform (300, Charger, Magnum), Chrysler is trying to pass off a tarted-up Durango as an Aspen (a name that brings it no honor) and a hideous Caliber clone as a Jeep. The former will find no friends and the latter degrades a venerable brand. The money spent on both “new” models could have paid for a much-needed refresh of the august PT Cruiser, or other aging products.

When gas prices skyrocketed, sales of Chrysler’s gas guzzlers tanked like everyone else’s. But instead of curtailing production of the slower-selling models, Chrysler continued pushing them off the assembly line. According to PR flack Jason Vines, the automaker’s dealer network is currently sitting on 600k unsold units. At the start of this month, DCX dealers are holding 36,500 unsold Chrysler 300s. At the current rate of sales, that’s an 84-day supply, when 60 days is considered a healthy “pad.” The inventory situation is so bad in general that dealers are refusing delivery of ‘07’s, further choking Chrysler’s chicken.

It is, in fact, a scandal. Peter DeLorenzo over at Autoextremist.com recently quoted a Chrysler “insider” who reported that “upper management has been building cars without dealer orders for close to two years in order to keep the factories open and the truth of their financial situation hidden… DCX 'sells' the unassigned units to their business centers and books the profit from these sales when necessary to prop-up quarterly profits.” On Monday, Automotive News reported that the company paid dealers as much as $750 per unit to take extra stock after its supply of unsold inventory reached 92 days.

Group CEO Tom LaSorda now says that the company will cut both internal costs and production. To that end, Chrysler recently asked the United Auto Workers to match the health care “concessions” given to GM. The union’s refusal doesn’t bode well– which could change once Chrysler starts shuttering factories and offering buyouts a la The Big Two. One wonders how Chrysler’s plan to import Chinese-made economy cars will affect that equation. Meanwhile, Chrysler has matched the Big Two’s zero percent financing to anyone who can make it through the dealer’s door, and added incentives on slow-selling pickups and SUVs, including some 2007 models.

DCX Chairman Dieter Zetsche has been curiously silent through the recent PR storm. The last time we heard from dear Dieter, he accused the UAW of being “irrational” in their resistance to healthcare concessions. Market analysts have been a bit more vocal, though. Jochen Gehrke of Deutsche Bank AG states DCX should sell Chrysler Group, which he says will “unlock” the value of Daimler’s stock.

Even with the $1.5b hit, DCX is in relatively good financial shape. But just like their cross-town rivals, no company can survive that kind of fiscal hemorrhage forever. In fact, it’s now clear that the business basics dragging down GM and Ford– a lack of investment in established products, the introduction of lackluster vehicles, the union strait jacket, burdensome health care and pension costs, dishonest or oblivious management, top heavy bureaucracy, a bloated dealer network– are also hobbling Chrysler. Perhaps it's time to combine all three automakers into a Detroit Death Watch.

By on September 27, 2006

bill_ford222.jpg This morning, I met with a management consultant who works for The Big Two Point Five. Back before the recent “unpleasantness,” Ford’s top brass engaged the consultant to tackle a marketing issue crucial to FoMoCo’s future. Department heads assembled. Despite overlapping fiefdoms and wildly different ideas for progress, the execs hammered out an innovative four-point strategic plan. Consensus was achieved. And then… nothing. Not one of the points was ever implemented. “These guys are scared to death of change,” he sighed. “Ford’s culture is always working against them.”

Although pundits recognize FoMoCo’s corporate culture as a bad, bad thing, they fail to identify the Blue Oval’s underlying take-no-chances, pass-the-buck, cover-your-ass management philosophy as the root of all evil. Reverse engineer all the decisions that lead to the Ford Focus’ interior, or the existence of the Freestar, or the plan to market a six-cylinder Lincoln crossover, or the general lack of killer cars, and it’s clear that the company’s corporate culture is slow, fat, lazy and stupid.

At the moment, Ford’s busy trimming the fat from the equation. At the top of the food chain, several of The Blue Oval’s biggest big shots are floating out the door on their golden parachutes: Steve Hamp, Chief of Staff; A J Wagner, Vice President of Ford Motor Credit Company; Dave Szczupak, Group Vice President; and Anne “Push Push Hug” Stevens, COO of the Americas. Upon her resignation, the last executive on the list left a love letter with The Detroit Free Press indicating the full extent of the ossification within FoMoCo: “The company has too many layers, the company is too bureaucratic, and it takes too long to get things done."

Note: this comment comes from the woman ranked number 22 on Fortune magazine's list of the “50 Most Powerful Women in Business” and number 41 on Motor Trend’s “Power List” of the industry’s top 50 execs. Meanwhile, further down the food chain, Ford is slicing 14k white collar workers from its North American payroll. That’s one-third of FoMoCo’s entire white collar staff. At the end of this process, Nicole Richie will have more fat than Ford’s management structure– leaving them with lazy, slow and stupid.

The Machiavellians amongst you might disagree, imagining the bloody hand of freshly-minted Ford CEO Alan Mulally behind all this, taking comfort in the carnage, predicting that a new, more market responsive corporate regime will follow. It’s certainly true that the best way to “cure” a diseased corporate culture is to knife as many slackers/potential enemies as possible, erring on the side of excess. But one need only consider the timing of the cuts and look at the top of the pyramid to conclude that it’s business as usual down in Dearborn.

The latest round of white collar cuts was announced prior to Alan Mulally’s arrival. That’s just plain dumb; even if Mulally didn’t swing the axe, he should have at least looked as if he was swinging the axe. Does the executive who appointed Ford's thirty-five million dollar man care? Obviously not. And what does that tell you about Billy Ford? My take: Bad Billy’s inability to walk away from the family firm he’s been running into the ground makes him part of the problem, not the solution. The fact that Baby Face Mark Fields– original architect of The Way Fordward and twenty-minute heir apparent– is still wandering the corridors of power is equally troubling.

All of which raises the single most important question for Ford’s future: who’s in charge? I Don’t Know is on his second executive savior and third way forward. Someone’s at FoMoCo’s got to sort out who does what first. The second they figure that out, the country’s third largest automaker can stop making so many product decisions that come straight from left field. Then they’d have a chance to sort out their corporate culture and start building desirable products in a timely fashion. Which is why Detroit's chattering class is waiting for Alan Mulally to step up to the plate and knock someone's head off.  

He better. Not to put too fine a point on it, the only way to motivate people is fear and greed. God knows Ford’s tried greed. For decades, they’ve paid off the unions. For decades, executives have failed upwards. For decades, the top dogs have enjoyed gold-plated pay packages and plenty o’ perks– regardless of their performance or lack thereof. Greed’s done. It’s time for fear. It’s time for a ruthless leader to step forward who’s ready, willing and able to excise the weak-willed in his ranks. When you hear Billy Ford mumble the words “Et tu, Brute?” on his way to a comfortable retirement in, say, the Maldives, THEN you will know that Ford is truly ready to move forward.     

By on September 27, 2006

scooby.jpg Germany was first, followed by France, England and Italy. Japan arrived a few years later, with Korea trailing by several decades. Since 1949, foreign car makers have mounted assaults on America’s automotive market. A few have flourished, others have had moderate success, but many have retreated after failing to establish a beachhead. And now another wave is forming, threatening to storm our shores. Entrepreneur Malcolm Bricklin is leading the charge, establishing Visionary Vehicles LLC to import a line of “aggressively priced, beautifully styled, high-quality vehicles” built in China.  Are we about to witness the next automotive revolution, or are we being asked to buy the Bricklin bridge?

Malcolm Bricklin has a, uh, "colorful" business background. When he was in his 20’s, Bricklin built his father’s building supply into a chain of stores. When the company became embroiled in lawsuits, Malcolm took his millions and left– just before the company went bankrupt. Bricklin’s next business venture: selling motor scooters built by Fuji Heavy Industries. After he realized Fuji’s Subaru 360 automobile was so light it could slip under the government’s safety regulations, he formed Subaru of America to import the tiny car.

Sales went fairly well until Consumer Reports named the 360 “the most dangerous car in the United States.” Sales plummeted and Bricklin bailed out of the business. But not before securing a thousand 360s in an attempt to establish a private race series (no really). Not long afterwards his financial backer sued Bricklin for misappropriation of funds. Bricklin moved on to his next– and arguably most infamous– project: the Bricklin SV-1.

Bricklin’s automotive namesake created a high price sports car clad in an acrylic plastic shell. The SV-1’s gullwing doors– its most distinctive feature– weighed almost 100 pounds apiece. The electro-pneumatic system controlling their operation was so failure prone Bricklin’s boffins had to design a way to exit the “Safety Vehicle 1” via the cargo hatch. To help Bricklin and his investors finance this venture, the entrepreneur convinced the province of New Brunswick, Canada to provide a $2.88m loan guarantee (in exchange for Bricklin’s production facility). Bricklin sold 200 dealership franchises and produced 2854 plastic fantastics. In 1975, the company went into receivership, leaving the citizens of New Brunswick with $23m in accumulated debt.

Ten years later, Bricklin resurfaced on the automotive scene, importing the Yugoslovian-built Zastava Koral under the name Yugo. By 1988, Yugo America was in financial trouble. Bricklin sold his share to Zastava for more than $15m. In 1992, after selling 120,000 cars, Zastava withdrew from the US market. A year later, Bricklin partnered with none other than Lee Iacocca to found the Electric Bicycle Co. The company sold expensive battery-powered bicycles through automobile dealers. In 1995, Electric Bicycle went bankrupt. Which brings us to Bricklin’s latest undertaker– I mean, undertaking.

After briefly considering bringing Zastavas back under a different name, Bricklin journeyed to Wuhu, China looking for a source of bargain-basement vehicles. Finding a willing partner in Chery, Bricklin started making plans to "redefine the price of luxury" by importing an inexpensive line of high-content vehicles into the US market. The company is a joint venture: a 60 – 40 split between Chery (i.e. the Chinese government) and Visionary Vehicles. Bricklin’s deal insulates him from competition; Chinese government regulations restrict American manufacturers operating in China (e.g. GM) from building cars for export. For now…

Bricklin’s plans call for importing a quarter-million units beginning in 2007. His business plan also estimates 100% growth per year for the first several years. If all goes according to plan (hardly a given), Chery’s first export into the American market will be a “BMW 3-Series/5-Series challenger for about $19k,” followed by a two-seat roadster for $15K and a “BMW 6-Series fighter at around $25k.” No less than twenty models are planned for the future, including a hybrid, an AWD sedan and a crossover.

Like many of Bricklin’s other ideas, Visionary Vehicles has hit a few “snags.” Thanks in part to a $2m franchise fee, the company has signed up only 20 percent of the desired 250 dealers. Chery has rescheduled its US launch to late 2008 or early 2009, while Malcolm looks for alternative sources of adventure capital.

There are many unanswered questions surrounding this venture. If Bricklin doesn’t secure 250 dealers, can he proceed? Can he succeed? What effects will recent talks between DCX and Chery re: building a cut price Chrysler or Dodge for the US market have on Visionary’s “exclusivity?” The biggest question is, of course, whether American car buyers will want Bricklin’s automobiles. Undercutting established econoboxes like the Toyota’s Yaris ($11,050) will take some doing. Despite all the talk about BMW's, will Bricklin's Chinese vehicles come with same cheap and not so cheerful stigma that killed Yugo's ambitions? Can Bricklin finally build a viable business? It’s too early to say, but I wouldn’t bet on it.

By on September 26, 2006

boblutzsequel01222.jpg Even as it struggles for its short term survival, GM has unleashed a cloud of hydrogen-powered publicity. A week ago last Sunday, GM announced that "Project Driveway” will deliver 100 Chevrolet Equinox Fuel Cell “test” vehicles to consumers in LA, Washington and New York City. The following Monday, GM unveiled their hydrogen fuel-cell powered Sequel. And last Thursday, The General delivered a fleet of fuel cell Chevys to the US Army. Does this mean that GM Car Czar Maximum Bob Lutz is finally right about something; that GM’s “moon shot” will put Toyota’s hybrids to shame and save GM?

In these environmentally sensitive times, it’s hard to criticize the world’s largest automaker for developing “clean” hydrogen fuel cell technology. But not impossible. Even if hydrogen fuel cell vehicles were ready to compete with gasoline-powered vehicles, the technology would require a massive new hydrogen production and distribution infrastructure. Even if the trigger was pulled five years ago, we're still talking decades. In fact, Bob’s boasts are more pie-in-the-sky than moon mission. [Note: How about some independent confirmation of the Sequel’s 300 mile range? GM has a bit of a checkered history in this area.]

Bottome line: GM can no longer afford the distraction, currently pegged at $100m per year. But don’t take my word for it. When posing next to the Sequel, Maximum Bob promised to nudge GM’s Board into investing more money in the hydrogen economy. "It would probably replace some other programs that we'd like to have in the high-performance area," Bob admitted. Just in case you thought GM’s resident loose cannon might present a coherent case to the Board, he then declared that fuel cell vehicles would cost less to develop than engineering diesel-powered vehicles that meet the EPA's 2010 Tier 2 Bin 5 regulations.

Meanwhile, Honda has just announced a high mileage diesel engine that meets those stringent new pollution regulations. Although the system still faces some technical hurdles, Honda says it will sell the powerplant stateside within three years. Oh, and they’ve also created a flexible fuel system that can run on any ethanol to gasoline blend between 20 and 100 percent, which they’ll sell in Brazil later this year. Oh, and they’ve figured out a way to make a hydrogen fuel cell stack 20 percent smaller and 30 percent lighter, improving their FCX hydrogen-powered vehicle's operating range by 30 percent, beating the Sequel’s stat by 54 miles (354).

Once upon a time, GM led the world in automotive engineering. While the company still shows the occasional glimmer of greatness (e.g. Magnetic Ride Control), The General has lost/is losing the technological arms race. There may be nothing fundamentally wrong with the company’s pushrod engines, but the market says that hi-tech, high-mileage, variable-valve, free-revving four cylinder powerplants are the business. Gas – electric hybrids may not suit the majority of GM’s customers, but there’s no denying that the Prius has convinced The General’s public that Toyota owns both the high tech and environmental responsibility rep (in addition to reliability).

If Maximum Bob thinks GM is in a financial position to catch up with its rivals in hydrogen fuel cell technology– or any other major technical development– he’s wrong. MB’s suggestion that spending big money on fuel cells would only require the sacrifice of a few high performance models was disingenuous– which is why he later said that the money required might mean a “slight delay” for mainstream products. Although the press failed to push Lutz on the point, one wonders if GM’s Texas turnaround chainsaw massacre has left the company with sufficient warm bodies to engineer new models with existing technology, never mind perform ground-breaking “blue sky” research. 

In fact, there’s only one way GM can catch up with its high-tech rivals: buy their technology. When GM CEO Rick Wagoner jetted off to Japan to meet with Toyota’s CEO and talk about God knows what back in May ’05 , it was widely anticipated that Rabid Rick would license Toyota’s Synergy Hybrid Drive for The General’s vehicles. Whether or not such a deal was even on the table, GM missed an important opportunity to get its shit together. If The General’s new[ish] SUV’s had been released with Synergy Drive powertrains in situ, it would have at least limited the gas shock SUV exodus.

And here comes the bus again! When presenting his new clean diesel, Honda President Takeo Fukui said he was “open to considering” a licensing deal with interested automakers. While GM put a Honda engine into the Saturn Vue, the chances of The General going hat-in-hand to Honda for new engine technology are extremely slim. Despite all the talk about GM’s “new sense of urgency” and its ability to “finally face reality,” the same hubris that got GM where it isn’t today is still in place. If The General really understood the gravity of its position, if it really knew just how bad its products are relative to the competitions’, it would do whatever it takes to rectify the situation. It doesn’t so it won’t. 

By on September 25, 2006

81taint2222.jpgIt’s been many years since the media entertained spurious claims about the toxicity of automotive plastics. Guess what? They’re at it again; ready to alert the world to the “dangers” of the plasticizers that make dashboards supple and vinyl pliable. Both ABC’s The View and National Geographic Magazine (October 2006) took major shots at these chemicals, known collectively as phthalate esters. Without these plastics, every car interior would have all the allure and comfort of an up-armored military spec Humvee.

Even before David Ewan Duncan’s “The Pollution Within” gets into high gear, the National Geographic’s subhead links automotive plastics and toxicity: “Thanks to modern chemistry… SUVs hit 60 in six seconds. But such convenience has a price: Chemicals that suffuse modern life– from well known toxins to newer compounds with unknown effects– are building up in our bodies and sometimes staying there for years.” In the main piece, Duncan carefully avoids calling phthalates toxins. They’re “chemicals of concern.” But the implication is clear: phthalates are poisonous.

Phthalates are found in a wide range of everyday products: shampoo bottles, medical equipment, toys, food wrap, cosmetics, water bottles and [woo hoo!] sex toys. When plastics get hot, the phthalates leech out. The haze that films the inside of our windshields consists of phthalates that have “evaporated” out of interior plastics and collected on the glass. Long-term phthalate loss accounts for dashboards becoming increasingly brittle and splitting. Phthalates also account for new car smell as well as the funny taste of water from plastic bottles left in the sun.

The human body absorbs phthalates through the skin, orally or through the lungs. The chemicals don't stay inside us for long; our bodies break them down and pass them out within a few hours or a couple of days. Nor do the chemicals build up in our body tissues. Long term exposure is considered safe; the plastics industry has used them since the ‘20’s without any indication (i.e. lawsuit) that they cause acute or chronic illness.

In the late ‘90’s, these plasticizers came under fire for a myriad of alleged health concerns. Phthalates were accused of being estrogenic and suspected of causing cancer. The European Union reacted to the anti-phthalate hysteria by banning some phthalate-infused plastics from children’s toys. Once again, the chemicals are under the preventative health industry’s microscope.

Meanwhile, allegations that phthalates mimic estrogen, the female hormone, offer some curious possibilities. Do cars with more plastics yield more sensitive drivers? Indeed, if phthalate-laden interiors were used more, would there be less road rage? Would women of child bearing age become more fertile? Would menopausal women riding in cars experience less severe hot flashes? And, if the use of phthalates were banned for use in autos, would the highway safety devolve under an assault of testosterone-crazed drivers?

I jest. In fact, the research conclusions prompting the estrogen claim are deeply flawed. Absurdly large doses of phthalates were administered through the skin to rats, resulting in some birth defects (e.g. male offspring with more than two nipples.) While this result has been duplicated in other rodent studies, it’s never been replicated in animals that more closely resemble humans. (Human skin is known to be more resistant to chemical absorption than rats’.) Furthermore, humans are exposed to much higher levels of estrogen-mimicking chemicals from other sources, including wheat, soybeans, potatoes, carrots, apples and coffee. Obviously, no one is proposing banning any of these foodstuffs.

Dr. Scott D. Phillips of the University of Colorado’s Division of Clinical Pharmacology and Toxicology wrote in the Journal of the American Medical Association, “This mischaracterization of the scientific evidence [regarding phthalate exposure] reflects a lack of understanding of basic toxicological principles… We put chemical substances into our bodies daily that can cause harmful effects in animals. It is the dose that differentiates medicines from poisons.” Aspirin in low doses is a miracle drug – a near-panacea. Yet, many a desperate person has ended their own life by ingesting sufficient quantities aspirin. A British study of infants exposed to phthalates through milk fed through plastic containers found no risk, even when applying the European Union’s 100-fold safety margin.

The belief that phthalates cause cancer is wrong.  The suspect phthalate, known as DEHP, has been cleared by scores of peer-reviews and research studies. The study used as the basis for this claim is now viewed as “junk science” and the use of these plastics in toys, medical equipment or cars is deemed to pose no human health risk.

While there are many chemicals, natural and synthetic, that merit careful concern, forty years of extensive research indicates that phthalates are not among them. Nonetheless, a lie repeated often enough takes on the ring of truth. And public policy based on such distortions could profoundly affect our cars’ comfort.  So enjoy sitting in your car. Breathe deeply. Caress the soft plastics. And put your mind at ease.

By on September 25, 2006

bondaston.jpgIn 1984, an inebriated Henry Ford II met Victor Gauntlett in a London bar. Gauntlet controlled Aston Martin, a venerable British manufacturer of race cars and gentlemen’s sports sedans. Aston's sales were in the tank and there was no money to develop new models. “For a lousy $15 million, I’d sell the whole thing” Gauntlett said. Ford looked at his drinking buddy Walter Hayes and said, “Wouldn’t that shake ‘em up back in Dearborn?” In ’86, Ford bought 75% of Aston’s shares. In' 94, they bought the rest. Despite the fact that FoMoCo's investment has just come right, it's auction hammer time. So what's next for Aston?

Ford spent billions remaking Aston Martin into a modern car company, complete with reasonably reliable products and a up-to-date design, development, production and distribution process. Aston’s financial and manufacturing problems were resolved, and a few outstanding cars produced. The DB9 and Vanquish, for example, are worthy successors to the DB5’s and 6’s favored by Britain’s most famous (if fictional) spy. This year, after forty years of red ink, Aston finally turned a profit. 

Although the brand gained profitability, something was lost in translation: exclusivity. Last year, Aston Martin sold 4500 vehicles. The company's latest model, the Vantage V8, clocks in at a relatively inexpensive $110k. What’s more (lots more) the company plans on producing 3000 examples of their “baby Aston.” This is exactly the sort of over-reaching brand extension you’d expect from the folks who tried to sell the world a Jaguar that’s a lightly dressed Ford Mondeo and a Lincoln Zephyr that’s nothing more than a tarted-up Ford Fusion. Ford has amply demonstrated that no one in the company save Alan Mullaly (owner of the new Lexus 460) truly understands luxury cars and their rich customers.

Now that Aston Martin is on the block, its new owners should note that the brand’s revival is a relatively simple matter. All that’s required is a quick and decisive return to the upper stratosphere. First, the Vantage V8 should be retired. While car critics have welcomed the model with open arms (aside from our Mr. Shoemaker), there is no evidence that any of these reviews have been written by an enthusiast with an annual income of at least $1m and/or assets above $20m (aside, perhaps, from our Mr. Shoemaker). In a world of affordable Mercs, Bimmers, Bentleys, Maseratis and Porsches, Aston Martin should stand above the fray as an obscure object of desire. In other words, it should be REALLY expensive.

To that end, Aston Martin should take the DB9 ($165k), Rapide ($200k est.) and the Vanquish ($255k) even further upmarket. Ferrari regularly markets cars that cost twice as much as a DB9, and sells every one, often years before they get around to making them. The recent Zagato coupe and the upcoming DBS (only 300 due to be built) are perfect examples of the "car too far" the company should produce. A $500k Aston (or 50) would draw wealthy pistonheads to Aston showrooms like moths to a flame-surfaced BMW.

Next, the moth-eaten showrooms must be upgraded. To their credit, Aston Martin has started to upgrade their dealerships to yacht purchasing levels. But too many Aston showrooms are still annexes to the local Jaguar dealer. Asking multi-millionaires to rub shoulders with plumbers who just bought a $30k Jaguar is simply not on.

Aston Martin should also exploit their heritage. Their rich racing history seems to have been completely forgotten during the Ford years. The Royal connection also needs more play. Prince Charles might be perceived as a bit of an old Fuddy Duddy by young people, but Aston buyers aren’t generally young, and Aston’s Royal Warrant is a literally invaluable marketing tool.

Ressurecting Lagonda is the final part of the Aston Martin revival strategy. Although I recommended killing the V8 Vantage, it could serve as the first Lagonda. A Lagonda that catered to low-end luxury sports car buyers could help preserve Aston Martin's identity as a truly aspirational brand. The marketing strategy worked well enough back when LaSalle introduced less affluent customers to the Cadillac aura, without sullying the Cadillac brand. Today's Maserati is a stepping stone to Ferrari, just as the LaSalle primed buyers for the leap to a Cadillac. A Lagonda to Aston transition would work a treat, for both. 

Ford is reportedly asking $1 billion for Aston Martin. Another valuation, 100 times earnings, would value the English car brand at $1 million. For a price somewhere in between, and a billion or so in additional investment, savvy investors could return Aston Martin to its upmarket roots, beat Ferrari at its own game, merchandise for millions and show Ford exactly what they pissed– I mean, missed.

By on September 23, 2006

x07st_vu0092222.jpg A hypnotherapist once told me that he began every session by asking his subject to close the door, hand him a pen, move closer, etc. He said that the sooner his subjects learned to follow small commands, the sooner (and more likely) they’d follow the big ones. When I read that Michigan Representative Mike Rogers wants the federal government to guarantee $20b worth of loans to help domestic automakers develop alternative fuels, hybrids and other “energy saving technologies,” I knew it was the same deal. Rogers is training Uncle Sam to bail out the Big Two Point Five.

Of course, Rogers was quick to distance his legislative efforts to clean up the planet and reduce our dependence on foreign oil from the “b” word. “This isn't the dreaded bailout word," the Wolverine State pol assured the characteristically credulous Detroit News. "This isn't a free pass for them to avoid painful decisions or restructuring. This is a chance for the automakers to compete on a fair playing field with access to the credit markets." Rogers said his bill will "level the cost of investment capital in the United States between domestic and Japanese auto manufacturers." Huh?

Was Rogers saying that the so-called domestics’ downgraded credit ratings– a result of their inability to put their houses in order– make it difficult for them to invest in “green” technology and, thus, place them at a competitive disadvantage vis-à-vis the Japanese (ignoring the Koreans and Germans)? Yes. In case you missed the point, “This [bill] is about supporting real jobs for real Americans through innovation" and “Ford's survival is in America's interest.” And yet, Rogers said the federal loan guarantees would also be available to non-domestics– as long as the research was conducted in the United States (preferably Michigan).

Setting aside the issue of which automakers would be eligible to save hundreds of millions in interest payments thanks to Rogers’ ability to manipulate the federal government on their behalf, the republican rep wanted his conservative constituents to know his bill is a hand up, not a handout. "This bill is fiscally responsible because it requires the loans be paid back," Rogers insisted. "I don't think this bill will cost taxpayers one cent." Note: “think.” Not even a seasoned politician can completely gloss over the fact that if one of the beneficiaries of his/our federal largesse goes belly-up, it’ll be sayonara to billions of bucks.

Which is why The Big Two Point Five gave Rogers’ proposal a lukewarm reception; they don’t want workers, suppliers, dealers, customers and banks to think they’re teetering on the edge of abyss. On the other hand… "It's an intriguing idea that merits consideration,” PR flack Greg Martin opined. “But right now our turnaround and our success rests on the advanced technology that we are putting in our cars and trucks today." (Pushrods rock!) "We find it encouraging that there is support from Congress to accelerate green technology," Ford spokesman Mike Moran said. DCX, whose existence owes much to federal loan guarantees, let its silence speak for itself.

Despite wrapping his $20b loan guarantee program in politically correct environmentalism and flag waving patriotism, Rogers’ bill doesn’t stand much of a chance. Not with an administration that can’t seem to reschedule a meeting between President Bush and the heads of America’s domestic automakers. Besides, staking our tax money on The Big Two Point Five’s ability to develop energy saving technologies? How’re those domestic hybrids selling anyway? Roger’s efforts are simply a bit more political grandstanding in the pre-election silly season; the obverse of California AG’s lawsuit against selected automakers for destroying the state’s ozone layer.

And yet Roger’s doomed bill presages the fun to come. Can/should/will Uncle Sam ride to Ford and GM’s financial rescue as it did for Chrysler? The bailout “debate” is on its way, pitting Ford and/or GM’s political muscle against capitalist theory. Most observers don’t rate the Big Two’s chances of sucking on the federal tit immediately before– or after– bankruptcy papers are filed. The imports' manufacturing beachhead on US soil and the domestics’ relatively small market share make their failure less of an issue than it was back when Chrysler was “too big to fail.”

Even so, the domestics’ end game will occur entirely in the political realm, where common sense plays second fiddle to emotions, and performances are orchestrated by people whose ability to maintain power depends on their ability to maintain appearances. In any case, if we begin drip feeding The Big Two Point Five now, it’ll make it that much easier to continue to do so in the future, which will make it that much more difficult for these companies to implement the fundamental changes they must make for their resurrection and long-term survival.

Recent Comments

  • Lou_BC: @Carlson Fan – My ’68 has 2.75:1 rear end. It buries the speedo needle. It came stock with the...
  • theflyersfan: Inside the Chicago Loop and up Lakeshore Drive rivals any great city in the world. The beauty of the...
  • A Scientist: When I was a teenager in the mid 90’s you could have one of these rolling s-boxes for a case of...
  • Mike Beranek: You should expand your knowledge base, clearly it’s insufficient. The race isn’t in...
  • Mike Beranek: ^^THIS^^ Chicago is FOX’s whipping boy because it makes Illinois a progressive bastion in the...

New Car Research

Get a Free Dealer Quote

Who We Are

  • Adam Tonge
  • Bozi Tatarevic
  • Corey Lewis
  • Jo Borras
  • Mark Baruth
  • Ronnie Schreiber