Category: Editorials

By on June 28, 2006

vette.jpgPSST… Hey you!  Yeah, you over there with the shiny new Corvette…  I have something to tell you…  C’mon over…  Now stand close so I can whisper something in your ear.  No, really… it’s a good thing.    Be sure to listen carefully.  I don’t want you to miss this.  It’s something you really need to hear about your baby.  Ready?  OK, here it is… HEY BONEHEAD!  THAT CORVETTE IS A CAR!!  TAKE IT OUT AND DRIVE THE HELL OUT OF IT!

For those Corvette owners who don't understand the concept, I need to explain.  First of all, I’m not recommending that guardians of 53’s, ’57 fuelies, ’63 Z06’s and the other 'Vettes critical to the marque's heritage should go out and thrash their historical artifacts to an inch of their lives (although I'm not against the idea).  Obviously, these vehicles need to be protected and preserved for future generations.  I’m talking about the non-treatment meted-out to your everday, garden-variety trailer queens and wannabees.  You know, the pampered bow tie bombers you see at every club meeting, cruise night and Corvette gathering. 

These seem to fall into two categories.  The first are 'Vettes with paint jobs that cost more than your average Hyundai, chromed to a fare-thee-well and displayed behind ropes like a priceless object d’arte. These are nothing more than full-scale Hot Wheel toys– and just about as useful.  The others are pimped-out stockers that bear silent testimony to what happens when an overabundance of cash intersects with a dearth of taste at the locus of an aftermarket parts catalogue. 

In both cases, you can tell the cars hardly ever leave the garage except when the owners show them off like some priceless Faberge egg.  It’s fun to watch, though.  The owner hovers nearby with polishing cloth and duster at the standby, watching warily in case someone dares touch his precious baby or a speck of dust should fall on it.  Some day I’m going to sneeze on one just to watch the owner pop a blood vessel in his neck.

Many Corvette owners who don’t participate in these spectacles exhibit equally strange behavior.  I have no problem with someone keeping their car looking good, but these people have gone beyond obsessive and now live in the realm of the irrational.  They won’t drive their car in the rain.  They spend exorbitant amounts on special waxes and beauty creams.  They wash it only in distilled rainwater and dry it with chamois from organically-raised sheep that were given daily massages to keep their skin supple.  They panic at the prospect of getting a stone chip in their extra-cost base-coat/clear-coat paint or a scuff on the (cheap) leather upholstery.  

Before you start screaming sour grapes because, obviously, I’m jealous of Corvette owners and if I had one I’d understand, know this:  I own a Corvette.  I wanted one ever since I went down to the Chevy dealer with my grandfather and sat in the ‘Vette while he did his business.  When I got to the point where my credit rating could handle the hit, I bought one.  And I drive it regularly, even in the rain.  I take long trips in it.  I carry my dog it.  I may wash it once a month– in a drive-through car wash. 

Some owners would say I don’t deserve a Corvette.  I say Corvettes were meant to be driven, not pimped, primped, and posed.  Laying aside whatever you think about Chevrolet or GM for a moment, you have to admit the Corvette is a great performance car.  It offers a combination of acceleration, handling, braking and fuel economy you won’t find in many other cars.  I don’t understand anyone who buys one then keeps it locked away in the garage, driving it maybe 100 miles a month.  What in the name of Zora Arkus-Dutov do they think Corvettes are for?

I’ll tell you what they’re for.  They’re for dancing down a winding road to the music of a small block V-8.  They’re for winding through the gears flat-out when the road turns straight.   They’re for transforming high octane petroleum distillates into the most fun you can have with your clothes on.  They’re the perfect antidote for ennui, a quicker waker-upper than a cup of Starbucks’ best.  They’re for entertaining the senses, for restoring your joy of driving, for having a balls-out, catch-me-if-you-can, power sliding good time.

The same criticisms can be leveled at owners of any number of cars.  What of the poseurs driving Jeep Wranglers whose tires have never touched the bare earth?  Many drivers wear their car like so much jewelry, trying make a “life style statement.”  They want everyone to admire their cars so they can sneer “I have one and you don’t.”  People like that should never be allowed to own a proper sports car.  They’re incapable of understanding their car’s soul.  They’re too wrapped up in themselves to notice it even has one.

By on June 27, 2006

consumer reportys.jpgFor decades, Consumer Reports has been the American automobile buyer’s primary source for vehicle reliability information.  Tens of millions of highly-educated, independent-minded people have made their car purchase based on a brace of red dots.  While I don’t care for the dots– they’re a blunt instrument that can hide as much information as they convey– I’ve always assumed that Consumer Reports’ (CR) underlying data was solid.  And then I took their survey…

Of the survey’s 19 questions, only one collects the data that's ultimately responsible for Consumer Reports' final, all-important reliability dots: question number 13. 

“If you had any problems with your car in the last year (April 1, 2005 through March 31, 2006) that you considered SERIOUS because of cost, failure, safety or downtime, click the appropriate box(es) for each car.  INCLUDE problems covered by warranty.  DO NOT INCLUDE 1) problems resulting from accident damage; or 2) replacement of normal maintenance items (brake pads, batteries, mufflers) unless they were replaced much sooner or more often than expected.”

CR’s form then lists the car’s major systems, with a simple checkbox next to each.  That means that multiple problems with a single system, such as ongoing hassles with a car’s electrics, count once.  Equally troubling, respondents are supposed to remember a car problem that may have occurred over a year ago.  They also need to remember whether incidents near the cutoff happened in March or April.  Respondents that err on the safe side and report problems that might have happened within the timeframe, and do this year after year, are likely to report some problems twice. 

There's an even more profound methodological iceberg dead ahead.  CR’s dots signal “SERIOUS” problems [note the caps], yet never defines the term. I’ve always wondered how CR staffers decided whether a problem is “serious” enough to include in their survey.  They don’t.  CR’s question 13 requires that individual respondents make the call, based on “cost, failure, safety or downtime,” or other entirely subjective criteria.


This is a buck that should not be passed. Anyone with a significant other knows that two people hardly ever agree on what constitutes a “serious” problem.  As CR does not provides clear guidelines as to which problems qualify as SERIOUS and which do not, the resulting data is not reliable.  Would it be so hard for CR to provide a definition of that includes a dollar amount or the number of days out of service? Apparently so.

Without unambiguous guidelines, extraneous influences intrude.  First, there’s the respondent’s general opinion of the car.  Things gone right can ameliorate things gone wrong.  Why else would some people keeping buying those pricey “black dot” jobs?  Second, the reliability of cars past shapes consumers’ expectations.  If the participant’s previous car lost a transmission, then a bad alternator may not seem so SERIOUS.  Unless the current car is the same brand, and the participant is starting to feel twice fooled.  Then a burned-out turn signal may seem SERIOUS.  And third, if the dealer was smart enough to play nice, maybe kicking in a free loaner, then a SERIOUS problem will seem less severe.  

Finally, we come to the part of the question which cautions that replacement of “normal maintenance items” shouldn’t be reported “unless they were replaced much sooner or more often than expected.”  This instruction lumps maintenance and repair items together, with no way for CR’s analysts to separate the data later (should they be so ambitious).  And, once again, the respondent must define terms, deciding what items count as “normal” and assess the gap between their expectations and reality (usually called irony).  

If CR is going to include wear items, it should specify how long they should last.  But how long should brake pads last?  Expectations are going to vary.  A lot.   Brake pad life is heavily affected by driving style, driving conditions, a tire shop’s financial goals and other factors that have nothing to do with reliability.  And batteries?  How many times were the lights left on?  How much crud has been allowed to build up around the terminals?  Asking average car owners to gauge their vehicle’s parts wear against an entirely subjective ideal does not a scientific study make.  If they really want to know about brake pads and batteries, they should at least ask about them separately, to keep the nasty things from contaminating the entire data set. And provide some guidelines.

I’m no triskaidekaphobic.  But Consumer Reports’ question 13 does nothing to instill confidence in their reliability ratings, and much to cast doubt on their value. Respondents and readers need a more scientific and, ultimately, more useful guide to automotive reliability.  Until CR’s survey undergoes a major overhaul, readers will be misled and manufacturers won’t have the valuable feedback they need to make genuine improvements.

[Michael Karesh operates www.truedelta.com , a vehicle reliability and price comparison site.] 

By on June 27, 2006

Wilkinsonporker.jpgI drive an iconic, high-performance European luxury car.  Well, let me modify that a bit.  I drive an iconic, high-performance European luxury car made in 1983.  And so could you, for the cost of a new Kia.  It’s a Porsche 911SC coupe— a car that’s no longer rare, collectible, fast, luxurious or particularly desirable.  But it is revealing.  A hundred and eighty horsepower!  A  pair of 225/50-16 tires in the rear!  A top speed of 135 mph!  Look out Kia, here I come!  My 25-year-old Porker highlights just how far automobiles have advanced since the time when Koreans were best known for their canine cuisine.       

My SC’s 3.0-liter flat-six originally came with a fuel-injection kludge (before I converted it to carburetors, just to rub in the antiquity).  It boasted an air intake system so convoluted the oxygen entered through the front door, walked upstairs to the guest bedroom, climbed out the window, crawled back in through the kitchen window and then went down to the basement to find the combustion chambers.  The less said about the tangled exhaust and constricted catalytic converters the better.  But hey, it had dual-zone climate control!  

We’re talking two levers that resemble lawnmower throttles, one left and one right.  The levers pull rusty cables that close trapdoors in the exhaust system.  (It’s a favorite path for mice seeking to occupy occasionally-driven Porsches.)  The movement forces air to circulate around the exhaust pipes before entering the cabin.  Bonus!  Any oil that leaks out of the lower cam covers (which seal about as well as a re-corked bottle of Argentinean Merlot) instantly vaporizes and blends with the hot air warming the cabin.  And if the exhaust springs a leak, you die of carbon monoxide poisoning.

The rest of a vintage 911’s cooling/fan/defrost controls remain a mystery– even to people who have owned these cars for decades.  Some levers go left, some right.  I carry a six-inch length of dowel to jam into the fan lever at full displacement, which sometimes seems to bring the windshield defogger to life.  The air conditioning never worked well, and you had to remove and bench-press the crappy compressor to do any minor engine work.  The Germans apparently did their hot-weather testing in Provence.   

And speaking of engine work, every 12,000 miles you had to gap the valves (Stuttgart had yet to discover hydraulic lifters).  If you didn’t, bad things happened.  My friend John Phillips III (Car and Driver scribe par excellence) admitted in a recent e-mail, “I had a 1974 911S whose valves I failed to adjust at the proper interval.  This resulted in a catastrophic engine event in Maumee, Ohio.  I had to leave the car at a gas station, call a cab, ride to the Toledo Airport, rent a car, drive to Columbus, rent a truck and trailer, go pick up the car, drop it at Midwestern Porsche-Audi, and leave it there for two months.”   Amor vincit omnia.

[A Porsche dealer charged the equivalent of changing your Toyota’s timing belt every 12k miles for this trickery.  These days, amid shrieked curses, slowly spreading pools of oil and dripping knuckle-blood, I perform the job myself.  I use a feeler gauge that looks like a laparoscope tool for a prostatectomy.  It beats working for a living.]

The 911 SC’s cruise control consisted of a soup can-size pneumatic cylinder and a Bourdon cable, most likely interchangeable with the one used for the “climate control.”  I threw all that away along with the a/c, so I have no idea how it works.  But I don’t think any electrons are involved.  Did I mention the SC’s road manners?  Probably not, since I spun the car so hard at Lime Rock last month I popped the windshield loose.  People who are serious about making older 911s handle put rods, bars, tubes, straps and welds all over the place in an often vain attempt to make both sides of the car fly in formation.

Had I purchased my SC back in the fall of ’82, it would have set me back about $35k moderately optioned: sunroof, a/c, manual leather seats, lousy Bosch fog lights, an even worse AM/FM Blaupunkt and some other stuff (all of which I’ve sacrificed to the Great God of Lightness).  That’s the equivalent of almost $73,500 in today’s money, or enough cash to buy a brand new, 325hp Porsche 911S (with no options whatsoever).

But what the hell.  Old 911’s respond to tweaking as well as a ’36 Ford flathead.  My heavily-breathed upon example puts out a dynoed 287 hp, and I love it when people ask me if it’s new.  Of course, just about any new car you can name would be faster, safer, more comfortable, more reliable, handle with greater assurance and stop quicker than a stock '83 911SC.  But it wouldn’t be better.

By on June 26, 2006

zerobig.jpgRon Tadross.  Say it softly and it’s almost like crying.  If you’re GM that is.  The Banc of America Securities analyst isn’t exactly what you’d call bullish on GM.  Unlike his evil twin, analyst John Murphy, Tadross sees GM heading for a cash burn flame-out.  "We believe GM management is glossing over the current and future cost of rightsizing the business," Tadross declared.  More to the point, he recommended that investors sell their GM stock, with a target that’s literally half of its current price.  In other words, when Merrill Lynch talks, nobody should listen.

Although the media types persist in calling GM plant closures and worker buyouts “rightsizing,” there is nothing “right” about the amount of debt GM is piling onto its bottom line.  GM reported today that 35k workers are heading for the exits.  The severance checks for these soon-to-be ex-employees will cost The General a net, after-tax charge of $3.8b.  At the same time, 12,600 Delphi workers are heading for the hills.  GM’s down for half, so that’ll add another $1b or so to the tab.  Remember: many of these workers will continue to receive pensions, only 4600 lose their health care benefits, and shuttering factories incurs some pretty heavy additional expenses.       

Clearly, GM CEO Rabid Rick Wagoner has decided that he can pay off tomorrow the costs of trimming production today.  Tadross doesn't share Rick's belief that GM's tomorrow never dies.  The analyst points to GM’s newly arranged $4.5b secured credit line as a sure sign that the company is cash-strapped– at a time when the demands on GM’s hoard are mounting like a tsunami nearing land.  Tadross predicts "serious cash burn" at the end of the year, as GM’s production drops an estimated eight percent and its “product pipeline peaks.”  In other words, GM can’t make money now, won’t make money later, and its bills are about to come due.

Rick Wagoner insists that the cuts have put GM on the right track.  In a statement issued today, The General’s General declared "These moves have given us a fast start toward achieving our stated objective of reducing GM's global structural cost from approximately 34 percent of revenue in 2005, to 25 percent of revenue by 2010, and setting us up to be successful for years to come."  That’s great news for people who forgot the old maxim that the secret to business is to take in more than you spend.  GM may end-up spending less, but it won’t mean anything unless it starts making more money.

GM’s earnings situation is both dire and deadly.  In a note to his clients, Deutsche Bank analyst Rod Lache estimated that every point of market share GM surrenders to its competitors equals roughly $1.3 billion in lost [pretax] earnings.  In May, the world’s largest automaker’s US market share fell three percentage points to 22.5%.  Using Lache’s calculations, if GM’s market share doesn’t recover, the world’s largest automaker is looking at $3.9b in lost income AND $3.8b for its worker buyouts.  No wonder they’ve announced a fire sale.

Wait; it’s worse than that.  It isn’t a fire sale.  Instead of launching an employee discount program to match Chrysler’s, instead of slapping cash on the hood, GM has decided to offer potential customers zero percent financing for 60 months.  The deal reflects GM’s desire to maintain its “value pricing," GM's attempt to bring its vehicles' manufacturer’s suggested retail price (MSRP) closer to the dealer’s invoice.  (Translation: the advertised price is closer to the actual sale price, and no funny business.)  But here’s the problem: because of falling demand for trucks and SUV’s, the vast majority of GM’s (and everyone else’s) truck and SUV buyers are thousands of dollars backwards on their loan.  They owe more on their vehicle than it’s worth.

Traditionally, GM dealers have used rebates to pay off the difference between what their potential customer owes on their old vehicle and what it’s worth in trade.  Now that there’s no cash on offer, now that there’s a smaller difference between MSRP and invoice, dealers won’t be able to bail out customers who are “underwater.”  Zero percent financing is wonderful (for those who qualify), but it maxes-out at 100% of a new car’s price.  So anyone who’s backwards on their current vehicle is going to have to reach into their own pocket to pay off most of their old debt.  No doubt dealers will call it a “deposit,” but the fact remains: a lot of customers will drive away in the same truck they drove in.

But zero percent allows Rabid Rick’s mob to maintain appearances.  See?  We stayed the course.  Once these ‘06’s are clear, once our new vehicles hit the dealer lots, once we’re right-sized, we’ll be back in the black.  Yes, well, there are an increasing number of well-informed GM watchers who believe that the black in question will be funeral attire. 

By on June 26, 2006

CarAssembly.jpgFor a second consecutive year, GM’s Oshawa production facilities have received J.D. Power and Associates’ “Gold Plant Quality Award.”  The award is given to the production facility with the fewest number of defects per vehicle, as measured by J.D.’s famous “Initial Quality Study.”  Oshawa created cars with just 43 defects per 100 vehicles.  The industry average was 124.  So what do you do if you have the second most productive assembly plant on the continent?  If you’re GM, you do the only logical thing possible: you close it.  

There’s no question that GM has too much of everything: brands, models, dealers, workers, factories and suits.  Although the media hails GM CEO Rick Wagoner for cutting (a.k.a. buying off) production workers and eliminating plant capacity, they’re forgetting that the same stupidity that lead to the cuts could well mean stupid cuts.  As GM downsizes its vast empire to match its diminished role in the US automotive market, it runs the risk of making too many cuts in the wrong places.  Like Oshawa.

top plants2.jpg It may be a piercing glimpse into the obvious, but a plant that produces the fewest defects per vehicle is also building your highest quality cars.  GM needs higher quality products like a losing football team needs touchdowns.  The days when close enough was good enough are long gone.  If GM is going to claw their way back against the likes of Toyota, Honda and Nissan, they can only do it with virtually defect-free products.  They know this.  In fact, they already claim success; continually citing a supposed “perception gap” between old (i.e. crap) and new (i.e. high quality) GM vehicles. 

Again, it all seems pretty simple: produce better vehicles at your award-winning plants and reap the rewards, right? Well here's the thing.  The vehicles produced at GM’s Oshawa plants are some of GM’s best sellers.  Oshawa’s Number 2 Plant produces the Pontiac Grand Prix and Buick LaCrosse.  The LaCrosse is the best selling vehicle under the Buick marque, accounting for some 93k units in 2005. The Grand Prix has only just been eclipsed by the G6 at around 120k units.  But here’s the rub: GM (literally) has no business making “best-selling” products that drop as low 93,000 units.  Their huge dealer network and corporate infrastructure require gigantic hits, regardless of their quality.  And yet…

By killing Oshawa, GM is revealing two important defects in its “right sizing” game plan.  First, the General’s generals are demonstrating their lack of focus on product quality.  Why kill your best plant before your worst, even if that plant’s products aren’t best sellers?  If a hockey team doesn’t make the playoffs, you don’t trade your best player, you rebuild around him (unless you’re from Boston).  Oshawa builds some of the best-built products in GM’s lineup.  Throwing that skill overboard in favor of less capable factories is insane.  Which brings us to the second problem: flexibility.  

Honda’s American facilities can change the platform-sharing vehicles that a factory produces in a matter of hours, tailoring production to meet changing demand (e.g. Ridgeline pickup to Odyssey minivan).  The new, smaller GM will need to follow Japan’s lead, establishing factories that can create more than one product.  This trend increases the importance of any given factory’s workers and processes; product changeover is nowhere near as easy as building the same thing day in, day out.  Again, it makes sense to use your A-team, not the accidentally successful B, C and D teams.

A recent GM internal report supported the philosophy.  It recommended that GM invest $400m in Oshawa to transform and amalgamate the two plants into a single class-leading, platform-sharing production facility.  The plan: let the men and women of CAW local 222 produce the upcoming (and day late) rear-wheel drive, mid-size Zeta platform.  If implemented, the end result would be a Canadian produced Cadillac DTS, Buick Lucerne and GM’s latest halo, the Chevrolet Camaro.  When asked about this report to save the golden egg laying goose, GM Car Czar Bob Lutz scoffed and dismissed its conclusions as “merely speculative’.  Speculative because transferring production northwards would require closing the DTS’ and Lucerne’s current Detroit/Hamtramck home.  In the UAW-appeasing, YIMBY (Yes In My Back Yard) world of GM, that ain’t gonna happen.

It’s not right.  GM should use its Oshawa facilities to their utmost capabilities.  The factory has proven that they can produce over 500,000 vehicles annually that rank among the best for fit and finish.  The Detroit/Hamtramck plant only cranks out 170,000 vehicles with the same number of employees.  GM should consider Darwin’s theory and let the back of the herd die.  Right size the right plants, kill the stragglers that keep dragging the brands down and invest in what will ultimately make you a better carmaker.  After all, it’s one thing to talk about quality.  It’s another to actually build it.

By on June 25, 2006

smallstang.jpgIf the first step on the road to recovery is admitting you have a problem, congratulations Ford, you’re on your way.  The Blue Oval Crew recently admitted that their overly-long product cycles were partly to blame for their current financial queasiness.  As the surprisingly satisfied owner of a 2000 Focus, I’ve earned the right to say: ‘bout time.  I was worried that the marketers’ standard question “Would you buy this car again?” had become strictly hypothetical.

In the six years since my Focus was new, I’ve changed jobs twice and addresses three times.  I got married, we’ve had a couple kids and what’s left of my hair is going a little gray.  I’m not exactly the same person I was in 2000.  But the Focus is basically the same car, save for a different engine and a couple minor styling fluff ‘n buffs.  The rest of the world got a groovy new Focus two years ago.  We got a chrome grille surround.

Why would any auto manufacturer have its products on a life cycle greatly exceeding the average term of a car loan?  I mean, I get the whole Alfred Sloan/GM ascending the social ladder business model.  There’s a car for everybody, but never the same car twice (unless it’s expensive).  Since I liked the Focus so well, I should be ready to trade up to the Fusion or Milan, right?  Wouldn’t I really rather have a little bit bigger, classier car this time around?  After all, I’m older and I’ve moved up in the world, haven’t I?  Or maybe a family guy like me needs something with some cargo capacity.  You can get two Pack & Plays into the back of an Escape, after all.  Hey, we could get you into a lease on a new Explorer for a few dollars more . . .

The problem is, I actually like small cars.  I don’t want or need anything bigger.  Most of the time, it’s just me, my briefcase and a cup of coffee.  And I kinda like 30mpg. I really want another small car— but one that offers me up-to-date engineering and design.  If Ford can’t provide it, what about some other “American” brand?  Chevy will sell me an Aveo (they didn’t build) or a Cobalt (I still can’t tell from the Cavalier it replaced).  Saturn has an Ion, which is basically the same car as the Cobalt except it goes “boing” instead of “crunch” in a fender-bender.  And DaimlerChrysler won’t sell me a car at all.  I have my choice of a snack-sized SUV called the Dodge Caliber or a PT Cruiser only slightly less superannuated than my Focus.  I could wait for the possible Dodge Hornet, but if I wanted to wait, would I be complaining about the all-new Focus I can’t have yet?

You’d think the Big Three would have learned the lesson of the ‘73 and ‘79 energy crises.  You’d think they’d stay competitive in the small car market.  You never know when an outbreak of hurricanes or mullahs will blow up gas prices, making car buyers think small again.  But since the modern era of American subcompacts kicked off with the 1970 AMC Gremlin, how many American small cars have been world-class? 

Maybe two: the 1995 Neon and the 2000 Focus.  Otherwise, American consumers have been treated to a desultory deluge of dorkmobiles.  You know the names.  Go look up the numbers.  A solid decade of Pintos.  Twelve years of Chevettes, Omnis, and Horizons.  Thirteen years of the first-generation Cavalier, followed by eleven years of the second generation.  All of this while the imported competition was on four- to five-year design cycles.  Small cars are still showroom pogey bait, as far as Detroit is concerned.  It’s just that these days they’ll push an SUV or a crossover on you, not an LTD.

You’re not supposed to fall in love with small cars.  You’re supposed to fall in love with their prices, notice their shortcomings immediately, then decide that maybe you can swing the payments on a new Malibu after all. So I guess I’m barking up the wrong org charts.  I didn’t realize that small cars are supposed to be a pit stop, not a destination.  I’m a bad customer for preferring a small car after I can finally afford a big one.

All it would take to keep my dollars flowing Detroitwards is for some manufacturer to show me that they care enough about small-car buyers to offer us two world-class efforts in a row, without a couple Olympiads in between. Will Ford’s new short design cycles lead us to better cars more often or will they lead to half-finished beta tests?  Time will tell.  But it’s OK– for some.  The steadfast (if endangered) American car buyer is used to waiting.

By on June 25, 2006

Dear Mr. Nasscar,

VIAGRA1.jpgHow the hell y’all doin’?  I was down to the barber shop the other day when me and the boys got to talkin’ ‘bout cars an racing an stuff.  Clarence sed how he’d red that NASCAR was fixin’ to change all the cars all over again.  He said y’all was fixin’ to make all the cars the same, and the engines the same, and on top of that, they’s ugly.  He said they’s all gonna be slower too.  Then Earl piped-up and said that meant there weren’t gonna be no more good crashes no more.  Why them crashes is the only reason Ida Mae goes to the races in the first place!  Jake sed y’all gonna kill the sport ded.

And why in the name of Sam Hill y’all lettin’ them Toy Otas in?  My granpappy didn’t fite in dubya dubya two and lose half his damn cheek bone so they could come over here an run them thangs with hour Chevy’s and Fords.  He fawt for our rites.  And anyway, everyone knows them farn car’s got four doors and six cylinder engines and front wheel drive.  That jest ain’t gonna to cut it.  We wanna watch cars built rat cheer in ‘Merica, runnin’ on ‘Merican tars, like one them Ford Fusions.  You let them farn cars in and the next thing you know we’ll all be tawkin Jap’nese.  Hell, we’re jest getting’ used to aabling Espan Yol.  Yew thank about that some time.

And another thing, what’s with truck racin’?  It’s stock CAR racin’.  Trucks is how we git to the race track, not what y’all are supposed to run on the track.  ‘Sides, they ain’t trucks!  Ain’t none of ‘em got a rebel flag er gun rack in the back window, and y’all shore cain’t tie no dead deer ‘cross them flimsy hoods.  Monster trucks – now them’s trucks!  They jest pop a couple of wheelies over some of them farn cars, blow our eardrums all to Hell and we’re good.  Yew ever seen it?  Now that’s entertainment!

Now me and the boys got to thinking.  We came up with some ideals how y’all can make everthang better.  Git back to racin stock cars, not them college boy engineer cars y’all are running now.  It jest ain’t the same like when I useta could go down to Bobby Ray Ford and buy me a car just like what Cale Yarborough drove.  Us Ford boys can’t brag much when ain’t no difference ‘tween a Ford an a Chevy an a Dodge cept for the stickers on the front.

Sumtin else y’all can do is stop chargin us so much to see the races.  It cost me and Ida Mae so much to go to the last race that I had to put off payin for her granma’s new teeth.  Y’all are making all kinds of money on adds.  Y’all got adds on the cars and adds on the tracks and adds on the TV races and adds all over y’alls web site.  Y’all got more dam adds than even that edmunds web thing has.  Peers to me with all them adds and everthing y’all sell with NASCAR stuck on it y’all could let us plain folk into the races and sell us beer for about what they charge at the tractor pulls!  Jew catch my drift?

An stop changin’ all the dam rules.  Ever time I think I got things figgered out y’all up and change things, even in the middle uv th’ season.  Sometimes I think y’all do it just cause yew can.  I don’t know how them poor drivers can keep up with it all.  Us fans shore cain’t.

The main thing y’all got to fix, though, is all them dam purty boy yankees y’all are hirin to drive.  Ain’t hardly no good old boys driving none of them nasscars no more.  And y’all are runnin them in places with names like Poky-no and Watkins Glen, wherever that is.  (One of them Watkins boys who lives out to the old Turner place is named Glen, but he ain’t never heard of that place neither.)  Y’all need to Mason Dixon the dam sport fore them northern college boys rurn racin’ any more than they have, what with their ‘puters and tell ‘em a tree stuff.  That ain’t right neither.

Y’all know them races got started down here with a few of our boys runnin shine.  I know most them done retard, but it’s high time y’all gave them races back to us southern boys an quit actin all high-falutin, big city corporate-like like y’alls Walmart.  If y’all don’t, well, forgive me for sayin’ so, but it’s bin quite sum time since we gave someone in a suit a dam good ass whoopin’. 

Sincerely,

Billy Jim Blankenbaker

By on June 24, 2006

doom.jpgFord and GM are launching summer sales.  The development reveals an open secret: the automakers are selling vehicles at a loss.  There are plenty of reasons for this.  The need to maintain cash flow, pay the Union, generate business for their finance arms and protect market share.  But this trend can’t continue indefinitely.  At some point, both of these companies need to produce profitable vehicles, and lots of ‘em.  But what kind?

Back in the “good old days”, Detroit made its profits with middle and high end cars and pickup trucks.  The Big Three only built small cars when recession and imports forced their hand.  And no wonder: there wasn’t any “real money” in small cars– at least not for Detroit.  Their bureaucratic manufacturing infrastructure and union obligations made it difficult to compete with smaller, leaner competitors.  Besides, it wasn’t much more expensive to design or build a big vehicle than a small one, and they always sold for more money.  

Eventually, American automakers surrendered the low-end domestic car market to the Japanese, Koreans and Germans.  As the years went by, the foreign competition gradually moved its products up-market.  Eventually, the Dai San launched luxury brands, created out of whole cloth (or leather).  These were worrisome developments, but dismissible.  Then, calamity: Detroit struck gold.

The SUV boom provided a serendipitous boost to the domestics’ bottom-line.  The ability to sell cheap-to-build vehicles at a premium price was worth billions (and funded a large number of dubious foreign acquisitions).  The SUV-fuelled “easy money” diverted The Big Three’s attention at the precise moment when non-Detroit brands were making serious inroads into the heart of the car market.  Now that the SUV market has cooled, the Big Two are left playing catch-up, looking for a new cash cow.  Unfortunately, the US car market has changed.

The middle market now belongs to the Japanese.  Before the SUV boom, the Ford Taurus was a major force.  Its two replacements, the Fusion and the Five Hundred, haven’t exactly set the class on fire.  Although the Mexican-built Fusion is a solid sales success, it’s smaller and cheaper than its predecessor; which doesn’t bode well for profitability.  The Five Hundred is big and plush and augurs more profit potential.  But sales have been weak.  GM wishes it had cars as distinctive (if underdone) as these.  Meanwhile, Toyota, Nissan and Honda are banking huge profits on highly-evolved– and continually evolving– mid-market motors.    

The size class above the middle has lost much of its volume and premium models to the SUV boom.  The “near luxury” class is also packed with killer competition.  BMW, Mercedes, Lexus and Audi have all reached down– joining Infiniti and Acura on their way up.  This combination of superb products, badge snobbery and customer service has marginalized Cadillac and especially Lincoln.  It’s worse yet for Buick.  And Pontiac.  And Mercury.  And Saab.  It’s hard to see what Ford or GM could do in the “near luxury” market to end well-earned “foreign” hegemony.  Even when The Big Two own a successful niche player (Volvo), fierce competition in the segment makes for slim margins.

And then there’s the crisis looming in the truck market.  Toyota and Nissan are bringing out new full-size trucks and ramping-up production capacity.  The same industry wags who said building small domestic cars was a waste of time now say US truck buyers are too brand loyal to defect to the new guys.  GM and Ford better hope so; neither company is in any condition to engage in an extended price war, and the loss of profits would be catastrophic to the rest of their holdings.

So where are the new “profit centers?”  Only two American cars are enjoying strong, profitable sales success: the Ford Mustang and the Chrysler 300 (and its Dodge cousins).  GM is planning a new Camaro to challenge the Mustang and maybe a rear-drive platform to challenge the 300.  But both the Mustang and the 300 have no direct competition at present, making the new models’ potential success hard to judge.  New, boldly-styled rear-wheel drive sedans may only fragment the existing market, rather than extend a profitable niche.

Which raises a scary question: even if Ford and GM come up with a hit vehicle or two, will they deliver life-sustaining profits?  A spot on the top ten list may guarantee profitability, but the ever-expanding number of product niches– and the number of automakers in each niche– makes it harder for any one product to achieve large (i.e. profitable) volumes.  The twin solutions: flexible manufacturing and foreign sales.  Neither of which are Ford and GM’s strong suit. In fact, GM and Ford’s best chance for profit now lies in creating a spread of must-have vehicles in smaller runs.  This strategy requires some serious money, which can only be generated by profits.  Uh-oh.

By on June 23, 2006

CarSalesman_652.jpgIn my last post, we examined your basic alpha nature, your need to dominate other people.  Did you read the comments after the post?  Wow.  Not very happy are they?  No surprise there.  As you know, most people think car salesmen are the scum of the earth: cheating, lying, arrogant, ignorant, over-aggressive sumbitches with their own circle in Hell (where they try to sell each other five-year warrantees for all eternity).  Are consumers wrong to hate you so?  Nope.  But don’t worry about that.  There’s nothing inherently wrong with your innate desire for interpersonal dominance.  It’s what you do with it that matters.

Remember media mogul Ted Turner’s desk sign: lead, follow or get out of the way?  It’s more than a warning; it’s every possible human interaction defined on 12” of brass.  When two or more people meet, those are the options.  The TTAC’ers who described their horrific experiences with car salesmen are, in the main, alphas (smart, car-savvy ones to boot).  They walked because they weren’t willing to follow your lead.  That’s alpha to alpha conflict for you; it almost always ends in tears.  More importantly, the end result was exactly the same as if these car-buying alphas were brochure-grabbing submissives: they “got out of the way.”  The followers?  They bought a car.

This is your job as a car salesman: turn as many customers as possible into followers.  And to do that, you’ve got to be a leader.  Not a bully.  A leader.  

Before I explain the difference between the two, I want to counter a concept that’s been infecting car sales for some time: rapport.  According to the trainers spreading this bone-headed pseudo-science (called Neuro-Linguistic Programming or NLP), rapport is the “quality of harmony, recognition and mutual acceptance that exists between people when they are at ease with one another and where communication is occurring easily.”  They’ve got lots of tricks to help you: matching, mirroring, modeling, pacing, etc. Bottom line?  They think you should be the customer’s friend.

Have you ever heard the expression “never sell to a friend?”  Well, exactly.  There’s no better way to ruin a friendship than to sell your friend a car.  As soon as something goes wrong, the friendship is toast.  As you know, a car is usually a customer’s second largest (i.e. most expensive) purchase.  As you may recall, your non-alpha car buyers are profoundly risk-aversive.  They don’t want a friend that can schmooze about baseball or house prices or restaurants.  They want someone they can trust to help them buy– or not buy– a car.   Confused?  Think of it this way: would you rather hitch a ride in an airplane flown by your best friend– no matter how well trained– or a professional pilot?  

Not to belabor the point, but did you ever have a teacher you really respected, admired and trusted?  Someone who taught you something important and filled you with confidence in yourself?  Did you play videogames with them at home?  I don’t think so.  (Again, resist the urge to think of any exceptions.)  A successful car salesman can be friendly, but he or she should never try to be the customer’s friend.  Ingratiating yourself to the customer means subverting your natural alpha tendencies to establish a peer-to-peer relationship.  That’s just plain wrong.  What car buyers want, what they need, what they deserve is a professional.  A leader.

Entire forests have died to create all the books on the subject of leadership.  Let me condense them for you.  A great leader is honest, passionate, knowledgeable, attentive, clever, patient, disciplined, committed, charismatic, open-minded, positive and, lest we forget, funny.  All you need to think about is honesty.  A great car salesman should never, ever lie to anyone.  Remember: your potential customers are looking for an excuse to confirm their profound distrust of your basic character.  One lie, no matter how small, and your ability to lead is history.  You can always fall back on bullying, but that sucks.  It erodes your ability to look yourself in the mirror in the morning and, eventually, makes your customers hate you on sight.

So, never lie about price, availability, depreciation, specifications, features, the dealer’s profit, your commission, your uncle’s role in the Kennedy assassination, what you had for lunch, your favorite football team, anything.  The NLP zealots are right about one thing: 90% of communication is non-verbal.  One tiny little lie, and your hyper hyper-sensitive customer will know.  They will never trust you again.  Nor should they.  By the way, do you know why you lie?  Because you’re desperate.  You don’t have a proven and comfortable sales methodology that takes you from first customer contact to vehicle handover and beyond. 

We’ll start on that in the next installment.  Meanwhile, the “right” thing for the customer to do is to trust you.  Well, it will be, when we’re done.
 

By on June 22, 2006

1962.jpgIt’s been said that prison is years of mind-numbing boredom punctuated by sudden moments of extreme terror.  I feel that way about commuting.  Despite driving’s many pleasures, the daily commute gradually erodes all sense of joy.  All those repetitive miles, one barely distinguishable from the next.  The same old CD’s in the changer, the same dumb ‘morning zoo’ antics on the radio, same streets, same turns, same times.  You eventually lapse into semi-consciousness; unaware, unable to recall the last five, ten, maybe fifteen miles. Until your autopilot slumber is rudely interrupted by, say, an oncoming tractor-trailer drifting over the center line.

For the first long second, the truck seems like some sort of a hazy mirage.  You don’t even react.  Then, as your heart suddenly palpitates from the adrenaline rush of imminent death, the truck drifts back.  No sweat.  You don’t even mention it to anyone later.  Why would you?  It’s all part of the deal. As are the deer. Based on the zeal with which these ruminants throw themselves into the teeth of oncoming traffic, you’d be forgiven for thinking there are 72 doe-eyed virgins awaiting each of these cloven-hoofed speed bumps upon their earthly demise. Sorry; Bambi has exhausted my patience and gets no sympathy. Having suffered thrice by the whims of the herd, I now root for the hunters.

Anyway, commuting teaches us a great deal about our place in the world.  Actually, make that our micro-world.  If you really want to get to know a car, spend a couple hours each day locked in its confines, subject to its every fault and foible.  No car can live up to this examination.  No driver can stand the punishment. I’ve commuted to various jobs from various home locations over the years. Most of my commutes have lasted a half-hour or less.  But the thousand-yard stare I have now?  It’s the product of an eight year, 40-mile commute.  That’s 3800 trips in one direction or other; tedium unmatched in modern times. Except by my fellow commuters, of course. 

It was a pleasant-enough drive at first, with reasonable traffic and acceptable scenery. It was long, sure, but who’s in a hurry to get to work, anyway?  Then they took my sports talk off the air and replaced it with waiting room quality jazz. That was the first of many slights that beat this commuter into submission. Months of winter snow and ice rendered a lengthy journey even longer, slower and more stressful.  Summer months offered little respite, as flagmen and orange barrels replaced inclement weather as my personal bane.

Niggling events and inconveniences became maddening personal assaults. Why, for example, is this corridor so important that the county feels obliged to send a half-dozen patrol units down it each morning; and yet so unimportant that they can’t dispatch a single snow plow?  Or why must the window malfunction take the form of an inability to work during warm weather, but not cold? 

Even if car and driver survive a close encounter of the endless kind, they won’t be friends when it’s over.  One of my longer-term mules, an import family sedan of remarkable unremarkability, did its level best to transport me without committing offense.  And yet, after a thousand trips or so, I hated it.  Hated it right down to the frame.  Even after 250,000 miles of partnership. Even after the car absorbed hit after hit-– deer, curbs, potholes, falling branches, a mailbox and even a hydrant (do NOT loan your car)– it kept on ticking like the proverbial Timex.  What did it get in return? Disinterest. Disrespect. Disloyalty. Just . . . dissed. Hey, that’s how it goes in the commuting game.

After a while, I accepted the reality. I quit racing the clock and began sneering at those white-knuckled fools risking everything to pass, to gain one better place in the endless parade. What’s the point? We’ll just be back again tomorrow.  That was then. Thankfully, I don’t commute any more.  Life has allowed me to trade that worn-out 40-mile drive for a fresh, four-minute walk. Some days (I can’t believe I’m about to tell you this) I don’t drive at all. And when I do get back behind the wheel, I’m happier.  I actually look forward to those days when I have errands to run and thus a reason to take my car.  The time away from my former commute has given back something I’d lost: the joy of driving.

 These days, driving brings back the feelings I had as a teenager, when jumping into a car meant endless possibility rather than endless responsibility. So I’m recovering day by day. It’s a shame that so much of the driving we do today is rote commuting.  Our cars deserve better, and so do we.

By on June 22, 2006

MFields_DC_002921.jpgLast Wednesday, Mark Fields spoke at a Competitiveness Forum sponsored by the United States Chamber of Commerce.  Fields has an impressive title: “President, The Americas, Ford Motor Company.”  He also has an impressive international resume: Managing Director, Ford of Argentina; CEO of Mazda; Executive Vice President of Ford of Europe, and Chairman and Chief Executive of Ford’s Premier Automotive Group.  The auto exec’s speech touched all the usual bases: ethanol, currency manipulation, health care, tax credits, etc.  When Fields turned his attention to issues of national pride and policy, his remarks were measured and concise — and made about as much sense as a Ford GT entering the Baja 500.   

According to Mr. Fields, the auto industry is “iconic to America” and Ford is “an iconic American brand.”  Of course, by “America” Fields meant the United States; not Paraguay, Honduras, Guatemala or Mexico.  On the other hand, Fields admitted that FoMoCo “faces a tough 2006 in North America.”  So maybe “America” means the entire North American continent, including Mexico and Canada.  Or… not.  “The United States is the most open and competitive automotive market in the world.”  So he was talking about the US and not the rest of the Americas?  Or even the rest of North America?  

Maybe.  Field asserted that the Mexican-made Fusion triplets (Fusion, Milan, Zephyr) are “gaining share” and the “Fusion … is our way of saying … the Honda Accord and Toyota Camry’s reign at the top of the American sedan market are no longer unchallenged.”  So a Mexican-built car is Ford’s hedge in the American market against Japanese-branded cars built on US soil.  This is getting more and more confusing.  But wait – there’s more. 

Fields bragged that Ford’s new hybrids are “posting record sales of late” and their “innovations led to more than 130 patents,” with more pending.  The Ford exec conveniently omitted the fact that Ford’s hybrid technology depends on technology licensed from Toyota.  Nor did he mention the Japanese-made transaxles and battery packs and German-built regenerative braking systems which make Ford’s hybrids possible.

Halfway through his speech Fields finally explained what he meant by an “American” car.  Like the Ford-sponsored Level Field Institute pressure group, Fields’ definition of an American automotive product relied almost entirely on US employment statistics: the number of Americans employed in America by foreign-owned automakers vs. the domestic-owned carmakers’ American workforce.  Even though Daimler-Chrysler is German-owned, Fields grouped DCX’ workers with Ford and GM’s domestic workers.  Translation?  In Field’s world view, “American-made” refers to any car, truck, minivan or SUV built in an American plant that isn’t owned by a Japanese or Korean company. 

Fields then castigated his Japanese and Korean competitors because “most of their design and engineering jobs are not located in America.”  Maybe that’s because they’re GLOBAL corporations that decided to locate their design and engineering centers inside their target markets.  If you look at the top models Honda, Toyota, Nissan and Hyundai sell in America, the majority was conceived in design centers located on American soil, designed by American-born designers. 

Anyway, for industry watchers concerned with The Blue Oval’s impact on US industrial policy, Fields’ speech raised more questions than it answered.  Why, for example, did Ford’s president single-out Japanese and Korean manufacturers for criticism, instead of censuring all companies selling cars on American soil that aren’t built in the USA by an American-owned company?  Could it be because that definition would include Ford-owned “foreign” brands: Volvo, Aston Martin, Land Rover and Jaguar? 

If you think about it, the cars made by these companies are just as “foreign” as an imported Toyota.  So why did Fields denounce “foreign” automakers that come here from other countries and establish a brand identity and manufacturing presence in the US?  They’re only doing the same thing Ford did in Germany.  And England.  And Australia.  And Argentina.  And… and… and…

Not to put too fine a point on it, Fields’ hypocritical flag waving was stunning in its rational inconsistency.  Fields’ speech bitched about foreign governments helping their automakers with currency manipulation, and then bragged “states and local governments subsidize new investments, in some cases as much as $160,000 per job. Governors get re-elected winning new plants.”  How can Fields criticize Toyota for investing in American (US) production when (according to various press reports) Ford has just pulled the trigger on an estimated $9.2 billion to update and expand its Mexican operations — to replace lost production capacity from closing plants on US soil?

Despite his assertions to the contrary, Fields’ speech was nothing more than a thinly veiled plea for a bailout from the federal government via tax credits and for protection from the very same free trade market that companies like Ford helped build.  If that’s all Mr. Fields has to say, perhaps he’d be better off restricting his remarks to the viability of Ford’s products in the American marketplace.  Then again, maybe not.  

By on June 21, 2006

fred2.jpgFirst, relax. You hate your job because you don’t know what you’re doing.  Face it.  You, a car salesman, have no quantifiable methodology for selling a car.  At best, you think customer "conversion" depends on your personality, product knowledge, perseverance and luck.  At worst, you think it’s a simply a matter of bullying the customer into buying a car.  You want to hear something funny?  Bullying IS the most effective sales technique.  I’m not recommending it, but if you really want to master car sales, you’ve got to understand the non-PC realities of human nature.

Before Ted Turner bought Montana and retired to shoot wildlife in a drug-addled haze, CNN’s founder had a sign on his desk that read “Lead, Follow or Get Out of the Way.”  Obviously, Captain Outrageous considered himself the leader; leaving everyone else to either follow his instructions or, as Ted liked to put it, f-off.  And boy, did The Mouth of the South learn to work that strategy, building a multi-billion dollar empire on the back of championship wrestling and baseball.  That’s because Ted Turner had an inherent understanding of his position in this world.  He knew he was a born salesman.  

It all comes down to testicle size.  (For women, it’s the amount of testosterone in their system.)  Men with larger testicles produce more testosterone than men with smaller testicles.  The hormone makes them physically stronger, much more aggressive and far more inclined to take risks than smaller-balled men.  As you might imagine, high testosterone or “alpha” males represent a minority of the total population.  Well, if they’re not at the beginning of their life cycle, they are at the end– after competing alphas have killed each other off, died from taking stupid risks or found their way into a prison cell. 

This, my friend, is you.  You are a high testosterone male.  Think about it.  Who in their right mind would be a car salesman?  There’s no job security.  There’s no income security; your livelihood depends on your performance on any given day, with any given customer.  If you want to know how you ended-up where you are, look down.  Not convinced?  Look around.  How many of your male colleagues are tall/large?  How many of them are losing their hair?  How many played contact sports in high school?  How many are cheating on their partner or just plain horn-dogging it?  How many are always sweating?  How many are team players?

These are your people.  But they are not your customers.  Car salesmen can’t get their heads around the fact that their customers do not share their psychology.  You want a bigger house.  A better car.  A better suit.  A better watch.  A better wife.  You were born to want MORE, and you’re willing to risk everything to get it and WIN.  Your customers have smaller balls.  Their primary motivation is to hang on to what they’ve got.  They were born to sniff the air, follow the crowd, minimize risk and NOT LOSE. 

This is why your customers fail to share your excitement about buying a new car.  The majority see car buying as an endless opportunity to lose/squander their precious resources.  In fact, the whole process scares them shitless.  You scare them shitless.  This is why car salesmen who are bullies do so well.  We’ve all heard stories of burly car salesman who literally kidnap and/or physically force customers to buy a car.  They do it because it works.  The evil alpha salesman establishes dominance over the beta customer, who eventually decides they’d lose more by not buying a car (like, say, their life). 

Again, this kind of bullying is not the right way to sell a car.  But in the absence of a positive, coherent, logical and successful method to honestly and effectively utilize a salesman’s natural dominance to sell a car; it’s the most efficient.  And please don’t go thinking about all the times this wasn’t or isn’t true.  If you’re going to learn how to sell a car properly, you need to subvert your natural tendency to focus on exceptions to the rule.  Alphas are born hunters, and hunters always look for the different thing: the old, weak or malformed member of an otherwise homogenous herd.  Sales is a numbers game.  Your goal is to sell cars to the majority, not the minority.  So forget all the examples that illustrate that I’m wrong.  Focus on all the experiences that tell you that I’m right. 

Last paragraph?  Wow.  That went fast.  There’s a bunch more practical stuff to come that’s gonna blow your mind and bring you bucks (YES MORE!).  Meanwhile, a quick question.  What if there’s a way to embrace your Alpha-ness that helps car customers make the right decision?  And what is the “right decision?”  

By on June 21, 2006

tirebalance.jpgI’ve just returned from a four day round trip to Florida after having endured a seriously annoying vibration from the front end of my award-winning minivan.  This after arranging a pre-trip rotation/balance/alignment at my award-winning dealership.  As I hover over the manufacturer’s service-visit survey (which was waiting for me upon my return), my pen hand freezes over the checkboxes.  One little tick might just result in the castration of the technician responsible for my tingling hands and inflamed attitude.  I can foretell the reaction from survey central.  Oh….My…Heavens!  A survey rating of LTP [Less than perfect] has been submitted!  Activate the GO TEAM!

These days, any visit to a manufacturer-branded service department invariably leads to a customer survey.  As you pick up your vehicle, all hands on the service deck make a cloying and pathetic plea for “excellent” ratings.  From the service “host” to the cashier with the mysteriously low-cut and tight attire, they all “remind” you that “five is the highest score” on the walkout survey incorporated into the service receipt.  Uh, sure.  Thanks.  Their lobbying is creepy, intrusive and inherently unethical, and it doesn’t end there…

Within hours, a letter from the dealership arrives with a heads-up: a manufacturer’s survey or (worse) phone call is headed your way.  The dealer staff’s continued employment depends entirely on your providing “only the highest rating” ticks on every question.  Further, if you feel unable to make these bubbly, effusively positive post-visit comments, you are despicably evil human filth– I mean, could you please give the service manager the basic courtesy of discussing your concerns with him prior to any negative assessments you might consider sharing with the brand’s customer relations monitors?

So am I to call my dealership and discuss how to get adhesive wheel weights to stick on uncleaned wheels?  Or more fun yet, tender the suggestion that maybe their highly trained technicians just did the rotation, figured the tires looked good enough and skipped the whole balancing procedure?  Or somehow blew the highly lasered and automated alignment process?

And I’ll still have to leave my vehicle– again– for a few hours.  If I want to avoid death by People magazine, I’ll have to rent a car (the only loans my dealer makes involve interest payments and lots of ‘em).  Moreover, I’ll face a repeat round of surveys, which could trigger another cycle of false feedback: “Was the service department friendly and courteous while correcting the mistake they shouldn’t have made the first time?” 

Please.  Car companies should not allow their dealerships’ personnel to brow-beat their customers with the potential consequences of an honest consumer report.  The dealership should simply ask the owner if the dealer’s service was up to snuff and be done with it.  If it turns out that they screwed up, the service department needs to suck it up and take the beating they deserve.  Yes, they should be allowed the opportunity to fix their screw-ups.  But using emotional blackmail to manipulate their esteemed customers into ziplipification– even if they attempt to “correct” problems later– enables substandard procedures to persist.  It’s a win – lose situation.

Maybe we should have some responses ready for these situations.  When the service department toady helpfully informs us that “five is the highest rating” we should ask,”Given that five is an odd number, what’s an average score?” When they tell us “If you can’t give us the highest possible ratings on every question, please contact our service department Manager immediately” we should counter “Wouldn’t that render the survey statistically insignificant, in that it would be an aberration of the sigma-six design coefficient theories outlined in Johansson’s seminal work “Survey and Assessment-Instrument Compilation for the Twenty-First Century Customer?”  

Of course, there is no such book.  But being able to cite it with authority will glaze every sub-erudite eye for miles.  And when the ever-so-helpful service folk overdo the gluteal-kissing with cheerful placards and/or five cent mints, remember that they really do want you to be satisfied.  So tell them you’d like to be allowed to complete all future surveys without hectoring, pleading, bargain basement bribery and cynical mind games.  Or, more comprehensibly, “piss off.”

And when you take your car in for a warranty recall, simple service or minor repair, and they put your steering wheel back on off-center, or get oil all over your engine cover, or fail to get the door fascia on properly, or over-torque the lug nuts, tell the manager about it and get things put right ASAP.  And then report the hassles on the ensuing surveys.  At the same time, manufacturers must do whatever they can to put an end to this charade.  They should mystery shop their dealers’ service departments or survey customers on pre-survey shenanigans.  The truth hurts guys.  Get used to it.

By on June 20, 2006

moonbuggy.jpgJonny Lieberman thinks SUV's should look like they're ready to win World War II or go to the moon.  Shrugging off that da-da-esque assertion, we schmooze about great car names of the past and JL's recent experiences with the Ford Focus (reviewed below). As a certain automotive website recently asserted that minivan ownership disqualifies TTAC's Editor from assessing automotive cool, I ask Jonny for his choice for coolest car under $18k.  Wouldn't you know: it's a BMW. 

By on June 20, 2006

alternatorwiring.jpgWhen people say a car has “character,” they mean one of two things.  First and foremost, the word is deployed to praise gross ergonomic errors.  We’re not talking about minor design quirks: Saab ignitions on the floor, CR-V shifters high on the dash, horns on the wheel spokes.  Pistonheads trot out the “C” word to heap praise upon those interior peculiarities that stand up and demand you notice them when you should be doing something else, like driving.  While enthusiasts have been praising these automotive “eccentricities” for years, it’s time for carmakers to write this character out of the program.  

I once read an editorial criticizing GM for finally placing the headlight controls on a stalk on the wheel.  The writer claimed The General was surrendering its “American character” by following some (but not all) foreign manufacturers’ lead.  Nonsense.  The dash-mounted light switch was ergonomically inefficient; stretching forward to turn the lights on/off was both uncomfortable and dangerous.  Even worse, the switch provided no feedback whatsoever.  GM’s light switch remained out of reach simply because of bureaucratic inertia and corporate parsimony.   

That’s no more “character” than Land Rover’s decision to locate their CD changer under the passenger seat (pre-Ford).  Did Volkswagen feel obliged to continue the “character” of its cars by building them without heat?  If a function or design is ugly or inconvenient to its user, it can only justify its existence by offering some form of compensation.  Saturn’s panel gaps may have been visible from low earth orbit, but that’s the price customers paid for dent resistance.  But hide my radio controls behind a menu– hide ANY controls I need to get along– and we’re going to have words. 

“Character” is also a term meaning “horrific quality.”  Cars with “character” must have at least one good feature– go like hell, turn on a dime, look like sex, etc.– along with a myriad of defects and problems.  Alfas didn’t have “character” because they were built out of compressed rust; their electrical and engine faults earned them the right to the descriptor.  Old British cars are notorious for having bags of “character.” Although credit is usually laid at the feet of the “Prince of Darkness” (Lucas electrics), the fact that anything and everything else mechanical was equally susceptible to a sudden interruption of service made them “memorable.”   

This brings the whole “character” issue (and the people who use the term) into focus.  If a flaw is predictable and universal, there is nothing special about it.  Real “character” comes from design so poor that you literally don’t know what can (or face it will) go wrong.  And if every problem is different, the car and by extension its owner are unique.  Jaguar owners’ clubs often given an award called “the cat’s bite” to the owner who had the worst breakdown in the last year.  “Please, tell us just how capricious, how temperamental, how “special” your catastrophe was.”    

Ordinary drivers often feel disconnected from expert car reviewers’ opinions.  How many mainstream motorists power slide through turns or assess aerodynamic stability over the ton?  But if car writers are narcissists and libertines, then “character” people are unfathomable masochists.  From a safe distance, S&M appears to be a more normal (and probably safer) practice than driving a car that “may” work every other weekend.  Besides the uncertainty, there is also the expense (special mechanics, special parts).  The driver/car relationship, seen from the outside, appears completely dysfunctional, even abusive.  Intervention can be tried, but success is doubtful.   

Of course, this love of “character” leads to strong, nay zealous devotion to a marque by a small group of loyalists.  The “believers” don’t love the vehicle in spite of its flaws; they love it because of its flaws.  Ordinary buyers may not see the appeal of a brand that can't build straight. But the sheer strength of the fanatics’ adoration builds the automaker’s image to the point where it can seduce an otherwise sane multinational car company into buying the entire company (Jaguar again).  

There is something to be said for this insanity.  As demented as it may be, the sheer devotion of these fanatics is almost touching.  More importantly, their desire for uniqueness reminds us of the appeal of the car, the individuality that comes with going where you want when you want.  I salute them for reminding us of the century-old roots of auto appeal, and I damn their judgment for doing it in a vehicle only slightly more dependable than those pioneering machines.  

In my wilder moments, I dream of driving some of these famous crocks.  I wouldn’t mind getting behind the wheel of some Paleolithic British roadster, but I’m not crazy enough to buy one.  My family had a Chevy Vega and a VW bus back-to-back.  That’s enough “character” for anybody.

Recent Comments

  • Lou_BC: @Carlson Fan – My ’68 has 2.75:1 rear end. It buries the speedo needle. It came stock with the...
  • theflyersfan: Inside the Chicago Loop and up Lakeshore Drive rivals any great city in the world. The beauty of the...
  • A Scientist: When I was a teenager in the mid 90’s you could have one of these rolling s-boxes for a case of...
  • Mike Beranek: You should expand your knowledge base, clearly it’s insufficient. The race isn’t in...
  • Mike Beranek: ^^THIS^^ Chicago is FOX’s whipping boy because it makes Illinois a progressive bastion in the...

New Car Research

Get a Free Dealer Quote

Who We Are

  • Adam Tonge
  • Bozi Tatarevic
  • Corey Lewis
  • Jo Borras
  • Mark Baruth
  • Ronnie Schreiber