Category: Editorials

By on September 8, 2006

2004_06_11_nomad14sm222.jpgIf Mom and Dad had it, we don’t want it. The principle has been an article of faith since homo sapiens first stalked the savannah. Bouffant hairstyles? Brylcreem? Gedoutta here. Eighteen-hour girdles? Puh-lease. When it comes to vehicles, there’s nothing stodgier than Mom's old station wagon. If thirty or forty-somethings think about the genre at all, it’s with mocking derision. From National Lampoon’s “Family Truckster” to That 70’s Show’s Vista Cruiser, the station wagon is the ultimate icon of suburban conformity and, well, blah. It really IS your father’s Oldsmobile.

Station wagons were born just after the turn of the century. Resort hotels shuttled wealthy guests and their baggage to and from the railroad station in large, open-sided motor vehicles. By the early twenties, these “depot hacks” were fully enclosed. In the thirties, the wood-paneled trucks (a.k.a. “woodies”) somehow became a status symbol for America’s gin and tonic set (Country Squire indeed). After the war, the first steel bodied station wagon was suburban by name, suburban by nature. Hundreds of thousands of station wagons roamed the burgeoning 'burbs, proferred by all but the toniest car brands. 

By the early eighties, the genre was kaput. Grown-up baby boomers would rather give up smoking pot than adopt the vehicles driven by their parents– even when their selfish genes forced them into more “responsible” transportation. Sales of the venerable station wagon dried up like a Death Valley rain puddle. Buyers flocked to the mini-van, a suburban version of the hippy love bus, and the SUV, a macho machine that helped them live out Walter Mitty fantasies of long treks through Marlboro country. Now that SUVs are PC pariahs and minivans makers continue to insist on building boring boxes, could American buyers be ready for a rebirth of the station wagon?

Some would say the genre never really died. Mercedes, Volvo and Saab have been building wagons since ever, appealing to a small but gradually increasing fan base of eccentrics, antique collectors and eccentric antique collectors. In 1995, Subaru butched-up their plain-Jane Legacy wagon with bigger tires and an aggressive grille (both obvious SUV cues). Sensibly enough, the company avoided the “station wagon” moniker, fearing that the name would connect the design to Mom and Dad’s vinyl-clad monstrosity. They called the Outback a “Sports Utility Wagon" and sold them by the boatload.

Although the Outback was but a blip on the automotive radar back in the days when SUV’s ruled the earth, it won a devoted following. The Volvo XC70 and Audi Allroad followed in the Outback’s muddy tracks. And now that the Outback and the other “macho wagons” have established credibility (especially in the Snow Belt), station wagons are starting to assume a more prominent role in manufacturers' fleets. The fact that DCX chose to introduce their chop top Dodge Magnum as a station wagon– rather than a four-door sedan– shows that at least ONE domestic manufacturer thinks a station wagon can be cool.

I’ve always believed wagons were God’s chosen vehicles. After all, what can a four-door sedan do that a station wagon can’t? Other than the sedan’s [highly subjective] advantage in the appearance department, nothing. Pistonheads will protest that station wagons don’t accelerate, corner or brake as well as their non-wagon counterparts. And no wonder; manufacturers usually delete the sedan’s high-performance parts from the station wagon's OEM equipment list.  When a station wagon gets the right greasy bits (think WRX, Magnum SRT-8) their performance is pretty damn close to the trunk-equipped version– and they retain the utility that makes a wagon, well, a wagon.

Face it: utility rules. Driving to work is pretty much the same whether you’ve got a sedan, a wagon or a coupe. But try picking up a load of lumber at Home Depot, taking the family camping at Yellowstone or moving a couple of best buds across town. The station wagon’s versatility quickly makes itself known. The way back's extra storage capacity is easily accessible through the wagon's low and level tailgate. With fold flat seats and a mesh barrier (that keeps cargo from turning into ICBM’s), you can stack all and sundry to the roof. And the wagon’s longer roofline allows easier mounting of cargo like bicycles or kayaks– one reason forward-looking car companies market “sport wagons” to young, hip singles.

SUVs, of course, also offer some of these advantages. But they come with excessive size, lousy fuel economy and poor handling. Ah, but has the stodgy station wagon finally jettisoned its cultural baggage? Uh, no. But with the cost of fuel heading hovering around $3 a gallon, an increasing number of American buyers are willing to sacrifice style points for utility. I hate to say it, but maybe Mom wasn't so stupid after all.  

By on September 6, 2006

warninglabel2222.jpgWhy do manufacturers of high end cars think I’m an idiot? Their automobiles tell me when their tires need air, when the coolant is low and when it’s time for an oil change. They [still] remind me to buckle-up, close my door and take my key. They warn me of approaching objects (front and rear). Yes, I know: this dumbing-down suits the majority of wealthy car buyers, who’d rather read a treatise on Keynesian economics than check their oil. Still, you’ve got to draw the line somewhere. Sun visor stickers are my personal line in the sand.

I just spent $270 replacing my Mercedes’ sun shields with virgin visors– just to rid myself of those bothersome airbag warning labels. I used to peel them off myself, but the stickers have become tackier and tackier (in every sense); my patient peeling and wiping is no longer effective. In my Audi and BMW, I’m not as lucky: the warning labels are embossed into the visor, both OEM and aftermarket.  

For all I know, it’s illegal to remove airbag warning stickers. I’m not concerned. For years, I have been removing stickers from my pillow which read, “Warning, these stickers are not to be removed under penalty of law!” I’ve never been arrested for this desecration of my own personal property. As far as I know, there is no warrant out for my arrest. The day the cops check for missing airbag stickers is the day I buy a big bore shotgun and join Oregon’s survivalists.

The airbag stickers warn you that short people and small children can be injured by airbags. No, really? More importantly, what’s it got to do with me? First, I’m not short and I am childless. Second, I don’t let kids ride in the front seat of my cars. (If I had kids, I’d consider it my responsibility to discover the safest way to carry them.) Third, short people have free will; they can weigh-up the dangers of front seat airbags and decide whether or not to drive a car, sit in the passenger seat or sacrifice their pride and jump in the back.

Why can’t I just sign a release when I purchase my vehicle stating that I understand that airbags are dangerous? After I purchase a vehicle in California, I have to sign statements saying I understand that there is no cooling off period and that the dealer can check my credit and invade my privacy and charge me $2.00 to inspect my tires. I never saw a sticker that warned me about this.

I want to know which lawsuit made these stickers a requirement in every vehicle sold in the U.S. Who determined that airbags were the foremost danger facing automobile drivers (literally)? Can a brightly-colored written warning label immutably attached to the most obvious (and therefore most annoying) location in our cars solve the problem? Are the people that need these labels even reading them? Can they even read?

Manufacturers should be concerned about more perilous threats to our safety. What about yakking on the cell or wiping snot off the kid in the [airbagless] backseat? How about drinking and driving? Fastening my seat belt? Speeding, not checking my mirrors or aggressive lane changing? Eating? Smoking (imagine how long that one would be)? Don’t these behaviors cause more accidental deaths than “killer airbags”? Perhaps there should be a warning label telling me to never attempt to drive in the city of Boston. No, instead I’m warned about a passive safety device that I’ll probably (hopefully?) never use.

Other than killing all the lawyers, there is an answer to this litigious lunacy: a test to determine whether or not you need to be protected from your own stupidity. (Once upon a time, a high school diploma or a driving test would’ve done the trick.) If you prove you possess a modicum of intelligence and simple common sense, you could carry a card that exempted you from these Nanny State warnings.

Your car’s owner’s manual would be half the size. You could just know that objects in the side mirror aren’t as close as they appear. And there'd be other benefits. When you bought a coffee from McDonalds, you could drink a cup of hot coffee that didn’t warn you not to burn yourself. You could fall asleep on the airplane in front of the flight attendants while they demonstrate to the knuckle-draggers how to buckle a seatbelt. Instead of a warning on cigarette packs, it would simply say, ‘enjoy.’

And the next time I visit a dealer, I could present my card and they would say, “Ah, Mr. Shoemaker, you want to look at these cars over here.” And there would sit my dream car: an automobile without idiot lights or warning labels.

By on September 5, 2006

mulally_n.jpgWas he pushed or did he jump? Either way, Billy Ford’s resignation as CEO of the family firm is yet more proof that The Blue Oval’s in big trouble. Not that he’s been trying to hide the fact. In his Newsweek interview, Billy telegraphed his intention to fall on his sword: “I've always said that titles are not important to me… What's important is getting this company headed in the right direction." And the new man is… Alan Mulally, Boeing’s now former Executive Vice President. Not to coin a phrase, one wonders if Billy told the board, “If it’s not Boeing, I’m not going.”

Billy’s press release hails FoMoCo’s new President and CEO and explains the choice: “Alan has deep experience in customer satisfaction, manufacturing, supplier relations and labor relations, all of which have applications to the challenges of Ford. He also has the personality and team-building skills that will help guide our Company in the right direction.” The aeronautical and astronautical engineer joined Boeing straight out of college in '69. Mulally's “customer experience” is limited to convincing airlines to buy jets. Not to put too fine a point on it, the Kansas native sure ain’t no car guy.

Still, point taken on the manufacturing and labor relations side of things. An assembly line is an assembly line, whether you're building lumbering behemoths that can or can not fly. And a good chunk of Mulally’s Boeing career was spent investigating jet crashes caused by weather– a situation not a million miles away from the effect of gas prices on Ford’s SUV business. And he’s certainly familiar with Ford-sized executive salaries. Forbes reports that Mulally drew down $9,961,985 last year, with $6,362,599 in stock options taxiing for takeoff.

One of the main reasons Billy Ford likes Mulally is that Mulally likes Ford. In his book “Working Together,” author James P. Lewis chronicled Mulally’s success at Boeing, from the depths of post-911 to the launch of the new 787. Lewis reports that Mulally was inspired by Ford’s last turnaround, starring… the Ford Taurus. In their statements to the press, both Billy and Alan referred to this appointment as karmic payback: “Just as I thought it was appropriate to apply lessons learned from Ford to Boeing,” Mulally said. “I believe the reverse is true as well.”

In case you were wondering how Mulally pulled Boeing out its nosedive to earn himself the top slot at America’s number three automaker, it’s all about the product, stupid. Despite the post-911 crash in airplane sales, Mulally’s team pushed forward on streamlining the company’s Byzantine production process and developing new planes. When the market eventually bounced back, Boeing was ready. You could argue that a rising tide lifts all Executive Veeps, and what else could Boeing have done anyway, but there’s no doubt that Mulally helped the Seattle-based company make better, faster and cheaper jets.

There’s also no question about Mulally’s leadership abilities. His “team-building skills” within and without Boeing are legendary. In a March ’06 article for Design News, Boeing’s Chief Engineer of the 777's interior design sang Mulally’s praises. "Alan exhibits every quality that you would want to see in a good leader–vision, trust, integrity, and, above all, an overwhelming enthusiasm.” George Brody also said, “He's just dynamic when it comes to getting people to pull together." Of course, a big part of Mulally’s confidence comes from his technical know-how. One wonders how long it will take Ford’s new CEO to get up to speed on the intricacies of car building.

Or if Mulally can readjust his internal clock to the car industry’s three year product cycles. For 37 years, the Boeing man was attuned to a two decade gap between a new product’s conception and customer deliveries. (You can count the number of planes he’s worked on with one hand.) And that’s on top of strategic thinking that extends out 40 years or more (a modern aircraft can stay in service 60 years). Ford has eight brands and dozens of models, each of which require some form of design, engineering and marketing right now– in addition to the models on the drawing boards or in development.

Again, Mulally ain’t no car guy. In fact, his appointment is reminiscent of John Sculley’s ascension to the top post at Apple Computer. The Pepsi Prez was also a hugely successful, gregarious outsider charged with turning around a failing multinational with a deeply entrenched corporate culture, that enjoyed tremendous customer loyalty. Sculley was also overseen by the same man who used to run the joint. Suffice it to say, Sculley’s tenure did nothing to help Apple, and plenty to hurt it. It remains to be seen if Mulally can win friends and influence people who are already clinging to their jobs by the skin of their teeth.

Mulally’s first test will be overseeing the deal or no deal happening or not happening at Aston, Land Rover and Jaguar. And then, it’s union time. Then we’ll see if Mullaly’s got what it takes to pull the yoke and save Ford from a death spiral into Chapter 11.

By on September 4, 2006

torrent_survivor222.jpgSo, General Motors has pulled its sponsorship from Survivor. Flackmeister Ryndee S. Carney claimed GM came to its decision “months ago, before the show made its recent announcement." The announcement in question: Survivor will divide its competitors by race and ethnicity. Carney quashed the idea that GM pulled the plug in response to the controversial formatting in no certain terms: “I think it's just a coincidence.” Think? Carney’s comment brings into question GM’s ability to tell the truth and, thus, to survive its evaporating market share, bloated dealer network, distended brand portfolio, lackluster product lines and horrendous cost structure.

Not to belabor the point (much), GM claims they pulled their $14.7m plug on Survivor three months ago. Yet on May 12th, GM and CBS publicly revealed The General's intention to increase their Survivor ad spend. In any case, Carney played dumb, insisting that GM was simply shifting support to TV shows offering product placement. "There's a limited number of possibilities as to how you can integrate a car or truck in a show [when] people spend their whole time on an island." Despite (or because of) the fact that a Pontiac Aztek played a role in a Survivor episode, Carney’s stab at PR humor set exactly the wrong tone. Instead of addressing a serious issue head on, GM smiled and sang “It wazzunt me.”  

Not to belabor the point (again), is it too much to ask GM to tell the truth? OK, Survivor sponsorship isn’t a big deal– even if would be nice to see one of America’s largest companies declare its distaste for a TV program that engenders racial or ethnic divisiveness. What about the fact that GM is cutting production in the fourth quarter by 12 percent, or 150k vehicles?  Now that’s serious; the move will torpedo fourth quarter revenues. The company’s press release states that the cut "does not reflect a reduction in GM's sales outlook but is consistent with our strategy to reduce low-margin daily rentals, and takes into account the plan to shift production of pickups to the next-generation pickups during the fourth quarter." No shit?

I guess I’m the only one who remembers that GM originally planned to cut production by eight percent, and consider the fact that the axe is falling on GM’s new[ish] gas-guzzling SUV’s somehow related to the increased decrease. To wit: during a recent conference call with reporters and auto industry analysts, GM’s Supreme Spinmeister Paul Ballew declared that GM’s production cutbacks were not a response to “a sudden deterioration in conditions.” "It's new news to you," Ballew said, "but it's not new to us." In other words, we know what we’re doing and we sure as Hell don’t have to tell you about it.

The first proposition is highly suspect, the second highly inadvisable. As I’ve said here before, GM CEO Rabid Rick Wagoner’s failure to articulate a specific, honest, clear and coherent turnaround plan that includes all of GM’s “stakeholders” will be his undoing. Yes, Rabid Rick says he has one, and frequently tells the world that The General’s adherence to this unexpressed timeline proceeds apace. Is it inconceivable that Wagoner’s reluctance to publicly declare his comprehensive recovery strategy reflect his unwillingness to be held to its dictates?

Yes, it’s inconceivable. If I held GM stock, or worked for the company, or ran a GM store, I would be furious at The General’s lack of transparency and accountability. “Keep the faith” is all well and good when you’re minting money, but that and $1.45 won’t get you downtown when the buses are no longer running (so to speak). Clearly, GM adheres to America’s new de facto standard for corporate citizenship: spin, gloss, weasel and waffle.

Take GM’s latest sales results. What are we to make of August’s 3.8 percent retail sales jump? First, it’s a year-on-year result, compared to last August’s cataclysmic post “Employee Discount for Everyone” hangover, when GM’s sales fell off a cliff. Second, sales of GM’s low-profit plain Jane sedans account for much of the rise. And third, we hear tell that GM’s “Anyone with a Pulse” financing continues, a development that will eventually hoist GM by its own petard. According to GM Marketing Maven Mark LaNeve, “Customers clearly are responding to the quality, value, versatility and fuel efficiency of our cars and trucks.”

Maybe so. But GM’s failure to change its business model, the implementation of forthcoming production cuts, the resulting affect on its cash position and the ongoing threat of a strike at bankrupt parts supplier Delphi overshadow any August cheer. And now that Billy Ford has admitted The Blue Oval’s dire straits, it’s clear that GM’s execs continue to live on an island of their own making, facing stronger, smarter and better fed opposition. News flash: GM’s tribe will not survive.

By on September 3, 2006

090106slcrpq800-0622.jpg One Christmas, I tried snowboarding on Big Bear Mountain in Southern California. With great determination, I flung myself down the slope. Each time I started to gain a little speed, I’d have to dive into the snow to avoid running over an over-privileged rugrat. Two days of voluntary horizontal shifting left me so sore I could barely walk for a week. Driving a Daytona Prototype car in the Grand American Rolex Series must be equally frustrating.

In the Grand American Rolex Series, the awkward snowboarders are the Daytona Prototypes: purpose-built, mid-engined racecars. Their powerplants are based on production models and cannot utilize any type of forced induction. There are currently seven approved chassis constructors and six engine manufactures. To further equalize the competition, the race organizers have divided the competition into three weight classes based on engine size. The smaller of the approved engines (under 4.0-liter) run with less weight and one extra transmission cog (six gears versus five). To add to the excitement and/or confusion, there are 42 permissible chassis/engine combinations.

The GT class cars are the snot nosed kids. The production based cars are far less exotic than their prototype companions. But don’t let their more mundane shells fool you; these cars mean business. Constructors usually scrap the stock in favor of a tube frame and beef-up the engines well above factory specs. GT class cars battling for honors range from Porsche 911’s to Pontiac GTO’s. The sport’s governing body also uses regulations to equalize the competition; including weight and horsepower restrictions.

With such vast gaps in performance between these two classes on track, the Rolex series sees more altercations than a moshpit at a heavy metal concert. GT traffic may be the bane of a prototype driver’s existence, but it’s entertaining for spectators. For example, a prototype car will often use slower GT traffic to gain an advantage over a trailing competitor. Of course, the GT drivers are supposed to yield the racing line to the prototype class…

Last weekend at Infineon Raceway, the number 23 Ruby Tuesday Championship Racing Daytona Prototype bumped fenders with two members of the GT class. First, a Daytona car overtaking two slower GT cars in the carousel forced driver Patrick Long off the track, dropping him from second to tenth. Later, a Daytona car hit Ruby co-driver Mike Rockenfeller from behind, damaging his exhaust and shredding body work. It was dangerous stuff, but just another day at the races for all concerned.

On a track like Infineon there are only a few areas for safe overtaking. The difference in power and agility between the classes is evident. Daytona prototypes simply can’t wait for these few prime opportunities to pass. They must pounce on their weaker competitors when they have the chance. Tracks like these highlight the predator and prey relationship of multi-class racing.

At any one time, some 40 cars compete on the same track. With all this traffic, the prototypes rarely get the chance to demonstrate their full capabilities. Drivers rarely approach the top speeds set in single class qualifying sessions. Prototype drivers are more or less limited to driving at the top speeds of the GT class. Although the prototypes’ specs exist in a different universe than the GT cars, the Daytona cars only complete on average of five percent more laps than the GT cars.

Sports car racing is one of a few series offering multi-class competitions. Single class competitions are auto racing’s commercial juggernauts. In the case of F1, it’s a good thing; their car’s performance stretches the drivers to their limits. NASCAR, on the other hand, might benefit from this added level of complexity. Drivers in the Rolex Series must always be on their toes. They must compensate for slower drivers and uneven terrain. The nine hour season finale today at the Miller Motorsports Park– a 4.5 mile course made up of 24 turns and 12 straight-aways– will showcase their skills.

The race will resolve the battle for the championship in both classes. Jörg Bergmeister leads the Daytona Prototype class by 19 points. If he finishes better than 14th, the title’s his. Last year champions Luiz Diaz and Scott Pruett are in the hunt, and chasing. In the GT class, Mark Bunting and Andy Lally take an eight point lead into the finale. The number 72 Tafel Racing Porsche 997 piloted by Wolf Henzler and Robin Liddell Right is right behind with his Racer Group Pontiac GTO-R is. But this isn’t a two pony race; the other Racers Group Pontiac GTO-R (#65) is also in position to clinch the title.

The Rolex Series finale ends a hugely competitive series. As the classes grow next year, the excitement will continue. After the checkered flag drops this Sunday, we only have to wait until January for more.

By on September 2, 2006

26fordsnyder.jpgSince the Model T, car owners have paid good money to make their rides stand out from the crowd. A brass radiator cap, special head lights, a steering wheel that pivoted out of the way– these are just a few of the hundreds of mods that could turn a Tin Lizzie into your Tin Lizzie. Today, the trend continues with an even wider (and wilder) array of goodies lining the aisles of automotive parts emporia, tempting whoever wanders past with the promise of aesthetic liberation. With a few exceptions, the only thing that results from these efforts is a 9-1-1 to the taste police.

I know taste is subjective. I realize that we live in a society that guarantees its citizens’ freedom of expression. But there should be limits to what someone can do to a perfectly good car. On what grounds can you defend putting a vinyl coating on your car’s roof so it looks like a convertible when it clearly isn’t?  Although vinyl roofs had their heyday in the 70’s and early 80’s, along with platform shoes with fish in the heels, this unconscionable vulgarity refuses to disappear. The Chrysler 300 is the current favorite for this abomination but anything with wheels seems to be fair game. Anyone ever see an Aztec with a fake convertible top? I have. I still have nightmares about it.

honda-crx-rear-spoilerbodykit.jpg Most of the cosmetic accessories sold today do little more than identify their owner as a world-class poseur. Can anyone tell me the logic of slapping air dams and wings onto a car that’s never driven anywhere but the streets at speeds that require no aerodynamic addenda? Air dams and side skirts are one thing on an M3 prepped for a race course. They’re something else entirely on a Honda CRX being driven back and forth to work. And they fool no one. Nine times out of ten, the only thing they’re good for is hanging up on speed bumps, curbs and car washes.

The bright chrome wheels that look like an attachment for a Cuisinart are equally ludicrous. Adding spinners to the wheels only heightens the impression they are better suited for slicing salami than supporting a set of tires.  Most cars are styled for specific wheel sizes; adding dubs or double dubs makes them look like something that ended-up in Big Daddy Roth’s waste basket. When you see a $2k car with $4k wheels and spinners, it’s all show and no go.  Sometimes you have to wonder if the engine can produce enough torque to turn over those monstrosities.

caprice008.jpg Special mention goes to that category of modifications known as donks, bubbles and boxes. For those of you who haven’t kept up with the latest in urban transportation, these are 70’s and 80’s era GM rear wheel-drivers that have been jacked-up to fit the largest set of wheels possible (26-inchers are the most common size), sporting paint jobs that cost more than the book value of the vehicle. Lambo-style doors are optional, but highly desired.  These sick cars (in the classic meaning of the word, not the urban vernacular) bring to mind Back to the Future III. You know; the scene where Dr. Emmett Brown retrofits the Delorean with stagecoach wheels.  I can’t imagine what it must be like to try to turn a corner in one of these tipsy-looking hoopties-– which may explain why you see them driven slowly on city streets and never on the highways.

Thankfully, some customizers limit their forays to their car’s interior (instead of assaulting the sensibilities of innocent bystanders). Once upon a time, automotive interior decorating was limited to some new seat covers and a pair of fuzzy dice. Today, there are almost as many ways to screw-up the inside of a car as there are people willing to do it.  You can cover your chairs, dashboard, headliner and doors with everything from cow spots to urine-colored leather. Steering wheel covers range from the patently faux (petrochemical leather), to what the fo’ (fake fur). Neon lights can appear everywhere from the ash trays to the cupholders.

fr019.jpgI’m not picking on America’s automotive underclass. I know there are dozens of tuners who inflict massive taste failures on box fresh, world-class sports cars: Porsches, Lamborghinis, Ferraris and yes, Aston Martins. I also know that most owners who individualize their rides have good intentions– in the same sense that a teenage girl with a Mohawk haircut only wants to draw a little attention to herself (so she can tell onlookers to f-off). Unfortunately, they have no taste. They don’t understand the subtle joys of owning the right car perfectly specced-up at the factory, unmolested. Luckily for us, rappers and sports stars do.  More and more of the cars I see in Celebrity Rides are just that. Thank God.

By on September 1, 2006

model_t_assembly_line22.jpg The flame wars regarding “imports” versus "domestics" have reached Fahrenheit 451. Ironically enough, I’ve doused those fires by banning “any comments that attempt to impugn this site's authors or its commentators for an anti-domestic car bias.” And I mean it. To those who would malign this website on that basis, I state for the record that TTAC writers apply their critical facilities without fear or favor, regardless of a manufacturer’s national origin. Although I haven’t asked my scribes to take a loyalty oath, I’m sure they love their country. What they don’t love is crap cars.

News flash: the publisher of this site, the author of the GM Death Watch, would like to see The General build an affordable sedan that kicks the snot out of the so-called imports. Why? I’m a pistonhead. I’d like to drive that car, and it would force other automakers to raise their game. I’m well aware that The Big Two Point Five’s supporters will perceive this statement as weak and irrelevant: a personal failure to place our nation’s best interests above personal passion. They believe that car journalists ignore the “fact” that promoting “foreign” cars endangers their fellow Americans’ economic well-being. They consider us the import-loving enemy within.

Back in the 70’s, when the import invasion was just that– an invasion of foreign-made cars by foreign-owned manufacturers– this argument carried some weight. But not much. If ever an industry needed a wake-up call, it was the U.S. automotive market. By and large, in general and in specific, The Big Three’s cars were crap. Now I’m not going to tender my exact definition of “crap.” Suffice it to say, many of the imports were better built, better handling, more fuel efficient and cheaper than their American competition. Equally important, the journalists who pointed-out the imports’ relative excellence were not responsible for their arrival, or the domestics’ abject failure to rise to the challenge.

Today, the “buy American” argument is totally without merit. A number of TTAC articles have noted the imports’ American design and manufacturing presence relative to The Big Two Point Five’s outsourcing. When GM, Ford and DCX build and import foreign-made cars and slot an ever-increasing number of Chinese parts into their vehicles, their supporters have no right to drape themselves in the American flag. They also have no right to label critics of GM, Ford and DCX products unwitting opponents of the American working class, when the companies themselves show no compunction about selling foreign-made products to their American customers.

Nor are The Big Two Point Five's Supporters on solid ground when they suggest that TTAC’s car critics have been so blinded by their love of “foreign cars” they can’t see that GM, Ford and DCX have caught-up with the competition. My writers know their way around cars. They know what makes an interior a pleasure palace or a penalty box. They understand the subtle differences between engines, transmissions, suspensions, brakes and steering. They are not in the thrall of European dynamics or style; they can appreciate a big, brash comfy cruiser as much as a gorgeous, sharp-handling sports car– regardless of the vehicle's country of origin. If a TTAC writer says a Ford product is two model cycles behind a comparable Toyota, it’s the truth– to the best of that writer’s knowledge and critical abilities.

The pro-Detroit flamers last refuge is reliability; I’m well and truly fed up with arguments on this score. Supposedly, the gains made by The Big Two Point Five’s products in the most popular reliability studies prove that their cars are now as good as anyone else’s (no matter what anyone says to the contrary).  In fact, the closerthanthis results listed by these studies simply show that the battleground over automotive excellence has shifted. It’s no longer good enough for a car’s suspension not to break; it has to deliver superlative ride quality. A long-lasting engine isn’t a major advantage; it’s got to be smooth, powerful and fuel efficient. The real competition now surrounds perceived quality and, lest we forget, dealer service. I don't consider it biased to suggest that The Big Two Point Five have a long way to go in these areas.

In short, TTAC is an equal opportunity website. Do I really need to cite all the positive reviews this website has given The Big Two Point Five's products, or the negative reviews afforded imported cars? Tallying-up the hosannas and Bronx cheers within those two categories would reveal nothing but an invidious distinction. The cars and their manufacturers get what they deserve. Nothing more, nothing less.

So here’s the deal. If you want to hash out this issue, do it right here, right now. Get it out of your system. Do American cars suck, or are journos giving them a bum rap? You be the judge, jury and… executioner. But once you’ve had your say, you’re done. If you disagree with a reviewer over his or her assessments of a car, feel free to let rip. But I will NOT tolerate knee-jerk xenophobic attacks. All such comments will be deleted. Their authors will be banned. That is all.

By on September 1, 2006

gallery_c450020a.JPGIn his own ew-inducing sort of way, Oedipus defined the Tragic Hero. His story teaches us that character is fate; the arrogant King can no more escape his destiny than a bad guy on a cop show. And so it is with the Ford Taurus, a vehicle named for either the constellation of the same name (minus the Ford) or the Zodiac sign ascribed to it. According to pseudo- science, Taureans are practical, reliable, patient, affectionate, competent, ambitious, determined, lazy, jealous, inflexible, greedy and stubborn. And some people wonder why the model took twenty years to die an ignominious death…

By on August 31, 2006

ford_mustang_shelby_gt500.jpg No question, the Ford Mustang is a galloping success. Both the base and GT models are a runaway success, contributing significant revenue to their corporate parent. And now legendary racer, sports car constructor and chili magnate Carroll Shelby is adding some hot tamales to the feed bag. The Shelby Cobra GT500 goes on sale any second now, saddled with a supercharged 5.4-liter V8 good for 500hp. Although there’s little doubt that Shelby’s performance package will be a well-engineered addition to the core car’s strengths, it’s still a case of too much too late.

Let’s Review. For 50 percent more than the MSRP of a Mustang GT, the GT500 buyer gets a supercharger, an intercooler, a race-proven T56 six-speed manual transmission, suspension mods, 18” wheels, wider tires, distinctive spoiler and grill treatments and one whole Hell of a lot of Shelby badging. Oh, and roughly 400 pounds of additional weight, which push this pony car into the Crown Vic weight class. And that’s what I’m talking about: Ford’s decision to add horsepower to the Mustang instead of reducing weight.

It may be a piercing glimpse into the obvious, but Ford could have made a serious performance car out of the Mustang GT simply by shedding weight. In fact, if the 300hp GT lost 700 pounds, it would have the same power-to-weight ratio as the 500hp Shelby GT500. A leaner, meaner, altogether keener Mustang GT would find a willing market, and serve notice to GM and DaimlerChrysler that Ford isn’t going to cede the ponycar market quite yet. There are a number of ways, most of them relatively cheap, to ditch the Mustang’s extra pounds.

Start by eliminating the air conditioning. This lightweight GT (call it the GT-L) would be a potential race-ready road car, not a boulevard cruiser for hot nights in Vegas. If it wasn’t for the Federal standards about defrosters, you might be able to leave off the heater. But even with a heater and defroster, the elimination of the air conditioning unit would drop a lot of mass, and some drag on the engine as well. Next, ditch the power windows. If Ford made the call, its suppliers could come up with a manual window regulator in a heartbeat.

Likewise, lose the electric locks. Real racers can push their own lock buttons down. Ditto for the electric trunk release. Once those are gone, the module that controls these functions and related wiring can also be deleted, saving even more weight. The radio and CD player can also go; the glorious fury of the Mustang GT’s V8 is music enough to a performance junkie. And while we’re at it, deep-six the sound deadening material behind the front seats. And the back seats, rear seat belts and shoulder harnesses.

Ford can use the front fascia from the base six cylinder Mustang, delete the fog lights and save a few more pounds. The cladding on the rocker panels can go, too. Who cares if the tires throw a little dirt on the side of the car? And off with the spoiler. A real racer is going to fashion a spoiler that works, rather than one that satisfies the design committee. Removing the spare tire, jack and tools will also liberate some major heft.

These simple steps would get the Mustang coupe’s weight near the goal of 2600 lbs. Several more radical changes would get the weight to less than 2600 pounds. How ‘bout manual steering? Back to the supplier for a manual rack and pinion gear. This would allow the elimination, and drag, of the power steering pump. A Mustang with manual steering would probably be a bear to park, but pistonheads aren’t going to buy this car for their grandmothers. The final step: kill the center console. This would require some new parts, but the existing console has to be a lot heavier than a few rubber boots around the shifter.

Tweak the car’s suspension, add appropriate decals and there you have it: a Mustang that’s fully competitive with the Shelby version, and a lot better handling to boot. As less is sometimes less, the Mustang GT-L’s development costs would not be prohibitive. Lest we forget Shelby himself jettisoned ballast when he developed the GT350, ‘way back in the 60s. It was a belter that burnished the image created by the Cobra. Porsche, Mazda, Honda and several other manufacturers build lightweight performance cars like these. Even better for Ford, they charge more money for them. That’s a business plan that FoMoCo should latch onto pronto.

Of course, not many people would buy this car. But there is simply no underestimating the street cred a GT-L would generate for Ford and its entire Mustang franchise. Of course, there’s nothing to stop ole Shel from putting his Mustang on a diet…

By on August 30, 2006

chryslerfairyad.JPGIn a recent Saab TV ad, a fighter jet transmogrifies into a 9-7X. The Transformers shtick tries to convince truck buyers that Saab’s SUV was “born from jets.” There’s one small problem: the 9-7X was born from a Chevrolet. The model’s built in Moraine, Ohio next to (and out of) Trailblazers. And get this. During the transformation the engine rolls down into the engine compartment sideways. Couldn’t the geniuses who made this commercial bother to remember that the Trailblaz… uh… 9-7X has a “north-south” engine, not an “east-west” one like current Saabs? And so car companies continue their assault on pistonheads’ intelligence.

Fuel efficiency is the latest battlefield. Both Toyota’s “Hybrid Synergy” and Chevy’s “we sell loads of cars that get 30 mpg or better” ads may fool most of the people most of the time, but automotive alphas realize both companies peddle vast fleets of gas-guzzling trucks and SUVs. We’re also aware that Toyota would prefer their customers to pick-up a profit-rich Sequoia rather than a high-tech loss leader, while Chevy would more happily put you in a Suburban than one its low-powered, low margin base models. And by the way, when did it become OK for automakers to advertise a vehicle’s EPA highway mileage without identifying it as such? 

By the same token, we must endure car ads which lure us into a patently absurd, alterative reality. How about that Suzuki ad where Joe Businessman leaves a commuter house, kisses wifey bye-bye, dives off a cliff and parachutes to his Vitara? The scenario inspired my teenage son to ask “If the Vitara is so good off road, why does he have to park it way down there? Why didn’t he just drive it home?” Honda’s recent ad for the Ridgeline is equally ludicrous.

A brown bear blocks fishermen driving home. Instead of simply driving past the beast or reversing out of harm’s way, one intrepid camper gets out, fishes a salmon out of the Ridgeline’s in-bed trunk and tosses it at the bear. It’s a good thing they didn’t have a bed full of camping gear; that bear would have had them all by the time Mr. Sierra Club got to the fish. Actually, it’s a good thing Honda’s customers aren’t generally that stupid; otherwise, simple Darwinism would winnow their market in no time.

And then there’s the “silly little fairy” line in the Caliber commercial. Anyone who knows cars, sexual politics or advertising understands that Dodge is gay bashing to macho-up the po-faced hatchback genre. Hummer’s tofu ad makes the same mistake in reverse, fighting a rear-guard campaign against people who see the over-sized SUV and mutter the word “over-compensation.” You know: the guy buys an H3 just to prove to he has adequate OEM reproductive equipment. The original tagline for the commercial was "Reclaim your manhood."  After a few airings it became “Restore the balance.” Apparently they didn’t want to alienate car-savvy eunuchs.

As a pistonhead of a certain age, I know that repetition is the better part of remembering. But how many times can a car mad curmudgeon listen to the faceless voice intone, "It's here, but not forever" about the Lexus model year closeout without wanting to shout “No, it just seems that way”?

And whose idea was it to use bobbleheads in the Jeep Compass commercial? Is the car really so lame The Dark Lords of DCX couldn’t find anything to say about it? While there’s a percentage of the population who’ll nod their heads in unison with their spokesdolls, surely Jeep should make some kind of case to people who are actually interested in cars, rather than assault us with bizarre imagery. Speaking of creepy, how about that Mercedes “Cruise Night” ad with a drag race between Celine Dion and a metrosexual?  Why would a German automaker want to show Americans a world where every single car is a Mercedes? That’s just not right.

It’s time for carmakers to try something novel that won’t insult their core clientele. It’s time for them to tell the truth to the people who know what’s what. For example, an ad for a Chevrolet Impala would show shoppers browsing rows of washing machines, refrigerators and Impalas, choosing the Chevy as their favorite transportation appliance. A Freestyle ad could show a divorced couple actually behaving like a divorced couple, instead of acting as if they’re on a date.

“Dr. Z” would confess that Karl Benz invented the car, not Daimler-Chrysler, and sell the 300 as the finest last gen E-Class Mercedes money can buy (including his beloved rear suspension).  Mazda would own up to the fact that their CX-7 has more in common with a Fusion than with a Miata, and recommend buying a CX-7 because it’s not a Ford. Oh, and no one would ever claim anything based on JD Power survey results.  Then again, maybe not.  

By on August 28, 2006

ostrich2.gifMotor Trend just reviewed the new Saturn Aura. Reading between the lines, it’s clear that GM’s mission critical mainstream motor is another in a long, not-so-illustrious line of “almost” cars. It’s “no sports sedan” with lots of “corner cutting” powered by a “crude” engine with “some looseness in the drivetrain.” The Aura is a “step in the right direction”– that leaves the badge-engineered Opel at least two steps behind the competition. Anyway, does it even matter? I reckon GM’s car business is beyond repair. 

For the first time, the California Motor Car Dealers Association published new car registration data listed by brand. In the second financial quarter, Toyota captured 24.4% of the Golden State’s automotive market. Honda scored second place, at 12.4%. Then it’s Ford at 9.6%; followed by Chevrolet, at 8.2%. If national sales follow California’s lead, GM is toast. There is no way The General can support its vast infrastructure, overhead and labor costs, there’s no way the company can downsize quickly enough, to survive on that kind of market slice.

The automaker’s California conundrum: the resale market. There isn’t one. Hundreds of thousands of California immigrants, first-timer buyers, commuters and elderly consumers swear by used Hondas and Toyotas. Their preference creates a vicious circle: buyers shun new GM products because they can’t unload them. In the mass market, big depreciation is a kind of living death.

Never mind the BS about GM’s products being torpedoed by left-leaning, import-loving— I mean, “foreign-owned automaker”-loving journalists. GM shot itself in both feet and both arms for decades, building rental fleet fodder instead of competitive product. Even if you accept the dubious notion that GM now makes automobiles that match Toyota's and Honda’s (on some levels), even if you swallow the argument that GM is suffering from an indefensible “perception gap,” there’s only way to reverse this death spiral: "must have" products.

Not decent cars. Not reasonably competitive cars. Not cars that only make sense because they’re so damn cheap and no other new car dealer (except Ford) will give me a loan. Not the new Saturn Aura. I’m talking about cars like the Saturn Sky— only with room for four adults and a trunk.

Saturn’s new motto– “Like Always. Like Never Before”– says it all. Here’s a company, indeed an entire corporation that needs to sever its ties to its mediocre, vainglorious past and build spectacular products. It just… can’t… do it. I know; Saturn’s motto supposedly reasserts their user-friendliness. But what does “Like Always” say to people who dismissed Saturn as a boring, out-of-date brand?

By the same token, what does “Like Never Before” say? It’s a po-faced claim that Saturn is better than it was, not better than the rest. It’s that inwards-facing commitment to relative improvement that defines the vast majority of GM’s products and condemns them to also-ran status. Not that GM knows it. The General’s complete obliviousness to the average non-customer’s opinion of their products is one of the most disturbing aspects of GM’s fall from grace. Well that and their failure to acknowledge their competitors’ achievements and beat their best-in-class benchmarks.

Detroit’s unjustifiable arrogance towards the imports in the 70’s is well known. But few people appreciate the fact that this holier-than-thou attitude is still in effect, informing everything the company does– and doesn’t do.  I recently received an email from a GM insider containing a memo from Ed Wellburn, GM’s Vice President of Design. After proclaiming “GM’s turnaround plan is truly working as witnessed by our 2nd quarter results”, Wellburn issued a new edict:

“Design Center is host to journalists, ‘celebrities’ and senior management up to and including the Board of Directors. The confidence we have in our products and people should be evident to anyone who drives on the Technical Center site, especially in the vicinity of the Design buildings and adjacent roads. 

“As such, I am directing that ONLY GM products be parked on the roads around Design and in the parking area in front of our building. Any employees or suppliers/vendors who are not driving GM products may use the west and north parking lots.

“Effective August 15, 2006, this policy will be in effect. After this date, any non-GM vehicles parked on the roadways or in designated parking areas in front of the Design building will be ticketed. In the case of multiple offenses, the vehicle will be towed at the owner’s expense.”

And there you have it: GM management’s desire to shelter in their own little universe, quarantined from the realities of the outside world. Think about it: Wellburn's directive sends both employees and visitors driving non-GM vehicles to the back lots. It also means that GM-driving designers who enter the building upon which their company’s fate depends only encounter GM products. In short, what you can’t see… can kill you. 

By on August 28, 2006

x-type2222.jpg Every time an automotive research firm releases the results of a reliability survey, the focus is the same: who “won.” Firms like J.D. Power only publicly release model-level results for the top performers. Even where these firms release scores for all contenders at the make level, journalists focus on the winners. After all, John Q. wants someone to tell him which car to buy in as few words as possible. In the process, any car buyer truly interested in identifying the best car for their needs and wants gets left in the dark.

Yet few people realize this. It seems so natural to focus on the winners, whether the topic is an election, the NBA playoffs, or vehicle reliability. But let’s play “which one of these is not like the others” for a second. If someone wins an election by one vote, they get the office. If a team wins a deciding playoff game by one point, they get to move on to the next round. And if you buy the car that won an award by one point, you get…what?

In most cases, you do not get the car that best suits your needs. When evaluating a car, most people care about more than whether or not it’s the least likely to break. They’re also likely to be concerned about how it looks, how it drives, how well the seat fits their rear and more. Often the award winner isn’t nearly as attractive, as fun to drive or as comfortable as a competitor. Tradeoffs are a necessary part of the purchasing process.

Most reliability surveys provide dot ratings– with unspecified ranges of reliability– for the non-winners. But without the actual, precise scores for all the contenders, trading off quality against other factors is impossible. Buy the award winner and you’ll have a pretty good idea of how much style, performance, or comfort you’re giving up. But you won’t know how much “quality” you’re gaining in return. Say it’s one dot’s worth. Well, how much is that? Unfortunately, to make a wise choice, you need to know.

In a basketball game, a basket at the final buzzer can and should be the deciding factor. The closer the game, the more exciting it is to watch. But vehicle reliability isn’t about entertainment (though the news stories that cover the awards may be). The closer scores are, the less they matter. And the scores are often quite close.

In J.D. Power’s 2006 Initial Quality Study (IQS), 30 of 37 makes fell within two-tenths of a manufacturing defect per car of the average. The difference between number three (Toyota) and number 32 (Hummer) was 0.27 problems per car. In J.D.’s most recent Vehicle Dependability Study (VDS), 23 of 37 makes fell within half a problem per car of the 2.27 average. Only four makes— three of them domestic— bettered the average by more than half a problem per car.

Real-world problems occur in wholes. A car cannot have 1.79 problems. So Toyota’s VDS score of 179 implies that the typical Toyota has two problems in its third year. And Ford’s score of 224 implies… much the same thing. Buy a Toyota over an alleged “Fix or Repair Daily” car, and you gain no guarantees, just a middling chance of avoiding a single additional problem in the third year.

No one gets all hung up on vehicle reliability to avoid a single additional problem. Most consumers simply want to avoid buying a lemon that’s in the shop “all the time.” Well, reliability scores based on averages don’t help. Say we’ve got two basketball teams. On one, the average height is 6'5”. On the other, the average height is 6'7”. Which team has the most players over seven feet? Using averages alone, it’s impossible to say.

Time to buy a car. You know the award winners, and not much else. Play it safe and you’re likely sacrifice style, performance or comfort to maximize your odds of having one or two fewer mechanical problems. Ignore the surveys and there’s no telling how much car trouble you’ll have. Maybe none at all. Maybe a lot. The research firms know. But they’re not going to tell you. They only provide potentially helpful comprehensive data to corporate clients willing to pay the big bucks. 

Hang in there. My website, TrueDelta , is committed to clarifying how cars differ in reliability, from the "best" right down the “worst.” We’re working hard to collect unbiased real-world data on your behalf. And TTAC can always be counted on to go beyond the superficial story. (How many critiques of J.D. Power’s methodology have you seen in the mainstream automotive press?) Someday soon, you’ll be able to identify the car that best suits your needs and wants— without playing a guessing game that’s stacked against you.

By on August 27, 2006

f1-safety-car.jpgF1 is the prima donna of the motorsports stage, steeped in tradition. To the idealistic amongst us, Max and Bernie’s show stills sings a siren song: dazzling technology, elite pilots, glitz and glamour, the passion of competition and the pursuit of perfection. The reality is somewhat grimier and less spectacular than the sport’s aura would lead us to believe. Even so, there are good reasons why today’s races have so little in common with the epic and sometimes fatal battles of the sport’s golden age.

The romantics among us picture Fangio’s Maserati 250F on the banking at Monza or Stirling Moss thrashing his revolutionary, mid-engined Cooper around Goodwood. Today, Monza’s banked corners are slowly going back to nature, their concrete remains spotted with graffiti. The German Hockenheimring has suffered a similar fate. Organizers have abandoned its tree-lined forest straights for a new, sanitized, Herman Tilke-fied version. The course is now utterly devoid of the character that gave the original circuit its allure.  F1’s powers have dismantled and discarded some of the defining facets of the sport.

And no wonder. While today’s spectators will never see Schumacher’s 248 F1 dart through the Masta Kink at Spa or streak through an un-chicaned Tamburello, drivers will never face the sort of needless dangers that typified these tracks. Lest we forget, Spa nearly claimed Jackie Stewart in ’66.

Stewart went off at Masta at more than 130mph, struck a stone wall. Trapped in his mangled machine, the driver lay battered in the cockpit covered by searing racing fuel for more than 15 minutes before rescue personnel arrived. Once the rescue team extricated Stewart from the car, it was a further 20 minutes before he arrived at a medical facility (the ambulance crew got lost en route). Upon arrival, the Scot was shocked to find that the “medical facility” was a dirty concrete slab surrounded by cigarette butts.

Stewart’s shunt at Masta shed light on the inherent danger of circuits run through villages and farmland, bordered by houses, trees, fences and light poles. The inherent dangers that almost led to Stewart's demise was remedied by the evisceration of the historic nine mile circuit at Spa-Francorchamps, curtailing its length by more than fifty percent and reducing average speeds considerably. Consider that the highest average speed achieved by a Formula 1 car over a lap at Spa was over 150mph, achieved in 1970 by then 20 year-old Pedro Rodriguez.  As a sign of the times, Rodriguez was dead less than 12 months later, a victim of the same safety deficiencies that defined early F1.

The Tamburello circuit's design contributed to Ayrton Senna’s death in ‘94. Both incidenta were catalysts for a sea change in safety and course design. That said, Senna’s tragic end elucidated the immense improvements in circuit safety. Unlike Stewart, Senna was surrounded by medical personnel and marshals less than 15 seconds after his Williams struck the barriers. Senna’s death has been attributed to a strike on his helmet by a piece of wildly flailing front suspension, ripped from his machine as he made contact with the Armco. Senna’s tragic end accelerated the push for greater driver and spectator safety that had begun in earnest following the notable shunts of the early 70’s.

Europe’s legendary circuits may lack the air of danger that made them legendary, but they’ve become quantitatively better circuits. For drivers, strategically placed run-of areas, deformable barriers and safety-conscious circuit design provide a critical measure of extra safety. The tracks are also designed with rescue crew response teams and medical helicopter access in mind (F1 races are now subject to cancellation should weather conditions ground the medical helicopter).

The removal of the trees that lined so many circuits, undertaken in the interest of preventing accidents like Jim Clark’s at Hockenheim, has improved sight lines. The 100k plus spectators that attend the German GP at Hockenheim annually are able to see much of the circuit from their grandstand seats.  The dark forest straights may be gone, but the spectacle is not. The much-lamented loss of character and length of many circuits has, in this case at least, greatly benefited the spectator experience.

The danger and heroism of the world of early F1 has passed into memory. And yet that legacy lives on beneath the increasingly corporate veneer. Moss’ Cooper, which had its humble beginnings as a 500cc F2 racer, has formed the basis for every F1 car that followed it. Spa’s Eau Rouge remains as daunting as ever. The MP4/21 McLaren Mercedes wears the silver that adorned its Teutonic predecessors. And the fact remains that just like in 1955, a Formula 1 car remains the absolute fastest way to get around a road course. 

By on August 26, 2006

dsc049102222.jpg A $60 tip might not seem like much in Reno, but at a Taco Bell? A customer asked the manager if she ever gave anything away for free. When she handed him the entire meal for nothing, he threw her three Andrew Jacksons. The exchange was no more inexplicable than some of the deals going down at the Reno-Sparks Convention Center during the Hot August Nights (HAN) car auction.

HAN is a weeklong, self-professed “celebration of rock-and-roll and cars.” This year, Mike Love, Bruce Johnston and their paid friends (a.k.a. The Beach Boys) entertained Baby Boomers to the tune of $50 to $75 a pop. Participants who preferred metal antiques could watch a nightly procession of chromed and metal-flake machines cruising up-and-down Virginia Street.

Meanwhile, Silver Auctions put some 900 vehicles up for grabs. I say “some” because gauging the exact number of vehicles for sale wasn’t easy. Towards the end of the auction, cars that hadn’t met their reserve (the owner’s pre-established minimum) were shuffled back and offered with “no reserve” (last bidder takes all).

shelby.jpg Anyway, on Thursday, two collectors proved it only takes two people to make an auction. Both guys wanted a 1966 Shelby-American GT-350 fastback coupe so bad they were willing to make the winner pay through the nose for the privilege. The car’s seller had stoked the fires by circulating a laminated sheet of paper listing the vehicle’s VIN number and the names of all the former owners. The provenance cited the original owner– an obscure (failed?) actor named Don Lococo-– and the date when the car’s color was changed to Wimbledon White with Guardsman Blue. It found a new home for $120k (plus six percent buyer’s fee).

The battle marked the start of Shelbymania. A 1967 Ford/Shelby-American Mustang 500KR fastback went for $167,500 (plus six percent buyer’s fee). Of course, both cars were original and correct— which is auction speak for “you can pay stupid money for this car and soothe your savaged wallet by telling yourself (and your wife) that you bought ‘the real thing’.”

That said, thanks to well-heeled muscle car collectors, the pursuit of authenticity ain’t what it used to be. Many of the muscle cars on offer were announced as “tribute” cars. It seems that “clone” and “recreation” didn’t bestow proper respect on these meticulously modified machines; so “tribute” has become the mechanically correct adjective to describe muscle-car wannabes.

Well fair enough. Many of these tribute cars were indistinguishable from– and better built than– the original article. For example, Lot 174 consisted of a 1969 Chevrolet Camaro powered by a 425 horsepower, 427 cubic-inch Chevrolet V8 connected to a Tremec six-speed manual. It was announced as a “Yenko tribute” car; a paean to the performance guru who convinced Chevy to build a limited run of 427 Camaros so he could plaster them with stickers and sell them at an appropriate premium. Sure enough, Lot 174 wore a full complement of Yenko decals and badges.

yenko.jpgThose who know about such things would have quickly scanned the Camaro’s VIN number and unmasked the imposter– if they somehow missed the six speeds atop the shift knob. And? The “Yenko tribute” Camaro was nice enough to fool most of the people most of the time. At $38,500, it was even something of a bargain.

Staying with the ersatz car theme, a couple of Dodge Challengers and Plymouth Barracudas “Hemi tribute” cars also went up for grabs. Again, because only anally retentive—I mean, extremely knowledgeable muscle car aficionados would smell a rat, the cars brought around $75k apiece. That’s not a bad deal for a non-factory Hemi-head look-alike, considering that Challengers and Cudas that were blessed with a factory-fitted hemispherical combustion chamber fetch high sixes and low sevens.

Woody wagons are hot as the beaches they once inhabited. One 1949 Pontiac station wagon sold at $51,250 with faux wood. The delicately hand-painted sides were so realistic that tapping on the painted metal (or attaching a magnet) was the only way to expose the ruse. As is the way of such things, the auctioneers forgot to share that tidbit. When the buyer discovered that he hadn’t bought a real woody, he accepted his fate. After all, by his own admission, he’d been drunk at the time. Can’t blame that on the auctioneers, eh?

bel-air.jpg The 1955-‘57 Chevrolets were the unofficial stars of the auction. It was buyer’s choice, from stock to pro-street. Prices ranged from $25,500 for stock two-door sedans to $75k to $85k for fuellie convertibles. Then there was a reminder of a simpler, goofier time: a 1958 BMW Isetta. The one-door wonder sold for an astounding $38,500 ($40,810.00 with buyer's fee). Why? Like the Taco Bell transaction, it was just another example of random financial chaos, adjusted, as always, for market trends.  

By on August 25, 2006

beret.jpg For over 60 years, The United Autoworkers Union (UAW) has sold itself as the protector of America’s working class. According to their web site, “We’ve used our bargaining power to demand – and win – a role for union members to ensure that consumers receive the highest possible quality cars and trucks.” Regardless of your view of the quality of UAW-built vehicles, the union’s gained tremendous power on the factory floor, secured a group of benefits that are the envy of workers everywhere and amassed a mountain of money. So, now that GM and Ford are in trouble, will the UAW give anything back? Here’s what the union has to lose…

The Big 2.5’s UAW members receive an average wage of $29.75 per hour and full medical coverage. They also get an average of 16.5 paid vacation days per year, on top of three weeks paid vacation (Canadian members get four weeks). UAW workers who transfer to a plant “outside of their area” get a $25k relocation allowance– even if they don’t change residence. Employment is guaranteed.

The UAW’s Director of Public Relations reports that only 40% of his union's membership work on automotive assembly lines. Paul Krell says the rest are drawn from a wide range of other industries— from casinos to government-funded schools. But even as the UAW successfully broadens its base, the total number of dues paying members has declined dramatically. According to Department of Labor, the UAW lost 144,719 active members from 2001 to 2005. The loss leaves them with 557,099 active members and over 500k retired members spread throughout the United States, Canada and Puerto Rico.

Crucially, despite the drop in membership, the UAW’s assets continue to grow. Over the same four years, the union’s financial holdings have increased by $93,722,955. At the end of 2005, the UAW reported assets totaling $1.235b, including over three-quarters of a billion dollars worth of treasury securities. The union earned $54.4m in interest income during 2005, mostly from their $914m strike fund.

Even when the UAW makes concessions, their cash flow remains sacrosanct. For example, the UAW struck an agreement with Chrysler that permanently denies seniority or full employee status to "temporary" employees at the automaker's Belvidere, Illinois facility. These “temps” receive 70 percent of a full timer’s pay as long as they work. After seven months, they get minimum healthcare benefits. And what do one third of Belvidere’s workers get in exchange for foregoing the usual union-negotiated benefits?  They get to pay full union dues and vote on UAW-Chrysler contracts. And that’s it.

It must be remembered that the UAW has some pretty heavy expeneses, albeit mostly overhead. In 2005, the union spent $8.2m on lobbying and political activities. Another $88m went to UAW employees’ salaries. Forty-two million more covered the UAW employees' benefits. Even if union dues drop, these payouts will continue apace. According to union rules, the Executive Board can divert $50m from their strike fund to their general fund to support operations (as they did at this year’s convention in Las Vegas). In fact, they can transfer up to $60m per year from the same source for the next four years.

In short, the UAW is a large and extremely well-funded organization. Active members enjoy high wages and benefits (estimated by bankrupt auto parts supplier Delphi to cost $76 per hour) along with unassailable job security. Retired members also receive an extremely generous pension and excellent health care provisions. But now that Ford and GM have paid off tens of thousands of the union’s senior members, it’s the less tenured and “temporary workers” who hold the key to the UAW’s— and the automakers’ —future.

Ford and GM’s worker buyout programs have removed the workers who can most afford to make concessions. It’s highly unlikely that the remaining, less well-paid UAW members will agree to significant cuts to their compensation. Union bosses know that holding the line on wages, pensions and benefits could throw Ford and GM into Chapter 11. They also know that large concessions would trigger wildcat strikes, which could also lead to Chapter 11. But most importantly of all, they know they have the cash and non-automotive member base to survive a nuclear winter.

Given these factors, the UAW will do everything in their power to maintain the status quo. In the main, they’ll hold the line on their current compensation. At the same time, they'll dress-up minor concessions as "historic givebacks:" proof of their concern for their employers' well-being. (The tactic will absolve them of any blame if and when the automakers go belly-up.) The “radical” union members are the fly in the proverbial ointment. Whether or not the union bosses can keep them in line will ultimately determine the timing of Detroit’s terminal decline.

Recent Comments

  • Lou_BC: @Carlson Fan – My ’68 has 2.75:1 rear end. It buries the speedo needle. It came stock with the...
  • theflyersfan: Inside the Chicago Loop and up Lakeshore Drive rivals any great city in the world. The beauty of the...
  • A Scientist: When I was a teenager in the mid 90’s you could have one of these rolling s-boxes for a case of...
  • Mike Beranek: You should expand your knowledge base, clearly it’s insufficient. The race isn’t in...
  • Mike Beranek: ^^THIS^^ Chicago is FOX’s whipping boy because it makes Illinois a progressive bastion in the...

New Car Research

Get a Free Dealer Quote

Who We Are

  • Adam Tonge
  • Bozi Tatarevic
  • Corey Lewis
  • Jo Borras
  • Mark Baruth
  • Ronnie Schreiber