Category: Editorials

By on June 19, 2006

Death-Spiral_Figure-Skating.jpg2.jpgGM swears up, down and sideways that they will not stage a repeat of last summer’s Fire Sale for Everyone discount program. And yet inventories are up, sales are down and if they look sideways they can see their competitors printing up blowout banners. “Value Pricing” be damned. The General knows that every sale surrendered to Ford, Chrysler and Toyota eats into its already dwindling market share, rendering GM’s production cuts less and less effective. Besides, the cuts are expensive. GM needs dealer cash now. So it’s not a question of “if.” It’s a question of “what then?”

This is the GM death spiral: larger and larger production cuts in response to a smaller and smaller market share. When GM CEO Rabid Rick Wagoner stepped-up to the microphone a little over a year ago and announced he was going to cut 25k jobs, the media was aghast. American manufacturing is under attack! Our industrial base is shrinking! These days car hacks and Wall Street celebrate the fact that GM and Delphi workers are rushing for the exits by the tens of thousands. I guess someone stashed that old saw about “not being able to cut your way to profitability” in the wood shed and forgot about it. Well, at least until the next financial quarter’s [delayed] results prove that a corner turned can lead straight to a dead end.

Meanwhile and still, stabilizing the patient is Rabid Rick’s first priority; otherwise the amputations will be a success and the patient will die. A great deal of attention has been lavished on the financial details of GM’s union buyout plan. Little has been said of the timing. While GM’s 113k union members are busy weighing up the pros and cons of trading “secure” employment for cash money and [somewhat] reduced benefits, their factories are busy churning-out vehicles no one wants to buy. Rick’s mob can’t shut off the spigot. All The General can do is whatever it takes to keep the pipeline open.

And that means discounts. Of course, GM will not call the next big US incentive campaign an Employee Discount. For one thing, it won’t be long before they don’t have any employees left. But seriously folks, Rabid Rick has once again given himself enough wiggle room to accommodate Greg, Jeff, Murray, Anthony and their entire international fan base. In a recent interview, Wagoner said GM would stick to its policy of “simpler pricing.” In case you missed it, those are the new code words for what was previously called “value pricing.” It’s the difference between “here’s what you pay” and “here’s what you pay and we’re not offering any discounts.”

Because, of course, they already are. GM’s $1000 “free gas” promotion is already out there, attempting to lure Californians into gas-guzzling SUV’s. And it’s spread to Florida. How long before the gas cash come-on gets a national rollout? Free gas, 0% financing, rebates– whatever you call it, however you dole it out, the money comes off GM’s bottom line. But it’s Hobson’s choice: lose more market share or lose more money. Of course, GM could tell its dealers to hold the line on price, watch inventories swell, and do both. That’s not only the worst case scenario, it’s the least likely. And speaking of timing…

GM has just convinced its banks to lend it additional money to pay for its union buyouts, plant closures, Fire Sales, etc.  The loan is fully secured.  Hence, S&P has lowered its rating on GM’s unsecured debt to B- .  That puts GM perilously close to the point where Cerberus can walk away from the GMAC deal, denying The General the long-awaited cash infusion.  Equally important, GM now admits it will draw on this line of credit to meet liquidity needs.  The good news for camp followers: GM won’t go bust today.  The bad news: the noose is drawing tighter. 

And make no mistake, the UAW hasn't stepped off the scaffold.  While last week’s UAW convention in Las Vegas had analysts betting that the union bosses are in a conciliatory (a.k.a. “realistic”) mood, when was the last time the UAW made any concessions to the automobile industry? The recent “health care giveback” was actually a $3b union-administered fund. Buyouts are not a concession. If we believe that Delphi is serious about reducing its workers’ pay, if we believe GM can’t fund the difference, the union will have to make concessions. Past history says it ain’t gonna happen dot bomb.

That’s because past history is the only reliable guide to future behavior. When GM launched its Employee Discount for Everyone program last year, the company pronounced it a tremendous success– and waltzed straight into a sales drought and catastrophic financial losses. What’s changed since then? The levels of unsold inventory are higher.

By on June 19, 2006

ethanol22.jpgThe United States has pledged to kick the oil habit before. But this time we mean it. Better yet, we have a solution that doesn’t require any of that furrin’ hybrid and diesel technology: E85. Produced from corn and other products grown in good old American soil, this 85 percent ethanol blend enables American-as-apple-pie small block V8s to burn less gasoline than a Prius. If every car, truck, and SUV were E85 now, why we could tell the Arabs to shove it! So all good Americans should buy an E85-capable full-sized SUV TODAY! Actually, on second thought, maybe we shouldn’t be so quick to “go yellow.” 

Brazil, poster child of the E85 movement, has farmed its way to energy independence. But the same solution won’t work so easily for the US. For one thing, Brazil produces ethanol from sugar cane, a much cheaper foodstuff than corn or anything else we can grow in the decidedly non-tropical Midwest.  Perhaps global warming will lend a hand?  In the meantime, every ethanol booster not wedded to corn interests cannot stop talking about switchgrass.  Research indicates that an acre of panicum virgatum might yield three times as much ethanol as an acre of zea mays.  But even if switchgrass proves a fruitful source of ethanol, its potential impact on US energy policy is minimal. 

Americans are gas hogs. While 186 million Brazilians burn the equivalent of about 10 billion gallons of gasoline each year (40 percent of it ethanol), 296 million Americans burn 150 billion gallons of gasoline each year (3 percent of it ethanol). In other words, if America really wants to be like Brazil, we should cut gas consumption use by 90 percent.  (Hint: not many Brazilians drive full-size SUVs.)  Otherwise, we’ll need ten times as much ethanol as Brazil to match the Brazilian fuel mix.  

Converting the entire U.S. vehicle fleet to E85 would require about twenty times as much ethanol as Brazil currently produces for domestic consumption. Guess what?  America is already producing as much ethanol as Brazil, and will soon pass them to become the world’s largest ethanol producer.  

To achieve full gasoline self-sufficiency, we could convert 140 million acres of farmland to switchgrass. That’s about twice the acreage currently devoted to corn and a landmass nearly the size of Texas.  Once we use American coal to produce the electricity needed to convert the result to ethanol, we’re there!  Or not.  Devoting so much American soil to ethanol would send farmland and food prices soaring. This will make American farmers very happy, and anyone who has to buy food unhappy.  We might have to starve millions to do it, but we’ll be able to feed our SUVs without foreign oil! 

Alternatively, we could import ethanol. If Corn Belt congressmen would agree to cut the protective tariff, Brazil would gladly increase sugarcane production to help meet our needs. Brazil has plenty of space for more cane fields. What good does so much rain forest do anyone, anyway?  No matter which route is chosen, this huge ethanol production expansion won’t– can’t– happen overnight.  As part of his energy less dependence policy, President Bush has decreed that American ethanol production must double by 2012.  If US gasoline consumption stops growing, by that date all US gas could contain five percent ethanol. Maintain this torrid growth rate, and by 2018, all American gas could contain ten percent ethanol. 

Guess what? Virtually all vehicles on the road today can already burn ten percent ethanol, commonly known as “gasohol.” In other words, existing cars can probably use all of the ethanol we can produce through at least 2018. So why do we need new, E85-capable vehicles and new E85 pipelines and pumps in 2006? Well, they do seem to make Corn Belt congressmen and their constituents happy. They help GM deflect criticism. And, perhaps best of all, an E85 Tahoe gets a CAFE rating of 33.3 miles per gallon. You see, this rating is calculated based on the very shaky assumption that E85 (only 15 percent of which is gasoline) will be used half the time. As a result, GM can sell more V8-powered vehicles without incurring fines. Without this loophole, it would have to actually sell more fuel efficient vehicles if it didn’t want to pay up.  

Of course, GM didn’t create this incentive. It’s just intelligently reacting to it. Congress, pressured by Corn Belt people and industries, created the incentive. But why does E85 make the Corn Belt so happy? Why not simply mandate more gasohol, which can be sold everywhere and used by everyone today? I have no idea. For some reason, no one seems to be talking about this possibility. Clearly, we should.

Michael Karesh operates www.truedelta.com, a vehicle reliability and price comparison website.

By on June 18, 2006

fordcrush2.jpgRemember Joe Isuzu?  In the late 80’s, the brand’s spokesman was an actor (David Leisure) playing a pathological liar who’d say anything to sell an Isuzu.  He claimed the Trooper could carry “a symphony orchestra” or “hold every book in the Library of Congress.”  The Impulse was “faster than a [catches a speeding bullet in his teeth]… well, you know.”  While Joe’s commercials-– and for that matter, the Isuzu brand– are busy fading from the American automotive landscape, his spirit lives on.  The main difference between Joe and no-Joe car ads: today's disclaimers are smaller.  You have my word on it.   

On second thought, look for yourself.  Most automobile commercials include a small disclaimer like “closed course,” “professional driver,” “do not attempt” or some other CYA statement mandated by the company’s legal department.  It’s there to protect them against ambulance chasers waiting for a buyer to injure themselves or (preferably) die when they try to make their vehicle do what it did in the commercial– even if that’s just driving around a corner.  You have to wonder about a world where companies showcase an SUV driving off-road, or a sports car zooming through a road course, then feel obliged to tell the buyer “do not attempt” to do the same.  Just what are we supposed to do with these vehicles?   

The TV commercials for the new Mercedes GL-class are probably the best/worst example.  The ads show the Alabama-built off-roader shrugging off the impact of a crash test sled, towing more than a Peterbilt can handle, hauling an entire vacation home full of stuff and tackling a slalom course so fast it sets the cones on fire (actually my first impression was the brakes were overheating so badly they ignited the cones).  All this wouldn’t be too bad if it was presented Joe Isuzu-style, with humorous disclaimers.  Instead, the word “fictionalization” appears in letters small enough to qualify as a DMV eye test, flashing by so fast it could serve as an Evelyn Wood final exam.   

Autodisclaimermania reminds of a five-year old who lies about breaking a lamp but thinks it’s OK (and he won’t be caught) because his fingers were crossed.  When it comes to portraying extreme performance capabilities that might not actually be, you know, possible, or, equally worrying, destroying the vehicle involved in the display, truck ads are particularly notable offenders.  Could someone explain what “underbody digitally modified” meant in the Ford truck ad showing an F-150 crushed between two bulldozers?  Did the frame crumple like a beer can against a frat boy’s forehead?  Why won’t they show us what really happened?  Or tell us they actually crushed four trucks to make that commercial?   

Then there’s a special category of ads operating so far outside the realm of reality they should be classified as novelization.  These ads try to sell us on a vehicle’s ability to cater to/create a particular “lifestyle,” or seek to fill us with warm fuzzies (WF) for a company building vehicles that can’t stand evaluation on their own or relative merits.  Here’s a simple question: how many Americans actually own a kayak?  How many go rock climbing?  Not as many as own SUV’s.  But that doesn’t stop their manufacturers from selling their lumbering land yachts as gateways to the great outdoors.  Nissan may urge potential owners to “tell better stories,” but it would be hard come up with more imaginative fiction that their lifestyle vignettes.  

The poster child for the WF concept is Ford’s “Bold Moves” campaign.  The Coca-Cola style ads show a quick cut montage of bold Americans doing courageous and noble things– from a teenager getting his first driver's license to a woman with breast cancer entering the Susan G. Komen Breast Cancer Foundation's Race for the Cure.  So… where are the cars?  They don’t appear until the ad’s closing seconds.  What does that tell us about Ford vehicles?  Either a great deal (Ford’s ethics, spirit and community service) or nothing (), depending on whether or not you got paid to throw around words like “target demographic.”  

Of course, Ford’s not the only one inviting customers to share their highly selective alternate reality.  Toyota touts their “hybrid synergy” but neglects to mention its profitable flotilla of gas-guzzling Tundras and Sequoias.  GM brags how many of its cars get better than 30 MPG in highway driving, but fails to disclose that their whips are a lot less efficient around town, and that their overall fleet hews closely to the Corporate Average Fuel Economy legislation.  (Unlike BMW.)  

You have to wonder who the car makers and their advertising lackeys think they’re fooling.  They aren’t fooling me and I doubt they’re fooling you.  The truth is they, like Joe Isuzu, they are only fooling themselves.  And if I’m lying, may lightning strike my computer.

By on June 18, 2006

surfbus2.jpgThe original idea: interview Jack Nerad about the type of cars parents buy for their teens.  When I finally got kbb.com's Executive Editor on the blower, he immediately informed me that A) He had no idea what we were scheduled to talk about and B) The press release about teen whips was released months ago.  So the guy works without a net and I'm behind the loop.  Shifting gears, I asked for their latest media mitzvah. "Cool Cars under $18k."  And then we get going and I discover that Jack's definition of "cool" takes us into some pretty strange areas.  Still, it's the journey that counts.  [Apologies for the audio levels.  We're working on it.]

By on June 17, 2006

pagani.jpgI like to clean.  I’ve never met anyone who can clean as well as I can.  Of course, there must be better cleaners out there.  After reading that English-born footballer David Beckham lines-up all the Coke can labels in his ‘fridge to face forwards, and only allows even numbers of cans, I reckon he’d be a worthy competitor in the rubber glove world cup.  But neither of us could hold a mop to Horacio Pagani.  After visiting his Modena Design factory, there’s no question that Pagani puts the “fast” in fastidious. 

The Zonda’s magnificent meticulousness snuck up on me.  When RF and I arrived at the supercar maker’s Milanese factory, I was not impressed.  Sure, the two-story glass building was a big step-up from all the small-volume English automakers’ filthy sheds, but Pagani's HQ was one of those generic structures that only looks good next to a small reflecting pool.  The interior had all the charm of a ‘60’s hotel: lots of tile, glass and hard angles.  If Zonda was trying to liberate Gulfstream go-getters from their money, I figured he’d have to do better than Arab chic.   

And then I saw a small, smear and dust-free glass case, just off a hideous central staircase.  Inside: a small group of metal die-cast cars, Group C racers, all carefully parked in the same direction, positioned in some non-chronological order known only to their owner.  Who was, of course, Horacio Pagani.  I later learned that these toys were Pagani’s Rosebud: the childhood icons that inspired his rise to greatness and gave him strength through his long and difficult climb to recognition (e.g. designing aluminum caravans and trailers).   

The fact that these toys had never been lost (most likely thanks to a doting mother of an only son) was revealing.  The fact that the models were chipped and beat-up was even more instructive.  Clearly, Zonda was a man who could live with imperfection—as long as it was arranged, ordered and contained in a perfectly clean receptacle.  My kinda guy, really. 

Not surprisingly, the Zonda was my kind of car.  My first Zonda had its rear carbon fiber panel open, revealing the most perfect arrangement of engine parts I’d ever seen.  Today’s high end cars use engine covers to make a semi-literal statement of bulletproof engineering.  The Zonda’s engine bay was a naked, unabashed and unadorned display of mechanical perfection.  Listen: the carbon fiber weave was exactly aligned and completely symmetrical.  That’s… crazy.  And yet, all Mercedes V12 engines deserve that kind of home. 

With the panel replaced, it was easy to see that Horacio had never lost his affection for those Group C cars, with their strange fighter jet canopies and long flat rears.  And then Horacio started pointing things out in short bursts of strangely-accented Italian.  See this line here?  Where the wheel arch meets the door?  Almost impossible.  You see that seam in the seat?  No machine can do that.  And yet it’s as perfect as a machine.  He had us peer, feel, listen, touch and yes, smell every detail of his creation.  

The cabin was a disaster: as tastelessly designed as it was scrupulously constructed.  The toggle switches were a joke, but a finely-machined, snick satisfying joke.  And the driving experience was seamless.  When RF surrendered the reins, I was amazed at how easy it was to drive the Zonda F at speeds so monumental I wouldn’t have been surprised to turn a corner and find Chartres Cathedral ahead of me.  There was an ease and simplicity to the experience that told me that Pagani's obsession with order was more than skin deep.   

After that experience, I’ve had a hard time driving so-called supercars.  I expect them all to be perfect.  You might think that climbing into an Enzo is intimidating, but I only felt a disturbance in my personal force when I discovered wires hanging loose under the dash (and got over it).  When bits of an Aston broke off in my hand, it was like watching a supermodel break a nail.  When we had to duct tape the Murcielago’s sunglass holder shut, you could almost hear my sigh over the engine’s howl.   

These days, I’ve started looking along panels for paint bubbles.  I shut doors four or five times, raise and lower the windows, just to get a sense of how a car's mechanisms negotiate the final territory between open and closed.  Strangely enough, given Mr. Wilkinson’s post, I’ve discovered that the passenger’s side vanity mirror is one of the best tests of a car’s depth of engineering.  How soft is the light?  How easily does the plastic cover slide across?  How smoothly does it move through its arc?  

The Zonda has ruined my ability to accept mediocrity— if, indeed, I ever had any.           

By on June 17, 2006

rollover2.jpgEver since the United States began issuing safety and emission standards, regulations have led to better cars.  Emission standards forced automakers to develop electronic engine controls, creating modern cars’ power and drivability.  Safety standards– seat belts, airbags, etc.– have saved countless lives.  But there’s one standard that’s not only ineffective, but antithetical to its stated goal: the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s (NHTSA) roof crush standard. 

NHTSA enacted FMVSS 216 in the mid-70’s.  Before then, unbelted passengers were often ejected during a crash and killed or injured by “external factors.”  It was assumed that roof strength played an insignificant role during serious accidents.  As seat belts gained popularity, NHSTA created its new roof crush standard to ensure that vehicle roofs wouldn’t crush belted occupants during a rollover.     

Rollover test.jpgFMVSS 216 requires all light vehicles sold in the United States to withstand a force equal to 1.5 times the vehicle’s unladen weight or 5000lbs. (whichever is less), with no more than five inches intrusion.  NHTSA’s technicians apply a measured force to one side of the roof’s edge, at a 25-degree angle (sideways) and a five-degree pitch angle (forwards), then measure the deflection, or failure, of the roof structure.  As a result of this requirement, car makers have strengthened their vehicles’ roof structures.  It would be easy to posit that the standard was– and is– an excellent piece of federal legislation.  A closer examination of the evidence suggests otherwise. 

The legislation’s framers knew that convertibles would never be able to meet the new roof crush standard.  So they exempted them.  At the time that the standard was created, convertibles were becoming increasingly unpopular.  NHTSA figured that extinction would make the exemption a moot point.  When convertibles made a comeback, the exemption provided valuable statistical data.  Unfortunately for the rule-makers, real world experience didn’t validate the roof crush standard’s original premise.  Passengers in convertibles during rollover accidents were not killed in any greater numbers than occupants of cars that met NHTSA’s roof crush standard.    

This empirical data has been ignored in the face of the increased lethality of rollover accidents.  Although rollover crashes constitute just three percent of all American accidents, they account for almost half of all fatalities.  That’s an estimated 26,376 deaths annually. But the assumption that a weak roof collapsed and crushed the passengers is simply not supported by the data. In 74% of cases, roof intrusion was not a factor. Rollover accidents are fatal because the occupants are usually ejected, or partially ejected, during the crash. 

Illustration3.jpgThe best way to meet NHTSA’s roof crush standard: increase the strength (and weight) of components at the top of the car, well above the center of gravity.  This adds significantly to an SUV’s “top-heavy” character, and contributes greatly to their propensity to roll when subjected to large lateral forces.  In other words, the requirement to make roofs stronger to withstand rollovers may well be making vehicles more likely to rollover.  NHTSA’s roof crush standard is creating a vicious circle; people may be dying because of the law– not despite it.    

Safety campaigners like “Protecting Health, Safety & Democracy” are lobbying the federal government to revise roof crush standards “upwards.”  They want roofs to be “stronger,” so they can withstand greater impacts.  Although it’s theoretically possible to find light weight materials that would withstand insult better than steel, in the real world, more stringent legislation would result in even more weight up top.  And that would mean that vehicles already more prone to rollover accidents will be made even more prone to rollover accidents by the increased stringency of the rollover protection standard.  

SSF_web.jpgThe past three decades have shown the basic futility of the roof crush standard. Yes, rollovers are a deadly and common factor in American road deaths.  But regulating the parts of the car that don’t tend to cause death or serious injury has little effect on real-world results.  If rollover protection is the goal, there are better ways to save lives.  Enforcing seat belt laws would have a major depressing effect on rollover fatalities.  Electronic stability systems have proven enormously effective at preventing rollovers from occurring in the first place.  Suspension systems that automatically lower the car’s center of gravity also have great potential.   

In any case, data gathered over the last three decades shows that it’s time to repeal NHTSA’s roof crush standard. The increasing trend towards taller vehicles, with a greater propensity to roll over, argues for the repeal of this standard completely, before it does even more harm.  While safety campaigners argue that the revised roof crush standards don’t go far enough, NHTSA should fully and scientifically investigate the likelihood that the exact opposite is true.  The rule-makers must admit the possibility that they’ve made a mistake, and find a new and more effective fix for a deadly problem.   

By on June 17, 2006

menzelphoto.com.jpgThe text after the jump appeared on Karl Brauer's blog "Karl on Cars" on Edmund's Inside Line.  I asked Mr. Brauer for permission to publish it here, without editing or commentary.  Nothing.  (The same response I received when I asked Karl to email me Edmunds' policy on press junkets and public disclosure thereof.) So, under the "fair use" principle, I'm publishing it anyway.  If Edmunds takes TTAC to court, I'll counter-sue for libel and send a note to the IRS asking about the tax implications of junketeering.  If Edmunds sends an email asking TTAC to remove this excerpt, I'll take this post down and publish the email. Anyway, Edmunds may have a million visitors [multiplied exponentially], but at least we have transparency, integrity and a spell-checker. 

Yada Yada Yada… "But one dark side to the "new media" is that anyone with an Internet address can badge themselves an "automotive authority" and subsequently expect the industry (and consumers) to take notice. After eight years at Edmunds I have a keen perspective on how hard it can be to convince the world you aren't just a punk kid with servers in your basement and a desire to get free test drives in new cars. In my case I was a punk kid with LOTS of servers and a desire to get free test drives…but I also wanted to provide accurate consumer information regarding those test drives to over one million visitors a month. That was in 1998, and our monthly visitor numbers are exponentially higher, as is the respect/cooperation we get from the manufacturers.

It wasn't always an easy journey, and I can relate to those publications still trying to achieve legitimacy in this ever-growing space. But I am also annoyed by those publications that break some basic rules of automotive journalism:

1. They target the established guys (like us) with all the usual "you've sold out and are owned by the manufacturers" crap. The most common battle cry is "the manufacturers pay for you to travel somewhere and drive their cars, so you obviously can't write a non-biased report." I think they mistakenly believe that by making such claims they can short-cut the process of becoming established themselves. Hate to rain on your parade guys, but there's only one way to make this trip — provide consistent, high quality automotive journalism over an extended time period (and I'm not talking a weekend, or month or even a year). Do that and the audience will come, followed shortly by respect from the rest of the industry.

2. They go after the manufacturers with false claims of influence to justify their own access to press vehicles. This usually comes in the form of lying about traffic numbers. And yes, I banged on the OEs to get press vehicle access over the years. Hell, I still do, as does everyone else in this space. Trying to get the hottest vehicles as soon as possible is part and parcel of being an automotive journalist. The difference here is that — once you're established — you can accurately claim people will be influenced by your road test content, and thus it's in the OE's best interest to be represented on your site. I've seen plenty of indigant editors out there who refuse to divulge monthly traffic numbers but insist they represent a core automotive Web site. Now why doesn't that behavior pass the smell test? The hypocrysy is also pretty hilarious. Do you think these guys would actually turn down a press event if they once got to the level of actually being invited? Me either.

3. When they don't get their way, they publicly trash said manufacturers and/or established publications. Apparently these guys feel that the best way to inform the automotive consumer/enthusiast is to whine about how nobody pays them any attention. Hey, as an automotive junkie you know what I really want to read about? How about 1,000 words on why manufacturer XYZ is a jerk because they won't give publication PDQ any cars? That's just fascinating stuff, let me tell you. Sure, we may have a First Drive on the Shelby GT500 and Acura RDX going up live tomorrow, but in the end we just can't compete against the ravings of an angry editor at a publication with 800 readers, now can we? Correction — after that latest rant they are down to 728 readers, and dropping fast…

Remember guys — the reader comes first. If you've got a problem with a manufacturer, deal with that manufacturer and spare your audience all the whining. Is there a specific publication I'm talking about here? Yes, there is. But there's no way I'm going to give them any additional publicity, so you'll all have to guess which one. Or maybe you don't care enough to guess (I'm hoping for the latter, as it further suggests a "not-a-moment-too-soon" death for this "illustrious" electronic rag)."

http://blogs.edmunds.com/karl/.ee91b8c

By on June 16, 2006

The Dunlop SP Sport Maxx 275/55R19 ultra-high (that's high!) performance tireI'm always amazed at how easily automotive PR folk slip into jargon-laden sound bites. I guess when your work involves something that doesn't appear on civilian radar– "my wife works with tires"– rattling off cool stats and technical terms to a pistonhead journalist must be the default option.  Still, I consider it my responsibility to try to get these technological flackmeisters to connect with their product, and us, on a more emotional level.  Of course, that only works if they do.  Dunlop's Janice Consolacion does.   

By on June 15, 2006

danger zone 2.jpgWell, here it is.  At the end of the proverbial day, a website saved is a website earned.  I’m sorry I prepared y’all for a quick and brutal transition into paid content, and then dumped a free site on you.  Psych!  Actually, over the last few days I gradually realized there was no way to give this ship a proper shakedown cruise without putting it on-line.  And if it wasn’t 100% ready for prime time, how in the name of St. Anthony could I ask you to pay for it?  Why I’d be no better than GM!  We’ve got plenty of time to make this the world's best automotive website.  

Many of you have emailed in technical suggestions,  which I immediately forwarded to Redwing.  Rest assured that the back end boys are assembling a punch list of all the geeky stuff that passed over the e-transom.  Feel free to continue the technological onslaught.  We’re still working out some functionality issues (e.g. all commentators need to be able to edit their posts quickly and easily).  I’m sure there will be others.  And please let us know quickly if something goes wrong: denied permissions, glitches in function, etc.  You are our eyes and ears (and we yours).  Use the comments button below.  

As for the site’s heart, soul and style, here’s what I figure.  The home page doesn’t have enough posts.  Well, that’s my take.  The old home page had around twenty items in descending chronological order.  Should we return to a lengthy home page or stick with the new shortened version (currently set at ten posts)?  A glitch resulted in some posts having two paragraphs on the home page, before the jump.  I preferred one.  Yes?  Do you miss the old open road animation at the top, or are you OK with a different detail shot every time?  Which buttons are confusing or redundant?  Is there something we missed?  Something you really like? 

Anyway, change is a bitch.  You should see the content management side of this bad boy; it’s got a more complicated back end than the first version of the last gen 7-Series.  (Who are these Word Press people and why do I think the name was originally used for a seventeenth century printing press modified to interrogate suspected witches?)  One thing I’ll be looking for: the car stats.  If they have to be migrated over by hand– a nightmare that will teach me far too much about torque– now might be a good time to modify them to include/exclude more info.  What stats are we missing?  And are there enough rating categories?  Forbes said no a while back.  What say you?  

No, I’m not having an attack of the Bill O’Reillies.  In fact, we’ve gone the other direction.  You may recall that Brock Yates’ work was slated to appear here.  At the sixteenth hour, Mr. Yates developed a cold.  Then he decided he wouldn’t put fingers to plastic on our behalf unless we paid him a significant amount of cash (after agreeing to a percentage).  Then it wasn’t the money, but the fact that the number of posts per month was too great (four) for his busy schedule.  Fair points all, and he’s free to negotiate whatever deal he likes.  But he might have mentioned this when we were scarfing sushi in Boston. I’ve left it that I’ll contact him again in two weeks.  Should I?  Guess which way I'm leaning…  

The really good news: our writers are getting better.   We’ve added some terrific new voices to the choir, and the regulars are sending in some pitch perfect stuff. Elton is about to throw down another gauntlet (should be interesting to see the comments).  A newbie named Jehovah Johnson starts off on Q7 patrol.  Mehta met a Morgan.  Williams thinks car manufacturers have a license to lie. Lieberman is condemned to Fords.  I’m about to Watch GM Die AND get a car to review.  And there’s lots more challenging material to come.  NOW how much would you pay?  Not THAT again…         

By on June 15, 2006

garage_2.jpgI remember spending an agonizing afternoon on my back, butt and knees on the cold concrete floor of my dad’s garage, trying to coerce a transmission, axle and wheel assembly back together. We’d just replaced my Jetta’s clutch, fried by a combination of adolescent exuberance and insensitive pedal technique. But, like some twisted Rubik’s cube, the various pieces defied logical integration. As afternoon drew into evening, my dad had a brainwave. “Let’s try again in the morning.” The next day, the parts simply fell into place; final assembly was as obvious as a pimple on a prom date.

That timeout was the trick that helped everything flow. It’s a technique I still use when confronted with seemingly insoluble problems: mechanical, psychological and spiritual. Like any boy who spends quality time working on cars, I learned a lot of life’s lessons in my Dad’s garage. Strange, then, that home repair, this crucible of character, this once pervasive American right of passage, seems endangered. I wouldn’t have expected our society to give up its garage culture without a fight. But then I wouldn’t have expected its original benefactors to be the same people conspiring to take it away.

"You can't work on a car yourself anymore." It's true: you can't. Even small garages would be lost without sophisticated and expensive diagnostic computers. Beyond that, imports have raised the electro-mechanical game to a level of near-total non-intervention. For decades, nothing could have been further from the truth; hundreds of thousands of cars received their regular maintenance and repair at the hands of their owners. One 1920's product manual urged owners not to be afraid of tackling these jobs: "Our company service men have no more brains than you do."

Now, all products are disposable. The impulse to fix instead of replace is gone, destroyed by the unstoppable efficiencies of mass production. Basic maintenance is either cheaply provided or rendered unnecessary. Change your own oil? About as likely as writing a personal letter. Check the transmission fluid? No way to do it on my car. The last time I bought wiper blades, the guy had installed them before I left the parking lot. Today’s corner garages are for pumping gas, slapping on an inspection sticker or parking.

All is not lost. In my Michigan locale, home garages and shops bigger than the houses they accompany are de rigueur. There are nearly as many auto parts stores in my neighborhood as there are gas stations. Those kids with their tuner cars, jeez. Even when Sears was having its recent troubles, the Craftsman division was still going strong. And there are custom bike and hot rod shows on TV every day of the week. All this seems to indicate that garage culture isn’t dying– it’s just entering a new phase.

The ambition for something better– faster, cooler or just plain different– continues drawing us back to the garage. Pistonheads are still entranced by the tools that make them feel productive and powerful. Attracted to the atmosphere that makes them feel vital and resourceful. It's labor, workmanship and expertise, but it's also escape and toys and play. It's a sanctuary. And important things happen when we return to it. We need those times. We need those lessons.

As the day-to-day drudgery of human existence is erased by the machines we create, it leaves less and less for us to do. Less to accomplish. Less to endure. We risk becoming idled and isolated. But the garage teaches us otherwise. It reminds us that the machine is an extension of the human. It is of the human, by the human and for the human. That's a lesson growing steadily in importance, as modern machines continue to elude our individual understanding and deny their dependence.

As machines become smaller, cheaper and more ubiquitous, they erode our general attitude of self-reliance. The garage teaches us otherwise. It demonstrates that we can overcome obstacles and alter our fates. It puts us in control and teaches both confidence and humility. It prepares us to look within ourselves for solutions and urges us to persevere. We need the garage. We need the sights, sounds and smells. The artifacts, rituals and garments. The benchmarks that help us understand and appreciate the social hierarchy built on knowledge, skill and craft.

We live in an age in which the quality of life for those of even modest means exceeds that enjoyed by almost everyone who has come before us. But modern conveniences take as well as give– sometimes before we even realize the importance of what’s been taken. We need to witness the automotive miracles worked and the mechanical souls resurrected. We need it for our sanity, and for our survival. We need the garage.

By on June 14, 2006

visor1.jpgOne afternoon, while watching a radar-controlled German ubersedan drive itself, the fading sun struck my eyes. Surrounded by microprocessors, solenoids, relays, pumps, controllers, fans, sensors, circuit boards and endlessly coursing electrons, I did what every driver must do: I reached up for a vinyl-covered board and pivoted it down to cover a small patch of windshield through which I now could no longer see. Excuse me? The $105k four-door was crowded with technology, all of it entertaining, much of it only occasionally useful. Yet no one had thought to correct, improve, replace, redesign or reconceptualize a device as primitive as the Budweiser Clydesdales’ blinders. What’s that all about?

In an era when even ordinary sunglasses readily change their opacity, and upmarket carmakers play pointless electroluminescent tricks with sunroofs, we still lower plastic panels in front of our face to block the sun on the windshield. You can't see through sunvisors. They cover only limited areas of the windshield. And because they pivot on a mechanical device as sophisticated as a drawer-pull, you can move them through, at best, two axes. In short, the sunvisor is a low-tech nightmare that needs immediate attention. In this it is not alone.

My first car was a 1936 Ford Phaeton. The vehicle had rubber strips on metal sticks that flapped back and forth to sort of clear the water off the windshield. The aforementioned 2007 supersedan has rubber strips on metal sticks that flap back and forth to sort of clear the water off the windshield glass. I've piloted Learjets that didn't have windshield wipers; they use artfully directed hot air. On final approach in the rain– the only time you're bothering to clear the windshield in a jet– the Lear wasn't going any faster than any big Mercedes, BMW or Audi.

How about jacks? Aren’t they the work of a genius? Actually they are. If you have to change a tire, you use a mechanical screw device invented during the Renaissance by Leonardo da Vinci. In fact, only da Vinci would still bother trying to use one. The rest of us call Roadside Assistance, since tires and wheels are too heavy to lift anyway. No, don’t bother telling me how much you and Pat Robertson can bench-press. The point is that the whole tire-changing ritual– jack, lug wrench, multiple nuts and studs– is still performed exactly as it was for a 1932 DeSoto.

Fuelling our cars also hasn’t changed since the Hoover administration. You unscrew a cap and stick a crude spigot into a filler pipe. Of course, this assumes you can find the artfully hidden switch that unlocks the little door covering the cap. I almost abandoned [an owner’s manual-less] Ferrari when it proved virtually impossible to locate the damn gas-flap toggle. The only part of refueling that’s improved since World War I is the gas pump itself, which now requires credit card activation.

True, there are ancient devices on/in cars that work wonderfully. A $1.29 hardware-store ignition key springs to mind. So how is it that car keys have grown in both complexity and size– to the point where I keep expecting the women in my life to ask, “Is that a luxury car key fob transponder in your pocket, or are you just happy to see me?” Heaven help you if you lose your lump in Mae’s couch; a new key now sets you back $400.

Consider hood latches. How many times have you fished around in that damn one-inch gap between hood and fan shroud, tearing gouges in your knuckles in the fruitless search for a latch release designed by a moron hewing to 100 years of tradition established by idiots? Who wrote the law that hood latches have to be accessible only by the flattened fingers of a concert pianist? Why do we need to go through the same hood-latch exercise our grandfathers did when everything else in the world can be made to answer to a remote? (The key!)

Understand that it’s the latch that pisses me off, not the opening system. To wit: Porsche has long since abandoned its perfectly good mechanical-cable hood-popping system for an electric release. So when you run the battery dead in a Porsche Boxster– easy enough to do when you raise the roof and forget to turn the ignition off– there’s no way to reach the battery. It sits quite happily underneath the electrically operated, now-immobile front hood. You have to get on your knees outside the driver's door, reach under the dashboard and use jumper cables to pop the switch that opens the front hood. Needless to say, you then have to repeat the exercise to jump the battery.

I guess we should be careful what we wish for.

By on June 13, 2006

JDPower-Awards.jpgAnother year, another J.D. Power survey. Since the non-profit Consumer Reports organization prohibits carmakers from using its ratings in their ads, “ranked highest in initial quality by J.D. Power and Associates” should start flooding the airwaves and Internet any minute now, with print sure to follow. But does all of this noise signify anything? Should those seeking trouble-free wheels be sure to buy one of J.D.’s winners? Hardly.

First, note the “initial” that qualifies “quality.” Power surveys car owners on “problems” encountered within their first 90 days of ownership. Most people understand that a car that’s reliable for 90 days isn’t necessarily reliable beyond that. But there’s a bigger issue. J.D. Power’s IQS has been redesigned (for the second time) to encompass a larger number of potential defects. And the more the IQS includes, the less it measures what most people want to know: vehicle reliability.

The previous redesign doubled the average number of reported problems per car by extending the IQS beyond defects (that can be fixed) to designed-in annoyances (that must be endured). For example, cupholder dissatisfaction famously slammed MINI’s score. The 2006 IQS report takes a step in the right direction by including subscores for "design quality" and "production quality." Combining two very different elements into a single score makes it unclear what the number represents. Yet this score receives 99 percent of the press coverage and 100 percent of the ad citations.

If you compare the rankings based on production quality alone, the brands’ relative positions change dramatically. BMW bounds 24 places to third; Buick jumps 14 to eighth; MINI ascends 13 to 16th; Mercedes-Benz climbs nine also to 16th; Subaru also gains nine to 19th. At the same time, Dodge drops eight to 27th; GMC plummets 13 rungs to 22nd; Nissan plunges ten, also to 22nd. Eight others change position by at least five slots. These include Chrysler, which shares many models with Dodge yet moves up five places, to fifth. Out of 37 brands, 16 rankings are heavily affected by the inclusion of design quality.

Beyond the cloudiness of the revised methodology, the way the results are reported and spun continues to put too much emphasis on relative rankings. In fact, absolute differences are often minuscule. Looking at defect rates alone, 22 out of 37 brands fall within one-tenth of a Problem per Car (PPC) of the 0.64 average. Thirty of 37 brands fall within two-tenths. Of the seven beyond this range, only one, Lexus, is on the top, and it only betters the average by 0.22 problems per car.

Stay with me here. The best brand, Lexus, has 0.42 problems per car, while the worst, Isuzu, has 1.10: a best-to-worst difference of 0.68 problems per car. Even this range results from a few especially low-scoring brands. The difference between number three (Toyota) and number 32 (Hummer) is a scant 0.27 problems per car. It’s ironic, since brands at the bottom of the chart receive the least attention in J.D. Power’s press releases. For years they didn’t even publicly release below-average scores.

Put another way, a Toyota compared to a Hummer has a one in four chance of having a single additional problem. Even comparing a car from Isuzu with one from Lexus, only two in three cars will have a single additional problem. What’s more, this additional problem is likely to be the only problem. Folks, we're talking about a single trip to the dealer for a single problem–which you still face nearly even odds of taking if you buy the best brand.

The reason why J.D. Power lumps design quality into the IQS is clear: without it, the differences between brands are rarely worth debating. And the smaller the differences, the less people care about IQS. And the less the pubic cares about IQS, the less automakers will pay to advertise IQS scores, and hire Power consultants to help improve them. This would truly be a problem– for J.D. Power.

J.D. needs to re-think their methodology and reporting. They should keep problems that require repair separate from other issues. Forget the brands, they don’t vary enough. Instead, emphasize model scores. Next, focus less on rankings and who is the best and more on the size of the differences and who is within spitting distance of the best. Finally, J.D. Power needs to shift their emphasis away from “initial quality” towards long-term durability. Manufacturers won’t like that a longer-term study keeps new models off J.D.-branded consumer radar, but anything less is, well, less.

Heck, J.D. Power might even rake in more cash this way. Anyone reasonably near the top—and not just those at the top—could advertise “ranked good enough in quality that you should focus on other criteria by J.D. Power and Associates.” No, it’s not punchy. Just the truth.

[Michael Karesh operates www.truedelta.com, a vehicle reliability and price comparison site.]

By on June 12, 2006

1971_chevy_vega21.jpgMy name is Robert, and I’m an obsessive. You may have noticed. You may have returned to an article on TTAC and clocked the fact that our writing evolves post-post. That’s down to me. If there’s a better way to say something, if there’s a single sentence with passive construction or a word that’s not pulling its weight, the text must die. If a reader spots a factual inaccuracy or logical inconsistency, it must be corrected. I’m not looking for credit; it’s just the way I’m wired. But if you want to know why GM deserves to die, why GM WILL die, there’s your answer. They lack obsession.

You’re car guys. You don’t need me to tell you this. You’ve encountered a GM product and seen, heard or felt cheap, lazy-ass design, engineering and manufacture. A rough-revving four, a removable seat that slices your skin, a button that feels nasty to the touch– some detail where you shake your head and think to yourself, if I was building a car, I wouldn't let that slide. I recently opened the trunk of an Impala SS and discovered an electrical cable hanging in air like a loose intestine from a hernia operation gone bad. The wire was wrapped in duct tape whose end was already starting to unfurl. As an owner, that would drive me nuts. As a builder, I’d spend my own money to put it right. It’s unforgivable. 

I’m serious. Don’t talk to me about building to a price. I’d rather not build the damn car than know that I’d participated in something so obviously crap. The next time you look at a modern GM product, take a mechanic and/or an engineer and have them show you the dozens of ways GM fails to go the distance. Even when they get it right, they get it wrong. The Chevrolet Corvette is an interior [and properly bonded roof] away from greatness. Why?

Suffice it to say, GM has too many brands, too many models, too many managers, too many dealers, too much union interference and a CEO who counts beans. GM apologists point to JD Power’s awards and tell the world that The General’s whips are good and getting better. Bullshit. Their cars, trucks and SUV’s are only “good” in isolation, or in comparison to the junk they produced ten years ago. Examine a comparable Toyota, and you’ll instantly understand that there's a reason GM has been losing market share for decades, and it ain't the media.

So now we hear that GM will live. That's the conclusion many pundits have reached since The General has finally fulfilled our prophesy and bailed out bankrupt parts supplier Delphi. Of course, Friday’s announcement that GM would pick-up the tab for extending the buyouts of Delphi's union workers, welcome 5k Delphinians back into its own operations and “top-up” the remaining workers' paychecks (so that Delphi can pay them less without paying them less) arrived without a price tag.

The Detroit News (DTN) reported the deal in full “historic agreement” mode (NB: the last time that happened, GM set up a $3b health care fund for the UAW and the DTN called it a “historic union health care giveback”). GM will supposedly pay 50% of the cost of the more extensive Delphi buyouts, which now include “up to $35,000 and full benefits to workers with at least 27 years on the job and cash buyouts, ranging from $70,000 to $140,000, to lower-seniority workers.” For some strange reason, GM, Delphi and The Detroit News all failed to a put a number on the new plan. Our best guess is about $1.2b, not including another $4b – $5b or so for pensions and health care benefits (for some but not all of Delphi's union refugees).

Delphi also revealed that it’s assuming (yes, assuming) that GM will provide a $50k payment per remaining worker, so Delphi can cut union pay from $27 to $22 to (eventually) $16.50 per hour. If 5k union workers remain, that arrangement would cost GM an additional $250m or so. If GM doesn’t stump-up the cash, Delphi still says it’ll play "how low can you go?" In that case, they're still talking $12.50 per hour– a number that has UAW strike written all over it. And even if GM stumps up 50 large per, will the UAW wear a $5 per hour reduction? Deep Throat says yes. I say no.

We both say it doesn't matter. Unless GM’s products sell for a profit sometime soon, the company can’t afford any of this. And they won’t sell at a profit, because, in the main, in detail and relative to the alternatives, they suck. To wit: a commentator on Autoblog named D recently said "I can throw a dart at a board covered in every new car offered by Honda, Mazda, Subaru, Toyota and I would be happy with whatever I get. Do the same with Ford and GM and the odds are I will be disappointed with some fleet car piece of junk." And there you have it.

By on June 11, 2006

flag2.jpgThe American consumer stands in the middle of a battlefield. The combatants: American and foreign automobile manufacturers, their unions, dealers and various representatives; politicians representing both northern and southern industrial states, and you. The stakes: profits, derived from the hearts, minds and wallets of red state car buyers. They’ve drawn their lines in the sand. They’ve loaded their weapons. They’ve fired their first salvos in what promises to be an ugly and protracted battle. And they’re all mentally constipated.

Ford drew first blood with its short-lived Red, White and Bold campaign. Characteristically, Toyota responded more authoritatively. Their “We're American” ad campaign declared that Toyota directly employs more than 32k Americans, and creates over 386k more jobs through its dealers and suppliers. Speaking at a visit to one of their Kentucky plants, Toyota’s newly-minted Chairman Fujio Cho spelled it out: "We have been working in the United States, contributing to the communities where we produce… Our workers here, almost all of them are U.S. citizens, so in that way, we are a US company." Then Toyota announced its intention to invade that unique bastion of working class America: NASCAR.

Next up: the Level Field Institute (LFI). Retired union workers from GM, Ford and Chrysler formed this “grass roots organization” because “when it comes to cars, ‘Made In America’ still matters.” The LFI admits that “measuring ‘made in America’ is getting more complicated.” But its ads aren’t bothered by fine distinctions: they simply list American jobs by manufacturer. Ford admits contributing cash to the LFI’s $1m TV, print and Internet campaign. The other domestics have lent the LFI emotional support. "I'm a little offended with Toyota's campaign," said Chrysler Communications Supremo Jason Vines, re-affirming the German-owned company's patriotic fervor. "They are a Japanese car company. Baseball, hot dogs and Toyota? Sorry, it doesn't ring a bell."

Then there’s the United Auto Workers (UAW). The union made their stand on the “buy American” issue perfectly clear years ago, when they convinced their employers to ban or segregate non-American cars from their parking lots. As far as they’re concerned, no true American would be caught dead behind the wheel of something that wasn’t built in an American plant by Americans who all belong to an American labor union and collect union wages (and, oh by the way, pay hefty union dues). The economic survival of the American middle class depends on American solidarity.

The truth is that “built” means “formed by combining materials or parts.” A car assembled in the United States is "built in America." If the artists formerly known as The Big Three (and their stakeholders) want consumers to “buy American,” they should decorate every vehicle assembled on American soil with foot-high letters proclaiming “Built in the USA.” Of course, the Ford Fusion needs a “hecho en Mexico” sticker, the LaCrosse merits a "Construit en Canada” tag and an Aveo should sport the appropriate Korean kudos. While they’re at it, US automakers should identify models sitting on platforms developed by foreign-based subsidiaries, and plainly label vehicles with engines built in China, transmissions built in the Philippines, electronics from Korea, or hybrid systems designed and made in… Japan.

In fact, when it comes to domestic parts content, even the LFI can’t avoid the flag-waving hypocrisy. If you scrutinize their list of US vehicles’ domestic content, you’ll see that there isn’t a single vehicle for sale that’s 100% American. Aside from the Mazda Tribute and Ford Escape (snap), the “most American” cars you can buy are only 90% domestic. And quite a string of losers it is too: the Mazda B-Series, Saturn L, Chevy Malibu and Ford Econoline. There are a few 95 per centers, but the LFI fails to mention that these models are either dead (Alero, Taurus) or marked for death (Marquis). The LFI lauds GM for providing the most US jobs (more than all foreign-owned automakers combined), but they neglect to mention GM’s huge and growing investment in Chinese parts manufacture.

Let’s cut to the chase. If you look beyond the ads and news articles about what is or isn't "American made," the real defining factor is whether or not the car is built by a company controlled by the union. The manufacturers being targeted by this campaign are those with non-union plants who enjoy a healthy relationship with their laborers and a healthy profit statement. The cars this campaign’s backers would have everyone buy are built in plants where the employees' allegiance is to a union, not to the company that pays their wages. It's time someone cut to the heart of this “buy American” campaign and exposed it for what it is: a rehash of the old "look for the union label" campaign. Americans didn’t wear it then, and they’re not about to wear it now.

By on June 10, 2006

gurney2.jpgRemember the Cougar? Not the oddly-shaped front-wheel drive Cougar of 2000 nor the big-bodied Thunderbird clone, nor even, God forbid, the huge sedans and wagons wearing “the sign of the cat,” but the 1967 original? Motor Trend’s Car of the Year was created from the Mustang. While it shared the Pony Car’s platform, it was NOT a badge-engineering model. Sales of the luxurious new coupe helped to lead the Blue Oval to some of the most profitable years in the company’s history. Hello? Ford? Anyone home?

It’s been a couple of years since the latest generation Mustang hit the streets. The retro modern two-door is a runaway success, easily out-selling the nondescript sedans that have become Ford’s standard bearers. At the same time, the Mercury brand languishes, offering customers nothing more than thinly-disguised Ford sedans and trucks. It’s time, past time, for the new Mercury Cougar. Stretch the new Mustang platform, drape it with drop-dead gorgeous sheetmetal, stuff it full of luxury (and a hundred pounds more sound insulation) and there you have it: a slam dunk sales winner and a halo car for a moribund brand.

In fact, there’s only one way a new Cougar wouldn’t work: if Ford re-sculpts the ‘Stang’s front and rear, tacks on some brightwork and badges the Mustang as a Cougar. That Milanese-style product would dilute the Mustang’s appeal AND fail to create a compelling reason for luxury car buyers to darken Mercury’s already dim door. An ersatz Cougar would drag the brand’s street cred even lower– if such a thing was possible. No; while a new Cougar would bring glory to a deeply wounded brand, it must be done right, or not at all.

A Cougar absolutely demands arresting styling. Since Ford’s hometown designers seem singularly incapable of creating anything other than boring and innocuous cars, why not call in Aston Design Director Marek Reichman, the man who penned the sublime Aston Martin Rapide? As PETA and other animal rights activists have made it virtually impossible for a big cat to work in the ad business, Mercury could make the Brit-born designer the brand’s official spokesman. “Aston Martin elegance made in America” would be a winning slogan.

Anyone who’s been fortunate enough to spend some quality seat time in a Land Rover, or a top-spec F150, knows that Ford can make great interiors. To produce a suitably luxurious Cougar, Ford could add luxury touches to the Mustang’s cockpit that aren’t available in the ‘Stang: automatic temperature control, twilight sentinel headlights, memory seats, sat nav and all the other luxury car necessities. Ford knows exactly how to do all these things, and I’m sure that they have the hardware on the Lincoln shelf to boot. If the new Cougar wants a “killer ap,” they could even fit it with a Borg-Warner dual-clutch paddle-shift transmission (a.k.a. Audi’s DSG).

A new Cougar could be Mercury’s re-entry into racing. If the Ford Fusion and a Toyota Camry can be NASCAR racers, surely the Cougar could be as well. Perhaps LeMans would be a better venue. After all, that’s where Aston Martin made their reputation. If Corvettes and Vipers can make a credible attempt, surely a Cougar, with the right preparation, could at least make a showing. The combination of a stunning design and the hype of a [properly promoted] racing effort would ramp up the excitement at Mercury dealerships to unseen levels.

Equally important, a “real” Cougar wouldn’t be a horrifically expensive endeavor for the cash-strapped domestic automaker. There’s nothing wrong with the Mustang platform that a little refinement couldn’t cure. Adding the aforementioned four inches to the wheel base would give the coupe passable rear seat room. The Mustang GT already has a two-piece driveshaft, so lengthening drive shafts shouldn’t pose a problem. Ford’s 4.6-liter, 300-horse, 24-valve V8 would be more than adequate. (The new Shelby GT500 powerplant would be a bonus.) All the engine really needs is a little more muffler, a little less intake and a lot more purr. And there’s plenty of room at the new AutoAlliance International assembly plant in Flat Rock, Michigan to build a “real” Cougar.

If Mercury had a Cougar, it might begin to look like the brand has a future, instead of simply surviving on life-support from Ford. It’s not a question of whether or not there’s a market for a “proper” American luxury coupe; there are more than enough foreign players in this niche to prove its potential viability. It’s not a question of money; a new Cougar needn’t start from scratch. It’s a question of will. When a brand loses its luster within the Ford Empire, it lacks champions to snatch back the resources it needs to grow. In car manufacture as in life, everything either grows or dies. Over to you Mr. Bill.

Recent Comments

  • Lou_BC: @Carlson Fan – My ’68 has 2.75:1 rear end. It buries the speedo needle. It came stock with the...
  • theflyersfan: Inside the Chicago Loop and up Lakeshore Drive rivals any great city in the world. The beauty of the...
  • A Scientist: When I was a teenager in the mid 90’s you could have one of these rolling s-boxes for a case of...
  • Mike Beranek: You should expand your knowledge base, clearly it’s insufficient. The race isn’t in...
  • Mike Beranek: ^^THIS^^ Chicago is FOX’s whipping boy because it makes Illinois a progressive bastion in the...

New Car Research

Get a Free Dealer Quote

Who We Are

  • Adam Tonge
  • Bozi Tatarevic
  • Corey Lewis
  • Jo Borras
  • Mark Baruth
  • Ronnie Schreiber