Category: Editorials

By on March 28, 2007

x07ca_ex0042222.jpgIn 2002, GM reinvented Cadillac. The brand’s edgy new “Arts and Science” look reflected a clean break with the sagging fortunes of the former “Standard of the World.” Unlike Ford, which consigned its Lincoln brand to badge-engineered boredom, GM declared its determination to re-establish Cadillac’s lost luster. The world’s largest automaker’s premium brand unleashed a raft of new products, a last-ditch, all-out fight against the relentless erosion of its large luxury car business. A five year report card is overdue. First, a quick recap…

By 2001, sales at GM’s erstwhile money-printing division had plummeted 60 percent from their historic highs. The average buyer’s age was at 65 and dropping (as in dropping dead). Though the Escalade luxury SUV (introduced in 1999) proved to be a highly profitable beast, Cadillac knew it couldn’t stake its future on the fickle whims of badge crazed blingmobilers.

Since The General has been unable to build small cars profitably since, um, ever, the company also knew that the Cadillac brand represented a mission-critical large passenger car profit center. So GM dedicated their new high-end Sigma rear wheel-drive platform exclusively to a line of premium sedans (CTS, STS) and a crossover (SRX). With lots of bragging about Nürburgring chassis fettling, the BMW 3-Series fighter CTS was the first out of the box.

The press gave the CTS rave reviews. After a sluggish start, sales peaked in 2005 at 61k units. Sales in ’06 are off 11 percent. Year-to-date (YTD) ’07 they’re down 27 percent. Anticipation of the redesigned ’08 CTS is keeping some intenders’ powder dry, but it’s clear the model still hasn’t found its happy place.

The mid-size STS peaked in its first full year (never a good sign). In 2005, Caddy dealers moved just 33k units. In 2006, sales dropped 23%. For ‘07, YTD sales are down by 16%. GM is depending on a major STS interior upgrade to save the day, but it’s probably too late.

Sales of Ye Olde front wheel-drive DTS (formerly DeVille) continue their perpetual free-fall. From 2001 through 2006, they’ve sunk some 40 percent. In 2007, YTD sales are off 26 percent. 

The SRX seems to be stuck in the low 20k sales range– despite the fact that crossovers are supposedly the hot vehicle segment in the current US market. The stealth-fighter inspired XLR folding hardtop coupe is literally invisible, with sales below 4k per year. In lockstep with the rest of the family, XLR sales were down 15 percent in 2006, and a whopping 50 percent in 2007 YTD.

After suspension tuning the CTS at the ‘Ring, GM convinced themselves they had enough street cred for a major European sales assault. Two years ago, GM established CCHE (Cadillac Corvette Hummer Europe). The unit’s modest sales goals: 20k units by 2010. The Saab-based, compact, diesel-available BLS was pegged as the volume seller.

The BLS was DOA. With Euro-‘Slades sucking up high test at to the tune of $200+ per tank, racking-up fuel costs that approach $1 per mile, it’s no surprise GM’s adopted a low volume, high mark-up strategy for their rapaciously thirsty gangstamobile. Pitching the $90k, badge-engineered GMT900 Yukon against similarly-priced, highly evolved, deeply admired Bimmers, Mercs, Rovers, Porsches, etc. has been about as successful as you’d expect.

Despite (or because of) the introduction of the Hummer H3 to the Eurozone, the CCHE operation’s projections are downwardly-moving targets. Independent analysts are projecting no more than six to eight thousand sales by 2010. Check back in six months.

Stateside, it’s clear Caddy’s domestic ops have been crippled by a bad case of beancounteritis. The Sigma triplets were handicapped from the git-go by their sub-par interiors. Initial pricing was overly ambitious. And the “Art and Science” design motif failed to seduce young up-and-comers.

And after the one-two-three CTS, STS and SRX splash, the product pipeline has dried up. The foreign competition is running circles around Caddy with a proliferation of variants. The New York Auto Show will offer a glimpse at some long overdue relief: a new 300hp, 3.6-liter V6 for the STS and CTS, a new CTC (a CTS coupe) and CTS-V and a V12-powered Mercedes fighter.

Prototypes of Caddy’s top-of-the-line luxobarge are running on a widened version of GM’s Zeta architecture (a.k.a. Holden Commodore / Pontiac G8). We’ll soon know if the new Caddy has the 16 Concept’s style. We’ll eventually learn if it can withstand the nickel-and-diming that stripped its predecessors of competitive appeal.

Of course, Cadillac is right to develop a higher high end sedan. Every Mercedes C-Class driver thinks (or imagines) that there’s some S-Class in his ride. Without a proper top-line model, denied credible conquesting Euro-fighters, Cadillac has quietly descended into Buick’s old territory: a semi-premium brand, with discount pricing to match.

Cadillac’s new products can’t come soon enough. Literally. If this year’s sales trends continue, 2007 Cadillac sales will be right back where they were in 2001.

By on March 27, 2007

ron22.jpgBy the end of the year, America’s automotive landscape will have changed dramatically. Chrysler Group will have new owners with new ideas (including, perhaps, dissection). Ford may or may not be in Chapter 11. General Motors’ fate is equally unclear. One big gas price spike and it’s all over bar the filing. And then there’s the United Auto Workers (UAW). This is the year the UAW renegotiates its contracts with The Big 2.5. If the union digs in its proverbial heels to maintain the status quo, Detroit’s doom will be delayed, but not prevented. As will their own.

The decisions made this week at Detroit’s Cobo Center will answer that question. The UAW’s quadrennial convention on collective bargaining opens today. About 1500 delegates representing over 800 locals from around the country will convene to discuss a number of issues facing the moribund union. They’ll have two days to establish their stand on issues ranging from contract concessions for healthcare and pensions, to what to do about their dwindling membership. They have two days to decide the future of the American automobile industry.

It won’t be easy. Just as GM is trying to extricate itself from rebate hell, the UAW must try to find a way NOT to give The Big 2.5 large concessions on healthcare, wages and pensions. Although the union’s “historic health care giveback” involved a $2b pay-off, common wisdom says the union is ready, willing and able to help Detroit roll-back their crippling labor costs. We’re going to find out exactly how far the union is willing to go to give aid and comfort to their employers.

That depends entirely on which faction within the UAW is sitting at the table. Although labor unions tout solidarity and the value of a united front, there’s a genuine power struggle going on behind the scenes. 

On one side, some union bosses are happily extolling cooperation; they’d like the press, their members and the rest of the car industry to think the UAW is management’s best friend. Jim Graham, president of UAW Local 1112 stated ‘‘Management is not the enemy. They’re trying to do the same thing we are: save plants. The enemy is the Asian market.’’

Yet Graham also admits the UAW wants to get in bed with “the enemy.” He notes the UAW is trying to organize workers in the transplants’ factories. Oblivious to the fact the workers in the non-union Georgetown Toyota plant made more last year on average than UAW workers did in Detroit, he states ‘‘In order to get a decent wage, people have to be organized.’’

While the UAW’s making nice with management and trying to move into enemy territory, they seem to have forgotten that their past demands got them where they– and their employers– are today. The bountiful benefits they demanded (and received) when times were good are the excess baggage dragging down Detroit, now that times are tough. When the concession demands begin, we’ll see how long this new friendship lasts.

This brings us to the other end of the spectrum:  hardcore factions within the UAW who want nothing less than a return to yesteryear. Soldiers of Solidarity, comprised mostly of Delphi and GM employees, will picket their own union’s meeting this week. They want the union to take a hard-line stance against wage cuts, pension changes and healthcare concessions.

Believe it or not, the Soldiers don’t believe The Big 2.5 are in dire straits. And they continue to see the company through the prism of class war; why should the fat cats be allowed to take food off their table? Strange but true: there are plenty of union members who’d prefer their employer’s death before personal “dishonor.”

So where does UAW President Ron Gettelfinger stand?  On the fence.

"There is a great deal of uncertainty in the auto industry right now, which causes a great deal of concern among our members and their families. We're doing our best to address those concerns – but it doesn't do anybody much good to try to predict the outcome of a bargaining process that hasn't even started yet."

No matter. Gettelfinger knows that it’s make or break time for the UAW, without any clear path to “winning.” If the “modernizers” hold sway and the UAW makes company-saving concessions to save its own skin, the union’s power over its members will diminish. As Sean McAlinden from the Center for Automotive Research said, “What’s at risk here are the core values of the union.” 

On the other hand, as Dave Cole from the Center for Automotive Research stated, "The existing situation is not survivable. The choice is, are you going to do something different or are you going to die with the domestic industry."

Whatever happens in the next two days, either way, Detroit will never be the same again.

By on March 26, 2007

1600x1200222.jpg“A potent, new, 500-hp engine that uses less fuel.” While the newly refurbished Porsche Cayenne Turbo offers well-heeled buyers many delights, you wouldn't think fuel efficiency was the first amongst them. Yet Porsche’s print ads for the off-roader are touting their uber-SUV’s improved frugality, positioning the machine as a fun-to-drive grocery-getter for, gulp, environmentally conscious consumers. If Porsche were alone in this misplaced appeal to green values, it could be dismissed as aberrant lunacy. But they’re not so it can’t.

This month, Honda introduced their new Formula One car. As their F1 entry has no official sponsors, the car’s surface is free from the usual blizzard of sponsors’ decals. So Honda wrapped their hi-tech race car in an image of the Earth made from signatures of people who’ve pledged– via myearthdream.com– to limit their planetary “footprint.”

And so a vehicle that gets four miles to a gallon– for entertainment purposes– has been transformed into a rolling poster for corporate sponsored environmentalism.  

“The people who work in F1 and the F1 viewers are probably the most difficult people to turn around into making a difference,” proclaimed Jenson Button to the London Times. ”So this campaign is important.” Honda’s F1 driver was clear about his “other” mission. “The idea is to raise awareness of global issues that we have and hopefully it’s going to make a difference.”

4758_1280222.jpgHonda’s left its supporters’ difference-making methodology suitably vague. Of course, turned around F1 fans can choose from Honda’s wide range of high[er] mpg vehicles, buy one its hybrid Accords or wait for models powered by the automaker’s clean diesel technology. It’s what marketing mavens call a “virtuous circle” or “a very clever angle.”

Honda’s inherently ludicrous “Save the Planet” F1 car proves that global warming is the new marketing hot button (so to speak). Of course, Honda’s a bit late to this morality play. Toyota’s Prius hybrid set the pace for automobile manufacturers everywhere, giving the Japanese automaker enough green cred to withstand the heat generated by its efforts to build The Mother of All Full-Size ‘Merican Pickup Trucks.

Although the high-mpg low-carbon Prius has not exactly set the sales charts on fire, the distinctively shaped vehicle success vis-à-vis its standard bodied hybrid competition (e.g. the hybrid Accord) has taught the automotive industry an important lesson: it’s not enough to do good for the planet. You have to be seen to be doing good.

112876907c250_02222.jpgThat’s why nearly every major automaker at this year’s 77th International Auto Show paid homage to the environment. Honda, Lexus and Toyota brought hybrid concept cars to the Land of Milk and Chocolate. Mercedes flaunted a new C220 sedan equipped with the latest clean-running BLUETEC diesel. Ze new C will produce nine tons less CO2 over its lifetime – from assembly line to junkyard – than the old version! Even supercar maker Koenigsegg presented an E85 powered version of their bonkers CCXR.

And no wonder. Throughout Europe, global warming has replaced the Soviet Empire as the invisible– though real– enemy. It’s got to the point where the European Union has “asked” Germany to consider putting speed limits on formerly sacrosanct derestricted sections of the autobahn. A Stern magazine survey claims 60 percent of Germans now favor autobahn speed limits to cut emissions, while 38 percent oppose them.

America’s response to global warming lags well behind that of our European allies. While there’s been a lot of talk (and an Oscar-winning movie) about reducing greenhouse gas emissions, policy changes have been illusory. Despite tax credits, hybrid sales are still paltry compared to CO2 belching full-sized pickups.

While environmentalists decry federal “foot dragging,” the free market is not insensitive to the issue. As petrol powered pistonheads have pointed out, even with gas at $3 a gallon, it’s hard to justify the “hybrid premium”: the difference in purchase price between a gas and gas – electric car based on fuel savings.

07_priustouringedition_0222.jpgAnd yet more and more US car buyers are willing to pay a bit extra for a bit more mileage. Why? Representative Michael Burgess of Texas put it best, when discussing his personal Prius. “It gives me a good deal of moral superiority when I drive.”

This fact has not escaped the fine folks down in marketing and product planning. GM, Ford, Porsche, Mercedes, BMW, Honda and others are realizing a large proportion of their target market– both princes and paupers– are starting to watch their tailpipes. Low carbon and high mileage cars, trucks and yes, SUV’s are continuing to creep to the top of the average buyer’s wish list.

As the Cayenne Turbo ads prove, this development has created endless opportunities for deceptive and self-righteous hypocrisy. But that’s not necessarily a bad thing. If green becomes the automotive industry’s new black, the resulting pretense can be seen as a case of no harm, no foul.

By on March 25, 2007

dr-z.jpg[Cue organ music] Welcome to this week’s installment of “That’s the Way the Daimler Benz!” When we last we left our hapless heroine, little Chrissie Chrysler, the not-so-sprightly maiden was tied to the railroad tracks. The fiendish Dr Z stood nearby, twirling his mustache, laughing maniacally as he mentally explored the options for disposing of Chrissie’s family farm. Will this be the end of our plucky paladin? Or will a courageous cowboy arrive to save Chrissie in the nick of time? Join us as we anxiously await little Chrissie’s final fate. [Fade organ music]

The latest episode of the Chrysler “restructuring” melodrama brings us news that Canada’s Magna Corporation and “a private equity partner” have made a $4.6b offer to buy Chrysler from DaimlerChrysler. Magna’s equity partner remains under wraps, but every indication (i.e. common sense) points to The Blackstone Group LP.

On Thursday, this enormous private equity firm announced an IPO aimed at raising up to $4b. Blackstone is one of three major equity firms (including Cerberus Capital Management and Centerbridge Partners) that’s expressed interest in buying the Chrysler Group from its German owners.

The “who” of this first offer may remain [slightly] mysterious, but the timing of the play wasn’t. Earlier this week Chrysler General Manager Tom LaSorda told a gathering of Chrysler dealers that an announcement about his employer’s future would be made “soon.” At the same time, Tommy Boy sent an email to every Chrysler employee urging them to “focus on the urgent job at hand–to develop, build and sell great products and establish the foundation for a long and prosperous future.”

Industry analysts and traders knew something was afoot.  DCX stock had risen as much as six percent on speculation that a deal is pending. As Howard Wheeldon, the automaker specialist at BCG Partners in London stated, "I would suggest there is some form of approach that has been made for Chrysler that is springing the shares to life." Well duh.

Ah, but will DaimlerChrysler go through with a sale? Some analysts have suggested the DCX is dangling Chrysler like so much bait to drive their stock up and bully the United Auto Workers into some major concessions. Others just want them to hurry up and get on with it.

Argus Research Corp. auto analyst Kevin Tynan states "I don't think Daimler-Benz is looking to dump Chrysler on the first company that waves a buck at them. But I think it would be in their best interest to let it go." 

According to Citigroup analyst Jon Rogers, a private equity company is the most logical buyer. But Rogers isn’t ready to rule out General Motors. Like former GM board member Jerry York, Rogers thinks the UAW is the linchpin. The union would be more open to offering concessions to GM than a financial buyer flush with cash. 

Even though GM has publicly stated they’re not interested in owning Chrysler, Rogers reports GM could easily borrow up to $18b toward restructuring Chrysler. A zero equity transfer to GM would create $9 billion in value– and the mother of all Detroit Death Watches.

Whoever ends up with Chrysler faces not one but two 900 pound gorillas in the proverbial room: the UAW and legacy costs. Back to former Chrysler CFO and ex-GM’er Jerry York: “I wouldn't even think about [buying Chrysler] unless I could form a true partnering relationship with the UAW.” 

Partner schmartner. UAW President Ron Gettelfinger has stated his union’s first priority in all of this Chrysler kerfuffle: stopping any sale. Although Big Ron says priorities two and three are encouraging a sale to an existing automaker or an equity firm, Chrysler’s new owner or owners will have to deal with the aftermath of what the unions would view as a hostile takeover.

Without concessions, the new boss’ revitalization plans would be stymied by Chrysler’s staggering pensions and healthcare costs. Goldman Sachs estimates that Chrysler’s next gen masters would inherit $16.5b in pension and healthcare liabilities. 

In fact, DCX may not be looking to benefit from the sale of Chrysler– other than divesting themselves of these obligations. University of Maryland business professor Peter Morici can’t see anyone paying much for Chrysler.  "The reality is that unless there are structural changes in the labor agreement, Chrysler Corp. is worth less than zero."

[Cue organ music] What does all this mean for our luckless lass, little Chrissie Chrysler? Sadly, she remains lashed to the railroad tracks, contemplating her fate. It seems that the rescuing cowboys are busy drawing straws, trying to decide who should have the honor of rescuing her from the evil Dr. Z., or whether if it’s even worth the effort. Join us again next week and watch one of her well-heeled saviors swing into action– or not! [Swell organ music then fade]

By on March 25, 2007

kimi.jpgAfter months of testing, teasing, politics and drama, Formula One’s 2007 season has finally sailed past the green flag. If last weekend’s thunder down under is any indication, the 2007 season may (or may not) provide a radical change from the increasing (not to say relentless) routine of F1 seasons past. There are new drivers driving new cars for new teams, and “old” drivers driving new cars for new teams. And thanks to rule changes, F1 racing technology has also altered in several important ways. Here’s the inside dope:

Although new FIA legislation has led to some major technological differences from seasons past, few of these are obvious to the naked eye. First and foremost, the much-decried “engine freeze” is now a fait accompli. All F1 powerplants are hereby rev-limited to 19,000 rpm. No further mechanical development is allowed. Other than attendant tuning tweaks, the 2007 engines must be identical to the units raced at the last two GP’s of 2006.

Rumor has it that the teams’ engines are, power-wise, more similar than ever before (as was the governing body’s intention). Some experts suggest that only 10hp separates the most and least powerful engines on the grid. This, of course, places ever-more emphasis on aerodynamic performance, which continues to evolve at a rapid pace.  

As for overall vehicle design, according to the Concorde Agreement (F1’s governing document), teams own the intellectual property rights to their car’s chassis. In other words, “customer” cars are disallowed. Skirting the new rules, the Toro Rosso and Super Aguri teams have chosen to field cars which are close derivatives of their A-teams’ designs.

The competitiveness shown by Super Aguri’s SA07 entry in Oz promises an acrimonious debate, scheduled for the arbitration docket once the European season begins.

On the tire front, ‘07 showcases the winner of the long-running tire war: Bridgestone. While many consider Michelin’s departure as a hit to the sport’s competitive nature, the FIA can now regulate vehicle performance by stipulating the level of grip provided by the tires. The change is bound to lower cornering speeds and increase emphasis on driver ability.

The regulations concerning tire use have also changed. Bridgestone will produce four dry compounds to be used throughout the season. At any given race, F1 teams will have two tire compound options (both chosen by Bridgestone). Teams will also be required to use both specifications of dry tire during the race, unless a wet tire is used. 

In order to increase greater fan involvement, the FIA has asked Bridgestone to produce tires that are “visually distinctive” from one another.  The softer of the two available compounds, the so-called “option” tire, is clearly marked as such.

This year’s F1 grid also sees a plethora of personnel changes. The headline: two-time and defending world champion Fernando Alonso has abandoned his reliable blue and yellow Renault for an unreliable silver arrows-throwback McLaren, displacing Big Mac driver Kimi Raikkonen. Raikkonen, widely considered the fastest man on the grid, has taken his title challenge to Ferrari. 

The Scuderia Ferrari team has transformed itself in the off-season. Ross Brawn (technical director), Nigel Stepney (race engineer) and Michael Schumacher (expert in questionable and effective race tactics) have all left for greener pastures. Only a handful of Ferrari’s race-tested, battle-hardened upper-level team members remain.

And so to Oz, where, despite all the alterations, it was business as usual for Ferrari.

Starting from the pole position, Kimi Raikkonen’s Fezza dismissed all comers with the same sort of clinical precision the team’s former German driver displayed for the last ten years or so. Raikkonen led every lap save the few following his pit stops. It was solid confirmation of the team’s series-leading off-season pace, offering the terrible prospect (at least for non-Ferrari fans) of yet another season of potential domination by the Italians.

Anyway, in traditional Finnish fashion, Raikkonen competed in two races in the last two weeks. Before the F1 circus, Raikkonen entered and won a 24k snowmobile race. Kimi raced under the oh-so-telling nom-de-guerre James Hunt, the bon vivant whose epic off-track shenanigans make Kimi’s legendary exploits look positively tame.

This is not to say Raikkonen is Schumacher. The Finn is a highly volatile guy; it remains to be seen if his hard-partying lifestyle (read: drinking bottles of vodka and exposing himself to strippers) will prove detrimental to his title hopes.

Finally, the calendar has undergone some tweaks. Spa-Francorchamps returns after a one-year hiatus for track and pit facility upgrades. The San Marino GP at Imola has been dropped and is unlikely to return.

All these changes were designed to reinvigorate the sport after Schumacher’s departure, and set the stage for a new crop of F1 superstars. If you look at the struggle beneath Raikkonen, the Australian GP indicates that it sounds crazy, but it just might work. 

By on March 24, 2007

100_0050222.jpgThe Truth About Cars (TTAC) has consistently criticized domestic automakers for some pretty basic mistakes: lack of focus, glacial product cycles, bland design and poor customer communications. I would be a hypocrite if I didn’t admit that this website suffers from these problems. But it is my full intention to address ALL of these challenges, so that we can keep faith with our basic brand promise. So, here’s where we’ve screwed-up and here’s what we’re going to do about it. Provided, that is, you agree.

I realize that the remains a major disconnect between TTAC’s new “parked url” look (ouch!) and our previous Zen rock garden gestalt. Not to mention the functionality issues plaguing the comment’s box and other areas. When I asked for your feedback on the new site design, you bloody well gave it. I immediately saw the error of my ways and promised to sort it all out.

After securing new funding, I’ve purchased www.ttac.com (active now) and re-hired the people who designed the original website. Starting next week, Redwing Studio will begin returning TTAC to its minimalist look and feel, and restoring lost functionality.

We’re not talking about a retro mod. We’re moving forward, in a new direction. And it’s important that you understand where we’re headed.

Since its inception, TTAC has provided readers with 800-word reviews and editorials. The mix has attracted a passionate, literate and engaged audience– as you’d expect for a no-holds-barred automotive website whose writing style requires high school or better reading comprehension.

While I’m proud of our literary output and fierce editorial independence, commercial reality demands that we must shift our focus to a more populist perspective. In other words, TTAC is set to become a car shopping site. Well, not entirely.

Here’s the idea.

TTAC will have two home pages. The first will be the “public” page (i.e. the one newbies land on). Home page one will have a proper review, author and keyword search function. It will also display ten review excerpts and the usual link to the full review (“more”). The blurbettes will include star ratings, and links to model specifications, pricing, comparisons and a car brokerage service. The column currently occupied by editorials will [eventually] be filled with ads and shopping-related links.

In short, TTAC’s new home page will offer a one-stop shop for consumers looking to research, compare and buy a car, using truly independent advice. Think of it as Consumer Reports with attitude. What’s more, we will stay in touch with “our” shoppers to assure a proper quality service and cater to their ongoing needs.

There will also be a second home page for you, our faithful, hardcore audience. “TTAC classic” will return to the “old” format of reviews and editorials stacked in strict chronological order.

Rest assured, the content itself will not change. The editorials will continue apace. They’ll be just as feisty and high-brow as ever. But the split will allow us to create a [let’s face it] less intellectual and more highly focused revenue-generating TTAC for a large number of car shoppers. Given our financial situation, this consumer service is critical to our continued editorial independence.

Needless to say, this new focus will take TTAC into uncharted waters. But my father taught me that business isn’t risky. People are risky. Well, some are and some aren’t.

The writers, editors, financiers, programmers and readers of this website are the most steadfast people I’ve ever met. To a man (and woman), they believe that telling the truth about cars is an inherently virtuous pursuit. They know that their work elevates the souls of those it touches– even if the truth hurts. They understand that those who have a vested interest in falsehood, half-truths and misdirection actively oppose our efforts. 

I believe in the people who make TTAC possible. And I believe that there’s nothing wrong with taking our mission into the mainstream. As long as we tell the truth to the only people who really matter– the people who buy, use and (hopefully) love cars– we will be rewarded with their trust and patronage. 

Now it’s your turn. Tell us where TTAC’s gone wrong– and may be about to go wrong. Tell us where TTAC’s gone right– and how we can capitalize on our strengths. Should we start reviewing used cars? Do we need better car photographs? Should we drop editorials entirely? Is there a killer ap we could bring to car shopping? Feel free to comment on any aspect of the site’s past, present or future.

After all, you are TTAC’s “300:” the automotive alphas whose ongoing support defend and protect us from those who would ignore us, co-opt us, or happily watch us disappear into the ether. Once again, we need your help.

By on March 24, 2007

imperialclubcom.jpgIn 1965, my family moved to Baltimore. From my seventh-grade perspective, it sucked. Iowa City was friendly, open-minded, cosmopolitan and relaxed. Towson was cold, prejudiced, provincial and uptight. I soon learned to loathe everything about Maryland– except crab cakes, soul music and the eastern shore. I became a rebel with a cause: driving. Read More >

By on March 23, 2007

ccsppg87822.jpgHow many of us sketched cars in the margins of our grade school notebooks? For a small minority, that’s the beginning of their life’s work. Those with the gift go on to enroll in design colleges to pursue a career in Transportation Design. Once there, the budding designers’ personal expressions are run through the meat grinder of de-constructive criticism. While the process is daunting, it is nothing compared to the “real world” of car design.

It doesn’t take a Human Resources Manager to recognize the automotive design studio’s crushing stoicism. Those with strong managerial allegiances get the credit they deserve. Others find their artistic expressions on the losing end of the cult of personality. In other words, being a good car designer doesn’t automatically make you a successful car designer. In the cloistered, hyper-competitive world of the automotive studio, networking, company politics and shameless self-promotion trump creativity.

So it’s much like your job, except worse. Imagine those no-nothing know-it-alls, pushy self-promoters and cronies clawing for recognition from the chief megalomaniac. Now imagine that your work, erupting from the very core of your soul, must be defended and nurtured in this environment. A cakewalk it ain’t.

Somehow, into this climate a car is born. To get the job done, the designer may create after the well-paid, well-dressed negative energy checks out for the night. Fraternizing with the clay modelers also helps: down to earth folks who translate a studio junkie’s 2-D rendering into a universally recognizable, high impact masterpiece.

Jeff Sanders lived this life. He was a master of Automotive Americana; someone who invented new forms without resorting to retro styling or cliché proportioning. He designed the custom trimmings on the first-gen Harley Davidson F150, a set of chrome wheels and a few gorgeous interior bits for the 2007 Lincoln Navigator. (Upcoming Ford products may flaunt the Sanders’ design language.)

The native Texan was a soft spoken, sensitive soul who somehow kept his head above the toxic soup filling Ford’s design studios. He kept the faith for two main reasons: his love of design and the dream of working for Ford, his favorite car company. His ‘67 Mustang project car provides ample proof of the artist’s emotional connection with The Blue Oval’s past, present and future.

Jeff weathered the design studio for five years in hopes of reaping the fruits of employment in a leaner, meaner FoMoCo. But things went sour after a particularly demeaning reassignment: his talent and creativity were neglected and ostracized for the last time. After turning down Ford’s white collar buyout plan, Jeff Sanders quit his “dream job” with his “dream company.”

Everyone thought Jeff’s analytical skills, gearhead personality and artistic talent made him a no-brainer for management-level success. But a phone call from the Michigan State Patrol shattered those beliefs. On March 8, Jeff Sanders drove his Ford truck to a secluded country road and committed suicide. None of his friends saw it coming, though we all wish we had.

Jeff and I were design students back in 1998. Aside from the Texas connection, his affectation for American Iron, effortless technique and acute BS detector made him my go-to guy. Jeff brought clarity to my muddy renderings and tightened up my sophomoric designs. I remember the good times; jumping in his truck in search of something, anything to take our minds off of next week’s verbal bloodbath.

I moved to greener pastures. Jeff joined Ford. He told me that somewhere between “Quality is Job 1” and “Bold Moves,” FoMoCo’s corporate design department had turned “teamwork” into a dirty word. I learned the personal struggles and political consequences of design rework. As Jeff put it:

“You want to know why cars look like shit? The designers are usually the last to touch the product.”

Jeff’s visits back to The Lone Star State were filled with laments about the cutthroat, ass-kissing environment and inflated rock-star personalities inside Ford’s design studios. I admired him for never playing that game, letting his brilliance shine on vellum instead.

Unlike most of our friends, I know why Jeff began his downward spiral: Ford’s design studio destroyed his soul. He lost the one thing that sustained him, that gave him a reason to live: his art.

Anyone in the car business knows that passionate designers suffer in the soul-crushing environment of the automotive design studio. While this website mercilessly punishes Detroit for not putting the product first, we got it wrong. People come first. No exceptions, ever.

People are the fertile soil that provides a bountiful harvest of products, innovations and profits. Losing a soaring spirit—especially one who single-handedly designed cars that might have restored Detroit’s fortunes– is a tragedy for all car enthusiasts. When a company stifles personal creativity, one way or another, something important is lost. Forever.

By on March 22, 2007

oldbeetle_hr222.jpgGermany’s IGM is the world’s largest labor union. What’s more, German law dictates that half of any German corporation’s supervisory board (minus one) must be “reserved” for its members. In Volkswagen’s case, even elected board members are subject to union influence; the politically malleable state government of Lower Saxony controls VW’s elected seats. As previously described, union control over “The People’s Car” has inflicted grievous harm on VW’s brand positioning. Yet in the last year, there have been signs of change.

Traditionally, Social Democrats have controlled the government of lower Saxony. In 2003, for the first time in thirteen years, the electorate voted the conservative-minded Christian Democrats into power. While not insensible to traditional politics, the new players are not quite as close to (i.e. owned by) the unions.

As an indirect result of the election, Volkswagen managed to convince the IGM to extend their working week from 28 to 33 hours– without compensation. While it’s still a ridiculous state of affairs, the concession would have been unlikely under a Social Democrat government. And it represents an important paradigm shift in VW’s labor relations.

The second change arrived courtesy the European Union (EU), who’re moving to throw out the so-called “Volkswagen Law” unconstitutional.

The Volkswagen Law was introduced in 1960, when the government of Lower Saxony raised cash by “semi-privatizing” VW (i.e. selling part of the company to investors without losing control of the supervisory board). The legislation stipulated that no VW shareholder could exercise more than 20 percent of voting rights, regardless of the size of their stake in VW. The set-up guaranteed the government's absolute power over VW— removing the incentive for a large institutional investor to buy a large block of VW’s stock.

When it became clear that the EU would entertain a challenge to the Volkswagen Law, Porsche AG saw a chance to finally gain control of the automaker spawned by its own founder and/or assure a supply of parts and technology. By the end of this year, when the law is officially overturned, Porsche will own at least 29.9% of Volkswagen: a controlling stake.

Of course, unlike any government (even if it isn’t Social Democrat), Porsche’s main objective is to make money. This Porsche knows how to do. As the world’s most profitable automobile manufacturer, as a long standing VW partner (e.g. the Touareg and Cayenne SUV's are platform partners), Porsche knows where to cut waste and inefficiency and how to maximize margins.

Things have already started moving at VW. Volkswagen is replacing its most important vehicle as early as 2008. The company has vowed to remove the production problems that make the Golf too expensive. It will have a less complex suspension, easier to manufacture doors and simplified electronics. VW is also likely to increase its reliance on more cost-effective outsourcing. Porsche currently produces about 20 percent of its own parts; Volkswagen still makes most of its own parts.

There will also be more economical cars. VW’s high-mileage diesels will soon share DaimlerChrysler’s BLUETEC filtering system, making them available to diesel-starved, California-compliant US states. VW recently unveiled their Polo Blue Motion, which is supposed to achieve a combined 60mpg. The emphasis indicates that VW understands the need to return to producing thrifty, reliable cars for the masses.

But even with Porsche’s help and without Detroit’s enormous legacy costs (thank you socialism), VW’s union contracts make building inexpensive German cars cheaply an uphill battle. Despite VW’s dubious track record for building “German quality” products abroad— the disastrous American Rabbit (Golf) factory and the hecho-en-Mexico Mark 3 Jetta spring to mind— the company understands the unavoidable need to build products well outside the Eurozone.

VW is certainly finding its feet in China. Working with its mandatory Chinese “partners,” Volkswagen is The People’s Republic most successful passenger car manufacturer. The company built and sold over 700k Chinese vehicles last year. Providing Germany’s unions can be appeased, it’s only a matter of time before Chinese-made VW’s start flooding into European and American markets.

If Chinese cars can embody “traditional” VW quality, if the Chinese government doesn’t suddenly nationalize their automobile industry, the German marque has a fighting chance to recapture its value-based brand promise.

It’s important to remember that VW’s brand portfolio got the company into this mess. While Bentley, Lamborghini, Bugatti and now Porsche occupy the high ground, Audi’s full-line ambitions still create embarrassing overlaps with its upmarket siblings AND the “core” brand. Model redundancies between Audi, VW and SEAT have left the Spanish brand in dire straits. At the bottom of the market, Škoda is extremely healthy, China continues apace and Malaysia’s Proton is set to join the family.

Clearly, Volkswagen, makers of the “people’s car,” still can’t quite bring itself to move the brand downmarket, back to its roots. It remains to be seen whether VW’s mid-market ambitions will ever be fully realized.

By on March 22, 2007

nazi_propaganda_kdf.jpgMy first car was a 1989 Passat station wagon. The Passat fully embodied the literal translation of the company’s name: the people’s car. It was reasonably priced, cheap to maintain and mechanically robust. The interior was roomy and practical. Compare it to today’s expensive, unreliable and over-plush Passat and you’ll know why the German automaker is in trouble. Volkswagen has lost their natural place in the market, a spot originally staked-out by Adolph Hitler.

In January 1933, twelve days after Hitler became German Chancellor, Austria’s native son announced that the German people would get a car that could travel at 60mph, fit four people and cost less than 1000 Reichsmarks. The next year, Ferdinand Porsche designed a prototype.

Production of the KdF-Wagen (KdF for “Kraft durch Freude” or “Strength through Joy”) began in 1939, the same year Germany invaded Poland. Germany’s pressing and ongoing need for military vehicles brought manufacture of the “people’s car” to an abrupt halt.

After the war, occupying British forces initially moved to sell the Wolfsburg factory. (Ford and Humber were amongst the potential buyers.) Then the Brits decided to restart production of the Beetle (as the KdF-Wagen had been rechristened). When the key players bailed, the government of the federal state of Lower Saxony stepped in.

The Beetle turned out to be the most successful car design in human history, with over 21 million examples sold. VW began exporting the Beetle around the globe, from Thailand to Sri Lanka to Nigeria to the United States of America. By 1970, the car Henry Ford II called "a little shitbox" racked-up enough sales (569,696) to become America’s top selling foreign car.

Even at the height of its success, Volkswagen was in trouble. It had put most of its eggs in a Beetle shaped basket, which was rapidly losing ground to Japanese and American-financed competition. Facing floundering finances, Volkswagen flirted with a Daimler-Benz merger. Instead, in 1964, VW bought Auto Union (later renamed Audi) from Daimler-Benz, and saved itself from ruin.

Auto Union possessed mission critical state-of-the-art technology for new models, including front wheel-drive and water-cooled engines. Initially, VW found a measure of success by lightly re-engineering Audi vehicles. In 1974, the company broke the mold with the Golf, a stunning worldwide success. Despite the innovation, the company continued to see inter-brand platform and parts sharing as the key to corporate success.

VW Chairman Carl Hahn put the theory to the test. In the late 80’s, Volkswagen bought controlling interest in Spain’s SEAT and Eastern Europe’s Skoda brands, and began slipping Volkswagen Audi Group platforms underneath new sheetmetal. Unfortunately, at the same time, VW became a victim of sister Audi’s success. As Ingolstadt’s finest took on BMW and Mercedes, VW moved into Audi’s traditional middle market, leaving lower cost SEAT and Skoda to fight it out at the budget end of the business.

Although it’s easy to see how German labor unions’ stranglehold on Wolfsburg left VW management little choice, mid-market was the worst possible place to position “the people’s car.” VW faced threats from Asian economy brands reaching upwards and German luxury brands (including Audi) reaching downwards– not to mention American and other brands fighting for its [new] target demographic.

At the same time, over-expansion and bad management were destroying the brand’s core value: bulletproof build quality. As VW's market share evaporated, rigid labor agreements forced the company’s German operations to crank out cars that couldn’t generate life sustaining margins. In a desperate move to cut the glut, Volkswagen agreed to a 28-hour work week– without significant wage reductions.

All these decisions culminated in a single vehicle: The Golf Mk V. Although it’s a fine automobile, the Golf’s latest incarnation is simply too expensive– both in terms of labor costs and manufacturing complexity– to rescue the brand’s declining fortunes. Volkswagen sells plenty of the new, German-made Golfs, but it doesn’t make a single Euro on any of them.

On the positive side, VW’s management has finally realized that it can’t change its image OR charge more money than the competition (which includes Audi). Which still leaves Volkswagen tied-up in a Gordian knot.

If Volkswagen wants to resurrect its reputation for engineering excellence and driving satisfaction– at a price point below Audi– it must do so outside of Germany (i.e. The People’s Republic of China) or find a way to dramatically reduce its labor costs inside Germany. The unions’ political power makes both options largely untenable.

The company’s only hope: Porsche’s move to overthrow the local government’s lock on majority ownership of VW. But even if the unions’ stranglehold can be broken, it still looks like the future of the brand started by a fascist dictator lies outside Europe, in a country run by a military dictatorship.

By on March 19, 2007

astonmartin_det06222.jpgLast Monday, an English racing mogul, a car-collecting Texas tycoon and a gaggle of Kuwaitis bought Aston Martin. While Ford’s retained a stake in the luxury automaker, The Blue Oval Boyz no longer have a say in Aston’s future. The press spun the deal as a sad but inevitable move: a sign of FoMoCo’s willingness to face financial facts. Well, here’s a bit of Inside Automaking: Ford didn’t put Aston Martin up for sale. Aston Martin jumped ship. 

From its inception in 1913 through 1987, Aston Martin was a poster child for bespoke luxury automaking– and “hobby trading.” Before Ford bought 75% of Newport Pagnell’s finest, Aston Martin had lost its numerous owners numerous millions. Under Ford’s management, Aston Martin achieved something akin to a miracle: profit.

Last year, Aston made an indeterminate amount of money (Ford has always refused to separate Aston’s finances from those of the Premium Automotive Group). Aston reprised its role as James Bond’s steed of choice (both old and new) in Casino Royale. And the company unveiled the Rapide, a four-door luxury sports sedan with a built-in chess set and champagne cooler.

This year, The Times estimates that Aston Martin will earn $74m on worldwide sales of some seven thousand cars. While that’s a cause for celebration for Aston fans, the production run represents roughly 0.1 percent of Ford’s 6.5 million annual vehicle sales. Even if Aston Martin beat their best estimates by 50 percent, it wouldn’t do squat for Ford's finances.

In 2006, Ford’s Premier Automotive Group (PAG)– Aston Martin, Jaguar, Land Rover and Volvo– dropped $327m. PAG sales were off just one percent, but their bottom line was beaten down by unfavorable exchange rates and warranty accrual adjustments at Jaguar and Land Rover. So Ford cancelled the Aston Martin Rapide.

This decision did not sit well with Aston’s management. Although John Walton, General Manager of Aston Martin North America, emphatically and repeatedly asserted that Aston was not for sale, someone forgot to tell its managers. Led by engineer, speed demon and Aston CEO Ulrich Bez, the execs made a bold move of their own: they started looking for new owners.

Discretion being the better part of valor, Aston Martin began quietly reaching out to potential suitors; by invitation, as it were. They found a willing conspirator in David Richards. The founding chairman and chief executive of ProDrive, a motorsport and automotive technology company, was already plenty cozy with Auntie Aston. Since 2004, ProDrive has been running Aston Martin’s FIA GT racing team. The UK company also prepares the GT1 DBR9 and the GT3 DBRS9 race cars for well-heeled privateers.

Richards liked the idea of owning Aston, but, sensibly enough, preferred to use OPM financing (Other People’s Money). Enter Houston energy investment banker, car collector and race team backer, John Sinders. Oh, and two Kuwaiti investment companies: Investment Dar and Adeem Investment Company. Despite the backroom maneuvers, or perhaps because of them, ProDrive’s proactive $848m offer found fertile soil in Dearborn. 

Apparently, not everyone was in the loop on this one. At a recent press conference, AM’s US GM described Aston’s separation from Ford as “bittersweet.”  Looking dapper in a navy blue pinstriped suit and perfectly enunciating the Queen’s English, Walton said that his longtime friend, Bill Ford, called him post-sale to ask, “Are you celebrating?” “Are you?” Walton said he replied.  “No,” said Ford.  “Nor are we,” Walton responded.

While Walton may be royally pissed that he was kept in the dark, he’s being something of a drama queen. The Aston sale resurrects the Rapide, a model crucial for Aston’s expansion. Also, as Top Gear’s recent Aston vs. Jaguar article demonstrated, Aston Martin needs to develop its models’ gearbox, handing, ride and engines. As EVO magazine’s review of a ProDrive modded Vantage demonstrates, the company has both the spirit and the technology for the job.    

The deal also assures access to Ford’s international resources. Remember: Aston relies on Ford for everything from its V12 to its Volvo air vents to its switchgear. With Ford’s $77m stake in the biz, the “new” Aston Martin can continue to dip into The Blue Oval’s parts bin and gain access to mission critical research, manufacturing, safety and legislative expertise. 

All of which means Billy Ford’s tears were of the crocodile variety. Although billed as an exit strategy, the Aston “sale” isn’t so much a matter of cutting deadwood as a tacit admission that the domestic automaker simply can’t afford to fund its former British subsidiary’s ambitions.

Bottom line: the corporate mothership is no better or worse off for jettisoning Aston Martin. But Aston Martin will be far better off with someone else taking the majority of the risk, and reaping the lion's share of the rewards.

[Side note: You can now also find The Truth About Cars at www.ttac.com]

By on March 18, 2007

33522.jpgThis wasn’t the first time I’d opted for European delivery. In fact, after counting all the license plates I’d collected from these international adventures, I discovered I was on my eighth visit. Normally, when my wife learns I want to go to Stuttgart or Munich, she digs in her proverbial heels. So I had to package my automotive connection with a week in Paris. I made the arrangements to pick up a BMW 335 at the Munich factory. Here’s how the deal went down…

My local BMW dealer booked my order, and then faxed my specifications and delivery date to the Fatherland. After factory approval, I filled out some simple forms, made a copy of my passport and faxed ze paypaz to Germany. In exchange, I received a five percent discount off the U.S. list price (the dealer is free to discount further). Done.

European rental cars are dull and expensive; figure that’s another $2k saved. Oh, and you also get to ignore the break in period and drive as fast as you dare on unrestricted segments of the Autobahn. As the MasterCard voice-over guy says, priceless.

As this was my fourth visit to BMW’s Munich HQ in two years, the staff treated us like old friends (i.e. they treated us with a certain awkward formality that would have instantly disappeared whilst imbibing local beer in a neighborhood rathskeller). After signing the inevitable insurance form (the European delivery package includes two weeks of “free” insurance), my hosts demonstrated a raft of electronic features I’ll never use, handed a picnic lunch and wished a safe journey. 

Our first destination: the Rhine River, about 300 miles distant. As we were motoring during harvest time, I wanted to stop en route to let my wife could experience Federweisser. That’s the German wine made from the first press of the grapes (like Beaujolais but nowhere near as frivolously named), traditionally served with a kind of onion quiche.

We stopped at the first decent looking town along the Neckar river: Bad Wimpfen. Meine Deutsch was good enough to accomplish the task at hand. Our appetites sated, we spooled-up the twin turbos and headed to Stromberg for Johann Lafer’s reknowned kitchen.

Cruising at 110mph on the Autobahn, you soon realize why German car makers couldn’t give a rat’s ass about cup holders. Who’s got time for coffee when the slightest mistake would take a half mile to conclude.

We arrived just before dark, just in time to unclench my hands from the wheel and freshen up for dinner. Our room was in an old castle tower, three stories tall, on the hotel’s third floor. For those of you keeping track, the bedroom was five floors from the restaurant. Excessive consumption of wine was… problematic. Fortunately, I was served the finest steak I’ve ever eaten (from Austria, no less) and, um, rabbit.

The next day we crossed into Luxembourg. I was only able to average 24 mpg in Germany. Restricted to a maximum of 80mph, I achieved closer to 30 mpg. Good thing too, since fuel cost upwards of seven bucks a gallon.

I wanted to go to Luxembourg, if only because I don’t know anyone who’s been there. We enjoyed a world class museum designed by I.M. Pei (not I. R. Baboon) and flaming garlic shrimp (Portuguese style) from Chez Bacano. Our third day included a jaunt across Eastern France, with pit-stops at Nancy and Metz, before settling in for the night outside of Reims.

I enjoyed the three finest glasses of wine of the entire trip: a 1999 Deutz Blanc de Blancs Champagne, a 2003 Puligny Montrachet and a 1999 Phelan Segur Bordeaux. My wife, who does not drink, savored every last drop of the Bordeaux. Of course, three or more ducks relinquished their livers for our gluttonous gustatory satisfaction.

The next morning we drove to the Charles De Gaulle airport to drop off the 335 at the shipper: TT Car Transit (easily located by Terminal 3). Unfortunately, the gentleman who normally handles my paperwork was delayed in traffic. As I had a plane to catch, his assistant located the Main Man via cell. He talked all three of us through the procedure.

Six signatures later, I removed the front license plate as a memento of the experience, handed over one of the car keys and let the nice lads at TT whisk us off to my departure terminal. Six weeks later, I picked up my ride, safe and sound, at my local dealer.

If you’re leasing your new Bimmer, you get one free month; so you pay for the car without possessing it for a couple of weeks. If you pay cash, payment in full is required 30 days prior to pick up. The warranty expires in four years, but the memories last forever.

By on March 17, 2007

h04_1792222.jpgAfter five years living in the quiet, sheltered and nurturing environment of Iowa City, Iowa, my family moved to Baltimore, Maryland. I was twelve– that pinnacle year of childhood. I was blissfully ignorant of the long dark tunnel of adolescence just ahead. And in those very last days of innocence in the heartland, I was graced with a peak automotive experience. Read More >

By on March 15, 2007

gmtenheigl02222.jpgIs it any wonder GM announced another deadbeat deal and cash incentives the day after they reported their long-delayed fourth quarter and year end financial results? Whatever else you can say about GM, you can’t fault their news management skills. If the automaker had revealed the package before the accounts were released, the discounting would have [rightly] be seen as a sign of desperation. Coming hard on the heels of a fourth quarter profit and a reduced year-on-year financial loss, the sale seems part of a successful turnaround strategy. Only it isn’t.

March madness: zero percent financing for up to 36 months and reduced-rate financing for up to 72 months, plus $1k in “customer cash.” The “Spring Sales Event” (for Chevrolet and Saturn) and “Upgrade Event” (for Buick, Pontiac and GMC) excludes Hummer, Caddy and Saab. More importantly, it includes all GM’s GMT900 SUV’s and pickups. In other words, the marketplace has ruled that GM’s Hail Mary pass is unintentional grounding.

On the macro level, the financial experts are beginning to lose faith in GM’s game plan. "For the first time in a long time, I am questioning their strategy," BNP Paribas analyst Brad Rubin told The Detroit Free Press. "The results aren't that great considering everything. It still isn't enough."

True dat. GM has cut its costs to the bone. They’ve sliced an astonishing $6.8b from their expenses. They’ve also butchered their GMAC cash cow (for a paltry $5b initial payout) and sold off everything that isn’t nailed down, including their Arizona proving grounds. The company’s launched a slew of new products. And they’re still losing money in North America. 

Forget smoke and mirrors accounting: “special charges” and “net profit.” Don't forget: (especially?) with its former CFO at the helm, General Motors filed its SEC paperwork si x weeks late AND restated its accounts all the way back to January 2002 AND admits that its internal controls on financial reporting are "currently ineffective.” So look at the cash flow. 

Scanning backwards, GM’s burned through $3.8b in cash in 2006 and $8.2b in 2005. Scanning forwards, GM CFO Fritz Henderson said his employer would experience “negative cash flow” for the rest of 2007. Looking backwards, GM’s “first quarterly profit since 2004” masks the fact that the North American market didn’t even break even in the fourth quarter, and lost $779m for 2006. Looking forward, the company has, um, shot its wad.

Despite the arrival of the Tahoe, Yukon, Aura, Acadia, Outlook, Silverado and Sierra, GM NA’s fourth quarter revenues fell by $1.2b, while market share slipped to 23.2 percent. U.S. sales tumbled six percent through February ‘07. GM’s CFO says the company has “some impressive models coming,” but does anyone really think that the Astra (imported at a loss), Vue, Malibu, G8, restyled CTS and hybrid versions of the Yukon and Tahoe will be enough to turn around GM’s U.S. fortunes?

“GM’s automotive results are anemic at what we still believe is the peak of the company’s product, pricing and cost reduction cycle,” Banc of America Securities analyst Ronald Tadross told his clients.

So the light at the end of the tunnel is the headlight of an oncoming train. Although it’s increasingly clear we can’t depend on GM for an accurate picture of its cash reserves, even if we accept their $26b figure, that hoard is under mounting pressure. Take off $10b for float just to keep the doors open. Remove $6b – $7.5b for the Delphi payoff. Peel off another bil for the GMAC blowback. And then watch the burn.

The truth is GM has depended on asset sales to maintain its liquidity over the last year or so. That gambit is just about played out. GM can off-load the rest of GMAC, sell its Allison Transmissions unit, and, um, that’s about it. While GM’s overseas operations are the only bright spot in an otherwise bleak picture, the General’s foreign profits can’t save the domestic troops from an ignominious defeat.

Simply put, GM’s North American operations are not sustainable. According to the mavens over at Fitch ratings, “Despite profitability on a reported basis, GM's margin levels remain insufficient for long-term viability given the economic and product cycles inherent in the industry.”

If the United Auto Workers agree to a massive roll-back in their pension and health care benefits this summer, if gas prices slide to the point where GM’s high margin pickup trucks and SUV’s experience an enormous sales surge, if the competition takes a major hit (safety, reliability, something), GM could, conceivably, live long enough to turn itself around. That’s just about as likely as it sounds.

Meanwhile, GM is rolling out its latest national sales campaign, sealing its reputation as the K-Mart of cars. It could be US car buyers’ last chance to pickup a bargain– before all Hell breaks loose. 

By on March 15, 2007

shock.jpgMention the word “hybrid” on an automotive internet site and commentators clump into two camps. It’s either “I save the planet while getting 97.467 mpg driving my Prius up Pikes Peak” or “I search and destroy hippy trust-fund Prius drivers with my jacked-up diesel F-350”. Despite this ongoing socio-political clash over mixed propulsion, hybrid sales have brought the technology into the mainstream. Which puts us in a better place to answer the obvious question: what’s the future beyond the hype?

In the automobile’s infancy, battery electric vehicles (BEV’s) outsold and, in many famous cases, outperformed cars powered by internal combustion engines. But lead-acid batteries limited the BEV’s range, dooming them to obsolescence. In 1902, Ferdinand Porsche attempted to forestall the inevitable by developing the first gas – electric hybrid. Needless to say, Herr Porsche had better luck with gas-powered tanks and sports cars.

A hundred years later, Toyota had the guts, vision and cash to develop their groundbreaking series/parallel hybrid drive (gas engine and electric motor alternately or simultaneously propelling the car) using NiMH batteries. Despite its success, Toyota’s Synergy Drive has generally been seen as a transitional technology.

GM’s highly touted Volt concept (which follows Porsche’s principles closely) supposedly represents The Next Big Thing. It’s a serial hybrid– an internal combustion engine runs a generator that charges batteries that power the electric drive motor. Conceptually, it's the most efficient arrangement.  

Why the century-long wait? Lead acid batteries are simply too heavy and inefficient to git er done (e.g. GM’s EV1). Suitable alternatives are just now arising. Toyota has announced that Prius III will use lithium-ion cells. As will the Tesla and GM’s Volt. The industry is searching for (and closing in on) the new Holy Grail: a small, safe, powerful, fast-recharging, affordable battery.

Meanwhile, the industry is mad about hybrids. Even the highly diesel-dependent Germans are getting into the game. DCX and BMW have a joint venture with GM to share a sophisticated dual-mode full-hybrid drive. Mercedes and BMW (hmmm) just announced a partnership to develop a second, cheaper, mild-hybrid system. And VW and Porsche are hoping that hybridizing the Touareg and Cayenne will save their SUV’s.

And no wonder. A full hybrid system can boost real world mileage by some 35 percent; that’s as great an efficiency increase (over gas power) as a diesel. Diesel fuel’s higher cost stateside (seven to 15 percent) substantially reduces any pocket-book savings. What’s more, the cost of manufacturing clean diesels is roughly equivalent to gas – electric hybrids. Hybrid components are becoming cheaper; diesels are already highly evolved.

So why not build a diesel hybrid, doubling the efficiency gain? It’s an expensive proposition, and the efficiency differential isn’t there. The Atkinson-cycle gas engine (as used in parallel hybrids) already closes the gas vs. diesel efficiency gap considerably. Improvements in valve control, direct injection and upcoming HCCI (Homogeneous Charge Compression Ignition) technology will narrow the gap further. And diesels have lost some efficiency with the latest emission controls, while the gas engine is poised for continuing economy gains.

Even if you’re not the pious Prius type, hybrid technology is already sneaking into your ride. Electric driven power steering, air-conditioning compressors and water pumps are all the fruit of hybrid technology, and spreading fast. Car builders love them; their use yields measurable fuel savings (up to 10% combined), allows quicker engine heat-up and disconnects the engine from other peripherals, making it micro-hybrid ready [see: below].

BMW just updated their 1 Series with these goodies. They also added brake energy regenerative system (iGR) that controls the alternator to charge the battery (as needed) when the engine is in over-run or going downhill. For good measure, an automatic-start-stop program kills the engine whenever neutral is engaged. Combined with improved Bi-Vanos valve control and lean-burn direct injection, the model’s efficiency has increased by 24 percent.

Prius purists may scorn, but “micro-hybrids” like the Saturn Aura Green Line are cheap ($1700 retail premium) and effective. The model’s belt driven motor/generator system yields roughly a 15 percent efficiency gain. With higher CAFE numbers on the horizon, look for more creative bundling of various degrees and forms of hybrid and related technologies. It’s not just about trying to catch or keep up with the Prius’ standard-setting full-hybrid approach.

Looking forward, plug-in hybrids like the [theoretical] Chevy Volt are inevitable. The DOE has said the US grid can recharge up to 185 million plug-in cars at night. Lithium for batteries is recyclable. Improvements in CO and other emissions are easier to deal with at the power plant source than in each car.

So if you’re in the “Prius search and destroy” camp, be prepared to keep your current battle tank going for a long time. The hybrid virus is regenerating and mutating quickly; it’ll be hard not to catch it.

Recent Comments

  • Lou_BC: @Carlson Fan – My ’68 has 2.75:1 rear end. It buries the speedo needle. It came stock with the...
  • theflyersfan: Inside the Chicago Loop and up Lakeshore Drive rivals any great city in the world. The beauty of the...
  • A Scientist: When I was a teenager in the mid 90’s you could have one of these rolling s-boxes for a case of...
  • Mike Beranek: You should expand your knowledge base, clearly it’s insufficient. The race isn’t in...
  • Mike Beranek: ^^THIS^^ Chicago is FOX’s whipping boy because it makes Illinois a progressive bastion in the...

New Car Research

Get a Free Dealer Quote

Who We Are

  • Adam Tonge
  • Bozi Tatarevic
  • Corey Lewis
  • Jo Borras
  • Mark Baruth
  • Ronnie Schreiber