Category: Editorials

By on July 11, 2006

Ford-Transit-Supervan32.jpgNoticed any Sprinters lately?  Not the kind that burn-up your local running track; the boxy, diesel powered Sprinter vans sold by Dodge and Freightliner.  If you’re a typical enthusiast, these vehicles are less likely to appear on your automotive radar than a Toyota Camry.  But the Sprinter should have been on Ford’s radar.  The commercial vehicle represents a rapidly growing market segment that DaimlerChrysler is busy claiming for itself. That’s a couple of hundred thousand trucks a year, with good margins.  Gone.

Mercedes launched the Sprinter in 1995.  The model arrived in a myriad of guises: crewbus, panel van or pickup; standard or high roof; with a choice of three different wheelbases and engine choices; and three window and seat configurations.  Freightliner first assembled the Euro-friendly Sprinter in the US for FedEx.  Chrysler now builds them and sells the machine through its Dodge dealers.  The Sprinter’s also found a following amongst civic groups and people who want a box on wheels to schlep seven kids, two dogs and four potted plants.

Another design coup by DCX?  Hardly.  Ford has been building a similar vehicle for some time.  The Transit is Ford’s Euro-spec commercial van, and it’s a huge success.  European commercial fleet magazines have given the Transit rave reviews.  People who’ve driven both rate the Transit superior to the Sprinter in many respects: user flexibility, seat configurations, number and position of doors and windows; the availability of various lengths and heights. The Transit is available in both front-wheel drive and rear-wheel drive, and offers an even wider array of diesel and gasoline engines than the Sprinter.  And the Transit’s flat bed and dump box options trump the Sprinter’s iteration count.

In short, the Transit is a worthy and logical competitor to DCX’ workhorse: a vehicle with all the versatility, economy, safety (ABS standard from the git go) and reliability America’s tradesmen need to help keep the country’s economy strong.  No wonder, then, that the United Parcel Service (UPS) started enquiring about a US version of the Transit for their enormous fleet.  Ford had a close and profitable relationship with UPS; the Blue Oval Boys supply the underpinnings for most of the parcel service’s brown, meat-loaf shaped trucks.  And yet Ford, awash in SUV profits, hung up the phone.  That was six years ago.

A year later, DCX’ announced that they were bringing the Sprinter into the US. Again, Ford chose to ignore the threat to their domestic market share and cold shoulder their easily-accessible potential response.  This despite the urgings of many mid-level managers in FoMoCo’s commercial truck division.  Again, the guys in brown repeated their request for a Transit.  Again, nothing doing.  Ford was concerned that a successful Transit might steal the sales from the Ford Econoline: the vehicle that dominated the US commercial van market for decades.   

This myopia has, once again, proved to be another lost opportunity for Ford.  Not only did DaimlerChrysler sell Sprinters to FedEx and other commercial users, but even American tradesmen are deserting Ford’s Econoline for DCX’ Sprinter. The square Sprinter is now seen all over suburbia, serving the men who service the furnaces, appliances, garage door openers and all the other appurtenances of suburban life.  A few early-adopters even bought them for personal use. DaimlerChrysler, having monopolized the minivan market for decades, now stands to own the boxy van market as well.

And now, even the men in brown have deserted Ford and equipped their delivery drivers with Sprinters. Perhaps they simply tired of asking Ford for a Transit of their own. The Ann Arbor area has at least four UPS Sprinters; UPS is putting them on the road all across America. GM’s refusal to enter the fray makes some sense; they don’t have a competitive product and they’ve got a lot more pressing issues to worry about (meeting the payroll, staying one step ahead of the bill collectors, etc.).  FIAT, Renault and Peugeot have similar products, but none of them have a US distribution network or name recognition.

But Ford has everything: a terrific product at a great price (most Transits are constructed in a hi-tech, low-wage Turkish factory), a strong reputation in trucks, and a stellar dealer and service network.  And just in case you’re thinking that the Transit isn’t sufficiently “American” for the job, clock this: as part of Alex Trotman’s Ford 2000 program, the Transit was designed and engineered in Dearborn.   

Ford’s product development team has shown themselves increasingly incapable of making more than a handful of products that appeal to large numbers of buyers. Now Ford marketing has shown themselves incapable of supplying an existing product to customers who are literally asking for it.  I’m sure there are plenty of “good reasons” for their reticence.  I’m equally sure they're turning a slam dunk to a game losing around-the-rim-and-out.     

By on July 10, 2006

ap_logo.gifI’m not a big fan of segregation.  Obviously, US car culture splits into distinct niches: hot rodders, low-riders, urban gangstas, tuners, etc.  Equally obvious, these niches attract adherents from specific ethnic groups.  But just as communities throughout my home state meet down at the markets as they root around for fresh ingredients for their ethnic cuisine, there is an element of respect and inter-mingling between these petrol-powered fraternities.  Anyway, I don’t get the male – female automotive divide.  I seriously doubt that there’s a female automotive perspective– even when it comes to child safety and minivanning.  So when I saw a press release about a new female-oriented automotive website, I decided to do what it said on the tin: ask Patty.  Turns out “Patty” is a male invention and the company producing the website makes its money sensitizing dealers to “women’s needs.”  I quizzed Jody Devere, President of www.askpatty.com, about the statistical justification for the segregation.        

By on July 10, 2006

jackal-12.jpgAfter carefully considering the potential benefits of a GM – Nissan – Renault alliance, auto industry analysts have concluded that the deal makes about as much sense as Finnegan’s Wake.  Well duh.  Anyone even vaguely familiar with GM’s current crisis knows there’s only one thing the General needs right now: vehicles that people want to buy, at a price that makes the company a profit.  This they don’t have.  And guess what?  Nissan – Renault can't give it to them.  Even if Nissan and GM and Renault could work together (a completely preposterous concept), you’d see a second gen Chevrolet Camaro long before you’d see a hit product.  No, there’s something else in play here…

To understand why this weird-ass multinational deal has progressed to the point where GM CEO Rabid Rick Wagoner and Nissan – Renault boss Carlos “The Jackal” Ghosn are headed for a Bastille Day chin wag, it's important not to "over think" it.  The main players' motivations run the gamut from self-preservation all the way to greed, and back.  To wit: the whole thing was started by a man who's lost a billion dollars on GM's shares.  I don't know about you, but if I'd dropped a bil on a bunch of losers who refuse to institute radical change or even set targets towards profitability, I'd want to A) protect my investment from Chapter 11 and B) kick some ass. 

From that perspective, convincing Nissan – Renault to buy up 20% of GM’s stock makes perfect sense. TTAC’s sources reveal that GM’s cash position is slipping well below $10b every month– perilously close to the $5b pad it needs to stay in business.  Inventories are still up, and sales are still down.  Kerkorian’s game of footsie with the foreigners would add $3b to GM’s kitty.  That could be enough money to keep GM afloat until the end of the year, when cash from the sale of its GMAC finance unit finally arrives. At that point, GM would enter another one of those endlessly reoccurring “false dawns.”  Kirkorian could sell off his stock at a profit and die in peace. 

Analysts don’t see cash as a factor.  They believe Kirk’s play was designed to replace Rabid Rick with the Jackal.  It's an equally plausible scenario.  Despite the fact that Rabid Rick's administration has been an unmitigated disaster, GM's CEO has displayed a unique talent for self-preservation.  His message– slim the structure, stay the course– appeals to all of those GM's constituencies who have a vested interest in maintaining the status quo.  Which is, of course, everyone other than Kirk Kerkorian.

To remove Wagoner, Kirk had to offer The Powers That Be a suitable alternative.  You want a turnaround?  Let's hire the only man on planet Earth who's already done the deed.  The stock market responded to the possibility of Monsieur Cost Cutter taking the reins at GM with predictable enthusiasm.  GM's Board of Bystanders reacted with equal predictability.  After a due diligence conference call with Nissan – Renault execs, GM’s conclave of corporate co-conspirators charged Rick Wagoner with the task of further exploring a GM – Nissan – Renault alliance.  The appointment assured a less than positive recommendation on the plan and a competitive entry in The Most Bizarre Business Meeting of the Year award.  

GM’s Board quite rightly perceived Nissan – Renault as rapacious raiders, and sent their main man to defend GM against the barbarians at the gate.  Never mind cover talk about corporate synergy.  Nissan – Renault doesn't need GM's production facilities, technology, parts, platforms, dealers or office space.  This is all about Carlos Ghosn desire to add another pelt to his collection.  Wagoner's mob knows it, and they don't like it one bit.  When Rabid Rick meets the The Jackal, one can imagine that it will be a pissing match the likes of which this industry hasn't seen since its earliest days.  And then everyone will get back to work, as Kerkorian tries to find another stick that he can use to beat-up GM.

Only this deal has already inflicted tremendous damage on GM.  TTAC's Deep Throat told me he took his car in for repairs over the weekend.  The guy behind the counter asked if he'd heard that Nissan and Renault were buying GM.  Remember when President Bush announced he wouldn't be bailing-out GM?  Same thing: a clear message to America that The General is on the skids.  Whether or not the Jackal replaces Rabid Rick, the mere possibility of a deal with Johnny Foreigner shakes already rocky public confidence in the world's largest automaker.  The tipping point– where lowered sales makes people less likely to buy a GM product– just got closer.  Like it or not, when next quarter's disastrous results are revealed, The Quiet Lion will be heard.

By on July 10, 2006

sebring2.jpgSometimes the photos don’t do a car justice. This is one of those times: the 2007 Chrysler Sebring is even uglier in the metal than it is in the photos. Hunting for a parking space last week, I had the bad luck to come upon a parked black 2007 Sebring in full production trim. Chrysler’s PR flacks gush that the new sedan is a “strikingly beautiful design” that’s “poised to inspire.”  They got the second part right. Chrysler fans are warned to look away as I share the fruits of my inspiration.

With the new Sebring, Chrysler’s designers have taken the art deco design cues that have made the Crossfire sports car such a rousing success (most depart dealer lots within a year of arriving) and transferred them onto the most cursed proportions in recent memory.  A rotund proboscis attached to a huge front overhang leads into a sweeping arched roofline that terminates in an abbreviated rear deck.  The Saturn ION employs similar proportions, as will the 2007 Nissan Sentra.  But Chrysler’s rendition is the worst of a bad bunch. 

Compare the Sebring to the 2003 Airflite concept that supposedly inspired it.  You know those made-for-TV movies that were supposedly “inspired by a true story?”  It’s the same deal: shared details, totally different result.  On the Airflite, the car’s nose is more chiseled and much less bulbous, the front wheel opening doesn’t crowd the front door opening and the roofline has more sweep and less arch.  The Airflite is strikingly beautiful.  The Sebring is an Airflite that’s totally let itself go.

airflite453.jpg Returning to the nose; round contours and huge, droopy headlights suggest a theme originally intended for a minivan, but later stretched for sedan duty.  As on the Crossfire, Chrysler’s stamped a half dozen grooves into the hood.  Perhaps they’re there for the dozen or so people who have lusted after a Crossfire, but did not buy one because they needed a back seat for the kiddies.

The doors are the best part of the design— by default.  As on the Pacifica, a deep undercut character line breaks up tall body sides. On the Crossfire, a character line that begins similarly performs a complicated transition from a concave to a convex surface. No awe-inspiring gymnastics here; just reasonably clean body sides whose sheerness conflicts with the blobby front fenders and amorphous rear lamps.

side.jpgSometimes when a car is designed, the designers and the engineers work at cross-purposes.  Bad proportions are one clue.  The window outline is another.  When the engineers fail to deliver the window outline the designers desire, the designers often “cheat”; they’ll tack on a black bit of trim to make it appear that the windows extend further than they do. It’s a nasty little trick that never works well: the automotive equivalent of heavy eye makeup. Then again, I once told a [long gone] girlfriend she might look better without so much eye makeup. When she stopped putting it on I realized why she'd been using so much. It’s like that with the new Sebring.

On a black car, like the one I saw, the black trim triangle disappears into the body. And, what do you know, my eyes wanted it back. Man, that’s one fat, ugly C-pillar.  Even if the window opening were as large as the designers wanted, the result still wouldn’t have looked good. The Sebring is only a couple inches taller than the Airflite, but those two inches, when combined with a seven-inch wheelbase reduction and a more conventionally-raked windshield, are passion killers. Like a pilot attempting an emergency landing on a short, alpine airstrip, the sweeping roofline must come down too far, too fast.  Seems the designers had given up on a graceful landing. They just wanted to land.

sebring34.jpg

The Sebring’s designers apparently ran out of any ideas, good or otherwise, once they reached the Sebring’s literal end. The sedan’s large tail lamps could be from any one of the innocuously styled, utterly forgettable sedans of the late aero period. Their shapelessness bears some kinship to the droopy headlights, but none to the rear quarters in which they are embedded.

Overall, the Sebring appears to be the outcome of a “just get it done” mentality. It isn’t hard to guess the source of such a mentality: DaimlerChrysler ended its decades-old partnership with Mitsubishi, the provider of the new Sebring’s platform, during the sedan’s development. Designers and engineers often have trouble negotiating the compromises demanded by art, science, budgets and regulations.

Spreading the effort across two companies that were increasingly at odds must have exponentially compounded this difficulty. It’s a shame the divorce didn’t come sooner. Because it did not, we have the 2007 Sebring, a car so hard on the eyes it might single-handedly destroy Chrysler’s lingering reputation as a design leader.

[Michael Karesh operates www.truedelta.com, a vehicle reliability and price comparison website.] 

By on July 7, 2006

22.jpgThere has been a little throw-down among the TTAC writers of late regarding the benefits of the DSG paddle shift transmission vis-à-vis the gold-standard fully synchronized five, and six-speed marvels of metallurgy, casting and machining.  I have to conclude that some folks just can’t master the manual shift manipulations to the point of self-satisfaction.  Well, I can’t play guitar by ear, so I like those electronic effects that help cover up my musical shortcomings.  But Chet Atkins and Van Halen like straight axes.  So what’s up with all the happy talk about automatics?  

So neophytes can’t shift or clutch properly, but they can flick those little shifter paddles– letting the computers match all the moving parts– and feel manly and proud.  Well those who have spent a lifetime distilling the purity of driveline harmonics will always enjoy more of the real essence of driving. Computerized shifts all feel and sound synthetically perfect and uniform.  But a maestro working the loud pedal, clutch and shifter does more than drive; he expresses individuality and emotion.  Think electronic drum machine vs. Buddy Rich.   

If you don’t quite get the value of this automotive self-expression thing, let’s start with the typical launch.  All that is required is a good clutch, accurate throttle and some decent hardened steel pipes.  OK; feeling a little down?  Go for a low-rev clutch-drop. The engine bogs down slightly until it catches and runs up to the first shift point.  A longish idling pause while snatching second continues the melancholy mood.  The slow second gear climb-out extends the dark, minor-chord.  All who hear intuitively understand the underlying color, whether or not they realize it.

Excited?  Hurried?  Joyful?  Then it’s a high-revving slip-clutch launch for you.  Spin the clutch facings a bit, then the [hopefully rear] tires.  When the traction finally locks-in at a few thousand revs, quick shift to second and upwards.  You have just performed the rapidamente movement of a concerto.  Light, frolicking, and gleeful. O happy day!  The fortissimo roll out, on the other hand… We’re talking a hammer-down, barking and staccato assault; an unmistakable musical notation that leads the listener to expect a crescendo of speed and fury.   

Then there are the shift nuances.  Remember: computers don’t have emotions.  Their mission is perfection in all things.  But this aria is human.  Are the shifts over-revving, clutch stabbing locked-down-throttle wailings?  Or are they blipped, measured and even?  Maybe there are uneven runs– long in second, short in third, matched in fourth and fifth—signifying indecision and doubt.  You are weaving an aural story as you drive, synchronizing man and machine, reacting to the environment, mastering Mother Nature through your own unique animal nature.

Finally, the downshifts. Does a slow turn end in a boggy fade-away or a two-gear drop and run? Insight?  You bet!  Coming to a stop, and nothing until a second or first gear catch… a little bored maybe?  Or is there a focused grouping all the way down through each gear?  Even some double clutching and blipping?  That’s a high energy player there.  And when everything tightens up with higher and higher pitch at the end of a gearing-down halt, it’s simply voicing the angst felt at the end of speed and forward progress.  But sometimes there is the sound of total surrender: the clutch-in coast-down to a full stop.  Maybe you’ll feel better tomorrow.  

The modern car is more than its parts.  It’s an instrument.  The designers and engineers create the musical score.  The suspension comprises the percussion section.  The aero is the woodwinds.  The exhaust the brass.  The engine plays the melody while you conduct.  The steering wheel is your baton.  The clutch and shifter set the tempo, while your throttling raises and lowers the orchestral dynamics.  Hushed here, hell raising there, you throw your head back and celebrate all that is sound, vibration and movement like a true conductor.  

My point is this: when you want to DRIVE, when you want to fully experience all that hurling large amounts of shaking and slamming metal and shape-shifting rubber encompasses, if you want to stand in front of the orchestra and feel it respond to your every whim, you have to take the baton and lead with your soul.  Commuter cars not withstanding,  when you get your Cayman S, your Corvette Z06,  Stradivarius Lotus Elise, or any really drivey road rocket, if you check the automatic box on the spec sheet you are robbing yourself of the thrill of being master, commander, large and in charge.  Your Song will not Remain the Same (apologies to Led Zeppelin).

So suffer a bad shift.  Kill the motor (preferably at a busy intersection).  Miss a gear. Hit the limiter.  Laugh at your foibles.  Have fun.  Modern love is not automatic.

By on July 7, 2006

clowncar.jpgRemember when you got your first 64-count box of Crayola Crayons?  After inhaling the trademark smell, your eyes were dazzled, your left brain inspired by an eye-popping kaleidoscope of colors.  You never knew there were so many different shades of blue and yellow and red and green.  You could draw anything you wanted and you’d always have just the right color.  And when you started drawing cars – man!  That’s when you’d pull out all the best hues.  Never ecru or black or white or gray, though.  No way!  You always drew your dream cars in the brightest Technicolor hues you could find.  Too bad today’s designers don’t remember those fun times.

The next time you’re stuck in traffic, look around.  Check out how many vehicles have been painted in minor variations of the same generic colors.  Carmakers’ color palettes currently range from uninteresting to downright depressing.  The occasional vivid yellow or red stands out like a hooker at a Liberty University pep rally.  Visit any car lot and you’ll find yourself awash in a sea of black, white, silver, gray and beige.  If you want something a bit more vibrant, you’re probably out of luck; most car makers who offer reds, greens, or blues usually do so in the darkest shades possible.  Even if you find a manufacturer willing to serve up something brighter, chances are you’ll have to special order it.

Boldly colored cars drove off the automotive scene at about the same time as bold styling disappeared into a gaping sinkhole of mediocrity.  Starting in the late ‘70’s, automobiles– and their Armani-clad designers– began to look more and more alike.  As the “bean counters” took over from the “car guys,” designers began copying each other and, eventually, themselves.  Mass market motors went straight from bold to boxy to droopy to dull.  The trend to dreary colors moved in perfect synchronicity with the shift towards dreary styling.  The relentless excretion of cookie-cutter, cost-cutting crap continued into the ‘90’s and the new millennium.  And now, even though fresh thinking has finally appeared on the design front, color choices are still stuck in the ‘90’s.

When the distinctive colors disappeared, they took the distinctive graphics and trim packages with them.  I guess we’ve become too sophisticated to be seen in cars decked out with stripes or other graphics.  Sure, there are the one-size-fits-all graphics you see on the rice burners; the ones that look like someone slapped paint on with a broom.  Close but no cigar.  Graphics should be tailored to the design of the individual car, highlighting its lines and making a statement specific to that model’s character.  (Only the MINI “gets it.”)  Think of your favorite Detroit car from the ‘60’s or early ‘70’s.  Chances are it has distinctive graphics that complete the overall “look” for that particular model.

With a few notable (and expensive) exceptions, interiors are just as lackluster as the exteriors.  If you’re offered any choice at all, it’s usually between funereal black, sallow tan, or death-pallor gray.  Even cars lauded for their interiors use varying shades of these same colors, just in higher-quality materials, with better workmanship.  Why did they stop offering the reds, the greens, the blues?  Where is it written everything inside a car has to be the same color?   A few cheerful colors on the inside would help alleviate the claustrophobic cave effect so common to today’s cabins.  Surprisingly, the designers’ color blindness extends to their concept cars.   Auto shows offer the expectant public radical shapes and funky designs– in the same four uninteresting colors as their production cars: white, beige, gray or black.

Instead of coming up with exciting new colors, car makers take the easy way out.  They commission their marketing lackeys to think of exotic-sounding names for the same old colors.  So now you can get Abyss, Neptune, Alloy or French Silk instead of black, dark blue, gray or beige.  But as the Bard noted centuries ago, a rose by any other name is just as red (or something like that).  Call them what you like, they’re still the same old boring colors that make the automotive landscape meld into a miserable melange of monochromatic monotony.

What ever happened to the automobile as a vehicle for individual expression?  Where are Sassy Grass Green, Carousel Red, and Statutory Grape when we need them?  Why no modern equivalents to the John Player Specials, strobe stripes or screaming chicken graphics?  We need choice, we need flair, we need pizzazz!  We need to bring some vibrancy back into the picture.  Perhaps we should send every design studio a brand new 64-pack of Crayolas.  I reckon it’s time they got back in touch with their inner child.

By on July 5, 2006

home_gregory1.jpgWay back in 602, the original Pope Gregory introduced the concept of the seven deadly sins.  His text Moralia in Job was designed to help lay people differentiate between venial sins, which could be forgiven through confessions, and capital sins, which are Hell to pay. About a millennium and a half later it looks like the management at Detroit’s Big Two automakers should have paid more attention in their catechism classes.  They seem to be harvesting a whole carload of karmic grief for their past corporate indiscretions, and wonder why it’s happening to them.  Let’s run down the Big Seven in ascending order of purported theological severity and see how they stack up.

Lust – Year after year, Ford and GM both coveted the title “America’s Best Selling Car” so carnally they dumped cars into the rental and fleet markets to inflate their sales numbers.  This succeeded in flooding the market with used cars, trashing resale values and destroying what reputation for quality they might have had.  Now their products are associated so strongly with “rental car” and “fleet” many buyers won’t consider buying anything they make.

Gluttony – In an attempt to expand their worldwide empires they both hungrily bought up other companies around the globe, totally oblivious to what it could cost them down the road.   As a result Ford keeps pouring piles of money into that black hole called the Premier Auto Group and GM is still reeling from the Fiat fiasco.  You can’t post profits very long when your feeding frenzies culminate in flushing billions down the corporate toilet.

Greed –  GM is the champion at stretching out product cycles to try to squeeze every dime out of an old design instead of investing money on product development (look up “hoary” in the dictionary and there’s a picture of the Cavalier).  Ford puts all their best efforts into designing and producing high profit trucks and SUVs while ignoring and all but abandoning the much lower profit margin vehicles in the passenger car market.  In the short term this kept expenditures down and the bottom line up. Today both have milked their cash cows dry and are standing by, watching helplessly as a whole bevy of modern subcompacts come ashore and roll into the awaiting arms of economy-minded consumers.

Sloth – Detroit has gotten lazy over the years.  Domestic car makers spend much of their time whining, dragging their corporate feet, and having to be forced into complying with inevitable federal regulations and fuel standards.  The manufacturers of imports quietly and industriously go about engineering innovative solutions to meet these requirements.  Detroit was once the world leader in automotive technology and innovation.  Now they license technology from the Japanese and bring out new models one product cycle behind the rest of the world.

Wrath – Since they seem to be incapable of beating the Japanese nameplates with competitive products consumers actually want to buy, execs from both companies are directing their vituperation towards those who purchase any vehicle not built by them.  They’re out making flag-waving speeches and running ad campaigns designed to make anyone who drives anything "foreign" look anti-American and portray them as a threat to the very foundation of the economy.  Most consumers see this for what it is – a last-gasp effort of an ailing industry and the backlash may cause more damage than the speech writers ever imagined.

Envy –  The Japanese automakers are much better than either GM or Ford at producing and selling what was once Detroit’s bread and butter.  Now they realize what they gave away and can’t stand someone else having it.  They want it back very badly.  But instead of working hard to retake it by producing competitive products, they cry “no fair” and go running to Uncle Sugar for government protection and corporate welfare. 

Pride –  Hubris reigns in Detroit.  For years GM was smug in their belief “as goes General Motors, so goes America.”   Ford went around thumping their chests about having the best selling vehicle in the country and resting on their laurels.  Both totally ignored the warning signs of impending disaster, thinking they were immune to the basic economic principles of supply and demand.  Sadly, both were wrong.

Well, it doesn’t look too good for the gang in Detroit, does it?  The troubling part of all this is they won’t own up to their past behavior, confess their mistakes and do the necessary penance.  With this much going against them even an Expedition’s worth of Our Fathers and an Escalade full of Hail Marys won’t be enough to bail them out.  If they don’t change their ways soon, looks like both may have to spend time in Chapter 11 purgatory.

By on July 3, 2006

Marx-Big-Wheel.jpgAs I’ve aged, I’ve begun to notice that certain carmakers are determined to enrich chiropractors and practitioners of restorative dentistry.  When driving my Nissan 350Z, I found myself avoiding pockmarked roads for fear of ceiling-related spinal compression.  Even on smooth roads, I couldn’t quaff carbonated beverages.  Since then, I’ve created a checklist of cars my increasingly fragile skeletal system cannot abide. This includes the aforementioned Z, the Acura TL, pretty much any Infiniti or Porsche product, the S4 and S6 Audis and the Lexus SC430.  There is a special sub-category— torture– reserved for the vehicles made by BMW equipped with run-flat tires.

I understand the concept behind run-flat tires. Changing a flat on the side of the highway is only slightly less dangerous than marshalling at an Estonian track day.  Since most people pull over at the first whup-whup, run-flat tires could be a life saver.  Drivers can reach service without the need to sit on the side of the road and pray that drunk, fatigued and inattentive drivers have already found a safe place to crash.  And then there’s the complexity and the mess.  I personally have no problem jacking my own car (it’s getting the jack re-stowed that puzzles me), but there’s no way to change a tire without ending up with the tire stats imprinted on your clothing.

Run-flat tires are fine in theory.  In practice, at least as applied by the Bavarians, it destroys all hope of a luxurious ride. I’ve sampled the BMW 645, 545, 650 IC and 330 with run-flat tires.  Every single one was harsh riding: introducing an unacceptable amount of impact-related violence to otherwise stable suspension and solid chassis.  And that’s without discussing the stiff sidewalls’ numbing effect on BMW’s formerly sublime steering, on top of the automotive Novocain BMW calls Active Steering.  In any case, compound run-flat fatigue with nineteen inch wheels (sport package) and there you have it: the ultimate punishing machine.  

German car lovers often shake their heads knowingly and point out that Bimmer’s backyard is also the original home of the billiard table road.  I’ve been to Germany often.  And it’s true; find a twisting two-lane road in the Bavarian countryside and you’ll be traversing a surface as smooth as a supermodel’s epidermis.  But it’s also true that the roads in and around Munich, and throughout the formerly communist eastern part of the country, are marred by potholes and bumps.  No; I think it’s down to age-related snobbery.

Perhaps BMW believes that once a potential customer turns 50, the tipping point where enthusiasts are suddenly willing to trade razor-sharp handling for long-distance commuter comfort, they should be earning enough money to afford their more expensive models.  This would explain why Bimmer’s most costly cars– the 750, M5 and M6– don’t sport run-flats.  Of course, that theory wouldn’t explain the fact that the 7-Series was the first BMW model to include the pre-Boomer’s worst nightmare: the iDrive mouse-driven multi-infuriating controller.  But it’s possible that BMW’s left hand doesn’t know what the right hand is doing— which is about as good a description of iDrive as I can provide. 

This run-flat torment is not the roundel’s exclusive domain, but they have certainly perfected the torture.  RF tells me that tire technology is evolving; that the 325i is not so bad, and that the comfort – handling nexus will eventually be sorted.  For the time being, nothing beats installing a couple of pairs of proper summer and winter shoes.  But I’m not happy buying a brand new car only to throw out (or wait out) the OEM tires for something that should have been installed from the git-go.

Meanwhile, I’m struggling to understand why we need wheels larger than 17” for street use.  As I drive down the highway next to a youngish person driving a Chrysler 300 with double dubs, I notice how the driver looks bobble headed as their car impacts abruptly over the slightest road imperfections. What is the point of this?  At the risk of pissing off at least three separate demographic groups, I blame women for both trends.

My wife loves the idea of run-flat tires.  In fact, she thinks all tires are run-flat capable (which explains why every flat tire in my house is accompanied by the need for both a new tire and a new wheel).  In addition, my wife doesn’t complain about the deterioration in ride quality from run-flat tires.  I suspect her tolerance for auto-related physical abuse is related to her reasoning for wearing shoes (especially high heels) that “look fantastic” but eventually, inevitably, hurt like Hell.  So let’s make those twenty two inch run-flat tires standard equipment on all the chick cars and let me have my seventeens and some Michelin Pilots and call it a day.

By on July 1, 2006

kerkoria.jpgRelax.  The news that GM stockholder Kirk Kerkorian has been playing footsie with Renault/Nissan doesn’t represent some kind of paradigm shift for GM or global capitalism.  When assessing Kirk’s secret plan— selling a minority share in GM to the Franco-Japanese automotive alliance— remember whose interests The Quiet Lion serves: his own.  This is not about GM.  It’s about Captain Kirk’s spectacularly bad investment in the world’s largest automaker.  But don’t take my word for it.  "Sometimes the news in itself is already the purpose," DaimlerChrysler's CEO announced upon hearing the news.  In other words, multinational automotive conglomerator Dieter Zetsche thinks Kerkorian is just talking up GM’s stock price.

Lest we forget, the octogenarian investor has lost about a billion dollars since he started buying up GM stock.  (I don’t care how many billions you’ve got stashed in Swiss bank accounts and offshore trusts, one less thousand million has GOT to hurt.)  Anyway, mission accomplished.  Despite the fact that GM-friendly Wall Street analysts have just celebrated GM getting smaller, the investment community is, let’s face it, a size queen.  The news that Captain Kirk has been busy whoring GM to dubious foreigner carmakers— I mean discussing the possibility of GM entering into a mutually beneficial strategic alliance– sent GM’s stock price soaring.  On Friday (always a good day to hit the market with a surprise), GM shares closed at $29.79 up $2.35.  

On the other hand, if Wall Street catches wind that Kerkorian is unloading a chunk of his 9.9% GM shareholding, the company’s stock price will swan dive.  So it’s not entirely impossible that Kirk’s play is what it seems: an attempt to save GM’s bacon.  And yet, on the face of it, a GM – Renault/Nissan hook-up makes no sense.  Even The Detroit News’ resident optimist sees no benefits to the deal.  “GM has spent the past 15 years pushing to achieve what the megadeal would purport to achieve," Daniel Howes wrote yesterday. "Economies of scale in purchasing, common manufacturing and product development processes, global leadership in developing world markets.  These megadeals seldom — if ever — deliver the ‘synergies’ their highly paid outside architects say they will.”  

Of course, there is one important benefit to Captain Kirk’s bold moves: cash.  If you take a close look at what’s been proposed, Kirk wants Nissan/Renault to partner up, then “seal the alliance” by buying 20% of GM’s common stock for $3b.  Three billion dollars doesn’t seem like a lot of money in the GM scheme of things.  It’s almost a billion less than GM CEO Rabid Rick Wagoner recently spent paying 37k union workers not to work.  But it’s not chump change either— especially when you consider the fact that GM is running on fumes.  Remember the extension of GM’s accounts payable and the new secured line of credit?  Cerberus does.  

The [fire] sale of The General’s GMAC finance unit to Cerberus Capital Management is the last bit of family silver The General has left to flog.  And it’s only two credit downgrades away from implosion.  Without GMAC cash, the show’s over.  In fact, it may already be too late.  GM’s vehicle sales are in the doldrums, there’s no Hail Mary in the pipeline, market share (dealer income) has gone south and a bunch of humongous downsizing bills are coming due.  Not to mention the possibility of an August strike at GM’s mission critical ex-subsidiary, bankrupt parts supplier Delphi (yes that).  Avoiding Delphi's cyanide pill may require another billion or so from GM’s threadbare corporate pockets.    

If you doubt that GM could be so cash-starved that The Quiet Lion would be allowed to sell the company’s soul to Renault/Nissan, consider this.  TTAC commentator Finance Guy recently alerted us that GM is offering its zero percent new car financing deal to anyone with a pulse.  More specifically, FG has resurrected 10 dead deals.  No wonder: GMAC will now buy down on credit tiers A to E (prime to non-prime buyers).  Cutoff is around a 590 FICO.  Typically people in that range can’t get a new car without a substantial down payment.  Obviously, GM is opening the floodgates.  There’s one word for that: Mitsubishi.  The Japanese carmaker’s US fortunes foundered on the rocks of easy credit, as hundreds of thousands of come-on-down loans blew up in their face. 

In short, the idea that GM would contemplate joining a Renault/Nissan “alliance” is a sign of the General’s desperation, not its ability to seize an international opportunity (whither Fuji, Fiat and Suzuki).  Viewed from another angle, depending on what the Franco-Japanese contingent want for their money, you might even say that GM’s breakup has already begun.  In any case, it’s yet another one of the bizarre episodes we’ve been predicting for some time: the end of days at GM.   

By on June 30, 2006

106_0629.jpgIt’s been while since I’ve written about The Truth About Cars (TTAC).  As you may recall, we were preparing to turn TTAC into a subscription site when we re-launched.  When I discovered that our payment software wasn’t ready for prime time, and the site design needed tweaking, I put the move on hold.  I’ve used the interregnum to ramp up our content, familiarize myself with the new site’s back end, commission a few improvements and… think.  I’ve re-read all your emails, sent out a survey, talked to a bunch of financial folks and come up with a new plan.  Here’s how I see it…

Imagine TTAC as a gated community.  By closing the gates (making it members only), we can maintain the site’s high quality housing (our rants and reviews) while avoiding “outside” pollution and crime (advertiser influence).  You can play (read and comment) with like-minded enthusiasts, safe from flame-throwers (flame throwers).  After surveying our readers, I know a fair few of you believe that our mission is worthwhile, and that paying $5 a month for this little corner of cyberspace is a fair proposition.  That said, timing is.  Everything.

Before we changed the site design, TTAC had 22k unique visitors per day.  When we made the jump, we lost 8k daily visitors, and our momentum.  The drop happened for two main reasons.  First, our New Content Notification system and RSS feeds went south.  Some of the faithful lost touch.  (Both systems are back on-line.)  Second, our Google links evaporated, which accounted for about 20% of our previous traffic.  (These too have been resurrected.)  We’re recovering lost ground, one reader at a time.  When we get back up to a large and healthy pool of potential subscribers, I can make the switch to subscription-only, confident that the take-up rate will make it worth our while.  But–

Once the gates are closed, the chances of recruiting new members will diminish dramatically.  Sure, automotive enthusiasts will still find their way to our door.  But the vast majority will look at the fancy gates and click on down the road.  And then I thought of a golf resort.  The general public is free to hang out at the main hotel.  If they choose, they can spend some time and money at the hotel’s restaurants and shops.  But they’ve got to pay to play.  And if they want to play golf on a regular basis, they have to become members.  In other words, TTAC needs both an exclusive members-only section AND a less exclusive “free” section.  

In practice, the new site’s member section would look and work much as it does now.  I hesitate to call the free section “TTAC lite,” but one part of the non-members site would offer mini-reviews, much like the format I designed for Part Two of Jalopnik’s reviews (stars with a few descriptive sentences).  Another, equally important aspect would be comparative data for car shoppers.  At least initially, we’re talking price, options and reliability info.  I’m currently negotiating with a gentleman who collects this kind of data.  He's one with the TTAC brand: complete editorial integrity and total transparency.      

So, TTAC would have a subscription-only “intellectual” side for passionate, witty and informed reviews and rants.  And we’d have a free “practical” side for mini-reviews and useful buying information.  The duality would allow BOTH sides of the site to grow and prosper, as the free side entices visitors into becoming paid subscribers while, at the same time, offering us new and exciting revenue streams (which I can’t discuss at the present time).  Again, I can assure you that neither side would compromise our overarching commitment to honesty, ethics and public service.  It is, after all, our brand.  Without that, The Truth About Cars means nothing.  Is nothing.

So, what do you think?  Is there are a market for what I’ve described?  Would a nuts-and-bolts aspect to TTAC cheapen our literary aspirations?  Do you think we should hold off on turning into a subscription site until the practical side is in place?  At the same time and in any case, how can we increase TTAC’s site traffic?  I’m a writer/editor by nature, but now that I’ve got the posting down to a routine, I’ve got time to market this sucker. (NB: From now on, during the weekdays, I’ll be posting new material first thing in the morning, mid-afternoon and early evening.)  Any help in this area would be most appreciated.  Please leave your comments here.

Meanwhile, I want to take this opportunity to thank TTAC’s writers.  I will be forever grateful for their time, talent, humor and integrity.  Let no one say that the buff books’ have the best writers.  The future of automotive journalism is right here, right now.  Thanks guys, for telling the truth about cars.  Working with you is an honor and a privilege.      

By on June 30, 2006

new monte.jpgThe prairie town where I grew up offered exactly one wholesome diversion for teenagers: an eight-block stretch of Central Avenue known as The Drag.  On Friday and Saturday nights, you'd “shag The Drag.” You’d drive from 12th Street down to the city square, then back up to 12th Street, shouting at people you knew or people you wanted to know.  Lather, rinse, repeat.  Your goal: make time with a girl from school or, even better, entrance an out-of-towner who had no idea of your previous track record (or lack thereof).  Of course, you had to come to The Drag in a cool car.  In the late eighties, one car bestrode our teenage world like a colossus…

There were plenty of acceptable Drag shaggers: the Chrysler Cordoba, Oldsmobile Cutlass Supreme and Mercury Cougar XR-7 spring immediately to mind.   But there was only one King: the Chevrolet Monte Carlo.  Oh, the Monte.  That was the car you detassled corn for, spending ten or twelve hours under the unforgiving Iowa sun with your arms over your head with some college student (obviously majoring in sociopathy) telling you to work harder.  Six weeks of that was like ten thousand years in purgatory.  At the end, though, you had enough money for a '76 Monte Carlo, a set of Cragar mags, and the finest Sparkomatic tape deck K-Mart would sell you.  You were ready to shag The Drag.

First, though, you had to straighten up the car a little.  In the main, this involved applying approximately 3.8 cans of paste wax to your Monte's oxidized exterior.  You had to buff that wax off with one of your dad's old, ominously stained t-shirts.  Since you never got all the wax off, you’d then suffer the heartbreak of finding telltale beige smears all over your gleaming ride.  But young men always suffer at the hands of their hormones, don't they?  And it was all worth it– the first time you saw a girl stare a little too long at your car.  Then you saw her staring at you.  That was even better.

Profiling, of course, is about all those mid-Seventies disco sleds were good for.  They barely ran, thanks to asthmatic, emissions-controlled V-8 engines that put out maybe 160 horsepower.  Cornering was unlike anything this side of Twisted Metal.  If you hadn't replaced your hooptie's shocks recently– and why would you, as shock absorbers can't be seen by casual onlookers– you hoped beyond hope that you wouldn't roll over onto the door handles if you tried to take a curve at anything close to the posted speed limit.  Need I even mention the gas mileage?  These prime examples of the North American Vinyl-Backed Road Pig make a Hummer H2 look like a Segway.

For these reasons and many others, your parents were on record as being 100% against buying a Chevrolet Monte Carlo.  Your mom thought it was just the perfect car for that nineteen-year-old with the Steve Perry hair and the sparse mustache, the one who'd already knocked over a couple Stop 'N Robs and spent time in juvie.  No way was her little slugger going to cruise the street in the official car of the Future Felons of America.  Needless to say, your dad was more practical.  He knew exactly what that Monte meant for him: “Dad, can I borrow ten bucks for gas?”  

Your mom thought you should buy the neighbors' Mercury Lynx station wagon.  Your dad noted that there were a lot of nice, low mileage Renault Alliances in the newspaper.  “Hey, son, with all you'll save on gas, you can probably buy hamburgers and Cokes for all those girls you meet on The Drag!”  Right, dad.  All the chicks dig that 1.4 liter engine. Can I have one of your Manhattan Transfer tapes while I'm at it?

You knew your strategy.  You'd spent the entire summer circling every $1200 Camaro in the classifieds.  You talked about the '72 Charger your study partner's cousin was selling– the one he parked behind a barn in 1977.  Dad, did you know he's only asking $800 for it?  After a couple months of you chasing every dumb two-door in a five-county area, the Monte you eventually found practically sold itself.  

Looking back, the idea that a Chevrolet Monte Carlo could make anyone seem cool was completely preposterous.  Even then, you may have suspected that you may not have been cool.  But somewhere deep inside, where it counts, driving the Monte felt right.  If, at sixteen years old, it only took a couple of opera windows and an elk-grain vinyl roof to give you a shot of self-confidence, what the Hell.  It was a fair trade.  It was the full Monte.

By on June 30, 2006

1962Seattle2.jpgI’ve seen the car of the future.  It's not a diesel.  It’s not a hybrid.  It doesn’t run on electricity or natural gas or elastometric energy storage units recharged by rodents operating exercise wheels, supervised by domesticated felines. The future is sitting in a corner of your local Ford dealer's showroom gathering dust: a Ford Focus with the optional 2.0 E engine. This little runner is what’s called a PZEV (Practically Zero Emissions Vehicle).  That's a cut better than a ULEV (Ultra Low Emissions Vehicle) but not quite as good as a ZEV (Zero Emissions Vehicle).  Ah, but the Focus E is still the best a tree hugger can get.

If you think about it (a rare activity for people who focus more on politics than scientific facts), a Focus PZEV has less environmental impact than an electric-powered ZEV.  The ZEV rating measures only tailpipe emissions– not a vehicle’s the total impact on the environment.  Consider the infrastructure that supplies the energy for the electric car. Plug in an EV-1 every night, and someone throws on more coal at the powerplant.  In many cities, a PZEV car like the Focus E emits exhaust that is cleaner than the air it consumes.  In fact, creating instruments to measure the miniscule amounts of pollution from a PZEV car is a growth industry, and a real technological challenge.

Ford's joined in this technological accomplishment by BMW (325ci), Honda (Civic GX), Hyundai (Elantra), KIA (Spectra), Mazda (Mazda3 2.0), Mercedes (E350), Mitsubishi (Galant), Nissan (Sentra), Subaru (Legacy 2.5), Toyota (Camry), Volkswagen (Golf) and Volvo (V70); to name but a few makes and models. 

[GM is notably absent from the list of automakers building PZEV vehicles.  For 20 years, GM offered the most fuel-efficient cars in America. Starting with the Vega through to the three cylinder GEOs of the ‘80’s and ‘90’s and the EV-1 electric car, GM spent a great deal of money to top the EPA's mileage list.  All these cars had one thing in common: no one bought them.  Eventually GM gave up this unprofitable pursuit.  While GM cars usually have the highest mileage in their respective categories, The General only makes a token effort (e.g. the Saturn VUE hybrid) to compete with high-mileage “loss leaders” like the Civic or Prius.] 

Of course, the gasoline-powered, internal combustion engine hasn’t finished cleaning up its act.  Every year, the old dear gets a little better.  Evolving technology– direct injection, semi-stratified charge combustion, higher operating temperatures, more reductions in internal friction, etc. — promises even cleaner and more fuel efficient cars in the future.  None of this is "news" in the media's view.  A cumulative 2% improvement in efficiency year on year doesn't make nearly as good a story as fuel cells, hybrids or diesels.  But spread this incremental improvement over 20 years and tens of millions of vehicle and the cumulative effect– in terms of the engines' overall environmental impact– is astounding.

There is a single but significant fly in the near-organic ointment: Americans don't buy fuel-efficient cars.  No matter how much the general public complains about the price of gas or the planet’s ascending temperature, the cleanest and most fuel efficient cars are often the most unloved.  The media never misses an opportunity to chronicle the "skyrocketing" sales of hybrids, but fails to point out that they're a relatively obscure breed.  Last year, total hybrid sales captured around 3% of the new car market.  Toyota sells more SUVs than that.  Since Toyota and others lose anywhere from $2k to $4k per car on their low-end hybrids, there is little incentive to drastically increase production and sales.  No wonder Bill Ford has pulled back from his public commitment to produce 250k hybrid-powered vehicles by the end of [this] decade.

So why do carmakers offer money-losing high mileage cars?  They have no choice.  As we’ve discussed here before, every car manufacturer has to meet a CAFÉ (Corporate Average Fuel Economy) number.  If Ford wants to sell Lincoln Navigators at a $10,000 markup without incurring a substantial EPA fine and/or negative PR fallout, they need a produce a passel of PZEV Foci to boost their fleet average– whether they sell or not.  Every carmaker suffers this problem.  Toyota chooses to lose their money on hybrids, and reap some positive PR. BMW pays the fines.  Ford, GM, Chrysler and others suffer in silence.

Few things are certain. But the most likely scenario for the car of the future is that it will be a lot like today's Ford Focus (minus the strange taillights, we hope).  It’ll be relatively small and simple, with an extremely sophisticated internal combustion engine. And, no doubt, gathering dust in the corner of the showroom, while buyers flock to the latest gas-guzzler, and pundits bemoan the state of the nation's oil consumption.

By on June 29, 2006

gate.jpg“Small is Beautiful” was released immediately after the ’73 energy crisis.  German economist E. F. Schumaker’s collection of essays tapped into the prevailing gestalt: a growing fear that the institutions that defined capitalism’s success had become economically and environmentally unsustainable.  Contrary to popular belief (i.e. the people who used the book’s title as a mantra without reading it), Schumaker wasn’t predicting or recommending the end of big business.  He simply believed that large organizations work best as small, independent groups acting in harmony.  Someone ought to tell Dieter Zetsche.

"We are convinced that DaimlerChrysler provides [Chrysler with] more resources [and] know-how [than its competitors] in many areas," DCX' CEO pronounced at yesterday’s US launch of the German-engineered Smart two-seater. In case you missed the point of Dieter’s diatribe, the carmaker is launching an advertising campaign tomorrow that touts the fact that Chrysler products benefit from German – American cross-pollination.  In short, a Chrysler is a better car than a Ford or GM vehicle because it’s got Mercedes DNA.

There are some obvious problems with this strategy.  Mercedes’ reputation for bullet-proof build quality is long gone, squandered in the relentless pursuit of growth and cost-paring profit.  (Proclaiming that a Chrysler is built like a Merc will cause many a previous gen S-Class owner to smirk uncontrollably.)  Toyota, Lexus, Honda and Hyundai have a far more credible and accessible claim to mechanical reliability than the three-pointed star.  Besides, the American public considers Mercedes a luxury brand (even if it doesn’t boast Lexian quality).  DCX’ new campaign risks an association that whispers to its target demographic “Hey Mac, wanna buy a cheap Mercedes?”

Best case: advertising a garden-variety Chrysler as a Mercedes-under-the-skin raises the “domestic” brand above Ford and GM’s growing pile-‘em-high-and-sell-‘em-cheap reputation.  But the ad campaign also threatens to trigger a worst case scenario.  Connecting a luxury brand with a mass market manufacturer (not that Mercedes isn’t a mass market manufacturer, but we’re talking about perceptions here) may alienate Mercedes’ US customers.  Cadillac almost died for the sin of dragging the brand down market, and they didn’t even advertise the fact that their cars shared greasy bits with their less mechanically gifted GM counterparts. Psst.  Hey Buddy, want to buy an expensive Chrysler?

Of course, the line between uplift and collateral damage could well depend on the ad agency’s execution.  Apparently, Dieter will be a figure of fun, which is both surreal (fun Germans?) and appropriate.  After all, this is the same foreign-owned automaker whose outspoken PR Supremo has repeatedly and pointedly blasted Toyota for daring to suggest it was an American company.  And the campaign began when a Birmingham barber asked Herr Zetsche what Mercedes had to do with Chrysler (“Ve ate them.”). But even if DCX’ German – American shtick works, the campaign reveals a fundamental flaw in Zetsche’s business strategy, and the strategy of all his competitors: synergy.

In case you forgot, synergy is the concept that replaced Small is Beautiful, once the oil supply (and public anxiety) eased.  Synergy says it’s OK to be big, as long as the “whole is greater than the sum of the parts.”  Supposedly, synergy creates “economies of scale” that makes huge business conglomerations more efficient.  Modern car companies?  Efficient?  Anyone who’s dealt with one on any level ever may beg to differ.  In fact, Schumacher had a thing to say about that back when jeans had bells: "The most striking thing about modern industry is that it requires so much and accomplishes so little.  Modern industry seems to be inefficient to a degree that surpasses one's ordinary powers of imagination.  Its inefficiency therefore remains unnoticed."

In all the talk about domestic automakers’ market share, union contracts, legacy costs, production capacity, rebates, incentives and product quality, no one seems to be interested in the fact that American[ish] car companies could well be the most inefficient enterprises on planet Earth.  I’ve received dozens of emails from people inside The Big Three describing their employers’ Kafka-esque bureacracy.  The reason these companies can’t stay on top of market niches, or update their existing vehicles to fend-off the competition, or maintain brand differentiation, isn’t money or will.  It’s sheer size. And the fact that their corporate cultures are entirely antithetical to genuine decentralization.

Schumaker’s central precept was easily understood: quality above quantity.  Growth isn’t everything.  Perhaps it’s too much to expect a huge company owned by shareholders to sacrifice the prospect of every-increasing earnings on the altar of personal fulfillment and environmental responsibility.  But Schumaker was right about the dangers of excessive size and centralization.  Meanwhile, DaimlerChrysler, GM and Ford are busy talking-up international platform sharing.  And Porsche, the quintessential “small is beautiful” sports car company, is trying to take control of Volkswagen.  Sometimes, the more painful the lesson, the more important it is.  

By on June 29, 2006

radar2.jpgI write driving articles for an international travel magazine.  Despite my editorial obligation to report on landscapes, history, culture and food; much of what I see passes in a blur.  I’ve driven obscenely fast through Europe, South Africa, Australia, Japan, Norway, Brazil and everywhere else they send me.  The only place I ever worry about speeding tickets is the United States.  Oh sure, I’ve had run-ins with local law enforcement all over the world. But I deserved to be pulled over, and the experience was more like a cultural exchange than a legal colonoscopy.

When I received a speeding ticket in Poland, I paid the $12 fine on the spot.  The trooper handed me a lanyard of what looked like Green Stamps.  “Souvenir!” I said, holding them aloft.  “Yah, soo-veneer,” the Polish cop laughed.  In New Zealand, the constable and my wife traded bungee-jumping stories while I fumbled for the registration.  “You can just go back to New York and forget about this,” he said, handing me a $130 speeding ticket.  I have no way to prove it, but the dignity of these encounters leads me to believe that highway cops in many foreign countries have a profound respect for a respectable-looking driver thrashing the beJesus out of a well-maintained high performance automobile.

The logic is both completely unexpressed and perfectly reasonable:  “He’s driving a Porsche/BMW/Ferrari/AMG/whatever.  I can assume he’s reasonably competent.  He can drive as fast as he likes, within reason.”  Of course, on a derestricted German autobahn, reason is irrelevant.  But if you’re driving fast and competently in Italy, Spain, Hungary, Portugal, Turkey, the former Czechoslovakia, etc., it’s hard to get a cop to look askance.  Of course, the people who live in these countries will tell you their highway patrollers are ogres, but they have no idea what serious highway-code enforcement is all about.

Money.  It’s all about money.  The way New York deals with speeding violations makes it obvious that punishment or behavior modification is not the point of US speeding tickets.  My most recent offense occurred in a sleepy hamlet called, I swear, Liberty.  I was ambling along at 80 mph in a 55 on a dry, deserted, wide-median, rural, four-lane highway.  After signing-off with Officer Humorless, I immediately filled-out the ticket and mailed it back to the authorities– with a not-guilty plea.  In return, I received an invitation to repeat my offense during a three-hour round-trip to the town traffic court.

After serving 10 minutes hard time on a bench in the Town Hall’s basement, the trooper who ticketed me called my name.  “Jeez, 80 in a 55— that’s a lot of points on your license,” my new best friend said.  “How about we make it ‘failure to obey a traffic device’ [i.e. going through a stop sign]?  Judge’ll charge you $100 and court costs, and it doesn’t go on your license.” Why on earth would a trooper offer this path to insurance premium paradise, and then offer it again to another two dozen feisty New Yorkers?

With half a dozen cops all drawing overtime, 50 or 60 citizens waiting to be charged, and a town justice and court clerk who have better things to do on a summer morning than process tedious paperwork, New York State has realized that all it takes is one guy who has read How to Beat a Speeding Ticket to lawyer-up and demand radar-gun certification records, and everybody will have to come back another day. So they gavel down $100 plus $40 in costs 50 or 60 times in as many minutes and everybody goes home happy.  “We don’t take credit cards,” the clerk smiled. “But there’s an ATM right down the street.”  

I have a gym buddy who’s the police chief in a nearby town.  “Get over it,” he laughs.  “You write magazine articles, we write tickets.  That’s what cops do.”  Ridding the roads of cell phone gabbers, left-lane bandits, tailgaters and seatbelt refusniks is irrelevant.  Just shoot anyone and everyone with a radar gun and collect the cash.  The Car Connection’s Speeding Excuses Contest would have you believe you can talk your way out of a fine.  In the Home of the Brave, you’re more likely to sell solar panels to Mahmoud Ahmadinejad than “fool” a speed cop.

Last summer, a moron in a Ford Excursion was screaming at the kids in the back when he rear-ended my wife’s Boxster.  Did he get a ticket for leaving Susan with eight broken ribs, a moderate concussion and a totaled Porsche?  Nope.  “We can’t ticket something we didn’t see,” another cop friend explained, “unless we get depositions from witnesses.”  There were plenty of witnesses, but I guess it’s easier– and more profitable– to stick a radar gun out the window than to push the paper that punishes a dangerous driver. 

By on June 28, 2006

64 Chevy.jpgOnce upon a time there was an automobile company that was so big that it looked like it was about to drive all the other car companies out of business.  This behemoth made every kind of car, from sports cars to limos, and every kind of truck, from the smallest to the largest. They made almost all of the busses that took people to work, and most of the locomotives that pulled trains across the county. Their diesel engines powered most of the construction equipment, ran the pumps that pulled oil out of the ground and moved ships on the seas.  There was only one cloud on the horizon: they were too successful. 

That company was General Motors.  The times were the turbulent ‘60’s.  John F. Kennedy was the President of the United States, and he was determined to knock GM down a peg.  JFK had the tools, in the form of anti-trust laws and an activist justice department.  Their goal: destroy GM’s supposed monopoly by removing Chevrolet from its corporate parent.  An epic fight began, that continued for an entire decade.  Eventually, the federal government became preoccupied with war, inflation and civil unrest, and withdrew their actions against GM.  But what if…

The Kennedy administration had split Chevrolet from GM.  At the time, Chevy accounted for roughly 35% of all US automobile sales.  If the Justice Department had been able to detach the bow tie boys from The General, the resulting, newly-independent automaker would have been the largest car company in the world, about as big as Ford and Chrysler combined.  America would have been left with four highly competitive automobile manufacturers: Chevrolet, GM, Ford and Chrysler.   

No question, Chevy could have gone it alone.  The brand had their own engineering staff and a number of unique platforms (e.g. the Corvair, Chevy II and Corvette).  Although Chevrolet’s hugely successful BelAir and Impala line shared Fisher Body underpinnings with other GM products, the issue could have been easily resolved.  GM had a long history of selling components to other carmakers; Chevy could have simply bought its bodies from Fisher.  Other centralized functions, such as marketing and purchasing, would have presented more of a logistical challenge, but nothing insurmountable.

Imagine a Chevrolet brand focused on building low-cost cars and pickup trucks, with a world-class sports car for a halo vehicle.  Freed from the obligation to tailor their cars to corporate platform sharing, Chevrolet’s lineup could have been distinctive, focused and original.  Family cars like the BelAir and Impala would have evolved without GM’s baggage, emerging from the 60’s ready to fend-off Toyota and Honda in the low-end sedan market.  Chevy could have responded to the deluge of quality imports with quality domestics. 

With a corporate focus on product rather than interdepartmental politics and intrigue, Chevy would have never wasted billions on Saturn.  It wouldn’t have had to sell cars of dubious international parentage, or rebadged someone else’s idea of a brand appropriate product.  Meanwhile, bereft of Chevrolet, GM might also have become a much healthier, more nimble and innovative company. For one thing, Pontiac, Oldsmobile and Buick would have been forced to survive on their own, instead of coasting on Chevrolet’s profits and parts.

Since each GM division already had their own engineering staff, Pontiac would have been able to develop its performance excitement at a higher price point than Chevrolet.  (The Firebird, when it appeared, would not have been a Camaro clone, but a distinct and distinctive car.)  Oldsmobile could have built on its track record of innovative engineering established by the Toronado, America’s first practical front-wheel drive car.  Buick might have used the same clever platform sharing that let them build a rear-wheel drive Riviera from the front-wheel drive Toronado to build solid luxury cars at relatively affordable prices.


GMC would be free to develop heavy trucks, rather than people’s pickups and utilitarian SUV’s.  And Cadillac, the “Standard of the World,” could have used the profits from Pontiac, Oldsmobile and Buick to remain a world-class luxury car, unsullied by the Chevrolet parts mentality.  A properly-regarded, properly funded Cadillac would never have embarrassed itself with affordable front-wheel drive trash.  The brand could have stayed on the high-road and built vehicles capable of competing with Mercedes, BMW and Audi– and generated profits from, dare I say it, international sales.

Of course, who’s to say a Chevy-less GM wouldn’t have screwed-up their business just as badly as today’s GM.  Or that a GM-less Chevy could have responded to the Japanese invasion with something better than the Vega.  Even so, we now have a General Motors that’s significantly smaller than JFK’s trust-busters would have dared propose, just inches away from bankruptcy.  Once that goes down, the smart money is on GM selling off or dumping everything except… Chevrolet, GMC and Cadillac.  What goes around, comes around.  

Recent Comments

  • Lou_BC: @Carlson Fan – My ’68 has 2.75:1 rear end. It buries the speedo needle. It came stock with the...
  • theflyersfan: Inside the Chicago Loop and up Lakeshore Drive rivals any great city in the world. The beauty of the...
  • A Scientist: When I was a teenager in the mid 90’s you could have one of these rolling s-boxes for a case of...
  • Mike Beranek: You should expand your knowledge base, clearly it’s insufficient. The race isn’t in...
  • Mike Beranek: ^^THIS^^ Chicago is FOX’s whipping boy because it makes Illinois a progressive bastion in the...

New Car Research

Get a Free Dealer Quote

Who We Are

  • Adam Tonge
  • Bozi Tatarevic
  • Corey Lewis
  • Jo Borras
  • Mark Baruth
  • Ronnie Schreiber