Category: Editorials

By on August 24, 2006

2007expedition_4652222.jpg Last Friday, Ford announced its largest production cuts in over two decades. The bold (not to say unavoidable) move comes in the face of evaporating truck sales; even large discounts on the formerly formidable F150 and Explorer can't move the metal faster than it's being built. With a debt rating that’s sleeping with the fishes, with the company’s “Way Forward” recovery plan in triage, with another disastrous quarter only days away, Ford is looking increasingly, irredeemably desperate.

The cutbacks are large in both scope and scale. Ford’s rolling production blackouts will hit ten assembly plants in total. The Blue Oval Boys will reduce output by some 21% for this year’s final financial quarter, shrinking total vehicle production to just over three million vehicles for the year (roughly nine percent behind ‘05 totals). Ford truck plants will fare the worst, losing 404k units from previous annual output targets.

That's not good. Last year, Ford’s F-Series pickup trucks accounted for nearly a third of the company’s 3.2m US sales total (or more than seven times Volvo's American sales). For the first time in three years, the F-Series will not reach its sales target— not even the revised 900k mark recently put forth by embattled CEO Mark Fields. With over 270k units depreciating on dealer lots, America’s best selling truck will bear the brunt of at least half of the cuts.

No matter how you look at it, coming-up short is gonna hurt. Ford’s Michigan Truck factory was once one of the world’s most profitable production facilities; through the late 90’s, it generated some $10b in annual revenue. While Ford doesn’t divulge production costs or profit margins for its individual vehicles, analysts indicate that each F-series pickup delivered $13k in profit. The evaporating truck market has put Ford’s cash cow on the barbie, and there aren’t any newborns ready to lactate greenbacks on their behalf.

Falling revenues are only half the problem. J.P. Morgan analyst Himanshu Patel figures Ford’s decision to downsize production will cost the company $1.4b this year, and around $2.7b in 2007. The main reason: Ford’s current contract with the United Auto Workers (UAW). Idled union workers will receive a Supplemental Unemployment Benefits (SUB) package. After an initial period of partial government support, Ford will have to pay them 95% of their normal take home pay for a 40-hour work week, for not working.  Union members with at least ten years’ service will still receive full employer-paid health insurance.

Looking ahead, the UAW contract also stipulates that no union worker can be laid off for more than 48 weeks due to a decline in sales or production. While it’s doubtful that production would halt for that long, the 48 weeks is cumulative for the entire four year agreement. Short term, expanding their blue collar buyout program is the only way for Ford to staunch their “death by a thousand cuts” labor cost wounds.

Unconfirmed reports indicate that Ford will put buyout offers on the table to all their hourly workers in the next week. UAW V.P. Bob King has already stated that he could convince his brothers to stay home– for the right price. But none of this will solve Ford’s cash crunch. Only an immediate series of blockbuster new products and a new, more favorable union contract can do that— neither of which is likely.

Again, there's no immediate relief on the product front. Sales of fuel-sipping B-segment cars are up 43 percent and growing. In most urban markets, Honda, Nissan and Toyota dealers can’t keep up with demand for their Fit, Versa and Yaris, which are selling at full retail or, wait for it, better. Despite finally admitting the seriousness of this market, Ford has yet to announce a B-segment buster.

Meanwhile, Ford’s desperation is there for all to see. Yesterday’s announcement that FoMoCo would follow GM’s lead and offer up to 72 months of zero percent financing to anyone with a pulse is a clear-cut indication that Ford is willing to do anything to stay in business— including cheapening the brand and mortgaging their future. Ford isn’t even trying hard to hide the fact that they’ve thrown open their doors to sub-prime borrowers. "If you were on the margin for being approved for a loan,” Ford flackmeister Jim Cain said. “You are more likely to get a loan today than you were a week ago."

The question is, is Ford more likely to avoid Chapter 11 than it was a week ago?  Ford's market share is still declining rapidly– from last year's 25.7% to this year's 18.1%. The company would like you to believe that the production cuts reflect a new, new realism and demonstrate management’s courage to make difficult decisions. Which may be true. But the old maxim “You can’t cut your way to prosperity” is just as true for Ford as it is for GM and DCX. Ford is still poised for breakup, merger or bankruptcy.

By on August 24, 2006

15-07-tundra222.jpgTiming is. Everything. Case in point: Toyota is about roll out its re-designed Tundra. The full-size pickup represents a huge investment for the automaker, including a brand new factory deep in the heart of Texas. By all accounts, the new Tundra will hit the market just as “lifestyle” load luggers have left the building, abandoning the genre for smaller, more fuel efficient machines. But as bad as Toyota’s timing may be for their corporate aspirations, it's worse for the so-called domestics.

It’s no secret that the majority of The Big Two Point Five’s profits (such as they are) come from SUV’s and pickup trucks. Nor is it a revelation that the enormous profits generated by the genre during the last two decades enabled their short-sighted product lethargy. Now that America’s truck optional buyers are leaving their gas-guzzling leviathans in droves, the Big Two Point Five are feeling the pain of putting all their eggs in a truck-shaped basket.

The Mustang is the only main-line car generating significant profit for Ford, and both GM and Chrysler are building direct competitors. DCX has the 300 and the Caliber, but their product mix is still heavily skewed towards SUV’s and pickups. GM is thoroughly truck-dependent. All three companies are busy retrenching, slicing production to match the new marketplace realities. All are incurring huge costs. When it comes to their line of profitable pickups, none are looking for a fight. But a fight is what they’re gonna get.

Many industry types scoff at the prospect. Toyota has been selling full-size pickups of one sort of another for over a decade, without great success. Nissan’s Titan jumped into the fray a couple years ago, to equally modest sales. Their failure to crack this money rich market segment begs the question: what have The Big Two Point Five done right?

Possibility one: the so-called domestics make great trucks. Despite general problems with vehicle quality, the Big Two Point Five have managed not to create a large pool of angry pickup truck buyers. Sure, they’ve built some duds, but nothing dire enough to alienate customers. The foreign owned automakers’ “full size” pickups have also been rather smaller, to no great advantage.

Possibility two: loyalty. The so-called domestics tout loyalty as their trump card, and concentrate their attention on beating each other up. But loyalty hasn’t kept foreign-owned automakers from making inroads into the compact pick-up business. And it hasn’t stopped Toyota from overtaking Ford in the overall U.S. sales chart.

Possibility three: luck. It’s not what Ford and GM have done; it’s what Nissan and Toyota haven’t done. Until now, Toyota and Nissan haven’t built the right products or added enough production capacity to build a significant number of pickups trucks.

Toyota is set to attack on all fronts. The company has spent hundreds of millions of dollars to create a Tundra that’s a match for the industry leader, the Ford F150. The new Tundra is bigger and stronger; more macho, durable and comfortable than any previous Toyota entry. If that isn’t enough to lure brand loyalists, Toyota will do whatever it takes to recoup their investment. With new American production capacity north of 250k units per year (and room for more), Toyota will react to market indifference by launching a price war.

There are two main reasons profit margins on pickup trucks are so high: supply and demand. In the last few months, U.S. pickup sales have tanked, flooding dealers with product, forcing incentives, driving down margins, slicing profit. The injection of tens of thousands of new Tundras into the market will surely accelerate this trend. Toyota’s non-union cost advantage, their never-say-die, take-no-prisoners attitude and their deep pockets all guarantee that it's only a matter of time before they undercut prices and force the so-called domestics’ to pare pickup profits to the bone.

Initially, the fleet sector may see the most action. On its home turf, Toyota puts a lot of energy into grabbing fleet clients to sew-up market share. Fleet buyers are far less brand loyal than private buyers; business owners are far more amenable to rational arguments. You can bet Tundra salesmen are busy boning up on their cost of ownership charts.

Truth be told, the so-called domestics are well-positioned to stave off the threat— at least in the short term. Their pickups may be mechanically simple, but they’re highly evolved with more than reasonable reliability. No matter how good Toyota’s Tundra or low its price, conquest sales will be a bitch. But The Big Two Point Five are vulnerable; they can’t afford to fight on price. They need every pickup truck buck to fund their new product plans. DCX may not suffer badly (for now). But Ford and GM are so cost-heavy, cash-starved and product deficient that fierce pickup competition could mean that their time at the top of the heap is finally over.

By on August 23, 2006

54darrincardb2222.jpgFirst off, I’d like to ask you a favor. Could you please take a couple of minutes and fill out this survey? The suits at FM Publishing want to hook potential Truth About Cars (TTAC) advertisers on the quality of our readership. As you are all Harvard MBA’s earning seven figure salaries ready to buy whatever high-priced goods we tout, FM should have no problem landing a major sponsorship deal with BMW (you know, aside from the whole flying vagina thing). No really; do what we do: tell the truth. Much obliged. Now, to my main point: should TTAC post once or twice a day, or more?

Last night, TTAC contributor Stephan Wilkinson returned from a somnambulistic sojourn at the Pebble Beach Concours D’Elegance. He fired up his Mac and discovered a large pile of our New Content Notification emails sitting on his e-mat. Wilkinson was not pleased. STOP CRANKING OUT SO MUCH MATERIAL! Wilkinson wrote that TTAC’s twice daily editorial output threatens to overwhelm readers with automotive information.

There’s evidence to support Wilkinson’s “no mas” position. Every time I put up a new post, at least fifteen subscribers unsub. The dearly departed who reply to my “Oops” email report that they’re drowning in TTAC emails (which renders my email a heavily ironic gesture). I’ve responded to these protests by A) shutting off the New Content Notification System as of today and B) commissioning Redwing Studios to create a program that will allow subscribers to limit/eliminate their New Content Notification emails. But the central point remains: two 800-word posts a day had dozens of subscribers hanging up the cybernetic do not disturb sign.

Is less be more? Would you be happier with just one post per day? As a jobbing journalist used to cramming prose into the infobeast like a French farmer preparing a duck’s liver for foie gras, the idea of cutting back on content scares me witless. In fact, I’m so freaked by the prospect I’m reluctant to try an experimental literary liposuction. But I can certainly see the advantages of streamlining our operations, for both of us.

Posting once a day would liberate editorial time/money we could use to improve each article. We could pay our writers more (maintaining their loyalty). We could afford our own review photographs and, perhaps, add video. We could bring back the stats and stars, in an expanded form (similar to the system I designed for Jalopnik). It would give me more time to commission, think and hone. And once-a-day frequency would give our highly intelligent, worldly and literate readers a full 24 hours to hash out the issues raised by each post. On the other hand…

I want TTAC to kick ass. Providing you’re not a triskaidekaphobe, click on “editorials” button at the top menu bar. I’ve split the content into 13 sections. In an ideal world, I’d have reporters for each of these beats. Even if we Zen down to once post per day, the math doesn’t quite ad up: lots of writers, lots of stories, seven posts. In other words, if TTAC published once-a-day, critical stories could get left behind.

Of course, that’s not your problem per se. TTAC’s strives to provide the highest quality automotive writing we can, in a form and frequency that suits you. So, again, I put it to you, the life and soul of this website. How often would you like TTAC to publish new material? Assume that the NCN email problem is solved and that maintaining our current pace (or more) would not require sacrificing quality. Meanwhile and in any case, thank you for your patience, consideration and support.  

By on August 22, 2006

darpa_challenge_sandstorm222.jpg Driving talent is as rare as the ability to play a sitar. Driver training is a joke. Driver testing is the punch line. In fact, there’s only one thing keeping the highway fatality rate from ascending epidemically: the car. Electronic braking aids, traction control, stability control, handling improvements, crumple zones, airbags, seatbelt systems, stadium-bright lighting, pavement shredding brakes, tires so good they make ‘70’s rubber look like wagon wheels— these are our saviors. And it’s time to take the next step: automation.

Cars should take all meaningful driving tasks away from the driver: braking, accelerating, steering, cornering, judging distances, interpreting (or even simply noticing) traffic signals and signs. I’m talking about a fully automated automobile; one where Nav screens and multi-media controller thingies no longer say, “Don’t be distracted by me while you’re driving.” A car where the computerized brain monitors your attention and begs you to be distracted, to play with the screen rather than messing with the car’s important controls.

There’s precedent. The now-ancient joke among airline pilots is that glass-cockpit crews still number three: pilot, copilot and a German shepherd trained to bite either of them if they touch any of the controls. Airliners are already totally automated, from takeoff to landing, and the skies have never been safer. If highly-trained professional pilots subvert their skills to safety technology for the greater good, shouldn’t we remove control of our two ton transports from Joe Sixpack?

When I say “automatic cars” I don’t mean the goofy things we used to see in Popular Science in the ‘80s: a freight train of Pontiac Bonnevilles doing 60 mph down The Highway of the Future, their bumpers six inches apart as they followed a buried signal cable like six beagles sniffing a collie’s cooter. Buried cables cost a gazillion dollars and require ripping trenches down the middle of every highway lane in the country. As Bill Gates discovered fifteen minutes after installing miles of fiber optic in his mega-mansion on Lake Washington, wireless rules.

And so it is with automated cars. Thanks to burgeoning wireless technology, everything to make the automated car work is already on shelves or in stationary orbit. We have all the tools we need to make a “driverless car”: motion and distance sensors, transponders, GPS receivers and telematics (the real-time, two-way systems used by On-Star, Lo-Jack, EZ-Pass, etc.); electronic steering, throttle and brakes. Create some complex algorithms and software to combine everything into an intelligent and (relatively) failsafe control system and you’re done. Literally.

If you doubt the automated car is coming, don’t. Mercedes’ intelligent cruise control– an automatic system that maintains a safe distance between cars– is a sign of things to come. From there, it’s a short step to building cars that talk to each other, facilitating the same sort of automated collision avoidance systems used by jetliners. And so it goes. Tires will calculate their coefficient of friction and adjust the throttle accordingly. Satnav will keep your car within its lane. And then it's stop signs and traffic lights that order your car to stop. Eventually you’ll have no more to say about your speed than you do aboard Amtrak.

Enthusiasts will argue that forcing drivers into automated cars is using a sledgehammer to crack a walnut. “Better driver education” is needed. “More testing. Stricter standards. Relicensing every two years. Traffic tickets for bad driving technique, not for skillful speeding.” Oh, absolutely. I also think driver’s licenses should be restricted to college graduates. That anybody weighing over 300 pounds should be made to live in North Dakota. And every U.S. citizen should be required to pass an annual spelling and grammar test in order to be granted an Internet-access license. That isn’t going to happen either.

Before posting dozens of specious reasons why the fully automated car can’t or won’t work— people won’t stand for it, lawyers won’t allow it, you can’t cover every country road, etc.– once again, consider the underlying rationale. We— you, me, every multi-tasker scarfing a breakfast burrito, every bozo in a pickup truck convinced he’s Dale Junior, every amateur street racer driving a ZO6 with all the talent of an XBox twiddler— are the problem. For that reason alone, the fully automated car will happen. As for cultural considerations…

Two thousand years, your horse was just as much a mark of wealth, virility and personal skill as a 911 Turbo or WRX is today. Millions of Saracens, Conquistadors, cavalrymen and cowboys would have told you that you were full of manure to suggest that one day, nobody but jockeys and hobbyists would ride a horse. I think it was Ferdinand Porsche who said that the last horse on earth will be a racehorse, and that the last car will be a racecar. So take heart, enthusiasts.

 

By on August 21, 2006

audi.jpg While GM and Ford continue their slow-motion fall from grace, Audi’s headed in the other direction. The German automaker’s U.S. sales are up, moving towards record levels. The company has a raft of new vehicles on dealers’ lots and more models on their way– from mid-market entry level models to the new TT roadster to the R8 supercar. Audi’s interiors are still the industry standard for design, fit and finish. They’re modifying their distribution system to increase customer choice and reduce dealer inventories. So is all well with Audi?  Yes and no.

Continuing on the yes side, Audi is poised to introduce a range of diesel powered vehicles into the U.S. market. The move comes just in time to meet pent-up demand for high mileage vehicles capable of exploiting federal “clean diesel” regulations, and may include a headline grabbing, brand-burnishing, diesel-powered sports car (the TT). At the same time, Audi has the fuel-efficient engines it needs to stay in the hunt for sales of luxury sports cars, hatchbacks, wagons and sedans.

Audi may also have discovered the “next big thing:” mid and full size hatchbacks. The American market has moved from SUV’s (with true off-road capabilities) to CUV’s (cars masquerading as SUV’s). The jump from CUV to hatchback is a logical progression (foreshadowed by the now discontinued Audi Allroad). Whether by luck or design, Audi’s ready. For model year ’09 / ’10, every model in Audi’s lineup will have a hatchback version, including their biggest model, the A8. Audi’s bread and butter A4 will be available as a sedan, wagon and hatchback. So what could go wrong?

Although Audi is well past the “sudden unintended acceleration” PR disaster that threw the company’s U.S. sales into reverse during the 80’s, reliability is the marque’s new bugaboo. While sister VW’s recent quality problems are well known, Audi owners have also been plagued with their unfair share of mechanical ailments, often without satisfactory resolution at the dealer level.

The problem is reflected by Audi’s dismal performance in JD Powers’ reliability surveys. As a direct result of these issues, Audis suffer frightening depreciation; negatively affecting leasing rates and new car sales. It’s a problem that must be sorted at both the factory gates and on the sharp end– the sooner, the better.

Meanwhile, Audi faces some important branding questions. For example, when three Audis recently received the Insurance Institute’s highest crash test rating, the company advertised the fact on TV. Since when is Audi Volvo? In fact, what is an Audi? While Ingolstadt makes some sporty cars, BWM still have that spin spun. Quality? Lexus. Prestige? Mercedes. Bargain? Infiniti. Bargain barge? Cadillac. Quirky? Acura. When you’re trying to make your move in the highly competitive luxury car market, you need to stand for something.

For years, Audi’s Quattro four wheel-drive system has been the industry leader. Audi has added the world’s slickest paddle shift/automatic transmission (DSG) to the equation. They also possess one of the best engines: a dependable and punchy four cylinder 2.0-liter turbo. If you combine Quattro, DSG and the 2.0T, you create an incredibly resourceful machine. The car can tackle severe weather conditions with confidence, deliver an exhilarating sporting experience on dry roads and waft with automatic ease in traffic. All this and entirely reasonable gas mileage.

Instead of publicly proclaiming their vague, boastful and indefensible “Never Follow” mantra, Audi should be touting themselves as master of the “practical sports sedan.” While the two-seat TT has carved a nice little niche for itself, blessing the brand with metrosexual glamour, and the R8 looks to be a terrific halo car, the company’s fortunes surely lie within its core competency: sure-footed sporting automobiles.

More specifically, Audi should concentrate on building and importing the “shooting brake” (a.k.a. sportback) concept car introduced at the Tokyo Motor Show. If Audi equipped the sportback with DSG, a 230hp version of the 2.0T powerplant (or a diesel) and Quattro four wheel-drive, they’d have America’s most versatile and practical sports car. With marginal restraint (so to speak), the sportback could generate significant U.S. profits.

Instead, Audi’s unleashed the Q7: a late-to-market, aesthetically-challenged, gas-guzzling SUV. What’s more, even though U.S. SUV sales are tanking (including arch rival Porsche Cayenne), Audi’s committed to expanding their SUV line to include the slightly smaller Q5 and smaller still Q3 SUV. The move will win few converts, dilute the brand’s message (such as it is) and distract them from their main mission.

Audi has some terrific products. But the way the company has used its tools does not bode well for their future. Audi doesn’t seem to understand its current strengths, or know how to carve-out a path to greater sales and profitability that takes advantage of those strengths. Like Detroit, Audi needs to do a little soul-searching and renew its focus on its “real” identity: fun-to-drive four-wheel drive sedans.   

By on August 21, 2006

fig_03222.jpgHow easy is your car to use?  I'm not talking about acceleration, steering or cornering. I'm talking about the mental effort required to successfully interact with your car’s secondary features, such as in-car entertainment or the trip computer. While controls like steering (the brilliant simplicity of a wheel), throttle (foot pedal farthest to the right) and braking (second-to-right pedal) are standardized for most vehicles certified for use on a public road, the majority of other controls are confusing enough to plunge an automotive reviewer (or a Hertz Platinum Club member) into RTFM rage.

Sometimes it’s a simple matter of old habits dying hard: in many ways the best interface is one you don't have to re-learn. If you're used to having to jab at a button several times to adjust the temperature several degrees while surveying the change on a display that’s located on the opposite hemisphere of the dash, that may be the best user interface—for you.

But that’s not the whole story when something as basic as starting the car has now taken on innumerous forms. Do you A) insert the key in a slot (to the right or left of the steering wheel or in the center console) and turn it or B) insert the key in a hole and push it or C) insert the key into a slot and push a start button or D) ignore the key altogether as long as it's on your person and then either push a button or twist a piece of plastic adjacent to the steering wheel? Each of these methods are used by at least one current production car—and I’m sure I’ve missed at least one type of ignition sequence.

Changing gears is a similar issue. If you want to upshift using an automatic transmission with a shift-it-yourself mode, do you tap the shifter forward, backward or to the right? Or do you use buttons on the steering wheel? If you use steering wheel buttons, do you push the button on the right to upshift or on the back to downshift and the front to upshift?  Or does the car instead use paddles behind the steering wheel? Which paddle do you use? Do you push or pull?  And in case you want to shift while turning, do the paddles rotate with the steering wheel or are they stationary?

Even something as simple as automatic door locks come complete with their own set of usability issues.  Do they lock when you put the car in Drive or when you reach a preset speed? Do they automatically unlock when you put the car back in Park?  Do they automatically unlock when you pull the interior door handle, and if so, in the back seat or just the front?  How do you disable them? Can you disable them?  Can you even answer these questions about your own car?

Clearly, usability and interface design principles are taking a backseat to aesthetics and automakers’ oddly conflicting compulsions to be both trendy and unique.  The problem is compounded by the unprecedented numbers of features being added to new cars, such as satellite radio and navigation, iPod integration, DVD players, Bluetooth cell phone connections, four-zone climate control, OnStar, heated and cooled massaging memory seats, etc. Without well-thought-out ways of interacting with these new features, the result is anarchy.  I’d like to know how many times BMW Assist has been summoned by X5 drivers who thought they were opening their sunroofs, since the corresponding buttons are poorly marked, nearly identical, and adjacent to each other in matching wells, for no apparent reason other than BMW’s ever-questionable ideas regarding aesthetics.

Annoyances aside, this is a serious matter. Among products that most of us deal with on a day-to-day basis, cars inhabit a special subcategory: products that regularly cause death.  Anything that requires us to dawdle too long with an in-car interface literally puts lives in danger, yet cars are still often poorly thought out or designed with form over function. No matter your opinion on how easy BMW’s iDrive controller is to learn, there’s no getting around the fact that you have to take your eyes off the road for significant periods of time to navigate through its seemingly endless hierarchy of menus.

While manufacturers may be aware of the problem, they’re not very good at solving it. They often seem to simply compete in shoehorning more features into fewer buttons, birthing such disastrous ideas as the aforementioned 11-way haptic feedback control knob (a.k.a. iDrive) and nearly equally—though differently—awful in-car voice recognition. For enthusiasts, these issues are particularly pressing. Any device which gets between them and driving is, rightly, reviled.  Any device that adds to their enjoyment without frustrating them is celebrated. For hi-tech-loving manufacturers, designing a car that’s easy-to-use that pleases the cognoscenti isn’t proving easy. 

By on August 20, 2006

montoya.jpg Formula One has lost two of its unique drivers: Juan Pablo Montoya and Jacques Villeneuve. Montoya was dumped— I mean, Ron Dennis decided that "with so many things happening in Juan Pablo’s life right now, he should take some time out of the car and prepare professionally and personally for the future.” Perhaps Mr. Dennis was referring to Montoya’s appearance at a press conference in front of sponsors' banners not affiliated with McLaren Mercedes, announcing he'd secured a seat in next year's NASCAR series…

Jacques Villeneuve has also departed the sport. Immediately after the German Grand Prix, Villeneuve informed Sauber-BMW that the injuries he sustained during the race meant he was “not ready” to race in Hungary. Without any further ado, the team ditched the Canadian for Robert Kubica, who became the first Polish driver in Formula One. After a brilliant drive, Villeneuve's "temporary replacement" became permanent.

Say what you will about Montoya and Villeneuve’s driving abilities, they were two of the most colorful characters on the F1 grid. Montoya’s combative Latin temperament always shone through in his driving. He won the CART Title in 1999 and the Indianapolis 500 in 2000, both on his first attempt. Montoya’s skill and determination also gave Toyota its first CART win that same year. In 2001, he switched to F1 with Williams-BMW and won the Italian Grand Prix. In 2002, Montoya scooped seven pole positions with no wins. Disillusioned with Williams, he signed to drive for McLaren for 2005. With both Williams and McLaren he won seven out of the ninety-five races in which he competed.

Villeneuve was also a CART star. In 1995, only his second year in the series, he won both the Indianapolis 500 and the CART title. With the help of Bernie Ecclestone, he secured a ride in the Williams-Renault. Driving the best car in the field, Villeneuve grabbed pole position in his first race. He followed that accomplishment with two more poles and four wins in 1996. In 1997 the Frenchman earned ten pole positions, seven wins and the F1 championship. Since 1997 Villeneuve has neither been on pole nor scored a win. He won eleven races out of the one hundred sixty five in which he competed.

When explaining his decision to abandon Formula One for NASCAR, Montoya stated that he “wasn’t enjoying the races.” He also justified his decision by claiming “I had done everything I had to do and I had achieved almost all the goals that I had. I only needed to win a title and I realized my chances were very small. Leaving was the best decision that I could have made.”  And in case you missed the point: “to fight for fifth position is not amusing.” While the statement was a standard rhetorical spin out, at least it showed a bit of tact.

Villeneuve took a rather less diplomatic approach. His first target was seven times champ Michael Schumacher. “He's a racer – but a pure racer, nothing but a racer and because of that, I think the day he hangs up his helmet people will just forget him”. And, “Michael simply isn't a great Champion because he's played too many dirty tricks and because he isn't a great human being. Yes, Senna played dirty tricks too but he did it with more class, more integrity. When he took Prost out at Suzuka in 1990, he said he was going to do it before the race.” So, playing dirty tricks is acceptable as long as you tell your fellow drivers that you will do it beforehand?

[As of this writing, Michael Schumacher owns the records for wins (89), pole positions (68), championships (7), fastest race laps (74), and most total points (1,338). It will be a long time before anyone forgets Michael Schumacher.]

Villeneuve’s next target was his former team. “I’ve led races, I’ve won races. I know how to do that. So I guess the question as to whether I’d drive for BMW next year was this: did BMW think they needed someone next year who could lead and win races? If they did, then they’d need me. If they didn’t then they wouldn’t. It just depended on how ambitious they were.”

When I think of “Villeneuve” I will always think of Gilles Villeneuve and Ferrari. People still talk about his wheel banging with Rene Arnoux in the 1979 French GP while fighting for 2nd place. Same goes for his heroic win in the 1981 Spanish GP, where he held up the 2nd through 5th place finishers for the final 18 laps. When I think of Jacques Villeneuve, I remember his recently released music video, which makes George Michael look butch by comparison.

Montoya will be missed. Jacques who?

By on August 20, 2006

intersport.jpgSuccessful racing teams don’t normally change drivers mid-season. A switch usually requires a Ricky Bobby type antic, a messy public encounter between pilot and Hawaiian Tropics model, sickness, injury or death. Team owner Roger Penske’s recent decision to shuffle drivers for his LeMans P2 Porsche RS Spyder is the exception that proves the rule. In fact, Penske isn’t punishing anyone for anything; he’s merely stacking the deck against his less-well funded competitors.

At a press briefing last week, Penske announced that he was splitting his two drivers– Sacha Massen and Lucas Luhr– into two identical, identically prepared Porsche RS Spyders. Massen will now be joined by fellow factory driver Timo Bernhard, the man famous for having the highest number of “fastest laps” of any GT2 driver in series history. Luhr buddies-up with Romain Dumas, a race car driver who finished in the top five in his class during every one of his three years in the ALMS series. Given the racing pedigree of the men behind the wheel of both cars, the sub-teams should provide formidable competition.

Of course, they are driving a car that’s the class of the field. Porsche’s factory racing team developed the RS Spyder at the request of Porsche Motorsports North America (PMNA). The chassis was developed by the German automaker’s engineers at their Weissach development center. Its V8 racing engine is an entirely new design that pumps out 500 – 600 horsepower (depending on intake restrictors). Although the car was developed for unnamed privateer teams, Roger Penske inked an exclusive contract to campaign the machine during this, its maiden season.

The car debuted at the ALMS finale at Laguna Seca last year. On its initial outing, the RS Spyder dominated the competition. It's set a blistering pace this year, usually taking the fastest lap in practice. Since then, Penske’s Spyder has traded wins for most of the season. And yet… the Penske boys are five points behind the much smaller and considerably less funded Intersport Racing Team. The main reason: reliability. Despite the owner’s deep pockets and his talented support crew, Penske’s mob hasn’t been able to shake out all the car’s gremlins. Penske chose to skip Le Mans for fear that his car would be stricken by the same mechanical issues that have haunted the car elsewhere. 

At Sebring, the number six car was forced to relinquish its lead by pitting just 35 minutes into the race with a bad alternator. The number seven car lead early but was forced to pit due to electrical problems falling back to 29th. They were able to get back into the top three, but ground to a halt trackside in hour seven, sidelined by a broken input shaft.  At Houston, the car suffered a terminal drive train problem while commanding the overall lead. Clearly, the Penske Spyder is fast, but it’s not robust enough to string together enough wins to clinch the series. Hence Penske’s calculation that two cars will double his odds of one of them surviving long enough to take the checkered flag.

Not if The Intersport Racing Team has anything to say about it. The current series leader enters the battle heavily out gunned; they’re running a new Lola B05/40 chassis with a four-cylinder, turbocharged AER engine with a recently enlarged intake restrictor. But what Intersport lacks in funding and firepower it makes up for with heart. Their drivers are Clint Field, a fresh-faced 23-year old from the Buckeye state, and Liz Halliday, an expert horse rider with Olympic aspirations.  Anyone who saw them persevere at Sebring to take the highest ever LMP2 finish knows they never say die.

Most teams would be discouraged to learn that Roger Penske and Porsche have teamed-up to compete in their class. They would be twice as disheartened to hear that Penske had “doubled-up.” But the Intersport Team has taken the entire saga in stride. Every time the Penske boys have wavered, Intersport has seized the day. Of course, it doesn’t hurt that Penske and Intersport are the only LMP2 teams competing full time in the series since the B-K Motorsports rotary-powered Mazda bowed-out earlier this year.

Ironically, the lack of a large field of competitors has made for an exciting season. The race at Portland was particularly thrilling, when the number 6 Penske Spyder surrendered a five lap lead with 15 minutes left in the race, due to a catastrophic engine failure on a routine pit stop. Penske’s efforts to secure the championship by swamping the competition may remove some of this excitement. But we certainly shouldn''t dismiss the never-say-never Intersport team. Time will tell how this drama will unfold: a Cinderella story with a fairly tale ending for Intersport, or a brutally efficient campaign delivering a resounding victory for Roger Penske. Watch this space.

By on August 19, 2006

lc9u193422222.jpg Never in my wildest dreams would I have imagined that a less-than-flattering Buick Lucerne review would score me a road test reprise on Prince Edward Island, Canada. Thanks to an internet-savvy Buick flackmeister determined to show me the light, the deal went down. Of course, RF pointed out that a junket courtesy of a diss-missed manufacturer was not without its dangers: brow-beating, brainwashing, alcohol poisoning and/or failed brakes. So I brought my Mom.

The five Buick Lucernes parked outside our hotel were a thing of beauty. Waxed to perfection, the factory orange peel provided reasonable reassurance that our press cars weren’t specially prepped ringers. As the Lucerne's Product manager gave us the usual product demo, I fixated on the Magnaride exhibit. Like sand in an hourglass, two saimesed syringes filled with Magnaride's iron-goo morph from maple-syrup smooth to unyielding concrete, depending on proximity to an external magnet. Damn, that's cool.

ADD episode over, I retreated to the gorgeous looking Lucerne's decadent interior. Product-guru Drew Kraisinger requested and gained permission to climb aboard. Mom retreated into the backseat to overhear a little Quiet Tuned susurration.

Touring the Canadian island confirmed one thing: the Lucerne CXS' ride and handling balance feels great on smooth roads at Matlock speeds. Catch island fever, though and you'll soon discover that the big Buick ain't no Hawaii Five-0 cop car. Even a mildly-aggressive downhill curve at 55mph sends the brittle tires howling in disapproval. Bumpy roads force the 18" rims into a chassis-crashing frenzy, leaving the front subframe dazed and confused.

I bitched and moaned while Product Guru Drew listened patiently, sending Mom down memory lane. She recalled my youthful ability to bombard car salesmen with facts and figures delivered in a manner befitting an American shock and awe campaign. Yes, and Mom knows Buicks. In fact, I figure she earned this junket by purchasing a two-toned, limited-grade, gas-sipping Buick Century during the brand’s (and Detroit’s) previous dark age (the early 1980s).

Now that Mom inhabits the Lucerne’s intended demographic (i.e. someone old enough to remember Rowan and Martin’s Laugh-in), Buick's press rep actively elicited her opinions. When pressed, Mom praised the Buick’s styling, comfort, quiet ride and (yes) the MP3 hookup, cooled seats and OnStar-backed cellular phone service. When asked whether she’d been won over by the big Buick’s charms, Mom displayed her mastery of situational ethics. “I would definitely consider purchasing this car,” she proclaimed, definitely considering our host’s generosity.

Once again, I opened my mind to the company’s decision to add high horsepower to a wrong-wheel drive chassis. If Japan sells fwd hp by the boatload, maybe there's a place for the V8-motivated Lucerne CXS. Then again, maybe not. The CSX’ Magnaride suspension and 18" wheels promise more than the hard tires and flaccid chassis can deliver. The suspension needs a Corvette-style user interface (i.e. a switch for touring or sport dampening). Add a front chassis brace (or three), give an option for sport tires, and Buick might have a contender in the "near-luxury" segment.

After a lobster lunch at a suitably charming beachfront bed and breakfast, Buick's PR-wingman joined mother and son for part two: a jaunt in the cheaper Lucerne CXL. Cholesterol be damned; the less-rich Lucerne became my favorite Buick in a matter of minutes. Conservative 55-series rubber (17" hoops) and a softer suspension (no Magnaride) creamed road imperfections, reducing chassis flex to a mere wiggle. The CXL’s exterior was also more appealing, flaunting chrome in all the right places. Gone are the afterthought tailpipe extensions and adhesive-backed decklid bling; replaced by a brilliant chrome grille. The end result was solid Buick spizzarkle in the Roadmaster tradition, for a lot less dough.

The CXL's (optional) Northstar V8 puts the power down with a rowdy soundtrack– immediately downplayed by our gracious host. Which set me off again. If you can't Quiet Tune those 32-valves, why not promote Buick as an American Muscle Car icon? Don't try to out-Lexus an ES350. I mean, every Lucerne in attendance had a wiggly shift knob, loose shifter and dashboards sporting rock hard plastics. Mom won't remember, but even her old Century knew better; its flat-out amazing what $9000 got you in a GM interior back then.

In fact, let’s face it: Buick will never be an American Lexus, no matter how much spin is spun or press junket petty-cash hides in the console. After chatting with the Buick folk about life, liberty and the pursuit of precision, one thing became clear: GM’s minions know they’re up against it. They spoke hopefully about their next new dawn: the upcoming Enclave sport crossover utility thingie. They even invited TTAC to its official media introduction. And then, upon our return, GM formally banned TTAC from its Dallas press fleet. Suffice it to say, Mom wasn’t surprised. Neither was I.

[Buick paid the Mehta's airfare, hotel, transfers, the test cars and food.] 

By on August 18, 2006

reliability.jpgOnce upon a time, a car that could crest 100K miles was a pampered piece of technology. To make it “round the clock” most machines demanded a tune-up every three to five thousand miles— at the very least. Today, high-mileage used cars with nothing more than a routine oil change under their [fan] belt are par for the course. Now that the goal posts have moved, how do we measure a vehicle’s “quality” and “reliability”? To some people the terms mean “the car starts when I turn the key and I don’t have to mortgage the house to keep it running.” To others, they mean “it looks and operates as well today as it did when I bought it.”  And to others it’s like pornography to a Supreme Court Justice: they can’t define it, but they know it when they see it. What’s your definition of reliability and quality? Are the two joined at the hip? Please post your answers below… 

By on August 18, 2006

70lux2222.jpgPlay word association with the average American consumer. Say the words “quality cars.” Chances are they’ll respond with “Toyota.” For decades, the Japanese automaker has carefully nurtured and perpetuated a reputation for producing well-built/reliable cars and trucks. As a result, the company’s US sales have grown like kudzu. As of last month, Toyota now sells more cars in the Americas than Ford. If you discount fleet sales (so to speak), Toyota’s totals are within shouting distance of GM’s, both nationally and worldwide. Despite this startling, seemingly unstoppable success, or perhaps because of it, the company’s supposedly impenetrable façade has begun to show a few cracks.

Toyota’s first foray into US manufacturing began with a 25% federal tariff on foreign pickups. Toyota reacted to the punitive tax by importing bare chassis and attaching the truck beds in an American facility. When The Big Three (who were about to introduce their first domestic small trucks) pressured Congress into widening the tariff to include imported chassis, Toyota built an American plant to assemble complete trucks. Once the Japanese manufacturer realized they could build competitive vehicles stateside, they began expanding their American operations.

To avoid the United Auto Workers (UAW), Toyota situated their new factories in “right to work” states. As many industry analysts have concluded, Toyota’s clean sheet factories (eventually aided by state-funded tax breaks) and non-union workforce gave them an immediate and unassailable advantage over their “domestic” competition. While GM, Ford and Chrysler were busy appeasing their unions, draining funds which could have been used to upgrade their ageing products and antiquated production facilities, Toyota hit the ground running and never looked back.

At some point, Toyota became a victim of its own success. The company’s double quick expansion, from perennial underdog to voracious overlord, has compromised their unique selling point: product quality. Specifically, Toyota has suffered a plague of recalls around the world. In 2003, the automaker recalled 200k American vehicles. In 2004, the number increased fivefold, to a little over one million vehicles. In the following year, the number leaped again, more than doubling to 2.2 million. So far this year, Toyota has announced five recalls affecting approximately 900K vehicles.

Again, Toyota’s rapid growth is to blame. For one thing, the company’s design centers have been understaffed. The shortage of in-house talent has forced Toyota to outsource, relying on its parts suppliers to design key components. At the same time, the automaker has increased the amount of parts sharing among different models. The practice has dramatically increased the scope of a "single" failure, as witnessed by last October's recall of 1.27m Japanese vehicles. Goldman Sachs estimates that design faults (e.g. rubber parts not thick enough to withstand engine heat and joints too weak to hold together) account for 68% of Toyota’s 2004 recalls. 

Andrew Phillips of Nikko Citigroup stated "Toyota's resources have been stretched quite a bit by the big increases in volume." Shinsei Securities analyst Yasuhiro Matsumoto lays the blame for Toyota’s declining quality squarely on Katsuaki Watanabe’s shoulders. He claims the CEO’s constant focus on cost cutting has created devastating production glitches. The resulting quality issues have become so alarming that Watanabe recently admitted, "I take this seriously and see it as a crisis." It’s just as well; Goldman Sachs analyst Kunihiko Shiohara estimates that it may take Toyota four years or more to achieve "a fundamental turnaround in quality levels.”

Toyota also seems to be off their game in predicting market shifts. True, the company displayed impeccable timing by importing the Yaris just as American demand for smaller, higher mileage cars kicked into high gear. But Toyota’s also about to begin production on a larger, heavier and more powerful full-size Tundra, assembled in a brand new $800m Texas plant. While Toyota sells the high mileage cars tree huggers love to hug, they also have the thirstiest truck fleet on the market. And now that large truck sales seem to be tanking, they’re gearing-up to produce them in record numbers. Only time will tell if they’ve made a smart move (i.e. if sales recover or GM goes bankrupt), but at this point their timing could hardly be worse.

Earlier this year, Toyota announced they were delaying the introduction of the new Corolla for a year to focus on the launch of the new Camry. This will leave the current generation Corolla in service for a Big Three-like six years. While the move could reflect a redoubling of Toyota’s commitment to quality, it gives the model’s competitors some much-needed breathing room. Is this a minor setback in Toyota’s relentless march on American market share or warning signs of a more fundamental, less easily solved problem? It’s too early to tell. But stay tuned. We’re on it.

By on August 17, 2006

09.jpgIt’s been said that walking on quicksand with helium balloons will keep you from going under. Now that The Blue Oval has finally realized that the sands have shifted beneath its feet, there are plenty of people selling the automaker balloons. The United Auto Workers (UAW) has publicly pledged to help Billy’s Ford’s boys “any way they can.” Michigan Governor Jennifer Granholm has proclaimed her willingness to sacrifice voters’ taxes to keep the Wolverine State’s assembly lines rolling. At the same time, Ford is contemplating radical solutions: cutting dealers, selling assets, forming alliances. Is Ford finding buoyancy or grasping at straws?

The UAW’s Koala Brothers’ announcement (“We’re here to help!”) stems from a general acknowledgement that Ford’s Way Forward has lost traction– if indeed it ever had any. At the same time, the union’s faux altruism seeks to overturn the common perception that “if you’re not part of the problem, you’re not part of the UAW.” To that end, Ford Division UAW Vice President Bob King recently signaled that Ford’s talk of inter-company alliances and another round of worker buyouts would “not be out of the question” provided they ensure “mutual survival.”

Of course, King’s statement reveals the obvious (if overlooked) fact that the UAW would have to approve any hook-up between Ford and another automaker. Which they would– provided Ford’s new partner agrees to maintain current salaries, pensions, working practices and benefits. (File that one under “Not Very Likely.”) As for the UAW’s willingness to accept further blue collar buyouts, the UAW’s members have a history of “helping” Ford by taking money for not working. Perhaps Mr. King would like to extend his assistance to closing Ford’s infamous, expensive and still not fully disclosed “jobs bank.”

In short, don’t look for the UAW to make any bold moves (a.k.a. “historic givebacks”) beyond pocketing Mr. Ford’s cash to leave the building. Why would they? Ford’s buyout offers only extend to high-seniority workers. Workers without a parachute won't entertain “short term” cuts to their compensation knowing that a new four-year contract with The Big Two Point Five is under negotiation for fall ’07.

Michigan Governor Jennifer Granholm’s relief plan is also a lot less than it seems– but in a nice way. Gov. Granholm and Michigan Economic Development Corporation (MEDC) President and CEO James Epolito want to save 56k Ford jobs (their estimate) by granting FoMoCo $151m worth of tax credits. Ford’s part of the bargain: invest a billion dollars in its Michigan facilities over the next 20 years. A billion bucks shared amongst nine major facilities is a laughably small amount. Unless Ford’s pulls the plug, the company will invest that much money in its Michigan plants as a normal part of doing business. When that inconvenient truth emerged, Granholm’s plan submerged, taking a lot of good will towards Ford with it.

And then there’s the real deal: Ford’s plan to trim its 4300 member dealer network. According to press reports, metropolitan dealers in 18 urban areas will close or merge with successful locales to streamline sales, increase margins and free-up overhead. This is a much needed, long overdue move; Detroit is home to 31 Ford peddlers and 14 Lincoln floggers. But the maneuver’s mechanics are murky. Ford spinmeister Jim Cain claimed "It's totally voluntary… We'll handle this in private and in a very collaborative way." Voluntary? Private? Collaborative? That sounds an awful lot like "cha-ching" to me.

Just like Ford’s plan to slice 30k jobs and close 14 plants, the dealer downsizing program will not be cheap. But hey, you gotta spend money to save money. As Ford has already dropped $10b on Jaguar, many have come to believe that selling the British brand will be Ford’s next great leap forward. Despite last week’s frantic comments by Ford CEO Mark Fields– “We will sell the furniture if it helps fund new products”– Ford’s not going to not let the Cat out of the PAG. As revealed on a recent TTAC podcast, Ford’s brand management has rendered Jaguar virtually worthless. They’d have to give it away. So Ford’s decided to [re]reposition Jaguar as a “niche” luxury brand, to give Jaguar buyers more of what they love: Ford Five Hundred switchgear.

Seriously, there is no newfound cash flow at FoMoCo, nor is there likely to be any in the near future. If things get bad, Ford will sell Volvo and team-up with anyone with deep enough pockets to bail it out. But we’re not there… yet.

President Kennedy once said “The great enemy of the truth is very often not the lie–deliberate, contrived, and dishonest— but the myth– persistent, persuasive, and realistic”.  The myth is that Ford is a can-do company can turn itself by sheer force of will. The truth is that Ford is at least three years too late and a few billion dollars short, wearing a union-made straight jacket, slowly sinking into bankruptcy.

By on August 15, 2006

badcredit_pic222.jpg A few days after GM's vice president of vehicle sales, service and marketing assured auto industry analysts that his employer will maintain incentive-free “value pricing," General Motors announced two grand cash back on the 2007 Chevrolet Tahoe, Avalanche and Suburban and the GMC Yukon, Yukon XL and Denali. To be fair, nobody took LaNeve’s price promise seriously. By now, everyone knows GM’s new(ish) SUV’s are a drug on the market, and it ain’t Viagra. There’s only way to move the metal: lower the price. Either that or stop making the damn things.

Last Friday (always Friday), GM CEO Rick Wagoner announced that The General will curtail production of its GMT-900 based SUV’s. Rabid Rick tried to minimize the damage by asserting that GM was going to halt “some overtime” on SUV assembly lines and introduce “other products” into the production mix— as if to say demand for GM’s gas guzzlers was still hot, just not sizzling, and besides, we can make some other stuff instead.

Yeah right. At the end of July, in an industry where a 60-day supply is an acceptable maximum, GM dealers were stuffed to the gills with Tahoes (82 days), Yukons (89 days) and Chevrolet Suburbans (75 days). Although the figures are not far off last year's, these are GM's "new" trucks.  August is going to be a bitch.

Meanwhile, Rabid Rick proclaimed that GM's share of the full-size SUV market has “boomed.” According to Wagoner, GM now “owns” 50 to 75 percent of various segments within the SUV genre— which is a bit like saying you’ve scored the best cabins on the Titanic after it hit the iceberg. The executive’s statement was a remarkable piece of spin, but it pales in comparison to GM’s creative accounting. Lest we forget, Rabid Rick ascended to his throne as GM Chief Financial Officer. Here’s a bit of what he’s learned…

Yesterday, The General’s GMAC finance unit signed a three-year, $10b funding facility with a Citigroup subsidiary. Four billion dollars of the money falls into a brand new category for GMAC: “unrated notes”. Unrated notes are papers representing loans that are so far outside traditional credit parameters that the vast majority oif insitutional investors are literally prohibited from buying them.

In other words, GM’s “Zero Percent for Deadbeats” summer blowout left GMAC with billions of dollars of risky loans. No surprise then that GM's finance arm reported that the unrated notes are backed by assets “not typically securitized by GMAC.” OK, here's the "creative" part…

Because the risk is so high, there's a gap between the money GMAC lent its less-than-perfect customers and the amount of money Citigroup paid for the loans. As part of the deal, GM has agreed to cover the shortfall (i.e. securitize the assets). It’s all a bit confusing (by design), but here’s the bottom line: GMAC carries little or no risk for the bad loans. GM buries a “charge” in its sales costs to cover the money paid to GMAC for the dicey loans.

The shell game maintains the illusion of higher average transaction prices, hides huge discounts/rebates and moves vehicles off the lot. Given that GM generates about $28b in North American sales per quarter, $4b in bad debt equals about 15% of sales (assuming 100% financing). Since most of this paper was written in 60 days, as much as 40% of GM's recent sales surge may be directly attributable to bad loans. Put that in your quarterly report and smoke it.

Just like last year’s “Fire Sale for All” program, the “Zero Percent for Deadbeats” program will eventually bite GM in the ass. Can you imagine what these vehicles will be worth when (not if) they’re repossessed? At the risk of sounding, um, deadbeatist, people with sub-basement level credit scores tend to smoke, spill beer, puke, rip up interiors, ding ‘em good and never fix a thing.  And speaking of repairs…

In the second financial quarter, GM downgraded its warranty expenses per vehicle to $325 (compared to $523 for the same quarter in ’05). GM’s improving reliability record is admirable, but it doesn’t justify that kind of drop. The revised figure added $433 million (the equivalent of $0.67 a share) to GM’s second quarter “profits.” Clearly, GM is ducking and diving, window dressing its earnings to mask the company’s true performance, or lack thereof.

The truth is things are not going well at RenCen. While GM has finalized its new credit line of $4.5b (on onerous terms), the company still withdrew an additional $2b from its VEBA on July thirty-first to cover health care reimbursement. GM’s continual need to tap into the VEBA account suggests a cash shortage.

Now that the GMAC sale has been postponed until next year, the need for operating funds could well become critical. While the risk of a GM default may not be imminent, a strike at bankrupt auto parts maker Delphi would be the tipping point. In the event of a work stoppage, GM’s credit line would be reduced by a billion dollars.

Industry watchers still say it’ll never happen. Meanwhile, negotiations at Delphi are stalled and the most recent final deadline arrives in two days. If Delphi goes down, GM goes down. If it doesn’t, the company's descent into bankruptcy will merely be postponed.

By on August 14, 2006

28002-rollover-accidents-2222.jpg The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has a mission: “Save lives, prevent injuries, reduce vehicle-related crashes.” NHTSA also commits itself to “providing the most accurate and complete information available to its customers, the American traveling public.” While NHTSA’s progress towards its stated goals is (and always will be) a matter of debate, the agency has failed us. They’ve failed to tell the truth about ABS.

Modern ABS consists of a computer (CPU), four speed sensors (one on each wheel) and hydraulic valves (attached to the brake circuit). When the CPU senses that one or more of the wheels are turning significantly more slowly than the others, it decreases the pressure on the braking circuit. If the wheel or wheels then turn too fast (freed from braking), the force is reapplied, creating a pulsing sensation through the brake pedal.

When Bosch’s Antiblockiersystem appeared on the US automotive scene in the late ‘70’s, safety advocates hailed electronically assisted braking as a life-saving technology that would reduce the number and severity of accidents. Tests under controlled conditions seemed to support the contention. NHTSA and the insurance industry quickly embraced and promoted the technology.

Thanks (in part) to insurance industry discounts, almost every passenger vehicle now sold in America is fitted with ABS. NHTSA’s web site proclaims “…an antilock brake system (ABS) is a safe and effective braking system. ABS allows the driver to maintain directional stability, control over steering, and in some situations, to reduce stopping distances during emergency braking situation, particularly on wet and slippery road surfaces.” The real-world evidence doesn’t support their claims. 

Researchers have compared accident and fatality rates for vehicles with and without ABS. Other studies have examined the driving records of ABS and non-ABS equipped taxi drivers in Munich and Oslo. The accident and fatality data shows that ABS exacerbates the severity of accidents in certain situations. The taxi study proved that drivers tend to take greater risks in cars equipped with ABS (although the difference in collision rates was not significant).  In short, ABS may do more harm than good.

More specifically, the studies show that ABS has no real-world effect on dry-surface braking, ABS-equipped vehicles take longer to stop on ice than non-ABS vehicles, ABS-equipped vehicles are more prone to roll-over accidents than non-ABS vehicles, ABS-equipped vehicles are involved more often in single car fatal accidents than non-ABS vehicles, and drivers of ABS-equipped vehicles tend to drive faster and apply their brakes later than non-ABS drivers.

The AAA Foundation for Traffic safety has determined that improper driver steering in an ABS-equipped vehicle can send it veering out of control. In their tests, jerking the wheel (as if trying to steer around an obstacle) in a 35 mph panic stop sent ABS-equipped cars careening across two lane widths. (Without the ABS, the car skidded in a straight line.) This behavior may account for the higher roll-over rates for ABS-equipped vehicles. Other research revealed that many drivers don’t use ABS properly; they pump the pedal as they would regular brakes.

NHTSA, the insurance industry, manufacturers and engineers are all well aware of ABS’ shortcomings. In 1994, Dr. Charles J. Kahane published a paper for NHTSA entitled “Preliminary Evaluation of the Effectiveness of Antilock Brake Systems for Passenger Cars." Kahane reported that “All types of run-off-road crashes – rollovers, side impacts with fixed objects and frontal impacts with fixed objects – increased significantly with ABS. Nonfatal run-off-road crashes increased by an estimated 19 percent, and fatal crashes by 28 percent.” Kahane also concluded that “Rollovers and side impacts with fixed objects… had the highest increases with ABS. Nonfatal crashes increased by 28 percent, and fatal crashes by 40 percent.”

In 1996, the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety published a news release titled “Antilock Brakes Don’t Reduce Fatal Crashes; People in Cars With Antilocks at Greater Risks- But Unclear Why.”  In 1998, Leonard Evans of General Motors’ Global R&D Operations checked NHTSA’s ABS crash data and concluded “it is unlikely that on dry roads ABS can materially reduce risk” and, more shockingly, “ABS is associated with a 44% increase in rollover risk.” In 1999, the Society of Automotive Engineers reported that “ABS was found to be associated with a 51 percent increase in fatal rollover crashes on dry roads. For fatal side impact crashes, ABS produced a 69 percent increase for unfavorable road conditions, and a 61 percent increase for favorable road conditions.”

The average cost of an ABS system is $240. Multiply that figure by millions of vehicles, add the number of lives lost and the injuries suffered because of ABS' ill effects, and the true cost of this potentially lethal braking systems is evident. At the very least, NHSTA should launch an immediate investigation into the advisability of fitting SUV’s with ABS. Meanwhile, you’ve been warned: ABS can kill. 

By on August 13, 2006

997gt3.jpg It's no secret that Porsche's 911 dominates the American Le Mans Series GT2 Class. Given their supremacy, you could almost say that the German marque owns the series, setting performance and reliability standards so high that any car other than a 911 is immediately classified as an hapless underdog. But the lap times they are a changin’. Sure, a Porsche has won a place on the podium at every race so far this season. Yes, they’ve scooped first place at half of those races. But a new breed of competition is finally giving the current 996 GT3 RSR a real run for the money. To review…

In 2004, a Ferrari broke Porsche’s GT2 supremacy by winning one race. In the 2005 season, team Panoz managed to repeat the feat to take the sole non-Porsche victory. The rest of the season volleyed between the Alex Job’s factory-supported 911 and the Petersen White Lighting “near factory supported” 911’s. All in all, Stuttgart’s finest won seven all-Porsche podiums and nine Porsche wins (out of ten races). Oh, and every top five championship team hailed from Stuttgart.

Porsche’s preeminence forced GT2 race fans to stake their allegiance on a racing team, rather than a car manufacturer. They chose their loyalties according to car color, driver nationality or whether or not a team was a privateer or factory supported. Fast forward to 2006 and it’s a whole new world. There hasn’t been a single 1-2-3 Porsche finish this season. In fact, Porsche is only batting .500; the mighty 911 has dropped three races to other manufacturers. Their biggest defeat: Panoz beating them to the checkered flag at both Sebring and Le Mans.

At the same time, the Ferrari F430 has become the class of the field. With a 4.0-liter V8 cranking out significantly  more horsepower and torque than its F360 predecessor, with a new, stiffer chassis delivering a huge increase in torsional rigidity, with more highly evolved aerodynamics creating a huge increase in downforce, it's the one to watch.

Although the season didn’t start so well for the Italians, the team has since sorted the make’s famed reliability issues and eluded the bad luck that plagued their early efforts. In Portland, the Fezza came from dead last at the start to finishing first by a 20-second margin. The car also destroyed the competition at Salt Lake to take first place. That’s a far cry from the old F360, which only accounted for one victory during its entire stint in the series. 

All in all, the lack of a new more competitive Porsche model in the GT2 class has created one of the best racing seasons in years. With the allowance of the GT2S class (which allows sedan-based cars to compete in the races but not for championship points), BMW has returned to the series. Lexus is about to make its debut with the new IS350 GT2. There have been a few races with three makes on the podium and five different teams taking the top spot. Better competition has made for great racing. And yet…

With its long history of class dominance, it’s no surprise that there’s still a Porsche team leading the American Le Mans Series GT2 point’s race. It’s also no shock that the out-gunned manufacturer is evolving its entry. The 997 GT3 RSR is based on the current gen 997 chassis, combined with a few pieces from the outgoing 996 GT3 RSR. Porsche has taken an unconventional step in the new car’s design: adding weight to enter a heavier class.

As the extra ballast can be placed anywhere in the car, the boffins at Porsche can now lower their car’s center of gravity and further refine the rear-engined machine’s handling. The move also frees the automaker to use wider wheels. To contain the new wider wheels, the car’s rear structure has been sourced from the Carrera 4 (which is now 50mm wider per side). The new chassis is ten percent stiffer than its predecessor. The new engine’s 3.8-liter displacement delivers 30 more horsepower than the 996’ 3.6-liter six, for a total of 485hp. 

The 997 GT3 RSR made it racing debut at the Proximus 24 Hours of Spa. Despite the Jekyll and Hyde reliability of the RS Spyder, the new car finished 1-2 in their respective class.

The prospect of Porsche’s return to total supremacy must be giving GT2 race organizers nightmares. To their eternal credit, the sport’s governing body is not contemplating any sort of “equalizing” regulations to hamper the 911’s. It’s gloves-off racing like it should be. Even so, fans have mixed feelings. While the Porsches have established a large and loyal fan base, even the most die-hard supporter must secretly wish for more competitive racing. Will they have it?  Watch this space.

Recent Comments

  • Lou_BC: @Carlson Fan – My ’68 has 2.75:1 rear end. It buries the speedo needle. It came stock with the...
  • theflyersfan: Inside the Chicago Loop and up Lakeshore Drive rivals any great city in the world. The beauty of the...
  • A Scientist: When I was a teenager in the mid 90’s you could have one of these rolling s-boxes for a case of...
  • Mike Beranek: You should expand your knowledge base, clearly it’s insufficient. The race isn’t in...
  • Mike Beranek: ^^THIS^^ Chicago is FOX’s whipping boy because it makes Illinois a progressive bastion in the...

New Car Research

Get a Free Dealer Quote

Who We Are

  • Adam Tonge
  • Bozi Tatarevic
  • Corey Lewis
  • Jo Borras
  • Mark Baruth
  • Ronnie Schreiber